Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD cut contact with her father

35 replies

DarthvaderbuttoyouitsjustDarth · 31/12/2022 16:32

My Adult DD cut ties with her father. I don’t actually mind this as he left me and started a new life with someone else AND had more children which at the time destroyed me.

The thing is, he didn’t really do anything wrong to our DD. She spent time with him and new family and loved having siblings.

She had a spat with her SM when she was in her late 20s and because her DF didn’t back her up, she told him she didn’t want to see him anymore. This by default meant her teenage siblings too. I think she thought this wouldn’t happen but she hasn’t seen them or barely spoken to them in over 2 years.

DF my ex clearly isn’t going to chose his DD over his new family. DD is stubborn but I wonder how she would feel if her DF died or her relationship with siblings continues to deteriorate. It’s too late for SM - she doesn’t want my DD anywhere near her which makes things harder to patch up.

AIBU for worrying that my DD has made a mistake or should I just enjoy not having to hear about my ex and his family anymore?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hardboiledeggs · 01/01/2023 09:39

sounds like she made the right call to be honest. He’s not exactly father of the year.

RavenclawsPrincess · 01/01/2023 08:42

Yes it is mystifying as to why he isn’t trying harder. She did block him and tell him not to contact but if he really wanted to, he could bypass all that. I know him, he is very much non confrontational so he’s probably decided that’s what she wants and he’s respectful of that. He doesn’t understand she would probably like him to actually try.

I’d understand this if we were talking about a teen. But your DD is an adult. This is manipulative behaviour. If someone blocks you and tells you not to contact them, then to continue to do so or “find a way around it” could be construed as harassment. The reason he is not “trying harder” is he is probably respecting what he thinks her wishes are. Perhaps the SM has some hand in that, but your DD has made her wishes very clear by asking him not to contact her and blocking him and I don’t think she - or you - have any right to be mad that he’s respecting that. If she’s blocked him, she also might not know if he’s tried to contact her periodically because the contact will have been blocked by her phone/messaging app!

I’m sure her DF has his part in this, don’t get me wrong, but this is totally unreasonable. People aren’t mind readers.

Martialisthebestpup · 01/01/2023 08:40

When her half siblings are adults they might all pick up the relationship on their own terms without involving their parents’ generation. Or not. Your DD fell out with their mum so they might be mad at her too.
It’s really not your problem OP. This happened when your DD was in her late 20s. You were not involved in any way. Stay out of it unless asked.

Anniegetyourgun · 01/01/2023 08:38

I think, in your situation, I would put the concerns you have put here to your daughter. She's an adult, it's her choice, but as we all know adults don't always get things right just because they got bigger. So just mention that it worries you and give reasons, but provided she's given all this due consideration then, as others have said, respect her decision. Presumably you've brought up a reasonably intelligent woman. She may put your mind at rest or she may simply not have thought of that angle. Or, as someone else said, she may believe she's being loyal to you, and it may help to know you don't expect that of her. Then say no more on the subject unless she wants to discuss it. That would work for me and I think for my DC (well, two of them at least).

DarthvaderbuttoyouitsjustDarth · 01/01/2023 08:33

Yes it is mystifying as to why he isn’t trying harder. She did block him and tell him not to contact but if he really wanted to, he could bypass all that. I know him, he is very much non confrontational so he’s probably decided that’s what she wants and he’s respectful of that. He doesn’t understand she would probably like him to actually try. The SM will have also blocked him from doing this as he’s quite weak. Oh well I’m just going to be there to pick up the pieces when she realises she can’t ever go back to how things were.

OP posts:
Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 01/01/2023 08:23

Is the fact that her dad isn’t even trying to make any contact with her not telling?

I mean if she did something horrendous or was generally problematic I’d understand.

However, if there was simply a minor falling out that has got a bit too dramatic, wouldn’t a normal loving father attempt to make contact with their child? Even just a text to check how she is, ask to chat about things?

Obviously It’s just a theory, as I don’t know the wider context.

Wibbly1008 · 01/01/2023 01:00

I get you are worried but there could be so many other dynamics going on for your dd that have informed this decision. It’s not your game, so leave her to make her choices and do as she wants.

gonnabeok · 01/01/2023 00:57

She's an adult. Her choice. He's an adult - he could make an effort being her dad and older but he's not. Leave it alone - it's not your fight to have.

WhiskeyStones · 01/01/2023 00:31

She’s made her choice, respect that. Don’t risk your own relationship with your daughter. If she wants nothing to do with her father, she’s probably best without his kids as well, less drama.

hourbyhour101 · 01/01/2023 00:21

Thisisworsethananticpated · 31/12/2022 23:33

hourbyhour101

some major projecting there

I think you might need to look up that definition. It's what I did when I was in similar situation to op.Not for my ex or sm but for my daughter..

Op has so far done none of what I did. But she's posted which makes me think that a echo chamber isn't what she wanted. If she was 100% she was right on all fronts and all was well, I doubt she would have posted.

I'm a adult step child as well. Not that that's worth much here.

But if your triggered or offended by what I put then that speaks to you more than it does to me.

tillytown · 31/12/2022 23:48

Your ex didn't have to side with his wife, he could have stayed out of it, by picking his wife over his child he told her she wasn't important. He could have continued to see his child, he could have continued to call/text and made sure the siblings all saw each other, he is the father, this was his responsibility, he hasn't done any of it because he doesn't want to. There is no way I'd be telling my child to try to make up with someone who clearly doesn't care about them.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 31/12/2022 23:33

hourbyhour101

some major projecting there

BabyOnBoard90 · 31/12/2022 23:26

YANBU.

if she's estranged from her siblings too then it sounds like she's a significant part of the problem

hourbyhour101 · 31/12/2022 23:20

Personally I think it was something and nothing that SM got all upset about but the fact DF took SM side was what really went nuclear with DD.

Also I really loath to say this but in for a penny.

You might think it was nothing, but clearly your ex didn't, the sm didn't, and some of the family don't (since family gatherings are awkward) and actually your Dd didn't think it was nothing because she wouldn't have done it right ?

So unless you share more of what happened. It's doubtful really bloody doubtful it's nothing. And as I said I have been in a similar situation and was no angel myself.. but still

hourbyhour101 · 31/12/2022 23:17

@DarthvaderbuttoyouitsjustDarth She made something that was all about the SM into a feud with her DF

So this is interesting. She started a fight with her father because her father didn't "pick her" and was focusing on sm for some reason, got ticked off started a fight with Dad and so went off in a strop for 2 years and you allowed it because it was better for your mental well-being.

You mention she could have coped if sm wasn't in the picture just dad and the kids ?

Have you thought that your daughter felt disloyal to you, by "accepting the situation" therefore went nuclear.

I say this as someone who's ex DH shagged around while I was pregnant with our second baby (after our first was born dtill) and went on to marry that women and that women be my Dd sm.

Guess what I like her, probably more than I do my ex. She's kind to my Dd and she wasn't married to me, he was. And Dd deserves a relationship with her dad free from guilt or loyalty binds that would only cause her damage in the future. Does it suck ?Sure. But I would walk over hot coal for my girl to make sure she doesn't pay for his mistakes.

It's not a pick me dance. It didn't need to be a pick me dance and I think you know you should have said that.

I'm sorry your ex was a shit and he left you, but he didn't leave your daughter. But if you were (understandably upset) and let your daughter blame the new sm. you have done a disservice to your daughter . Greatly. And you could help her fix this instead of choosing what's comfortable and preferred to you. For her.

He broke your marriage vows, if your daughters angry. She should be most angry at him. But it seems so very par of the course blame the women entirely. But these men aren't lured in by black magic.

At some point you just have to move on, which if you can't listen to info about them, shows me deep down you haven't.

The opposite of love isn't hate its indifference.

Fix this. And yes I know I'm going against the grain and MN ethos here and will be slaughtered but I said what I said.

DarthvaderbuttoyouitsjustDarth · 31/12/2022 22:47

As much as I hate to say it because he hurt me badly, my ex was always really good to our DD but he moved on and she wasn’t really comfortable with the situation. She was a pre teen when it all happened.
When she would stay with them, I think she found it too much to accept. I think if it were just her, DF and her siblings she would have still been speaking to them now. It was the SM and the fact DF took SM side. Personally I think it was something and nothing that SM got all upset about but the fact DF took SM side was what really went nuclear with DD.

OP posts:
Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 31/12/2022 22:23

Reugny · 31/12/2022 21:44

She isn't her step-mother's child so will always be second to her own children.

She is her father's child and while sometimes especially, when she was not an adult, would be first his priorities over which child needs more from him will chop and change.

I meant second fiddle to her siblings in terms of her father.

obviously parents should support whichever child needs it in whatever way needed. However some parents do have favourites or black sheep. I wondered if there was a wider context of her feeling she wasn’t treated well by her father or was scape goated etc.
Hard to know if she’s reasonable or not without knowing about how healthy her general relationship was with her father.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 31/12/2022 21:56

I’d support her as she’s made this decision as an adult
but gently encourage into some therapy to help process such a momentous decision

Reugny · 31/12/2022 21:48

Tell your DD that when you parents are all dead that the only people she will share a family history with are her siblings including her half-siblings.

Then leave her to do the right thing.

My mum told me this to help stop me arguing with all my siblings.

Reugny · 31/12/2022 21:44

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 31/12/2022 17:36

Is there a wider context here? Eg was her step mother difficult to her, we’re things difficult during contact, was she always second fiddle to her siblings? If so then maybe cutting contact was right.

I understand you don’t want her to have regrets, but on the other hand do you want her to continue a relationship that is unhealthy/damaging.

I would encourage her to maintain links with her siblings and then leave it at that.

She isn't her step-mother's child so will always be second to her own children.

She is her father's child and while sometimes especially, when she was not an adult, would be first his priorities over which child needs more from him will chop and change.

DarthvaderbuttoyouitsjustDarth · 31/12/2022 21:38

You just want your kids even as adults to not make major life choices they live to regret.
I feel like she did act rashly and I know as her mother that she will regret it one day. She made something that was all about the SM into a feud with her DF and ultimately the SM got what she’d always wanted - my DD out of the picture. It’s sad. Makes for very awkward wider family gatherings too.

OP posts:
Mrsjayy · 31/12/2022 17:45

DarthvaderbuttoyouitsjustDarth · 31/12/2022 17:30

Indeed he has made very little effort since. It’s not him I’m concerned with - I have no time for him or his wife. I worry my DD will regret the estrangement from her siblings. The only contact she has from them is the odd text message. Admittedly I know she could try harder with them too but I dare not say that and am trying to stay out of it.

I think the odd text message is better than nothing, she might regret stuff and that really is a shame but she has her own mind.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 31/12/2022 17:38

The thing is, OP, we all make choices we regret. If this has been going on for 2 years then either she doesn't regret it (having had time to think about it) or she's too stubborn to go back on it. If all she's had from them is the odd text it doesn't sound like they are making much effort, either.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 31/12/2022 17:36

Is there a wider context here? Eg was her step mother difficult to her, we’re things difficult during contact, was she always second fiddle to her siblings? If so then maybe cutting contact was right.

I understand you don’t want her to have regrets, but on the other hand do you want her to continue a relationship that is unhealthy/damaging.

I would encourage her to maintain links with her siblings and then leave it at that.

DarthvaderbuttoyouitsjustDarth · 31/12/2022 17:33

I’m probably not articulating this very well in the interest of keeping it brief.

in a nutshell I just don’t want my DD to regret the choices she has made in her estrangement from her DF and his DC. At the same time I enjoy not hearing about them and feel a bit bad for that.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread