Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say the NHS does not have too many admin staff?

131 replies

Leakingtoilet · 31/12/2022 10:10

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/12/30/nhs-has-many-admin-staff-not-enough-managers/

We don't have enough staff to get the job done, hence the fact we are constantly offering admin and secretarial overtime. It seems that way in most other departments that I have dealings with. Plus it's really difficult to recruit to vacant posts.

Anyone have a different experience?

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 15:20

@Anotherusernameanotheday
i dont think mumsnet has that much sway, that the NHS will change the amount of managers or admin due to mumsnetters opinions.

Leakingtoilet · 31/12/2022 15:07

@Anotherusernameanotheday ummm what? Where did I mention 3 visits? I thought I made it clear in my OP that I work for the NHS and have done for many years

OP posts:
Anotherusernameanotheday · 31/12/2022 14:58

@Leakingtoilet lol. You definitely feel there are too many high level managers. On the basis of what ? The feelz or real evidence ?
Someone bases their opinion on 3 visits. No wonder the country is the way it is. Policies made on the back of cigarette packets, Brexit ministers turning up at
meetings without any notes and random mumsnetters opining about things they have no clue about.

user1497207191 · 31/12/2022 14:23

UsingChangeofName · 31/12/2022 13:22

This 100%

I have examples from every time I have had to have contact with hospital appointments for myself, my dc, or my parents over the last 30 years or so of how time wasting the processes are and how inefficient the whole system is.

I'm sure - like in most organisations - there are people who are slackers and people who work incredibly hard, and the vast majority who do the work put in front of them, but they are being expected to work with such inefficient systems.

My OH has cancer which requires long term chemotherapy via a 4 weekly drug cycle. It's the same every 4 weeks, starting with a blood test for which they send the bag/paper, then the blood test needs reviewing, then the prescription for chemo drug package is instigated and "pinged" to the hospital pharmacy. Pharmacy can't issue it because one of the drugs is "controlled" and needs authorisation, so they contact oncology to get someone to authorise it, then it can be handed over. Every 2 months a phone consultation with the oncologist has to be fitted in. Then the next appointment has to be made for the next blood test, someone has to post the blood test bag/paperwork, and so it goes on. Exactly the same every month.

You'd think it could be streamlined? No, it's a bloody nightmare. Either they forget to book the blood test, forget to tell us, forget to post the blood bag/forms, forget to instigate the prescription, forget to authorise it, forget to book the telephone consultation, etc. It's a full time job for him, and every step is a different dept, so multiple phone calls to find out who's not done their job! Usually he ends up having to phone his "cancer specialist nurse" as she's the only one who has access to all staff involved and knows the process - he always apologises to her as she should be doing clinical work but nearly every month she gets sucked into sorting out the shambolic admin. Last time, she spent an entire afternoon phoning around trying to sort it out as the next day he was due to start his monthly chemo and literally nothing had been done after his blood test - results hadn't been reviewed, prescription not instigated, etc etc.

7Worfs · 31/12/2022 14:04

Thank you to the knowledgeable posters who commented on my post re QR bracelet. I’ve no clue about the NHS so it’s interesting to see why it would/wouldn’t work.
One thing I disagree on though - documenting actions and treatments absolutely is admin. Looking at a labour ward again:
Value-add actions - direct care to mother and baby
Necessary non-value add - documenting treatments, stock management etc
Non-value add - duplication of effort, manual workarounds inefficient systems and processes

NHS need to enhance the value-add, automate/optimise the necessary NVA and eliminate the NVA. To my knowledge some trusts have solid Lean programs parroting those principles but nothing is done on a national level.

user12345678213 · 31/12/2022 14:02

Q2C4 · 31/12/2022 13:24

I entirely agree with this. It's madness.

How is that going to be paid for?

Good luck to any party that says "our priority for the NHS is to spend £20 billion to network and computerise the NHS and privately owned GP surgeries, which will not involve recruiting a single extra nurse or doctor nor solve the huge shortages in the workforce, oh and will take about 10 years to implement"

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 14:01

yes @Rebelyells
it varies from department to department as i said.
but months is not the norm.

Rebelyells · 31/12/2022 13:50

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 13:26

n example:
In outpatients a clinician sees a patient then dictates a letter, a medical secretary types the letter, someone posts the letter, the GP admin team scan the letter and upload it to their system. This process takes months

it doesnt take months,
the typing is generally outsourced for a start, the letter sent electronically.
depends on department how long it takes,
would be quicker with more admin staff, to process. so they are necessary.

I'm not sure you can extrapolate your experience to all other areas

I went to orthopaedic outpatients first week in August. Letter to GP uploaded in late November to system 1. I received my postal copy around a week before it was uploaded

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 13:49

you could be paid better in Aldi

Wishesa · 31/12/2022 13:45

I'm surprised they can recruit any administrators, my local trust are always advertising at c£18k for admin staff.

mumda · 31/12/2022 13:43

All these letters being sent to and fro - are they really just a series of tick boxes rather than someone actually penning a missive?

RagzRebooted · 31/12/2022 13:28

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 11:40

although i dont really know how the GPs work their electronic systems
do they print off the letters and scan onto notes
or just scan onto notes?

At my surgery, the referral letters are dictated by the GP (some of whom take longer to do this than typing it would take) and saved to the patient records, then a request sent to our secretary who types them up and sends them electronically to the hospital.
Not too inefficient, although if all GPs could type at a decent speed it would be faster for them to type their own as they go. Usually a short paragraph is sufficient.
A referral form or being able to book directly would be better. Surely specialitied don't really need a personal letter for each person, just knowing the GP thinks they should be seen should be enough.

Having every part of the NHS on the same IT system would save so much time. We have district nurses employed by the Trust who see some of our patients, but they use a different IT system so they can't see our records and we can't see theirs.

Patients leaving hospital/having procedures get a discharge letter. This is sent electronically to us, usually, but not quickly and I've often seen the patient for their follow up appointment before the letter is on the system. In most cases, having read the letter before they enter the room means I'm all set up and ready to go as I know why they're here and what to expect.

We don't have enough admin, it's shit pay for a job that's often stressful. We need huge overhaul of systems and processes.

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 13:26

n example:
In outpatients a clinician sees a patient then dictates a letter, a medical secretary types the letter, someone posts the letter, the GP admin team scan the letter and upload it to their system. This process takes months

it doesnt take months,
the typing is generally outsourced for a start, the letter sent electronically.
depends on department how long it takes,
would be quicker with more admin staff, to process. so they are necessary.

Q2C4 · 31/12/2022 13:24

Rebelyells · 31/12/2022 10:57

The number of admin staff could perhaps be reduced if the NHS invested in modern and functioning IT systems that integrated across primary and secondary care.

An example:
In outpatients a clinician sees a patient then dictates a letter, a medical secretary types the letter, someone posts the letter, the GP admin team scan the letter and upload it to their system. This process takes months

I entirely agree with this. It's madness.

UsingChangeofName · 31/12/2022 13:22

user1497207191 · 31/12/2022 11:40

Exactly this. The NHS "needs" it's current level of admin staff because the processes are inefficient and cumbersome. The systems need radical reform. If there's one organisation that needs the old "time and motion" studies, it's the NHS. I have no doubt at all that the vast majority of staff are busy and hard working! But a hell of a lot of what they do could be streamlined, systemised, etc. into more efficient processes. It's still harking from the old ages where it was easier/cheaper just to employ more staff rather than actually tackling the cumbersome working practices.

This 100%

I have examples from every time I have had to have contact with hospital appointments for myself, my dc, or my parents over the last 30 years or so of how time wasting the processes are and how inefficient the whole system is.

I'm sure - like in most organisations - there are people who are slackers and people who work incredibly hard, and the vast majority who do the work put in front of them, but they are being expected to work with such inefficient systems.

PikachusSmarterBrother · 31/12/2022 13:19

@antipodeancanary - I'm at the top of Band 7, and it seems to be impossible to get any admin support, even though I have too much other work to do.

SongforWhoever · 31/12/2022 13:18

My last NHS admin role was a complete nightmare due to overwork and lack of staff. Managers thought we could perform miracles doing the work of three people and criticised us if some tasks were not completed. Stress levels were enormous. Lots of people tell me it has got worse. This was a London teaching hospital.
I do get annoyed when people say there are too many admin staff.

mumda · 31/12/2022 13:14

jobs.theguardian.com/job/8404722/director-of-discharge-to-assess-and-home-first-transformation/?LinkSource=TopJob

Our 5 key principles demonstrate our belief in the delivery of ‘safe, high quality care every time’.

  1. Being a clinically led organisation
  2. Quality and safety at the heart
  3. A positive patient experience every time
  4. A great place to work Managing our money well
Notanotherusername4321 · 31/12/2022 13:13

Years ago I got a zero hours contract in an NHS department. I was a student at the time.

solved a shit load of problems as admin staff are nearly all women, and need holiday/time off over school holidays. As a student I was more than happy not working in term time, then doing every hour I could in the holidays.

so everyone got to take a/l around their kids, I got to earn a decent chunk without sacrificing my study time. The department was rarely short staffed so no backlog and everything got updated in less busy periods.

I did this for 5 years until I got a full time job. I ended up working across 3 different departments as once word got out I’d just be asked if I could cover x or y as miss smith was on holiday and they had a clinic.

i don’t know why this isn’t the norm. As far as I’m aware it’s never been done before or since.

MoreSleepPleasee · 31/12/2022 13:12

I have 2 friends who do admin for the NHS and neither are overly busy at work.

FlirtyMelons · 31/12/2022 13:08

antipodeancanary · 31/12/2022 12:17

I'm a band 8, so paid quite a lot as far as the NHS goes. I have no admin support whatsoever. I do my own scanning, typing, photocopying, make my own patient resources. I make my own stationery orders, chase up missing PPE, contact the courier myself when things go missing. I phone and make my own patient appointments and send out confirmation letters. I take and type up minutes. I spend at least half of my time doing admin tasks that someone paid one third as much as me could do in half the time and better. I have no particular clerical skills. I used to have a clerk, but she was disappeared as a cost saving measure. Surely anyone can see how ridiculous this is.

I didn't see this post before I posted my comments, exactly this is the issue we are having. It feels like we streamlined management and admin staff (the general public tend to believe this is where the main issues are in the NHS) but actually it was totally the wrong thing to do. We are now almost doing a full circle to ensure that clinicians are doing clinical work for the bulk of their time with the correct support in place.

Leakingtoilet · 31/12/2022 13:08

Obviously i read the article before posting. A lot of processes at my trust are already electronic. Notes have been electronic for years. Letters go straight to GPs electronically. Referrals are electronic - paper referrals from GPs are not accepted, they have to come via e-referrals. Appointments go out via text or patient portal, can also have letter if requested.

None of this takes away the need for admin staff.

OP posts:
FlirtyMelons · 31/12/2022 13:05

In the trust I work in (Mental Health mostly) we are actually looking at getting more admin staff in some areas, the clinical staff are absolutely inundated with additional work that does not actually need a clinician to do so this would really help in getting more patients seen and the clinicians doing the work they should be doing. Also none of our receptionists are just receptionists either, they are extremely busy and generally cover many areas as well as manning the front desk. They do an amazing job and being on reception in the mental health units/services is very demanding, and dangerous at times.

Obviously this isn't the case in all trusts or departments, I am sure there are many that aren't efficiently run.

Blossomtoes · 31/12/2022 13:04

Helplesstohelp22 · 31/12/2022 13:01

My old hospital's bereavement office had 10 admin workers who sat around loudly complaining that the junior doctors hadn't done the death certificates by midday (because they were still on the ward round).

My old hospital’s bereavement office was staffed by one person.

Helplesstohelp22 · 31/12/2022 13:01

My old hospital's bereavement office had 10 admin workers who sat around loudly complaining that the junior doctors hadn't done the death certificates by midday (because they were still on the ward round).

Swipe left for the next trending thread