Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think toddlers don’t need snacks?

389 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 31/12/2022 18:56

I was just pondering this when washing up. I’ve never really given DD snacks, she has her 3 meals a day and that’s usually it, maybe once or twice a week she will have a digestive biscuit or yoghurt if dinner is going to be later than usual. However it seems like when we go on days out with other mums and toddlers, they come laden with snacks that are whipped out every hour or two. AIBU to think toddlers don’t really need to snack and this might be contributing to the obesity crisis?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HuggingtheHRT · 23/04/2023 13:35

Whatever works for your circumstance, I say.

My DS is 9 and still continuously snacking. He's one of the most active kids I know and is whippet thin because he's constantly on the move. (He is autistic and stims by running and jumping mostly.) So trying to keep calories intake up is an absolute necessity.

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 23/04/2023 13:04

Everyone is different aren’t they so it’s impossible to generalise.

DD had a tiny appetite until she was about 6, rarely snacked and hard to get a full meal in her. She was very petite. Now she’s average size and has a better appetite, including snacks some days but not others.

DS has always eaten virtually nonstop, he gets very “hangry” without lots of snacks. He’s like a whirlwind constantly and must burn it all off as he’s very slim.

Florenz · 23/04/2023 12:49

If I was the government and I wanted to combat obesity I would tax junk food - massively, and use the revenue to subsidise the cost of healthy foods. I would also take junk food out of supermarkets and make them be sold in a special store.

TheEverdelightfulsamantha · 23/04/2023 12:47

Some adults need snacks - some don’t, kids are the same - my DS is very high energy, runs and moves a lot and has always needed to eat regularly- he gets very ‘hangry’ and ceases making logical choices - he eats a balanced diet, high in protein at meals but does need snacks when he is hungry, peanut butter on toast, a handful of peanuts, humous and pitta or carrots, sometimes a bowl of museli - we try to make the snacks low ish in sugar, but high in protein which seems to help him - always eats a full dinner.

my daughter wants to snack - but doesn’t need too - she could eat an entire cake / large pack of crisps / multi pack of twix (in our defence it was lock down, DH and I were both on calls in different rooms and she very crafty interpreted our off screen go away hand signals as ‘eat all the twixes!’ 😂) but we don’t let her do that because a)those things are unhealthy and b) she wouldnt eat dinner

sometimes I’m ravenously hungry about 11 am so I have a snack, sometimes I’m not so I don’t

00100001 · 23/04/2023 12:35

Berklilly · 23/04/2023 08:26

These aren't snacks, they are treats...

A banana and an apple a treat? 🤣🤣

Besides, if you're eating it between meals, whether it's a cucumber stick or a doughnut...it's a snack...

Berklilly · 23/04/2023 08:26

00100001 · 21/04/2023 07:26

Snacking isn't why kids are obsese.

You and your kids never ever once ate food outside of meal times.... I find that hard to believe tbh.

Never had candyfloss/doughnuts at the fun fair? Never had popcorn at cinema? Never had a mid morning biscuit with a drink? Not an ice-cream at the beach? Not had a pack of crisps on the way home from somewhere? Never had a little cake at a café? Never had any sweets from their Halloween/party bags outside of meals? Never enjoyed an apple at the top of a hill after a walk. Never had a banana after swimming? Never in all of your lives have you accepted a biscuit/sweet/chocolate when offered?

These aren't snacks, they are treats...

00100001 · 23/04/2023 07:19

Florenz · 23/04/2023 02:09

Part of the problem is that fun fairs, cinema visits, days out somewhere used to be a rare treat. Nowadays parents "structure" their kids days with activities and every activity seems to require a snack. When I was a kid most school holidays we'd be playing outside all day, running around etc, sometimes not even returning home for lunch. Snacks are absolutely part (not all, but part) or the cause of the childhood obesity.

Some snacks for some children are part of the problems, yes. But snacking in of itself isn't an issue.

A child eating something like this in a day;
Large bowl of frosties, chocolate milk for breakfast
Large doughnut mid morning
Lunch of leftover take away pizza slices and a grab bag of Doritos and a mars bar
Afternoon snack of sweets and sausage roll
Dinner of 3 turkey dinosaur and 5 potato smiles, followed by a large ice-cream

Isn't going to have the same outcome as a child who has;
Boiled egg and wholemeal toast
Small Apple sliced and tbsp peanut butter for snack
Lunch of pasta and pesto with 3 cherry tomatoes, 1" cucumber and 4 olives
Snack if babybel
Dinner of home made chicken casserole, cabbage, carrots and mash followed by greek yoghurt and a dollop of honey.

Florenz · 23/04/2023 02:09

00100001 · 21/04/2023 07:26

Snacking isn't why kids are obsese.

You and your kids never ever once ate food outside of meal times.... I find that hard to believe tbh.

Never had candyfloss/doughnuts at the fun fair? Never had popcorn at cinema? Never had a mid morning biscuit with a drink? Not an ice-cream at the beach? Not had a pack of crisps on the way home from somewhere? Never had a little cake at a café? Never had any sweets from their Halloween/party bags outside of meals? Never enjoyed an apple at the top of a hill after a walk. Never had a banana after swimming? Never in all of your lives have you accepted a biscuit/sweet/chocolate when offered?

Part of the problem is that fun fairs, cinema visits, days out somewhere used to be a rare treat. Nowadays parents "structure" their kids days with activities and every activity seems to require a snack. When I was a kid most school holidays we'd be playing outside all day, running around etc, sometimes not even returning home for lunch. Snacks are absolutely part (not all, but part) or the cause of the childhood obesity.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/04/2023 10:59

I think smaller meals with healthy snacks in between is healthier for most toddlers and smaller children. However, of course everyone is different.

I don’t think loading up kids at meals in order to stretch through to the next meal is necessarily a better option than letter them eat a smaller amount when hungry.

Geckle · 21/04/2023 10:50

Snacking isn’t the reason why children are obese.

Some children snack, some don’t. Same as adults.

It’s not a big deal and not my concern.

00100001 · 21/04/2023 07:26

emptythelitterbox · 21/04/2023 03:32

Never had snacks as a kid neither did my children.

Advertisers think everyone should have something constantly.

The rates for childhood obesity are high.

Snacking isn't why kids are obsese.

You and your kids never ever once ate food outside of meal times.... I find that hard to believe tbh.

Never had candyfloss/doughnuts at the fun fair? Never had popcorn at cinema? Never had a mid morning biscuit with a drink? Not an ice-cream at the beach? Not had a pack of crisps on the way home from somewhere? Never had a little cake at a café? Never had any sweets from their Halloween/party bags outside of meals? Never enjoyed an apple at the top of a hill after a walk. Never had a banana after swimming? Never in all of your lives have you accepted a biscuit/sweet/chocolate when offered?

emptythelitterbox · 21/04/2023 03:32

Never had snacks as a kid neither did my children.

Advertisers think everyone should have something constantly.

The rates for childhood obesity are high.

saltandpepper86 · 21/04/2023 03:09

mine ate more snacks as toddlers than they do now as teens, their tummies are only small so little and often is a good way to go, snacks don't have to be unhealthy.

Fandabedodgy · 21/04/2023 01:36

Mine did.

Or he would become a hangry evil demon.

pollymere · 21/04/2023 00:42

I liked to use snack time as a way of introducing new foods. I think it's a common part of toddler group and nursery to sit down and have something at ten or eleven. I don't think it needs to be more than a small portion of cut up fruit. A few berries or similar. Mine liked cubes of cheese with a couple of bread sticks or a toddler friendly biscuit with a drink. Certainly nothing more.

UndertheCedartree · 19/04/2023 20:40

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 31/12/2022 19:05

I agree with you OP. It seems like a relatively knee phenomenon that children must constantly be fed. We never smacked as children! And I have never given my kids snacks (although the fruit bowl os a free for all). They have 3 substantial meals a day, if children are hungry between eating meals then it could be they’re getting empty calories.

I don't think it's a 'new phenomenon'. As a child of the 80s we always had elevenses and afternoon tea.

Wenfy · 19/04/2023 20:30

DemBonesDemBones · 19/04/2023 19:29

@Wenfy 'incredibly sporty' eh. Grin

DD bikes, runs and plays hockey competitively. She won a scholarship for long distance running as there’s a tiny chance that she may be good enough to train with Team GB.

OoooohMatron · 19/04/2023 19:51

Stealth boast much

DemBonesDemBones · 19/04/2023 19:29

@Wenfy 'incredibly sporty' eh. Grin

montessorinanny · 19/04/2023 19:26

I work as a childminder and we have a morning snack. The children who come to me are aged from young babies to 5 year olds. They are aware of the time we normally have snack and you can guarantee they will be standing beside me at exactly 10.30am and they can't the time yet. I have always given a morning snack as most have breakfast early. I also have had children whose behaviour has become terrible due to a sugar dip so when they are given a healthy snack they are so much better behaved. The size of the snack however does depend on how much of their lunch they will eat.

Tibtilkobkob · 19/04/2023 19:06

ShirleyPhallus · 31/12/2022 19:04

Toddlers don’t need snacks but mums do need judgemental parenting ey

😂

Wenfy · 19/04/2023 18:56

I agree with you. I don’t snack. DH doesn’t snack. (we come from non-snacking cultures). None of the DC have ever snacked and they are incredibly sporty. All of us need to feel properly hungry before we can eat but I guess everyone’s different.

KinkyMom · 04/01/2023 01:54

It just depends on the kid in question. Mine is in the first percentile and she gets very hangry if she doesn’t have a snack so we always provide. She gets two snacks day. The first one we always try to make a healthy snack, carrots, broccoli, apples or a fruit cup. The second snack is usually a bit more fun. A muffin, cookie or half a donut.

She’s always had trouble keeping her weight up though so we aren’t too finicky about how much she eats.

If yours is a healthy weight and doesn’t fuss without a snack then I say you’re doing good mum!

kateandme · 04/01/2023 01:49

Milk and custard creams at nursery.
Tuckshop out the school window anyone.space invaders pickled.mini jaffas.random bowls of cereal.onion.penguins. cheesestring.sunny d.little curved tubs they bought out for your Pringles ha.after swim chips in the cafe or choc bar from vending machine ?
Choc bars when you finally started walking on your own.
Choc cornflakes cake and ice buns.i think even bacon rolls were served!
Snacking is not new.
And we are fine.apparently waaaay healthier than today's kids who are limited,shamed,weighed,diet cultured,shouldn't snack because they are fat fat fat fat fat which is such a bad thing to be.
Blah.
Seems to be a correlation over to "unhealthier" folk when we became so disordered and obsessedwith just what people did or didn't eat and how to limit it.

DistantSkye · 03/01/2023 17:15

I'm 38 and remember having fruit/babybels/bread sticks etc when I was in primary school so I don't get where the idea that snacks are a "new phenomenon" has come from 😂

To answer the OP - actually I think you're right in that there is now an abundance of less than ideal food marketed at toddlers and young children (so things like packs rice cakes/heinz biscotti/toddler biscuits and oat bars) that aren't particularly nutrient dense but are vaguely filling. As part of a balanced diet they probably aren't that bad but I guess if they make up a big part of a kids diet it's not great. However I think you knew exactly the kind of reaction you'd get when you posted about mums whipping out tubs of snacks every 2-3 hours! It sounded a bit smug.

I guess it depends what kind of lifestyle and what your timings are like - like are you a sahm or does your DD go to nursery? My two are up with me at 6am so having breakfast before they go to breakfast club before school (they don't like the cereal there apparently 🙄) and generally they do need a snack between 6am and lunch at school at 12.30/1pm. I don't think that's unusual for a child. But if I had a more relaxed morning/breakfast at 8 and lunch when I chose, and they were at home with me, maybe they wouldn't need a snack and I could have more.time to judge what other parents do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread