Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have questions about sex/gender

294 replies

Stereotypicallyconfused · 01/01/2023 10:59

N/C for obvious reasons as likely to get called transphobic but genuinely just confused & want to understand.

I'm a cis woman & therefore clearly have no understanding of what it feels like to be trans & it's hard to have a conversation with people about it. Firstly, I don't think trans people should have to put in the emotional labour to explain (but equally I don't know how you get to understand without having conversations) and secondly, having questions inevitably gets you labelled as a bigot.

I've never questioned what it feels like to be a woman. I just feel like me & I've never thought that how I feel is defined by my sex. I like things that are stereotypically male pursuits & dislike things that are stereotypically female pursuits (and equally vice versa). I'm bisexual so don't fit the "norm" in that respect either.

I feel like wanting to change your gender plays into the gender stereotypes moreso than if you just lived how you wanted to live (wore what you want, liked what you want etc). If there's no intention of ever fully transitioning (I know people that aren't) then I don't understand why you need to say you're the opposite gender. Surely you're just you?!

I know several trans people and obviously respect their pronouns and treat them with the same respect and kindness I would anyone I know. Regardless of the fact I don't understand.

OP posts:
PrplePanda · 03/01/2023 01:48

Sex refers to our biological make up, what dna we are born with, whereas gender is more societal and based on how others perceive us.

To be trans means you have (usually) negative emotions surrounding your body image and the way you feel in your body, giving someone the desire and feeling of a need to transition to the opposite sex.
Issues around gender occur from people now wanting to be viewed in a particular way. Some people may not want to be defined as 'feminine' for example and this may eventually lead to them referring to themselves as non-binary.

If you do not have any strong emotions about changing how you are or that there is something different about you then I wouldn't worry. I am also a bisexual women and have wondered the same things as you but not being super girly or liking more masculine activities doesn't mean you're having issues with your gender identity - this is all totally normal!

I have tried to simplify my explanations here so hope it makes sense. I've learnt this from talking with people I've met in the LGBTQ community and also my own research. I do agree with you though that it's hard to learn and I understand why so many people are open minded but scared to learn because of fears of being accused of being offensive!

Invisibleeye · 03/01/2023 01:25

purpledalmation · 01/01/2023 11:19

I'm a typical woman (fuck the non term 'cis'). I fancy men, I'm married, have children, work in a sector with male and female workers. I like 'female' type hobbies, but I also do woodwork, decorating and cycling. I rarely wear dresses, just jeans and trousers. I don't have a fascination for dressing in ultra feminine clothes or puffing up my lips with fillers. I don't even understand what it is the feel female, I just feel like a human being.

I'd say I am trans sceptical and don't understand the urge to wear a dress if you are a man or a suit if you are a woman. The whole thing leaves me cold, even though I have a trans friend. I love her as a friend, but just don't get the urge to wear female clothes.

Cis is literally just a prefix that is the opposite of the prefix trans. So it’s not a “non term” - it’s just English!

Stereotypicallyconfused · 03/01/2023 01:00

I've started reading the book by Helen Joyce - it's just a preview but I'd quite like an audio book copy.

It's definitely given me lots of food for thought.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 02/01/2023 14:42

OK, then maybe l'm not a cis woman. I guess that's why it's so complicated because gender is so hard to define as is 'identify'. I describe/define myself as a woman, I have the body of a woman but it's not my 'identity'. I no more identify as a woman as I do having brown eyes. It's the rest of society who labels me and I don't (never have) liked it.

WallaceinAnderland · 02/01/2023 14:27

WhatDoYouWantNow · 01/01/2023 18:05

What is a CIS woman?

Dunno. Cunt In Situ?

Creepinglight · 02/01/2023 13:38

WarriorN · 01/01/2023 18:04

Coming back to the OP:

If there's no intention of ever fully transitioning (I know people that aren't) then I don't understand why you need to say you're the opposite gender. Surely you're just you?!

This isn't really about trans people. This is people saying they're the opposite sex because they can.

And based on that, they expect imagined compliance from everyone else.

And an expectation that they can be afforded the same rights in law as women do, which is safeguarding based on their sex and vulnerability to male violence and rape, pregnancy and specific medical needs, sometimes relating to their religion.

You do understand it. And it isn't right.

This.

Yfory · 02/01/2023 13:27

Hi op - try typing "Helen Joyce" into you tube and have a listen to some of the many conversations she has been part of. See if what she has to say helps you to understand.

GreyCarpet · 02/01/2023 13:10

I'm a woman because I'm an adult human female. Not because of the interests I have (mostly stereotypically masculine) or because of the clothes I wear (mostly stereotypically feminine because of my body shape).

We are all just people. Our bodies are sexed. We have interests, hobbies, preferences and personalities but none of that changes our sexed bodies.

Many of the female people who identify as trans are doing so to avoid the pitfalls of being a woman (sexual objectification).

Many of the male people who identify as trans are doing so because they are turned on by the sexual element of it.

Others are doing it because they were brought up in homophobic/'traditional' families where stepping out of the gender norms for your sex made parents worry that their offspring would become gay or never find a husband.

The trans movement claims to reject gender stereotypes yet it can only exist through strict adherence to those gendered stereotypes - either those of your own sex (the meaningless term cis); the opposite sex (trans) or (like most people) a mixture of the two (the equally nonsensical non-binary).

In reality, we are all non-binary, gender free, agender whatever you want to call it because none of us adhere strictly to sex based gendered stereotypes.

Unless we have a point to make...

It's an aggressive men's rights movement and, because of this, women's voices are ignored, ridiculed and silenced in it.

I don't know anyone over the age of 25 in the real world who is on board with the current trans position.

Shelefttheweb · 02/01/2023 12:52

JudgeRudy · 02/01/2023 00:12

I 'just feel like me' too. I'm a cis straight woman but for me what defines me as a woman is simply my body, where as l believe a transgender person defines themselves by their sense of self/gender. I have no body dysmorphia, lm fine with this body, but Ive always disliked being 'gendered' because of it.
I don't actually feel like a woman in a woman's body, I feel more like an 'it' in a woman's body, if that makes sense. I'm pretty sure I'd feel comfortable in a man's body too. I've never really identified as white either but my skin says I am.

So are you saying that like me you identify as a biological woman but not partially as being of female gender? Maybe there's lots of people feel that way but never really analysised things.

If you call yourself a ‘cis’ woman then you are saying you are ONLY a woman because you like female gendered (ie stereotyped) things.

Ladysodor · 02/01/2023 11:38

Its called body dysmorphia and it’s a mental illness. I’m a woman (adult human female) and I also object to the term ‘cis’.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 02/01/2023 01:13

There is no such thing as as a 'cis woman'
Women have zero need to 'identity as' anything. They are women because they were born female. There is no special inner gender essence.

To use 'cis woman' implies that there is another type of woman. There isn't, because transwomen belong in the men's category. They are a subset of the male sex class.

JudgeRudy · 02/01/2023 00:12

I 'just feel like me' too. I'm a cis straight woman but for me what defines me as a woman is simply my body, where as l believe a transgender person defines themselves by their sense of self/gender. I have no body dysmorphia, lm fine with this body, but Ive always disliked being 'gendered' because of it.
I don't actually feel like a woman in a woman's body, I feel more like an 'it' in a woman's body, if that makes sense. I'm pretty sure I'd feel comfortable in a man's body too. I've never really identified as white either but my skin says I am.

So are you saying that like me you identify as a biological woman but not partially as being of female gender? Maybe there's lots of people feel that way but never really analysised things.

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 21:55

Stereotypicallyconfused · 01/01/2023 10:59

N/C for obvious reasons as likely to get called transphobic but genuinely just confused & want to understand.

I'm a cis woman & therefore clearly have no understanding of what it feels like to be trans & it's hard to have a conversation with people about it. Firstly, I don't think trans people should have to put in the emotional labour to explain (but equally I don't know how you get to understand without having conversations) and secondly, having questions inevitably gets you labelled as a bigot.

I've never questioned what it feels like to be a woman. I just feel like me & I've never thought that how I feel is defined by my sex. I like things that are stereotypically male pursuits & dislike things that are stereotypically female pursuits (and equally vice versa). I'm bisexual so don't fit the "norm" in that respect either.

I feel like wanting to change your gender plays into the gender stereotypes moreso than if you just lived how you wanted to live (wore what you want, liked what you want etc). If there's no intention of ever fully transitioning (I know people that aren't) then I don't understand why you need to say you're the opposite gender. Surely you're just you?!

I know several trans people and obviously respect their pronouns and treat them with the same respect and kindness I would anyone I know. Regardless of the fact I don't understand.

OP, not sure if this was recommended, but have you read or listened to Helen Joyce’s book Trans ? Or Dr Kathleen Stock’s Material Girls. Or Abigail Shrier’s Irreversible Damage for background on what is happening to the young female transitioners.

It might be a good way to read something and then look further. I am sure others will have other recommendations.

My advice is to read widely from different perspectives. Go to original sources, be careful when reading disseminations of that original document, there are plenty of poor quality articles and studies being pushed as revolutionary. (For instance: An American scientific blog post often gets posted on MN as some kind of authoritative work, but it is very poorly argued and evidenced. )

But if I had to recommend just one book, Trans would be it.

howmanybicycles · 01/01/2023 21:39

judaskween · 01/01/2023 17:34

Prolly should ask trans people about this, Mumsnet isn't exactly the best source for unbiased information on the trans community.

OP is asking questions about sex and gender. Not just about being trans. Trans people often have a very rigid and narrow view on a broad topic which, despite what some trans people say, has a massive impact on most people, not just trans people. If you want unbiased information, don't ask privileged what adult males.

bellinisurge · 01/01/2023 20:54

You aren't cis. There is no such thing. Women are all shapes, sizes, belief systems, political opinions, colours, religions, straight, lesbian, bisexual. Some of them even have sex-specific DSDs. Transwomen are not women.

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 01/01/2023 20:50

SuperPup86 · 01/01/2023 12:12

I'm always curious by the amount of posters on threads such as this - or twitter - who have 'several trans friends' or similar and often claim that of course it poses no issues bla bla bla.

For such a small percentage of the population I find it odd that your average person seems to know quite so many.

The figure usually quoted is 0.5% - that is one in 200 people. I think most people will know more than 200 people. Family, friends, colleges, neighbours, partners friends, families and colleges.

I'm part of a hobby group that has approximately 500 members - I don't know them all as friends but I know the vast majority well enough to recognise them in the street, say hello to and to be aware of the couple of middle aged men in that group that now identify as women.

I have never met any of my colleagues children but I am aware that between the 30 or so of us in the office that one has a non-binary daughter and one has a trans child. (I am also aware that both of these children are young adults in same sex relationships who attend universities that are fully captured).

Echobelly · 01/01/2023 19:37

@belowfrozen - I think we have a generation that is looking at adolescence through the lens of gender very intently, and it will be worked through and will seem a bit cringe to kids a few years younger!

So they're thinking 'I'm not like most girls, maybe I'm non binary" or 'i don't like the way my body is changing and I'm not sure who I am [ie, normal adolescent feelings], maybe I'm trans' I suspect the vast majority of these kids will move away from trans identity as they actually start maturing sexually, although I think it's also possible we will see more non binary people in general.

The moving away is not, of course, going to take the form of actually saying they're not trans, it's just going to be, as has just happened with the first of DCs mates to ID as non binary, going back to their original name and saying (verbatim quote from this friend) 'Oh whatever' when asked about pronouns- ie, letting everyone drift back to their given ones.

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 19:35

I think that the "trans community " is a narrow segment of the total trans population

There is a world of difference between say India ( ?) and buck angel in what they think and how they feel

Britinme · 01/01/2023 19:16

Prolly should ask trans people about this, Mumsnet isn't exactly the best source for unbiased information on the trans community.

And you think you'd get unbiased information from the trans community?

Happiestwithtea · 01/01/2023 18:51

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 18:46

“I just think sometimes it can be so unbalanced here in terms of a range of views about this and I think it tends to feel like people like me who are somewhere in the middle get shouted down and told to get back in their box.”

If you actually spent time on the board you denigrated yesterday, maybe you would indeed understand that if you are ‘somewhere in the middle’, you would find others agreeing with you.

Instead, you seem to want to portray reasonable views as extreme and in the minority.

And again, many of us have trans loved ones in our daily lives. And are dealing every single day with the impacts and ramifications of ideological beliefs and constant calls to ‘be kind’, ‘there is no harm’ and all the other calls for kindness that you and other posters make.

I take your point. I suppose if someone is calling you uneducated, neglectful and spamming your posts shouting “klaxon…” with others then joining in and all that it makes you a bit angry and more extreme in your own replies. No one likes to feel they’re being laughed at.

I am being less extreme now because we are engaging with each other respectfully. Which is the point I was trying to make about people saying “you lost me at cis”.

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 18:46

“I just think sometimes it can be so unbalanced here in terms of a range of views about this and I think it tends to feel like people like me who are somewhere in the middle get shouted down and told to get back in their box.”

If you actually spent time on the board you denigrated yesterday, maybe you would indeed understand that if you are ‘somewhere in the middle’, you would find others agreeing with you.

Instead, you seem to want to portray reasonable views as extreme and in the minority.

And again, many of us have trans loved ones in our daily lives. And are dealing every single day with the impacts and ramifications of ideological beliefs and constant calls to ‘be kind’, ‘there is no harm’ and all the other calls for kindness that you and other posters make.

belowfrozen · 01/01/2023 18:35

WarriorN · 01/01/2023 18:28

Kids get a lot of extra special attention if they're "trans."

I can see this being a plus for some that we know.

belowfrozen · 01/01/2023 18:33

In our case one child has been identifying as the other gender for some years. But the rest suddenly became trans at Yr7/8. Previously no mention.
One of the girls has always had just girls as mates, was into girly stuff etc Then announces she's actually a boy when she goes to high school. Uses a boys name at school etc but her parents refuse to entertain it. She also still only hangs out with all the girls.

Happiestwithtea · 01/01/2023 18:31

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 18:02

By the way, if you stuck around and actually engaged without the snide disparaging remarks aimed at MN FWR board (because that was were you were posting), you would realise that many of us have trans loved ones in our daily life.

You constant call for kindness do have consequences. Particularly if you are using pronouns for children and teens that are under treatment programs that unless you know the family well, you may not know.

This is indeed a very complex issue and not one that is solved by ‘being kind’ all the time. And often, being kind for trans people is not actually being kind for children and all female people.

It’s not even about being kind. It’s about not just shouting someone down with things like “you’ve lost me at cis” when someone asks about something. I don’t really want people to be kind to me for the sake of it. I know it’s a complex issue, and I can be just as much of an arse as the next person.

I feel I’ve derailed the thread and I apologise for that.

I just think sometimes it can be so unbalanced here in terms of a range of views about this and I think it tends to feel like people like me who are somewhere in the middle get shouted down and told to get back in their box.

ZiriForEver · 01/01/2023 18:29

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 15:44

Have you just assumed that samphire isn't transgender?

I suspect many people are transgender if you dig deeply

I mean any female person who thinks women only describes their biology is strictly speaking transgender
Any female who doesn't feel aligned with any gender identify is strictly speaking transgender

, it's just many don't really care or don't want to be associated with the transgender community

Ok. I am adult human female. Based on that I'd say I am a woman, but I don't identify myself with feminine stereotypes and I never understood what the inner self of womanhood some people including males are referring to should be, so I probably don't share the same identity as them, and they don't share my identity with me. I'm definitely not a man, I don't have male body and I don't want people to talk about me as if I had one.

If it makes me trans by your definition, I should start voicing my trans voice and say that trans comes in many ways, so many ways that it renders whole concept of gender identity totally irrelevant and not worth mentioning anymore. I can say that many of "us, trans people" support single sex spaces, single sex sports, sex based reporting. I still see value in talking about gendered socialisation, but I see the value only on statistical scale. Individual identity is irrelevant, dress as you wish, choose a job and hobbies you like, respect sex-based division when relevant and get on with life...
And anyone who disagree with me is being transphobic :)