Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get dd assessed for autism against her wishes.

180 replies

NosyNeighbour22 · 31/12/2022 18:43

My dd is 12 and I now suspect she is autistic to some degree. Although I had earlier suspicions her primary school didn’t see any issues so I left it as she seemed to be getting on ok. However since moving to secondary school her lack of social skills had become a lot more apparent and I’m worried that she will struggle.

I have never told my dd I think she is autistic, I’m not sure how to broach that with her. However she does have certain sensory issues that sometimes make her life difficult eg can’t wear tight clothing or anything cropped or short sleeved which makes it difficult for her to find clothes in shops that sell to her age range. She can’t wear her hair up as she find it uncomfortable so she has to keep it really short for school. There has recently been discussion about her school uniform changing from a hoodie to a tie and blazer which I know dd would struggle with, so I used this to broach the possibility of finding out why she is so sensitive to clothing etc and told her that if there was a proper reason for it then the school might not make her wear a tie. However she was really upset at the suggestion that there might be something ‘wrong’ with her (her words) and said she didn’t want to go to the doctors or talk to the school about it.

There are other signs socially that there is an issue but dd doesn’t see them at all so I would have to point this out to her in a very blunt way for her to understand and she would be extremely upset by it. Had anyone been through this with an older girl and can advise the best way of going about it or AIBU for making her get assessed if she doesn’t want to?

OP posts:
CleoandRalf · 31/12/2022 23:07

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:47

And those who's Autsim effects them what they deem to be to severely will be rejected.

And I wouldn't assume their bar is particulary High.

They’d then be rejected regardless of a diagnosis, as the behaviours don’t disappear without one.

BigMadAdrian · 31/12/2022 23:07

I haven't read the whole thread - I'm sorry, I know I should.

My dd was diagnosed this year, the day before her 13th birthday, She flew through primary school - 'thrived' as the school put it, multiple awards at prize giving, popular, etc - it was all masking.

The transition to secondary school really threw her difficulties into the light - it was much harder for her to mask and copy, she was ostracised and called a 'stalker'. She became suicidal.

Diagnosis has made the most enormous difference - alongside the right therapy (ASD specialist is crucial - CBT doesn't work) and medication (propanolol). We have also pulled her out of school and she is doing very well home schooling.

Google Holly Smale (Geek Girl author) - she has done a lot of radio recently.

I have been drinking and this whole topic is highly charged for me - it's been a tough year - so sorry if not particularly coherent. Pm me if you'd like to discuss more.

I have very recently name changed after a long stint with one username - I've posted about dd under the previous username. And about my own struggles.

Athenen0ctua · 31/12/2022 23:07

secular39 · 31/12/2022 22:50

I'm sorry OP but I cannot believe your asking this question on Mumsnet. You are an adult, you know of the implications of what not having a diagnosis can bring. If you speak to many newly diagnosed autistic adults, they often say that they wish they had known that they were not "weird, "rude" or "dumb" at school/by others, but that they were Autistic.

At 12! She is not mature enough to see what a diagnosis can bring. You wouldn't ask this question if your DD had something medical going on (I.e. in underlining illness which can impact her life) so why is this any different??

I was diagnosed as a teen and wish it had never happened. I wished I would wake up and it was just a bad dream so often. I wish I had been allowed to wait until I was ready to make my own decision to pursue it.

secular39 · 31/12/2022 23:03

There are no biological markers for autism, so umm yeah it is a social construct, and society has given a label for behaviour that deviates from the norm

I don't think it's just socially construct. I do believe Autism has some genetic/biological markers. There already is some evidence of genetic markers that are presented in some Autistic individuals. Look at the Genome project. I'll give it another 50 years scientists to discover the genetic hallmarks of Autism.

AdInfinitum12 · 31/12/2022 22:59

secular39 · 31/12/2022 22:50

I'm sorry OP but I cannot believe your asking this question on Mumsnet. You are an adult, you know of the implications of what not having a diagnosis can bring. If you speak to many newly diagnosed autistic adults, they often say that they wish they had known that they were not "weird, "rude" or "dumb" at school/by others, but that they were Autistic.

At 12! She is not mature enough to see what a diagnosis can bring. You wouldn't ask this question if your DD had something medical going on (I.e. in underlining illness which can impact her life) so why is this any different??

Because actually at 12 she is able to give consent to be assessed. If she doesn't want to, she cannot be forced.

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:57

itsgettingweird · 31/12/2022 22:55

They won't allow entry to people who's autism cause them to many issues

Someone who doesn't have a diagnosis of autism of Asperger's or ASC won't get onto the military if they have issues that could affect them during service.

If there's no documentation and no obvious signs then they will almost certainly get in. After their in they will be the militarys issue.

Although the military do a fantastic job of breaking people and a terrible job of fixing them so I wouldn't advise anyone with any problems to go in.

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:56

itsgettingweird · 31/12/2022 22:51

I'm actually going back and forth on wether to formally have my children diagnosed. So far I'm on No as the benefits do not outweigh the issues that the diagnosis will cause.

Do you also though accept for many a diagnosis outweighs the negatives of not knowing or understanding themselves?

At their age this is not a concern. As they grow they will be familiar with neuro diversity and I will offer them the options they have available

itsgettingweird · 31/12/2022 22:55

They won't allow entry to people who's autism cause them to many issues

Someone who doesn't have a diagnosis of autism of Asperger's or ASC won't get onto the military if they have issues that could affect them during service.

JustKeepBuilding · 31/12/2022 22:55

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:47

And those who's Autsim effects them what they deem to be to severely will be rejected.

And I wouldn't assume their bar is particulary High.

Well yes, but at least people are now allowed to be considered on their individual merits rather than a blanket ban on everyone with autism and only considering some with Asperger Syndrome.

itsgettingweird · 31/12/2022 22:51

I'm actually going back and forth on wether to formally have my children diagnosed. So far I'm on No as the benefits do not outweigh the issues that the diagnosis will cause.

Do you also though accept for many a diagnosis outweighs the negatives of not knowing or understanding themselves?

secular39 · 31/12/2022 22:50

I'm sorry OP but I cannot believe your asking this question on Mumsnet. You are an adult, you know of the implications of what not having a diagnosis can bring. If you speak to many newly diagnosed autistic adults, they often say that they wish they had known that they were not "weird, "rude" or "dumb" at school/by others, but that they were Autistic.

At 12! She is not mature enough to see what a diagnosis can bring. You wouldn't ask this question if your DD had something medical going on (I.e. in underlining illness which can impact her life) so why is this any different??

itsgettingweird · 31/12/2022 22:49

There are no biological markers for autism, so umm yeah it is a social construct, and society has given a label for behaviour that deviates from the norm.

But that's the same for many diagnosis's.

My ds has a diagnosis of a very rare genetic neurological disorder. There isn't every gene for that discovered yet and many more are being discovered with research. He's on a genetics study.

His diagnosis is based on the behaviours of his muscles fitting a pattern.

Every single thing that has a name is a social construct - it's been named by someone finding similarities in things.

Autism, adhd, dyslexia, dyspraxia etc etc are all diagnosis ds based on a pattern of behaviours.

Autism isn't diagnosed if there is other explanations for a behaviour or it doesn't have an effect on every day living. Eg - if it isn't disabling.

My ds diagnosis of autism was actually reviving for him. He understood his brain was wired differently but yet there's a whole host of other humans who function that way.

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:47

JustKeepBuilding · 31/12/2022 22:43

It is not the same thing. The old rules didn’t allow anyone with autism to be considered, only some of those with Asperger Syndrome. The change in rules allows those who would have had an autism diagnosis rather than Asperger Syndrome diagnosis (if it was still diagnosed separately rather than all encompassed under ASD) to still be considered on an individual basis.

And those who's Autsim effects them what they deem to be to severely will be rejected.

And I wouldn't assume their bar is particulary High.

JustKeepBuilding · 31/12/2022 22:43

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:34

" those individuals suffering mild or entirely non-disabling Asperger’s Syndrome may meet the entry standards following an assessment by an occupational health physician and gaining a favourable assessment after pre-entry tests of suitability for military"

It's the same things just fluffier.

They won't allow entry to people who's autism cause them to many issues.

It is not the same thing. The old rules didn’t allow anyone with autism to be considered, only some of those with Asperger Syndrome. The change in rules allows those who would have had an autism diagnosis rather than Asperger Syndrome diagnosis (if it was still diagnosed separately rather than all encompassed under ASD) to still be considered on an individual basis.

AdInfinitum12 · 31/12/2022 22:40

TheSecretMayBeOut · 31/12/2022 19:31

Rubbish

you just don’t disclose it ! I didn’t for my job

You can't just "not disclose it" for the military, or it certainly wasn't back when I went through the process. As part of your application your medical records are sent straight from your doctors surgery.

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:36

Badlytrainedspaniel · 31/12/2022 22:34

@Bigbadfish - You aren’t making any sense

How so? A diagnosis isn't necessary or sometimes beneficial..

There was a really interesting discussion on TikTok about the negatives of a diagnosis. This was from people predominantly in the USA though so they faced further issues.

Badlytrainedspaniel · 31/12/2022 22:34

@Bigbadfish - You aren’t making any sense

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:34

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:32

No, because a broken arm say requires aid to heal. A diagnosis on the NHS epically isn't completely necessary right now.
A broken arm won't stop someone from their chosen career or emigrating to a chosen country.

" those individuals suffering mild or entirely non-disabling Asperger’s Syndrome may meet the entry standards following an assessment by an occupational health physician and gaining a favourable assessment after pre-entry tests of suitability for military"

It's the same things just fluffier.

They won't allow entry to people who's autism cause them to many issues.

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:32

Badlytrainedspaniel · 31/12/2022 22:30

@Bigbadfish - Your attitude is bizarre.

The same applies to mental and physical health issues as well as neurodevelopmental disorders. And ?

No, because a broken arm say requires aid to heal. A diagnosis on the NHS epically isn't completely necessary right now.
A broken arm won't stop someone from their chosen career or emigrating to a chosen country.

JustKeepBuilding · 31/12/2022 22:31

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:27

So....pretty much the exact same thing.

They will judge the person and how their ASD effects them.

Again, still a risk.

I don’t know how you can say they are “pretty much the same thing”. One says “Whilst those diagnosed with autism are excluded from joining the Services on medical grounds” the other says “considered on a case by case basis.”

CleoandRalf · 31/12/2022 22:30

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:27

So....pretty much the exact same thing.

They will judge the person and how their ASD effects them.

Again, still a risk.

It’s really not the same thing. You claimed it would rule them out, it will not automatically rule anyone out.

You've based your opinion on outdated information and instead of learning from that you’re doubling down.

Badlytrainedspaniel · 31/12/2022 22:30

@Bigbadfish - Your attitude is bizarre.

The same applies to mental and physical health issues as well as neurodevelopmental disorders. And ?

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:27

JustKeepBuilding · 31/12/2022 22:20

That quote is taken from here and is now out of date. Up to date information from the Navy’s eligibility guidance here states “Candidates with Autistic spectrum disorder will be considered on a case by case basis.”

So....pretty much the exact same thing.

They will judge the person and how their ASD effects them.

Again, still a risk.

BungleandGeorge · 31/12/2022 22:22

I do think Asperger’s (or a more acceptable name for it) is a useful distinction, and the entire classification and testing for all ND is very male orientated and discriminates against females. It all needs a total rethink really.

JustKeepBuilding · 31/12/2022 22:20

Bigbadfish · 31/12/2022 22:16

"Whilst those diagnosed with autism are excluded from joining the Services on medical grounds, those individuals suffering mild or entirely non-disabling Asperger’s Syndrome may meet the entry standards following an assessment by an occupational health physician and gaining a favourable assessment after pre-entry tests of suitability for military service"

That quote is taken from here and is now out of date. Up to date information from the Navy’s eligibility guidance here states “Candidates with Autistic spectrum disorder will be considered on a case by case basis.”

Swipe left for the next trending thread