Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say the NHS does not have too many admin staff?

131 replies

Leakingtoilet · 31/12/2022 10:10

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/12/30/nhs-has-many-admin-staff-not-enough-managers/

We don't have enough staff to get the job done, hence the fact we are constantly offering admin and secretarial overtime. It seems that way in most other departments that I have dealings with. Plus it's really difficult to recruit to vacant posts.

Anyone have a different experience?

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 13:01

there are bar codes in use already

CarPoor · 31/12/2022 13:00

7Worfs · 31/12/2022 11:05

if I had the powers, I wouldn’t look to hire more admin, I’d automate.
For example in maternity: each mother is issued a bracelet that can scan QR codes and link directly to the patient record.
Every time there is a round of obs/painkillers etc just use the correct code on their bracelet, done.
Then there can be automatic reminders for repeat actions at certain intervals.
This wouldn’t even be that expensive to set up - a fraction of the failed Track and Trace.
Care will improve so much by freeing up midwives to focus on patients.

But that's a system in place in lots of NHS trusts? A bracelet you scan to link to records. But you also need a system which has all their records/obs/meds imputed for that to work. Which exists but is expensive and difficult to set up I terms of the infrastructure needed.

You still need to do the obs for every patient, and input them. You still need to document the medications you've given and doses, you can't just scan a bracelet and then the system knows you've given paracetamol. Lots of trusts have online prescribing systems that give you tasks or reminders but youve got to be looking at the computer, which is obviously normally during a drugs round. So this system doesn't prevent you doing a drugs round

I don't really see what problem this is solving or how it would save the NHS any time or money.

Yes a proper integrated electronic system does save money and time but there isn't just a simple "oh scan a bracelet" solution that doesn't cost billions to set up

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 12:59

She added that creating region-wide shared back office systems could cut down on this bureaucracy.

she has a pipe dream

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 12:58

Ms Hewitt said by international comparisons the NHS has too few managers, but too many administrative staff.

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 12:56

i did @Blossomtoes
no need to be superior

Blossomtoes · 31/12/2022 12:44

where on earth does the Telegraph get its opinions?

From Patricia Hewitt who was pad by the government to carry out a review of the NHS. A huge amount of admin work could be automated with the right IT infrastructure. If you’d bothered to read the article you’d know this.

CremeEggThief · 31/12/2022 12:43

Eh? Surely everyone knows too many managers is a massive issue in the NHS and has been since at least the early 90s?

EddietheEagle · 31/12/2022 12:42

7Worfs · 31/12/2022 10:55

My only experience with NHS is maternity ward stays. The midwives do a ridiculous amount of admin.
Every time they do rounds for painkillers etc they spend more time documenting what they are doing than the action itself.

That's just basic level nursing. Everything had to be documented by the registered nurse or midwife dispensing the medication, or on paper it has not been done.

This is not an admin task.

Catmuffin · 31/12/2022 12:42

The government constantly finds scapegoats to blame for their failures and underfunding. The Telegraph is their mouthpiece. Constant scapegoating makes this country a nastier place than it was before the tories were in power

CarPoor · 31/12/2022 12:40

Jimboscott0115 · 31/12/2022 11:59

I'm in the middle here. I believe the NHS does have ridiculous amounts of admin staff but it's not the workers fault, it's the poor IT systems. Last time I was in a hospital I was in a waiting room while my daughter got an x-ray and I was watching the sheer volume of paper being moved between files by the staff at the reception desk thinking what a huge amount of wasted resources there was.

However, I think it's pretty clear that these paper shuffling roles are needed because the management and leadership simply haven't invested in the technology that could take much of this away, so the staff are clearly needed. There are hugely complex international corporations with thousands of staff yet with fractions of the admin roles needed, simply because they have the systems in place to remove the need for paper being moved from one file to another, or one department to another.

However, there are some clearly archaic processes in the NHS that would save significant time. My daughter got her x-ray and then proceeded to wait an hour while the x-ray images were burnt onto a CD that she then had to take with her to her dentist. I mean, come on - this is ridiculous both in terms of time, effort and resources to simply get some images to my daughter/ her dentist - they're only digital images and email exists.

So no, the NHS isn't overstaffed with admin people for the systems and processes they have in place, but those systems and processes need a huge overhaul.

An email copy of xray is not diagnostic. You cannot change the contrast etc. You need the image to be on proper xray software.

Hospitals can transfer xrays electronically to each other, but they can't to a dental practice as a dental practice is a private business and not part of the NHS. You can send a copy via email but it's a bit pointless, and again only if the dentist has an encrypted email. This is a dentist issue not an NHS one.

I think everyone thinks "oh just update the systems". But in practice it's not that simple. It's not an easy problem to fix.

The letters seem sounds archaic (although in reality most GPS get electronic copies of letters). But it's not that simple to fix. For example dictating is much quicker than typing, so okay you can send an email which is basically what most letter systems are. You need to be able to talk to each other as clinicians. So what you call each other? But GPs/consultants don't have time to answer each others calls while running a clinic. You type up your own emails? But that takes time away from seeing patients

You book patients straight into a consultants clinic? But then the consultant has no control in who they see and no opportunity to triage - resulting in wastage and also missed cancers etc

pianaoff · 31/12/2022 12:39

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 11:40

although i dont really know how the GPs work their electronic systems
do they print off the letters and scan onto notes
or just scan onto notes?

In our areas of different surgeries and the surgery I work in. All letters come through electronically to our system. They all sit in a batch and admin/reception will then file into the patients record. The system picks up the patients details, we just need to change the letter type to whatever department it came from. We check if there is any action and if so pass to the GP. I'm honestly shocked all surgery don't work like this.

pianaoff · 31/12/2022 12:35

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 31/12/2022 11:37

I really can't understand why there is still so much paperwork in the NHS. I have dodgy eyes so have been under the Opthamology team since I was 4, I have this huge thick file that is dragged out every 6 months to circulate through the hospital, being dropped on a desk then transferred to another desk then taken into a test room and dropped on another desk. On testing day when I have to have a whole host of different eye exams and stick my head in a bazillion different machines all in different rooms culminating in a 2 min chat with the consultant, I spend more time waiting for my file to catch up with me so they can do the test than I do actually doing the tests.

Why isn't it all electronic now?

I know it can be because when I was in for my gallbladder via A&E they were updating on the computer and using phone apps.

Then there's the somewhat ridiculous letter in triplicate that's put in my hospital file, sent to me by post and sent to my GP by post who put it in a pile and finally get round to scanning it and adding it to my GP record a month later which I can access via an app on my phone. Why can this not just be added to my NHS record by the hospital and my GP receive a notification of a new entry?

Any BA/process analyst would have a meltdown trying to get past the complete lack of efficiency.

In our area it's all electronic and never seen a patient walking round with their own files unless they've asked for all the letters themselves to have. Surely it's on the system already?

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 12:35

dont knock part time workers!
it is very behind the times imo to force all staff to work full time

lieselotte · 31/12/2022 12:34

No, it seems clear to me from what relatives (and people on here) have said that the admin situation in the NHS is dire. Consultants' secretaries generally only working part-time and no cover for the whole week just being one example.

It would also seem sensible to me for GPs to be assisted by medically qualified assistants who could do a lot of the referral letters etc so they don't have to work 12+ hour days doing admin. A GP doesn't need to do every referral letter, many will be very routine and it would make sense for a para-professional to do them, and save the GP's time for the more complex cases and letters.

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 12:33

the hospital 40 minutes away uses the same computer system as some of the departments where i work, not all.
but in a different way!
and we cannot see what each others input

MyNameIsErinQuin · 31/12/2022 12:31

We’ve used the NHS more this year than ever (and very grateful to all of the fabulous people who we’ve seen) and my observation would be that there is an enormous issue with systems. We are at GOSH and have to provide paper copies of letters from local hospital which are then copy typed into their system. GOSH send me correspondence via the app which requires action by Gp. It’s quicker for me to print it, take it to the Gp for admin to scan and send to the doctor than waiting for it to appear directly. Local hospital requires blood test and asks GP to action. I get the letter electronically but the Gp needs paper copy in the post. Which they scan, print, give to Gp who signs, then it’s rescanned then actioned. It’s madness and must drive NHS staff crazy!

pianaoff · 31/12/2022 12:30

Fathercrossmas · 31/12/2022 10:58

It needs large scale digitalisation. My GP shouldn't have to write a letter to a consultant to then receive a letter back, to then write another letter etc etc to get a simple appointment. It should be an online booking system with no letters! All records in the same place. I know they are trying but the whole system is so clunky.

This is what we have in our area. All letters are electronic and come straight to us through system1. It goes into a big batch and admin then puts onto their records but the system picks up the patients details, we just change to what type of letter it is.

Florenz · 31/12/2022 12:29

Tell the staff they can have a pay rise only if they accept modernisation and efficiency drives which will mean the loss of many jobs.

CarPoor · 31/12/2022 12:28

To update the systems tou need a load of new infrastructure. You need new computers, better WiFi etc. It costs so much. You need teams of people transferring existing paper records to modern computer systems. It's a massive task

pianaoff · 31/12/2022 12:28

Rebelyells · 31/12/2022 10:57

The number of admin staff could perhaps be reduced if the NHS invested in modern and functioning IT systems that integrated across primary and secondary care.

An example:
In outpatients a clinician sees a patient then dictates a letter, a medical secretary types the letter, someone posts the letter, the GP admin team scan the letter and upload it to their system. This process takes months

We use system1 and all letters are electronic. It comes from the hospital or where ever straight to us. We do get the odd occasional letter in the post and we do scan on record etc. But the rest are electronic.

pianaoff · 31/12/2022 12:26

The surgery I work in has 9000 patients across 2 sites. Yesterday there was only 4 admin/reception staff in. (Recetion staff do the the admin) we had to close one surgery due to no staff after the one covering was due to finish. Weekly we have 2 or 3 staff at either site. Most shifts working alone.

I blame management & the partners because they only offer minimum wage when every other surgery in our area are on above £10.00 and then incentives on top. No one in their right mind would come to our surgery when the one down the road offers a significant amount more. I only stay because the hours suit me and I don't drive yet but I will be out as soon as I pas my test.

CarPoor · 31/12/2022 12:26

I would say too many ineffective managers. Not enough admin staff.

A proper up to date system across the NHS would be massive time saver. I think the NHS wastes huge amount of money on subpar electronic systems that don't work and need changing in a few years.

But ultimately I think the problem is the NHS has even running on empty for years, and it gets emptier and emptier. And it's never going to be as simple as employ more admin

jevoudrais · 31/12/2022 12:24

7Worfs · 31/12/2022 11:05

if I had the powers, I wouldn’t look to hire more admin, I’d automate.
For example in maternity: each mother is issued a bracelet that can scan QR codes and link directly to the patient record.
Every time there is a round of obs/painkillers etc just use the correct code on their bracelet, done.
Then there can be automatic reminders for repeat actions at certain intervals.
This wouldn’t even be that expensive to set up - a fraction of the failed Track and Trace.
Care will improve so much by freeing up midwives to focus on patients.

This idea has been around for years, look up PLICS. It's expensive to run with little cash saved though. The government don't do invest to save, and the NHS doesn't have enough in its back pocket to do it at scale either. Our funding is only ever very short term focussed.

iRun2eatCake · 31/12/2022 12:24

My Trust is going over to having digital patient records. Marvellous you would think....

Except...when the patients started coming in to us with no paper medical notes.... we couldn't access the online notes as we'd not been given the equipment to use.

The laptops we now have are so slloowww. The WiFi isn't strong enough to cope ...... l could go on....

Trouble with the NHS no one person overseas everything so whoever decided to bring in the online patient records.... wasn't tasked with actually checking we had a effective WiFi or resources to use.

PikachusSmarterBrother · 31/12/2022 12:21

The department I work in doesn't have enough admin staff or managers, so I imagine it varies between departments and Trusts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread