Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that if you get to the point of an NHS ASD assessment that you probably do have some form of ASD?

106 replies

Bepisicola · 31/12/2022 13:59

AIBU to think that if you get to the point of an NHS ASD assessment that you probably do have some form of ASD?

I know that managing to get a referral and then assessment for ASD on the NHS is about as likely as scoring a private audience with the almighty, therefore I am given to believe that if you’re ‘bad’ enough to get to this point, then you probably will get some sort of diagnosis?

This is my situation and the psychiatrist has said she does not think I have ASD. I disagree and am wondering where to turn to next?

OP posts:
Boulshired · 31/12/2022 14:14

As adults there are difficulties with the diagnosis process in that some other causes can lead to trait like behaviour but that are not part of ASD as they are not lifelong. There are links with Anorexia and ASD, but anorexia also can lead to ASD like traits. Differentiating the two from someone who was not diagnosed with ASD as a child is more difficult. Other mental health conditions and other conditions such as ADHD make the scoring complicated.

helloisitmeyourelookingfor · 31/12/2022 14:10

I'm a senco and do quite a few referrals

I'd say about a third that go all the way to panel are diagnosed, a third are 'watch and wait' where they are reviewed 2 years later (mainly girls) and a third are recognised as having traits but do not meet the diagnostic criteria

But you are right, you need significant traits to get to assessment

PermanentTemporary · 31/12/2022 14:09

Possibly. I would agree that getting a diagnosis of ASD is not the same as having it.

I would say the NHS paediatric service in my county is hugely different for different ages. The preschool clinic is excellent AFAIK. Then so far I know two children really well who only got into the service at primary school age and were then reviewed at secondary school age. Both were told they were not autistic by the primary school age clinic and were then diagnosed around year 10. The parents of those children say they aren't the only ones this happened to.

The thing is that both of these children were very straightforwardly autistic - really not subtle or difficult to diagnose. But the specialist clinics are so thinly spread- you could be talking one individual who is a clinical lead for a county whose word carries huge weight in the clinic, and they may have an outlier view of autism.

I hope you can get a second opinion if you need one.

entropynow · 31/12/2022 14:04

Bepisicola · 31/12/2022 13:59

AIBU to think that if you get to the point of an NHS ASD assessment that you probably do have some form of ASD?

I know that managing to get a referral and then assessment for ASD on the NHS is about as likely as scoring a private audience with the almighty, therefore I am given to believe that if you’re ‘bad’ enough to get to this point, then you probably will get some sort of diagnosis?

This is my situation and the psychiatrist has said she does not think I have ASD. I disagree and am wondering where to turn to next?

A diagnosis is based on criteria, if you do not meet them, you don't get one.
That is not the same as saying "100% neurotypical, carry on"
It's possible to have autistic traits which may respond to certain approaches and life hacks.
It really depends what the diagnosis would be for. If to help signpost you to help and support, as an adult you can find these yourself. If for other reasons, eg disability support, could be more tricky. But that depends what the presenting issues are.

loafintheoven · 31/12/2022 14:04

That's a really difficult question to answer. What would you do differently if you got a diagnosis? Would it materially change anything for you? Are you wondering whether to stay on the waiting list? And what does the psychiatrist think? I don't think it's an unreasonable assumption, but I certainly wouldn't say you're guaranteed a diagnosis.

BackBeatTheWord · 31/12/2022 14:03

The people who get to the point of having an assessment are obviously far more likely to have ASD than a random person in the general population. They're also probably suffering from symptoms which make their life difficult to have gone to the trouble of getting their assessment. NO I don't think in all cases they have ASD though. There are other issues which can present in a superficially similiar way which is why it takes a highly trained professional to actually carry out the assessment (rather than just the GP or self diagnosis).

If you genuinely feel you weren't properly assessed and it's important to you to get a diagnosis could you save up for a private assessment? The NHS services are highly stretched and a private appointment tends to be longer and more in depth. They could possibly also investigate other explanations for you.