Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say the NHS does not have too many admin staff?

131 replies

Leakingtoilet · 31/12/2022 10:10

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/12/30/nhs-has-many-admin-staff-not-enough-managers/

We don't have enough staff to get the job done, hence the fact we are constantly offering admin and secretarial overtime. It seems that way in most other departments that I have dealings with. Plus it's really difficult to recruit to vacant posts.

Anyone have a different experience?

OP posts:
FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 31/12/2022 11:37

I really can't understand why there is still so much paperwork in the NHS. I have dodgy eyes so have been under the Opthamology team since I was 4, I have this huge thick file that is dragged out every 6 months to circulate through the hospital, being dropped on a desk then transferred to another desk then taken into a test room and dropped on another desk. On testing day when I have to have a whole host of different eye exams and stick my head in a bazillion different machines all in different rooms culminating in a 2 min chat with the consultant, I spend more time waiting for my file to catch up with me so they can do the test than I do actually doing the tests.

Why isn't it all electronic now?

I know it can be because when I was in for my gallbladder via A&E they were updating on the computer and using phone apps.

Then there's the somewhat ridiculous letter in triplicate that's put in my hospital file, sent to me by post and sent to my GP by post who put it in a pile and finally get round to scanning it and adding it to my GP record a month later which I can access via an app on my phone. Why can this not just be added to my NHS record by the hospital and my GP receive a notification of a new entry?

Any BA/process analyst would have a meltdown trying to get past the complete lack of efficiency.

WimbyAce · 31/12/2022 11:34

In my team we are generally understaffed at grass roots level which is due to staff retention and recruitment. I do agree there seem to be too many in management level although can't comment on what they actually do.

Lemonyfuckit · 31/12/2022 11:33

Maki79 · 31/12/2022 11:04

Have you all read the article?

The nhs badly need tech investment. Not least because it hugely improves patient safety. Digital systems that are joined up between primary care, acute care, social care are key to reducing the requirement of administrative tasks, and releasing time to care for clinicians.

There are not nearly enough managers ime. I am one. I work ridiculous hours, as do all my peers and its pretty thankless. This is supported in the article. The nhs has less managers than other countries. My pay on paper is good, but it's barely minimum wage when I work it out as an hourly figure. It's unsustainable.

In my experience (corporate rather than clinical), in my trust:

Execs/senior mgrs are driven by anxiety to meet their targets/financial sustainability/PR on top of the hugely stressful operational circumstances trying to keep patients safe. This stress feeds down the chain.

Very difficult to recruit, therefore too many temporary staff, charging high daily rates, and demotivating permanent staff as well as reducing overall funding available.

Across all bandings, there are not enough admin and clerical staff who apply critical thinking to their tasks. Not enough willingness to learn and develop, again this is across all bandings. Several gems of staff who carry the load of others.

My DH is in a similar role and your post absolutely chimes with his experience of the same.
Managers get demonised (or indeed all non-clinical staff) but the reality is they're needed so that clinical staff aren't spending even more time doing admin, and are badly needed in terms of the large scale projects required to update the technology and improve efficiency. I can't read the article as it's behind a paywall but I don't think pitting managers against admin is the answer. Efficiency of process is required but that takes people to deliver it. And properly remunerating and attracting permanent staff to fill some of the many recruitment gaps rather than the counter-productive spending on temporary staff at vastly higher day rates.

Alexandra2001 · 31/12/2022 11:33

About 54% of NHS staff are professionally & medically qualified, then add in porters and other non pro trained but patient facing roles.....

For my DD she could not do her job without a team of admin staff in the discharge team..... all worked off their feet and on just above NMW.

However, i don't understand the internal market stuff... and the privatisation of so much that should be NHS, wheelchairs and other mobility aids all private sector, all charge a fucking bomb to clean and supply.

How much is all this costing the NHS in additional staff and private profit?

FangedFrisbee · 31/12/2022 11:31

7Worfs · 31/12/2022 10:55

My only experience with NHS is maternity ward stays. The midwives do a ridiculous amount of admin.
Every time they do rounds for painkillers etc they spend more time documenting what they are doing than the action itself.

It's not that kind of admin. Midwives and nurses can't outsource that kind of admin, no one else can sign to say they've referred to a dr or given a medication etc,
Our PIN is worth too much. If something happened it wouldn't stand up in court

I think this thread is about admin staff who send letters and fill appointments etc, which we need more of!

rookiemere · 31/12/2022 11:29

It's very easy to say flippantly there are too much or too little of certain staff, without looking at root cause of the issues.

Someone in another thread said that appointments were all sent out by letter, meaning loads of people missing surgery and "wasting " NHS time because they didn't know they were meant to be there.

It feels like they need external people to go in and really analyse the problems and come up with solutions that are realistic to instigate.

Flapjackquack · 31/12/2022 11:23

I’d say there are too many admin staff in the wrong places. DH works an admin role and is run off his feet. When I worked there for a short period before I started the career I have now, I spent a huge amount of time twiddling my thumbs. I told them when I left the role needed to be part time at most. Still hired someone new full time.

Recently I haven’t been to an appointment without there being at least two receptionists who spend most of the time chatting to each other and doing nothing else. I know the secretaries tend to be very busy though.

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 11:23

of course there arent too many admin staff!
there are too many unnecessary managers
we know this
where on earth does the Telegraph get its opinions?
how soon do you want your letter?
do you want your email/phone call answered?

Untitledsquatboulder · 31/12/2022 11:21

Having just had an unbelievable struggle to match deliveries of medical supplies to actual need (I have a big stack of ùnneeded feeds in my garage despite turning away 2 deliveries) I think YANBU. Certainly I believe our local hospital would save a fortune or at least break even if it employed an admin officer to deal with ordering and supplies.

BitterTits · 31/12/2022 11:18

We band 3s and 5s did the legwork. The organisation of the department was far too top heavy and would have functioned much more efficiently if there weren't so many band 7s sitting in offices conducting research. The balance was wrong.

wonkyheadwoes · 31/12/2022 11:15

BitterTits · 31/12/2022 11:05

I worked in audiology for a couple of years as a band 3 technician. In a dept of approximately 2, staffing was as follows:

2 admin
6 band 3s
3 band 5s
5 band 6s
6 band 7s
3 band 8+

I genuinely believe that therein lies the problem.

You'll need to explain why this was a problem?

BitterTits · 31/12/2022 11:06

25

BitterTits · 31/12/2022 11:05

I worked in audiology for a couple of years as a band 3 technician. In a dept of approximately 2, staffing was as follows:

2 admin
6 band 3s
3 band 5s
5 band 6s
6 band 7s
3 band 8+

I genuinely believe that therein lies the problem.

Swg · 31/12/2022 11:05

I have cancer. A lot of my life depends on being able to get through to consultant’s secretarys. Appointment needed to be cancelled due to covid and I need an override because the next regular one is two months away? Secretary. Prescription not gone through to GP? Secretary. Critical illness form not through? Secretary.

Unfortunately these things are getting harder and harder to get sorted I presume due to lack of staff. Prescription issues regularly take days to sort - which is not ideal when they need to be ordered in and I need them to not die. A missed appointment took a week to be able to contact someone to reschedule - and that was a week of constant calling. And the critical illness cover - cover which will allow me to rest, recover and not worry about work for a year - took six months, PALS and a letter to my MP to sort.

All of which makes me a terrible drain on the economy. You can’t work if you literally need a week a month to call around and organise your illness. You can’t resign work to be ill if you don’t know if your insurance will pay out. You just sit there on sick leave for months being ill and expensive.

7Worfs · 31/12/2022 11:05

if I had the powers, I wouldn’t look to hire more admin, I’d automate.
For example in maternity: each mother is issued a bracelet that can scan QR codes and link directly to the patient record.
Every time there is a round of obs/painkillers etc just use the correct code on their bracelet, done.
Then there can be automatic reminders for repeat actions at certain intervals.
This wouldn’t even be that expensive to set up - a fraction of the failed Track and Trace.
Care will improve so much by freeing up midwives to focus on patients.

Maki79 · 31/12/2022 11:04

Have you all read the article?

The nhs badly need tech investment. Not least because it hugely improves patient safety. Digital systems that are joined up between primary care, acute care, social care are key to reducing the requirement of administrative tasks, and releasing time to care for clinicians.

There are not nearly enough managers ime. I am one. I work ridiculous hours, as do all my peers and its pretty thankless. This is supported in the article. The nhs has less managers than other countries. My pay on paper is good, but it's barely minimum wage when I work it out as an hourly figure. It's unsustainable.

In my experience (corporate rather than clinical), in my trust:

Execs/senior mgrs are driven by anxiety to meet their targets/financial sustainability/PR on top of the hugely stressful operational circumstances trying to keep patients safe. This stress feeds down the chain.

Very difficult to recruit, therefore too many temporary staff, charging high daily rates, and demotivating permanent staff as well as reducing overall funding available.

Across all bandings, there are not enough admin and clerical staff who apply critical thinking to their tasks. Not enough willingness to learn and develop, again this is across all bandings. Several gems of staff who carry the load of others.

Krustykrabpizza · 31/12/2022 11:04

Yes the bloody letters back and forth are ridiculous.

It's not just about how many staff there are, but about how efficient the processes are. I spent some time as a typist for hospital letters and it was dull, inefficient and long-winded. I was fast but we had another typist who spent a lot of time staring in to space and did 2-3 letters an hour.

Fathercrossmas · 31/12/2022 10:58

It needs large scale digitalisation. My GP shouldn't have to write a letter to a consultant to then receive a letter back, to then write another letter etc etc to get a simple appointment. It should be an online booking system with no letters! All records in the same place. I know they are trying but the whole system is so clunky.

Rebelyells · 31/12/2022 10:57

The number of admin staff could perhaps be reduced if the NHS invested in modern and functioning IT systems that integrated across primary and secondary care.

An example:
In outpatients a clinician sees a patient then dictates a letter, a medical secretary types the letter, someone posts the letter, the GP admin team scan the letter and upload it to their system. This process takes months

7Worfs · 31/12/2022 10:55

My only experience with NHS is maternity ward stays. The midwives do a ridiculous amount of admin.
Every time they do rounds for painkillers etc they spend more time documenting what they are doing than the action itself.

TodayIsFridayHooray · 31/12/2022 10:55

In my team (and in the whole trust as far as I can tell) there are way too many managers and not enough admin ...

AlexandraJJ · 31/12/2022 10:51

It’s becoming increasingly difficult to attract good admin staff, they can be paid better elsewhere. I’ve worked in a number of NHS trusts and the ratio of clinical to non clinical staff has been roughly the same at 80:20. You have to have back office staff to keep the whole thing moving. Articles like this frustrate me. It’s easy to take random pot shots at things in isolation and focus on that without viewing all the issues and prioritising and joining up the dots as a whole.

TheDietStartsTomorrowOrMaybeTheDayAfter · 31/12/2022 10:46

I work in the NHS. In our trust, there’s so many at 8A and above. Proportionally, it seems like there’s far too many that are needed to manage the bands 2-7. You need more on the ground and fewer at the top earning the mega bucks. My manager regularly tells me that they put posts out to advert 2-3 times before they find someone. Sometimes no-one at all even applies!!

AIBU123456789 · 31/12/2022 10:34

Catoneverychair · 31/12/2022 10:17

There are too many managers.

Absolutely. Every time something/someone isn't working as it should we just add another line of management to fill the gaps.

Bestcatmum · 31/12/2022 10:31

Same here, we don't have enough admin staff send we rely on them heavily or we can't get anything done.