Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Late birthday

69 replies

Suzie1963 · 31/12/2022 08:01

Aiba i have 2 grown up sons both with partners, i have recently had a birthday not a big one however i didnt get a card or a present from any of them on my birthday, they both made contact one by phone and the other by text saying they will see me the day after, i lost my temper saying theres no point in coming the day after as my birthday is over by then. I had changed arrangements to be home on the day of my birthday so had arranged to go out for the day the day after, anyway the next day late on one of my sons rocked up with my 2 youngest grandchildren with 2 bunches of flowers from the local garage, refused to come in as it was just a fleeting visit, i said going forward i wont be celebrating my birthdays or xmas as i cant cope with the stress of waiting in etc and them not coming to see me, we all live within 5 miles of each other, we had words i told him to shove his flowers up his ar$€ and he called me a poisonous old cu₩£ and to never darken his doors again, this has been going on for yrs now some times i get a card sometimes i dont, mothers day and xmas are also similar, last minute presents picked up with no thought put into them, i have just had cancer twice since 2019 and really they couldn't give a toss about me. My eldest son took to messaging me threatening to run me out of town and damaging mine and my husbands cars if i didnt apologise to his brother. Am i the arsehole for finally stating enough is enough?

OP posts:
startfresh · 31/12/2022 09:39

Sounds like too much drama and expecting too much.

So glad my parents don't actually give a toss about their birthdays, so I make the extra effort when I can.

My ILs, however, are overly invested in their birthdays.

Unfortunately, birthdays aren't as important when you get older. I would hate my DC to feel beholden to me on one day rather than possibly working out a day that works best.

You had no plans. Maybe they forgot to mention Sunday by mistake and thought they had the conversation, you didn't firm up plans.
You were rude, if my mum behaved like that when I took her flowers, I would be done with her.

BlastedPimples · 31/12/2022 09:36

I'm never really sure why, over the age of 21, birthdays are such a big deal.

DashboardConfessional · 31/12/2022 09:35

You hadn’t made any plans with them and according to your op they have form for forgetting or doing something rubbish. so whilst it’s not very nice that they did it, it was silly to assume this year would magically be different.

This. If you are going to passively-agressively wait around til 3pm instead of texting to ask when they're coming, it's a test you already know they'll fail.

That said I'd be pissed off by the vague "at the weekend". I certainly don't sit in all weekend and they just assumed you'd be in on the Sunday with no plans.

Bagzzz · 31/12/2022 09:30

Yabu
You anc your son are passing this down to the next generation shouting in front of your grandchildren.

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 31/12/2022 09:30

This does sound like it could all be improved by adapting your expectations OP. Most adults are fairly flexible and would be happy to celebrate their birthday the day or even week after. Maybe in the future just make concrete plans for when your sons will see you and try to be a bit more flexible. Obviously it would be lovely if they spent a long time selecting heartfelt gifts but lots of adults would be happy with a bunch of flowers on their birthday.

It sounds like you have very high expectations which you don't communicate clearly. Your sons may well feel that whatever they do will be met with dramatic disapointment so end up avoiding you because it tends to end in tears.

thunderstruckk · 31/12/2022 09:26

I think YABU - there were no concrete plans to meet on the actual birthday, when they text to say they'd see you the day after you got annoyed and told them not to bother and lost your temper.

It's your own fault that you changed your plans without any confirmation of other plans, you just assumed without checking (and if they know you and your DH had plans on the Saturday, no wonder they planned for Sunday!).

I think you are being really dramatic and then to kick off on the doorstep when they turned up with flowers and tell them to shove the flowers up their arse (including the grandchildren?!) is so so dramatic and rude.

Your son shouldn't be threatening to damage cars in anger at all though!

A lot of drama over things you've created in your own head, I think it all sounds very immature.

Greensleevevssnotnose · 31/12/2022 09:21

I don't think I would be rushing to see you, birthday or not. You saw them two day previous I would think that was enough. I see my parents about once a year and it's nice but never on their birthday. A card and a phone call is enough.

Neolara · 31/12/2022 09:21

I think you all need to get better at clarifying arrangements in advance so you don't get into situations where people have different expectations of what is going to happen.

EnyoClytemnestra · 31/12/2022 09:21

By your own admission, you've let this type of behaviour go on for years, so more fool you really. You are treated by others the way you allow yourself to be treated, so if you are now fed up with it, let them know

TimBoothseyes · 31/12/2022 09:20

Sorry Op but YABU

Not only do I not see my DD on my birthday (it's usually a week - 10 days after depending when she can get time off work), but I don't see any other family or friends either until afterwards as they are all busy with their own families that day.

Seriously you need to calm down and grow up.

Aprilx · 31/12/2022 09:16

The tone you are even using on this thread is quite telling and you are coming across as having quite a toxic personality. If somebody told me they would be coming over the weekend I would probably ask for clarification so I can be ready or ensure I will be in. Or I really would take it as a very casual and loose arrangement, I wouldn’t cancel all other plans and then sit in seething because somebody has not adhered to a plan that existed only in my mind.

And if you (general you not you) are seeing somebody the day after their birthday, it is customary to bring any card or gift along the next day, you don’t need to post it.

RicherThanYews · 31/12/2022 09:15

You deserved at least a modicum of thought on your actual birthday Op. If this occasion really was as you say, the last in a long line of poor behaviour from your children, I am not surprised that you snapped. I hope that you had a nice time with your husband and that he treated you to something lovely.

Christmasnero · 31/12/2022 09:15

You hadn’t made any plans with them and according to your op they have form for forgetting or doing something rubbish. so whilst it’s not very nice that they did it, it was silly to assume this year would magically be different.

if I was them id find it frustrating that you assumed, then said don’t bother coming anyway, then threw a further tantrum by saying you weren’t even going to celebrate anymore. It all just feels very unnecessarily dramatic. Before we even get to the point where you tell him to shove the flowers up his arse, presumably said in front of his children.

they may be tight on money or time. Or there may be more to this than you’re saying. It’s interesting that you don’t consider their perspective or how you contributed to this at all. Even down to you assuming weekend meant Saturday, despite no one saying this.

their behaviour after that is inexcusable but also very immature and dramatic, much like your own.
You all need to start communicating better and maybe you need to assume they won’t be part of your birthday plans. Sounds like you have a husband who wants to make plans with you though so have a lovely time with him in future.

HallieBo · 31/12/2022 09:13

Sounds like there's a back story... it all sounds a bit toxic.

gogohmm · 31/12/2022 09:10

Sorry op but you are making yourself sound ridiculous. When someone says at the weekend but no specific time or day, that means at the weekend, you make an assumption and assumed wrong. There's nothing wrong with coming the next day if they were busy. Sounds like your sons needed safety in numbers!

Edinburghmusing · 31/12/2022 09:08

@Untitledsquatboulder well unless it was her sweet sixteenth it’s a grown ups birthday. It’s really not a big deal.

the OP wants a day of everyone celebrating how wonderful she is. I imagine her sons don’t think she is wonderful and don’t particularly wish to celebrate her….

upfucked · 31/12/2022 09:07

Suzie1963 · 31/12/2022 08:58

If you knew me you would know i am certainly not controlling or ott, it just shows they have no respect for me, they didnt say till 3pm on my birthday that they werent coming, i just hope you dont treat your parents tge same way

But they had never said they were coming.

Orangepolentacake · 31/12/2022 09:06

What is the actual problem with a card/gift the day after your birthday, if that’s when someone sees you?
not telling you when they were coming is not ok but also you could’ve asked so you knew to plan

Untitledsquatboulder · 31/12/2022 09:06

Is it childish to expect your adult children to make more than a token effort?

BackOnTheBandWagon · 31/12/2022 09:06

Why wouldn't you give a present or card after a birthday? I find that really weird.

Your sons were incredibly rude (not for coming on Sunday, but for their subsequent reaction), but then you were rude too, and being precious.

Edinburghmusing · 31/12/2022 09:06

You are being unreasonable

what is even more unreasonable is that even though you have posted for other peoples opinions you will not change your opinion

upfucked · 31/12/2022 09:06

Suzie1963 · 31/12/2022 08:35

I was at my sons on the thursday before my birthday, he said we'll be up at the weekend, my birthday was on the saturday so i assumed he would be up that day, apparently him and his brother decided they would both come together on the sunday but neither of them told me that until afterwards

But you didn’t ask. Seems like a whole host of inability to communicate and some extremely toxic language on both sides and toxic behaviour from you.

TidyDancer · 31/12/2022 09:06

Is there more you aren't saying OP?

On the surface, it doesn't sound like they've done anything wrong. They said they would come at the weekend, they never made a firm arrangement with you. You may have been disappointed but it doesn't really excuse you behaving like a brat in front of the children. You then get into a shouting match in which neither of you behaved well.

Your other DS shouldn't have got involved and said some nasty things but I'm assuming this isn't the first time something has happened. I'd be stunned if there isn't a backstory.

evemillbank · 31/12/2022 09:03

You sound pretty childish

Plumbear2 · 31/12/2022 09:02

Suzie1963 · 31/12/2022 08:58

If you knew me you would know i am certainly not controlling or ott, it just shows they have no respect for me, they didnt say till 3pm on my birthday that they werent coming, i just hope you dont treat your parents tge same way

My parents understand sometimes I carnt come on their birthday. They also wouldn't tell me to shove flowers up my arse. They would be greatfull just as I am when they carnt come on my birthday.