Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to buy a house directly opposite affordable housing

342 replies

SpainToday · 31/12/2022 17:34

I have name changed for this because I expect to get annihilated.

DH and I are considering reserving a plot on a new development. I think all developments now need to have a certain amount of affordable housing. Our first choice of house would be directly opposite three affordable plots and this is a real sticking point. DH is also wary. There were originally 8 plots with our preferred design of house, they have all sold except this one and I suspect that’s the reason.

Of course we could always go with our Plan B type of house round the corner, but that seems such a shame. When we bought our current home, 12 years ago. One of the mortgage questions was proximity to any affordable housing, so its clearly an issue.

Am I worrying unnecessarily?

OP posts:
clairelouwho · 31/12/2022 19:27

I think that there is a lot of misconceptions about what affordable housing is.

Affordable housing is not the same thing as social or council or HA housing. Many, like me, who utilised the scheme to get on the ladder, OWN our properties and pay the mortgage just like everyone else.

We're not living there for free. Some maybe shared ownership-mine isn't-but other than the fact that we used a government scheme to get on the ladder-there's no difference from people who used the scheme to people who didn't.

There's nothing wrong with social housing either-but it's wise to stop conflating the two.

Gandalfsthong · 31/12/2022 19:27

My sister lives opposite a row of affordable housing on her estate, all lovely people/families, the house next door then are a nightmare! A little naive to assume you can tell what neighbours are like based on the type of house, but think you know that.

hennybeans · 31/12/2022 19:26

I think one factor to consider which might put me off living opposite affordable housing is size of the properties which can bring other issues.
Generally these houses are going to be smaller and terraced or semi detached. Builders like to cram as much in with as little parking and space for things like garages and bins as possible. If you’re paying a high price for a house that is detached with enough parking, etc, you are losing out a bit to have crowded houses opposite you where people will be parking anywhere they can squeeze a car, half on the pavements. Also bins will be everywhere as there generally isn’t enough space to keep them out of sight. This is no reflection on the people who live there, it’s just the way it’s designed. And if I was paying a premium for a bigger house, I would prefer to live near similar houses that were also built with enough space.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 31/12/2022 19:26

The fact your plot is the only one left in 8 tells you you're absolutely not the only buyer with this concern

Yes it probably does, because rightly or wrongly many would rather avoid such locations, which is why developers often try to avoid building them

As so many of us have said you can get issues anywhere, but while living in a council/HA/affordable property most certainly doesn't indicate a problem family, being a problem family very often means it'll be the council who are providing the housing - and because councils often get involved in all manner of lower cost properties it can be difficult to know who's housed the residents

All of which is why research is vital ...

toocold54 · 31/12/2022 19:25

other people get brand new houses for free and then trash them.

No one gets brand new houses for free.

They still have to pay rent or mortgage.

The rent is as high as private rent on new build estates, even with the social housing.

tolerable · 31/12/2022 19:24

to be honest-yes.you are bu. is as much\if not more chance your next door neighbours are drug dealers //paedos//undesireables //buy to let...than them who have to prove their legit earnings to afford entry level house purchase

DirectionToPerfection · 31/12/2022 19:23

You can't choose your neighbours OP, the only way to absolutely ensure peace and quiet is to live in a detached house in the countryside.

Lara9891 · 31/12/2022 19:23

@Badlytrainedspaniel I saw it and I know places like that exist but we certainly do live in social housing. My local housing association is lovely and I keep my house well presented and clean. I had awful experiences living in a fairly well to do areas because of the awful snobs looking down on us there.

PaperMonster · 31/12/2022 19:22

I live on a HA estate where most of us work in public sector eg social worker, nurse, teacher etc. There are a few private houses and we had sooooo much trouble with one of the owners. Thought he was a cut above because he owned. Total knob he was. And he had parties in the summer in the garden and his guests’ cars would block us all in. Thankfully he moved away and the loveliest people moved in. Really don’t know what the hell you’re expecting!!

toocold54 · 31/12/2022 19:21

YABU

Whatever worries you have about living opposite are going to be the exact same issues if you live around the corner surely?

What are your primary concerns?

Hairybaker · 31/12/2022 19:20

We lived in a shared ownership flat to get on the housing ladder. Four of the other floors in the apartment block were for social rent.
Yes there were some lovely tenants but the majority were not. Police were a regular presence and it was a nasty atmosphere. I would not live next to social housing again as our experience was awful.

myrtleWilson · 31/12/2022 19:20

fist bumps @witheringrowan for first class explanations of s106 etc including the counter cyclical nature of affordable provision in market downturn.... housing bods unite

Taillighttoobright · 31/12/2022 19:19

PinkSyCo · 31/12/2022 19:15

Can’t you save up and buy a house out in the sticks somewhere? It would be very unfair of you to inflict your snobby family on decent people.

OP just wants a peaceful life! Are you saying that this can’t be achieved in estates with affordable housing in them so her snobbiness would have to be invoked in the form of complaining about it?

DottieUncBab · 31/12/2022 19:19

Affordable housing is completely different to social housing. We live on an estate that was 40% affordable housing so there’s a couple of blocks of flats in the estate as they are considered affordable. In fact one of this blocks (two story block is directly opposite us). It’s completely fine.

Lozzybear · 31/12/2022 19:19

Don’t do it. I’ve been there and regretted it. Rubbish in the front gardens, smashed windows, anti-social behaviour….heartbreaking when you put everything into buying your house and other people get brand new houses for free and then trash them.

Taillighttoobright · 31/12/2022 19:17

OldTinHat · 31/12/2022 19:10

Absolutely do not buy that house. Your neighbours will loathe you for being arrogant and stuck up.

Buy on an estate and be part of a community. Don't want to be part of a community? Then buy somewhere in a field where you have to worry about no one but yourselves.

God, living in a field sounds brilliant. But then there would be fly-tipping on the verges.

PinkSyCo · 31/12/2022 19:15

Can’t you save up and buy a house out in the sticks somewhere? It would be very unfair of you to inflict your snobby family on decent people.

APurpleSquirrel · 31/12/2022 19:15

I live in a newish estate (10yo) - it has mostly owner-occupied properties, with a few affordable houses & a block of HA flats. We've been here since it was built. In that time the only times the police have been called out has been to the HA flats - including a brief manhunt - but that's only happened a few times.
Tbh the most problems arise from the owner-occupied properties, who all have 2-car drives/spaces & yet many seem to find parking on their actual parking... problematic. So instead of parking on their drive/space, they park in front of their house/opposite someone else's drive/or have more vehicles than they have spaces for.
So OP, tbh I'd not worry about the affordable housing, & look much more closely at the parking situation for the whole estate.

dolor · 31/12/2022 19:15

LOL so you don't want to live near poorer people, is that it? 🙄

clairelouwho · 31/12/2022 19:15

I am going to go off on a rant here because OP's post is directed at people like me and to be honest, it annoys me that people think like this.

All new build developments have to provide a certain amount of affordable housing. This is not the same thing as social housing or council houses. They are schemes, not dissimilar to the "Help to Buy" schemes of a couple of years ago. I happen to have bought a house under the "affordable housing" scheme on a new build estate.

My house is exactly the same as any other house on the estate. Only difference is that under the scheme I was able to qualify for a reduced price from its open market value. I couldn't afford to buy without it as I was a single buyer-and this scheme enabled me to get on the property ladder. I still had to provide a substantial deposit, go through all the financial checks and balances and prove I can pay the mortgage and then some.

They are schemes to help first-time buyers get on the property ladder and only apply to those who fall into very specific categories i.e. a) wouldn't be able to afford it at open market value even with the assistance of the Help to Buy scheme b) live or are an essential worker in that specific area etc and be able to prove you have sufficient ties/reasons to need to live in that area.

There is no difference from a person buying a house on the scheme that I did and a person getting support to buy a house through the Help to Buy scheme and yet only only of those would be classed as unsuitable by the likes of you to live opposite of. If you discovered your new neighbour had utilised Help to Buy to purchase their home, it's doubtful you'd cast the same aspersions about them.

I've lived here nearly 3 years and the only neighbours I've ever had issues with were those not in the affordable housing, having loud parties etc. Never any issues from those in the affordable housing.

I suppose people like OP think that only the well-off or those with dual-income households who can afford the prices should be able to buy a house and everyone else is just a lowly criminal rather than a normal person who just wants to get on the ladder and have a nice home for their families.

Please OP don't move in opposite-no one needs your or your DH's snobbery living near them.

WetLettuce2 · 31/12/2022 19:14

Disgusting thread.

Disgusting question.

Omgthishurts · 31/12/2022 19:13

I lived opposite affordable housing once OP. I came out in a rash and started wearing my dressing gown to Lidl. Don't risk it.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 31/12/2022 19:13

SpainToday · 31/12/2022 17:48

CrapBucket · Today 17:41
I bought a new build and they made a big deal of pointing out where all the affordable and social housing was on the plan... I couldn't care less. Most of the people round here are lovely, the only ones who aren't, live in the big posh house.

I had exactly the same comments from our sales negotiator, the affordable housing was a separate colour on the site plan. So if even the builder is warning people then there must be a reason? We are a very average household, and can’t afford to get this wrong.

I'm wondering what you think you'll catch by living in among the poor people? Most arseholes I've known have been well enough off. So not sure what you think it actually means?! No one is asking you to buy something in a slum area full of druggies etc. The poor people won't be able to afford the drugs if they have a mortgage. The arseholes aren't obliged to let you know in a similar manner. Hmm

imalreadygone · 31/12/2022 19:12

Naff off

C8H10N4O2 · 31/12/2022 19:12

SpainToday · 31/12/2022 17:55

Thank you to the the posters who have explained the concept to me. We are not looking to buy a large property, we are not particularly high earners and certainly are not snobs. We just want a quiet life.

When in a hole, its a good idea to stop digging, even if its to bury that aspidistra.