Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have questions about sex/gender

294 replies

Stereotypicallyconfused · 01/01/2023 10:59

N/C for obvious reasons as likely to get called transphobic but genuinely just confused & want to understand.

I'm a cis woman & therefore clearly have no understanding of what it feels like to be trans & it's hard to have a conversation with people about it. Firstly, I don't think trans people should have to put in the emotional labour to explain (but equally I don't know how you get to understand without having conversations) and secondly, having questions inevitably gets you labelled as a bigot.

I've never questioned what it feels like to be a woman. I just feel like me & I've never thought that how I feel is defined by my sex. I like things that are stereotypically male pursuits & dislike things that are stereotypically female pursuits (and equally vice versa). I'm bisexual so don't fit the "norm" in that respect either.

I feel like wanting to change your gender plays into the gender stereotypes moreso than if you just lived how you wanted to live (wore what you want, liked what you want etc). If there's no intention of ever fully transitioning (I know people that aren't) then I don't understand why you need to say you're the opposite gender. Surely you're just you?!

I know several trans people and obviously respect their pronouns and treat them with the same respect and kindness I would anyone I know. Regardless of the fact I don't understand.

OP posts:
cosystripysocks · 01/01/2023 12:54

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 12:36

Yes. There are indeed some long term trans posters.

And if OP does ask her trans friends about this she may we get a very GC response. I did. That's what peaked me, about 5 years ago. I stopped defending them and actually asked them about their thoughts on gender and sex. Guess what? They don't think they have changed sex, don't think they are the opposite sex, they know who they are and find they are more comfortable in their own skin if they take on the external accoutrements of the opposite sex.

In short they would, and have, been vilified by Stonewalled TRAs. Because they don't toe the current "replace sex with gender, remove all single sex exemptions" line of thinking.

Don't presume...

You agree with me then that the OP should ask her trans friends what they think, cool. And no we can't presume what their answers would be, as you've found.
Maybe would be nice to hear from some of those long term trans posters on this thread and the rest of us should butt out.

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 01/01/2023 12:52

I'm a cis woman & therefore clearly have no understanding of what it feels like to be trans
If it is a given that a non trans person clearly can't know how it feels to be trans why isn't it also a given that a man clearly can't know how it feels to be a woman?

SuperPup86 · 01/01/2023 12:48

You probably know or have been around many trans people and won’t have even known. Several members of my family are very vocal when it comes to their opinions on trans people and yet they have been around dds friends from university, 3 of whom are trans, and they have not had a clue any of them were born male

😂😂

Sure...i bet I'm surrounded by penis-owners in dresses and make up daily and have no idea.

You win the award today for something else that never happened though. I mean not only does your DD have three trans women as friends, they're completely indistinguishable from women. No tells such as height, build, voice, Adams apple or just general facial construction, all the things that make your sex immediately distinguishable in the vast majority of humans...amazing! 😁

AlisonDonut · 01/01/2023 12:46

The thing about the new fangled trans activism, is that THEY call old school transsexuals 'truscum', the new fangled trans activism is as far from actual transsexuals as it is possible to be. They have taken it and formed it into a woman hating ideology.

This ideology currently has women calling themselves 'cis' as if they are a sub set of their own sex. They hate people who have had the 'op', and they are quite delighted to frighten you and your female relatives and friend in a female toilet with their penises and then get you kicked out for reporting them.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 12:39

SuperPup86 · 01/01/2023 12:12

I'm always curious by the amount of posters on threads such as this - or twitter - who have 'several trans friends' or similar and often claim that of course it poses no issues bla bla bla.

For such a small percentage of the population I find it odd that your average person seems to know quite so many.

Some of us were young Gender Benders of the 80s. We all have friends who maintained what is now called trans identities.

And it does/has posed issues. Issues that have changed over the decades. Anybody claiming that there have never been any problems is revising their personal history.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 12:36

minimarshmallowsmore · 01/01/2023 12:02

Really? I don't think I've ever seen a post from a trans person on mumsnet. What kind of reception do they get here if they post? No trans people have replied on here so far so it's hardly a conversation with balanced perspectives.

"Transwidows" are not trans voices.

The OP says they know several trans people so maybe if their question is genuine and they really are interested in what trans people really think they could ask them? They could also search the internet for things trans people have written about their experiences. If all they want is for people to affirm what they're saying, and just a back and forth of people saying "no I don't understand it either, it must not be legit" then this was the right place to ask.

Yes. There are indeed some long term trans posters.

And if OP does ask her trans friends about this she may we get a very GC response. I did. That's what peaked me, about 5 years ago. I stopped defending them and actually asked them about their thoughts on gender and sex. Guess what? They don't think they have changed sex, don't think they are the opposite sex, they know who they are and find they are more comfortable in their own skin if they take on the external accoutrements of the opposite sex.

In short they would, and have, been vilified by Stonewalled TRAs. Because they don't toe the current "replace sex with gender, remove all single sex exemptions" line of thinking.

Don't presume...

ScoobyDoNot · 01/01/2023 12:35

blacksax · 01/01/2023 11:41

You lost me at 'cis'.

This

Shelefttheweb · 01/01/2023 12:35

’Cis’ means you accept women are purely women because they identify with regressive sex stereotypes. How can you consider yourself ‘cis’ if you reject these stereotypes? The fact that you like stereotypically male pursuits (like most women to some degree) would categorise you as non-binary under this system. But lo, you now have no word to define your sex. You have no way to ask for spaces free from males to get undressed, or have data to record your lower pay or means to object to it, no data on differential response to drugs based on sex, no means to ask for a female nurse to carry out your smear test. These have now all gone...

But yes, sure it is ‘kind’ to go along with the fantasy that destroys our rights and call men ‘she’ and record them as ‘female’ because it makes them feel powerful.

Somanysocks · 01/01/2023 12:34

blacksax · 01/01/2023 11:41

You lost me at 'cis'.

Yup, me too

Happiestwithtea · 01/01/2023 12:32

SuperPup86 · 01/01/2023 12:12

I'm always curious by the amount of posters on threads such as this - or twitter - who have 'several trans friends' or similar and often claim that of course it poses no issues bla bla bla.

For such a small percentage of the population I find it odd that your average person seems to know quite so many.

You probably know or have been around many trans people and won’t have even known. Several members of my family are very vocal when it comes to their opinions on trans people and yet they have been around dds friends from university, 3 of whom are trans, and they have not had a clue any of them were born male. We haven’t ever discussed it, why add more fuel to the fire, and they will never know.

I find it odd the other way round - that so many claim they don’t know any. I can think of at least 4 that I know of, and probably more that I’m not aware of.

It really isn’t as unusual as people want to make out. It’s just people don’t tend to go out wearing a badge declaring it and despite what Mumsnet wants us to think it isn’t always as obvious to tell as people think it is.

anyolddinosaur · 01/01/2023 12:30

Well I have a distant trans relative with a trans partner. It would be impossible to ask them anything directly - they are now so full of hate that you would be labelled transphobic for asking. Other, closer, relatives who were involved when they were still at the questioning stage have told me it's what you would expect - autistic homosexual young person who didnt like things stereotypical for their sex. Then they found Mermaids. Health is now ruined as is their partner's health.

I address them by name and I'll use their preferred pronouns when speaking to other family members. I knew nothing about the trans movement until
after their transition. I have not told my relatives that I'm upset at their safeguarding failure, they do know that I wont support Mermaids.

roarfeckingroarr · 01/01/2023 12:29

Gender is essentially a collection of outdated stereotypes. Being gender non conforming is fairly standard but doesn't convey special status. People who want to conform to stereotypes that don't match their birth sex can do so, no one is stopping them, they have the same rights as we all do to live, dress, be called what they like.

It becomes a problem when gender is conflated with sex and the sex based rights of the less powerful group are eroded.

StopStartStop · 01/01/2023 12:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Appletreefarmyard · 01/01/2023 12:14

I am not sure how important/ necessary it is to understand what it is like to have experiences that others have. I think it's helpful/important to recognise that others' lived experiences can be different to ours and that we can't know what that's like.

I do not have a gender identity. I find it upsetting when others assume I do and impose this on me (eg by calling me cis). I use this experience to empathise with those who do have a gender identity and have others impose something unwanted on them too about their identity.

The challenge for me is that I am female (a term that I use to refer to my natal sex) and strongly reject and suggestions that this has any bearing on my choice of clothes, hobbies, or interests. I don't view being female as something you can identify in to or out of.

Therefore, I have issues with people using the term female to refer to an identity - let alone this identity being based on sexist stereotypes.

I think the solution to all of this lies in language, and having terms to depict sex- based categories and terms to depict gender-based categories. I accept that this is difficult for those who are distressed by their sex.

WarriorN · 01/01/2023 12:12

*They're the women who experienced a great deal of abuse and coercion from their husbands.

SuperPup86 · 01/01/2023 12:12

I'm always curious by the amount of posters on threads such as this - or twitter - who have 'several trans friends' or similar and often claim that of course it poses no issues bla bla bla.

For such a small percentage of the population I find it odd that your average person seems to know quite so many.

Lennybenny · 01/01/2023 12:12

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3145470-Break-it-down-for-me?reply=74977577&utm_source=reply&utm_medium=share

This absolutely explains what we're seeing at the moment.

WarriorN · 01/01/2023 12:11

"Transwidows" are not trans voices.

No they're not. They're the husbands of the women who experienced a great deal of abuse and coercion from their husbands.

As children of transwomen also experience.

www.transwidowsvoices.org/

childrenoftransitioners.org/

Happiestwithtea · 01/01/2023 12:04

minimarshmallowsmore · 01/01/2023 12:02

Really? I don't think I've ever seen a post from a trans person on mumsnet. What kind of reception do they get here if they post? No trans people have replied on here so far so it's hardly a conversation with balanced perspectives.

"Transwidows" are not trans voices.

The OP says they know several trans people so maybe if their question is genuine and they really are interested in what trans people really think they could ask them? They could also search the internet for things trans people have written about their experiences. If all they want is for people to affirm what they're saying, and just a back and forth of people saying "no I don't understand it either, it must not be legit" then this was the right place to ask.

This. 💯

Lennybenny · 01/01/2023 12:02

I also strongly believe that no one under 18 should be able to medically transition. The amount of children who think they're gay or trans when it's a major hormonal issues and puberty will correct it.

Yes I know its not like that in all cases but how many of you have dc who are currently wondering if they're gay...its mainly dd who struggle with the identity but no-one seems to notice.

minimarshmallowsmore · 01/01/2023 12:02

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 11:48

And yet there IS a long term trans presence here. Not just those who report threads like this for simply existing, but transmen and women who have added to this debate for years.

We also have transwidows who know only too well how destructive this whole issue can be.

If OP (any of us) could find a space like this.to discuss directly with any group of trans people we probably would. But there isn't, we can't and anywhere we do we get posts ranging from your signalling of your distaste to being directly told to fuck off and die. Simply for trying to work out why the biological fact of our sex has become yet another commodity for some men.

What you call transphobic bullshit is women saying no to those men!

Really? I don't think I've ever seen a post from a trans person on mumsnet. What kind of reception do they get here if they post? No trans people have replied on here so far so it's hardly a conversation with balanced perspectives.

"Transwidows" are not trans voices.

The OP says they know several trans people so maybe if their question is genuine and they really are interested in what trans people really think they could ask them? They could also search the internet for things trans people have written about their experiences. If all they want is for people to affirm what they're saying, and just a back and forth of people saying "no I don't understand it either, it must not be legit" then this was the right place to ask.

Lennybenny · 01/01/2023 11:59

purpledalmation · 01/01/2023 11:19

I'm a typical woman (fuck the non term 'cis'). I fancy men, I'm married, have children, work in a sector with male and female workers. I like 'female' type hobbies, but I also do woodwork, decorating and cycling. I rarely wear dresses, just jeans and trousers. I don't have a fascination for dressing in ultra feminine clothes or puffing up my lips with fillers. I don't even understand what it is the feel female, I just feel like a human being.

I'd say I am trans sceptical and don't understand the urge to wear a dress if you are a man or a suit if you are a woman. The whole thing leaves me cold, even though I have a trans friend. I love her as a friend, but just don't get the urge to wear female clothes.

This probably explains me in the best way. I don't understand those who aren't actually transitioning but are wearing make up, skirts and having long hair. That to me is just cross dressing. Anyone who fully transitions and is therefore without the obvious bits, has in my mind and opinion, changed and should be referred to as trans xxxx.
I struggle with being labeled Cis as this means someone else has made a label for me.
I also don't understand why women's rights are being changed but mens don't seem to be. Transwomen are up in arms over people with a uterus or chest feeders but transmen don't seem to have a public platform for stand up wee'rs or those who tuck.

I find it annoying to be labeled as transphobic because I have an opinion on someone who only wears make up being able to call themselves a transwoman and expect me to stand in a changing room with what looks like a man with a beard and eye shadow.

FleeceDuvet · 01/01/2023 11:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WarriorN · 01/01/2023 11:54

AlisonDonut · 01/01/2023 11:49

So much to unpick but there is a thread on the norty step (AKA FWR) called 'break it down for me'. Make a coffee and have a read and then come back here and post your thoughts.

Was thinking the same.

Break it down for me? www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3145470-Break-it-down-for-me

WarriorN · 01/01/2023 11:53

As a wider political movement, trans people (trans women, who are male) telling women that men can be women too, is the latest move of the patriarchy.

Controlling who is defined as a woman and what we are allowed to say is the ultimate misogynist move.

You will be experiencing it as a very different thing on an individual level. Individuals are individuals. At a political level it's anti women.