Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say the NHS does not have too many admin staff?

131 replies

Leakingtoilet · 31/12/2022 10:10

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/12/30/nhs-has-many-admin-staff-not-enough-managers/

We don't have enough staff to get the job done, hence the fact we are constantly offering admin and secretarial overtime. It seems that way in most other departments that I have dealings with. Plus it's really difficult to recruit to vacant posts.

Anyone have a different experience?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EddietheEagle · 03/01/2023 09:33

Nixbox · 03/01/2023 09:28

@EddietheEagle admin within the NHS covers loads of different roles. Some are straightforward admin and some are quite specialised.
FIL does mental health admin and he has undergone a lot of training about legal aspects of detaining patients under the mental health act for example. He reviews the paperwork in a lot of detail to make sure that it complies with the law etc.
I don’t know what band he is but I know there are other staff in his department on higher and lower bands.

That's interesting

I wonder what band the straightforward admin is?

Nixbox · 03/01/2023 09:28

@EddietheEagle admin within the NHS covers loads of different roles. Some are straightforward admin and some are quite specialised.
FIL does mental health admin and he has undergone a lot of training about legal aspects of detaining patients under the mental health act for example. He reviews the paperwork in a lot of detail to make sure that it complies with the law etc.
I don’t know what band he is but I know there are other staff in his department on higher and lower bands.

NHSisbroken · 03/01/2023 07:59

I'm one of these awful non clinical band 8s and my role is to improve patient safety. Its 8am and I've been at work an hour already. I had written a long post but I've deleted it because no one wants to hear it, band 8 management is the enemy after all. Suffice to say I'm burned out and am in the process of applying for jobs, if I don't get a new job I'm going to quit anyway, I've had enough.

sashh · 03/01/2023 06:54

Leakingtoilet · 31/12/2022 10:21

Yes I agree with that. Although it depends what you class as a manger. I definitely feel there are too many high level managers who make decisions without actually knowing what is happening on the floor. It's very frustrating.

Absolutely.

When I run the world NHS managers who are not in patient facing rules will have to spend one week a year working shifts in various departments.

I had to leave my NHS career because of disability, I could have been moved to admin but there was no option for that.

olympicsrock · 03/01/2023 06:50

I’d love more admin in my senior clinical role. My letters wait up to 4 weeks to be typed. The nurse practitioners spend 50% if their time doing organisational roles, arranging appointments , phoning patients . So much of this could be done by more secretaríal time.

current secretary has too much work to do in paid hours , feels stressed. Manager says no money for more hours . So we are in danger of her quitting due to stress / sickness. She won’t be the first.

Willmafrockfit · 03/01/2023 06:38

They can never get rid of staff,
they just promote upwards or sideways instead of just saying your services are no longer needed

adomizo · 02/01/2023 22:50

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 31/12/2022 16:37

I'm a band 4 admin I line manage 10 then my band 5 manages me and my team
Then the 6 manages the 5, 7 manages 2 x 6's and some 8's aren't "operational" and don't manage anyone it's a bizarre

But overtime is needed and expected to get all the stuff done If my team didn't want to do it for extra money we'd be really behind

Yes this is my experience there are just far too many bands and lots of the work is interchangeable nowadays ........and a band 5 for example is not a consistent role across different departments...sometimes they might have 10 staff to manage sometimes none. Reduce the number of bands across the board and pay people better.

EddietheEagle · 02/01/2023 22:27

Boystomenslowdanceatweddings · 02/01/2023 22:13

Band 4 NHS admin in MH services here.
I wouldn't say there's too many mangers but their duties don't match their pay in my humble opinion.
I work around the corner from them so can hear what they're doing most of the time. There's a lot of duplication of what we're doing already. So a referral comes in, we look at it, assign a clinician to check in, get more information, make an action plan. Then in a few hours the 8a manager will come over flapping about the same referral, they have already, having not checked in with us (the referrals team) rang the referrer and done exactly the same thing as us but less efficiently. So that's a band 8a doing exactly the same task that I, an untrained band 4 can do.
I found myself once, having been working since 7am, feeling extremely stressed that I had to cancel a patient who was due to be transferred that morning as we now had no beds. I was in the queue of the local coop having just dropped my kids off and about to rush into work and I saw one of the managers in the queue, humming and buying an expensive breakfast. I thought 'he isn't feeling any of this stress, the stress of bed management, telling people that they won't be moving when they have been waiting ages and they're all really unwell. He's not logging on at 7am after being frantically emailed by the nurses on the night shift. He just gets up, goes to work, buys a nice croissant.
There's so many admin who work so so hard in mental health services. I know a band 5 who supervises 36 admin staff. That's a lot of responsibility!

I'm intrigued.
Why are admin staff band 4, and not lower? Have you got lower bands beneath you?

Boystomenslowdanceatweddings · 02/01/2023 22:13

Band 4 NHS admin in MH services here.
I wouldn't say there's too many mangers but their duties don't match their pay in my humble opinion.
I work around the corner from them so can hear what they're doing most of the time. There's a lot of duplication of what we're doing already. So a referral comes in, we look at it, assign a clinician to check in, get more information, make an action plan. Then in a few hours the 8a manager will come over flapping about the same referral, they have already, having not checked in with us (the referrals team) rang the referrer and done exactly the same thing as us but less efficiently. So that's a band 8a doing exactly the same task that I, an untrained band 4 can do.
I found myself once, having been working since 7am, feeling extremely stressed that I had to cancel a patient who was due to be transferred that morning as we now had no beds. I was in the queue of the local coop having just dropped my kids off and about to rush into work and I saw one of the managers in the queue, humming and buying an expensive breakfast. I thought 'he isn't feeling any of this stress, the stress of bed management, telling people that they won't be moving when they have been waiting ages and they're all really unwell. He's not logging on at 7am after being frantically emailed by the nurses on the night shift. He just gets up, goes to work, buys a nice croissant.
There's so many admin who work so so hard in mental health services. I know a band 5 who supervises 36 admin staff. That's a lot of responsibility!

PinkiOcelot · 02/01/2023 21:48

Florenz · 31/12/2022 11:44

It's a very old-fashioned organisation and there has never been any incentive for them to modernise, they get the money anyway and going fully digital would mean less jobs.

Going totally digital with an all singing all dancing, very expensive IT system has made my job 10 times harder. It’s shite. It takes much longer to do anything, you can’t find anything, it’s just not fit for purpose.

Willmafrockfit · 02/01/2023 17:14

@nomorecheeseforme

it happens regularly,
bad luck for the poor band 4 tbh

nomorecheeseforme · 02/01/2023 12:52

PikachusSmarterBrother · 02/01/2023 11:17

@wonkyheadwoes, I think some posters might be conflating line management and management - these are different things though, and the same person might not necessarily be doing both depending on the department.

I just can't envisage how a band 4 administrator would line manage 10 people. That makes no sense to me at all.

PikachusSmarterBrother · 02/01/2023 11:17

@wonkyheadwoes, I think some posters might be conflating line management and management - these are different things though, and the same person might not necessarily be doing both depending on the department.

wonkyheadwoes · 02/01/2023 11:11

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 31/12/2022 16:37

I'm a band 4 admin I line manage 10 then my band 5 manages me and my team
Then the 6 manages the 5, 7 manages 2 x 6's and some 8's aren't "operational" and don't manage anyone it's a bizarre

But overtime is needed and expected to get all the stuff done If my team didn't want to do it for extra money we'd be really behind

When you say you manage 10, what do you mean exactly?

NeedAHoliday2021 · 01/01/2023 12:09

The reality is not enough managers but nobody wants to believe that. If we want significant change to create a service that can meet the demands of the future it’s not going to happen by magic, it needs managers making strategic plans but they don’t have time because they’re too busy putting out fires. Those earning 8a and above are not sitting with their feet up. However, threads like this and the media do love to complain about managers… the same managers that actually made amazing things happen over the last 2 years including the vaccine roll out. Nurses didn’t do that alone - clinical, admin and management work together in the nhs so stop pitching us against each other. We are one team with the same aim and all need each other.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 01/01/2023 12:03

a doctors view on whether the nhs is over managed Doctors view

tl dr - no it isn’t

I work with the nhs a lot and one of the many problems is the sheer complexity of the problems trying to be solved eg falls in the elderly. Multiple causes, many of them outside the control of the NHS eg uneven pavements, pavements covered in slippery leaves or ice, falls on buses because drivers don’t wait for older ppl to sit down before pulling away, glasses that are no longer the right prescription. We have to meet with so many different organisations to try and coordinate a response but at the end of the day the elderly who fall end up on the NHS doorstep

To say the NHS does not have too many admin staff?
Nixbox · 31/12/2022 16:55

@7Worfs it depends what you mean by documenting treatment. Each drug needs to be signed for/ documented by the person who administers it. You wouldn’t save time by having someone else documenting each dose as they would have to have something to check that it was given, so it might as well be documented by the person giving it (and this doesn’t even cover the legal aspects of administering drugs).
But if you meant someone summarising the treatment at the end “patient x got five days of antibiotics” then an electronic system should be able to spit something like that out automatically. Should being the important word here. Our system would not give you that information easily - someone would have to interpret it manually as the automated reports are complicated.
We could probably change our system to something that gave more meaningful automated reports but that system may not be as easy to use on a day to day patient facing basis.
Treatment summaries are partly automated “tick box” style reports - surgeries have specific names and codes to identify what has been done - but there is always extra detail added manually such as complications, alterations to plans etc and I suspect this will always need to be done by clinical staff to be specific enough. Not a surgeon but I read plenty of surgical notes.
Someone much earlier on the thread mentioned the wrong address on an appointment letter, sending patients to the wrong area, which led the posterto believe the letters were manually prepared. I had an appointment years ago, automatically generated, but corrected by hand with different email and phone number, plus a note saying that nobody knew how to fix the template.

PikachusSmarterBrother · 31/12/2022 16:46

@OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside, there's not a direct relationship between band and line management expectations though - my role is Band 7, and wouldn't usually be expected to include any line management responsibilities.

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 31/12/2022 16:37

I'm a band 4 admin I line manage 10 then my band 5 manages me and my team
Then the 6 manages the 5, 7 manages 2 x 6's and some 8's aren't "operational" and don't manage anyone it's a bizarre

But overtime is needed and expected to get all the stuff done If my team didn't want to do it for extra money we'd be really behind

SellFridges · 31/12/2022 16:33

@Eeiliethya

Totally. I work for an international corporation. Every time I or a colleague attend a medical appointment, have contact with a school, or need to deal with the council, it results in a conversation about the type of impact we could have in a year. The processes are dreadful and an overhaul would benefit all involved.

EddietheEagle · 31/12/2022 16:02

There's definitely too many managers. Too many chiefs and not enough indians. And they all sit in their cosy offices, tip tapping at their computers, rubbing their hands together thinking of their salaries.

Eeiliethya · 31/12/2022 15:55

7Worfs · 31/12/2022 11:05

if I had the powers, I wouldn’t look to hire more admin, I’d automate.
For example in maternity: each mother is issued a bracelet that can scan QR codes and link directly to the patient record.
Every time there is a round of obs/painkillers etc just use the correct code on their bracelet, done.
Then there can be automatic reminders for repeat actions at certain intervals.
This wouldn’t even be that expensive to set up - a fraction of the failed Track and Trace.
Care will improve so much by freeing up midwives to focus on patients.

I agree.

Part of my role is building quality management systems, process improvement and efficiency.

What I wouldn't give to spend a year streamlining the NHS with digitalisation, trust alignment, improved communication and new processes.
Would be my dream project, I'd do it for free Xmas Grin

tass1960 · 31/12/2022 15:37

Willmafrockfit · 31/12/2022 13:26

n example:
In outpatients a clinician sees a patient then dictates a letter, a medical secretary types the letter, someone posts the letter, the GP admin team scan the letter and upload it to their system. This process takes months

it doesnt take months,
the typing is generally outsourced for a start, the letter sent electronically.
depends on department how long it takes,
would be quicker with more admin staff, to process. so they are necessary.

The only time my clinic letters take more than a few days post clinic is if I am on holiday. This is because there is no cover for my job when I am off. From consultation to GP receiving letter electronically less than three days normally. Will take longer to reach the patient because of the post. Anything urgent will be typed and processed that day or next day at the latest.

Anyone in our department taking months to get their letters out would be in trouble.

BlancmanegeBunny · 31/12/2022 15:35

From personal experience I would say there are too many managers and too much administration!
Communication is atrocious and there is a ridiculous amout of duplication!
The NHS must change to work smarter!!!
My father was under a number of different departments which often resulted in a blood test appoinment being sent by each department within days!!!

DontFeatureMeOnSocialMedia · 31/12/2022 15:27

I work for Adult Social Services. If I want to send some confidential information to someone in the NHS I have to check which trust they work for (there's an overlap of different trusts providing different services in our area). One trust will accept secure email. One won't. The one that won't has to receive it by post. It then has to be scanned by one of their admin to be added onto their system. So a simple job that would take less than five minutes takes a few days when you add posting time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread