Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU thinking there's something weird about my sister?

95 replies

Ginnyfromtheblock · 31/12/2022 02:46

My sister is 30 and has a habit of either over-embellishing to make out she's very rich or just generally lying. She's been lying about small things from a young age but nowadays it tends to be things like:

  1. An anecdote I or someone else may have said in conversation once upon a time, and she's now forgotten about who said it and uses it in conversation as if it was her and her story eg. A tradition of hers is making hot choc in a flask and taking it to winter wonderland when it is in fact something I do. Completely innocuous but also a blatant lie.
  2. Buying designer things for herself or her husband and then posting photos on Instagram saying she's being spoilt by her husband
  3. She hates her in laws (they are a bit rubbish and create unnecessary drama) but they throw rather lavish parties whether it's something like a baby shower or a kids birthday party, they're always very 'perfect'. But will post photos on Instagram of their fancy looking events (which she spends the run up and after the event moaning to me about how awful everyone is) saying how much she loved the day and how blessed she is to have such fun in laws
  4. Every single photo she puts up of herself is completely edited so that she looks almost like an alien. Her waist is tiny in the photos, her skin a lot more fair than it is (we have olive skin). She is in actual fact a size 16 and nobody in my family agrees that she looks like what her photos do.
  5. About 10 years ago she lied to a love interest about being sexually harassed at the student bar at uni so he would feel bad about not having spent the evening by her side. I know it was a lie because I wantrd to speak to uni security about it but she wouldn't let me and in the end it came out that she made it up.
  6. A friend of hers recently phoned me asking if she was ok as she hasn't heard from my sister since her operation. I asked my sister what operation as I didn't know about it. She just said, 'oh sorry about that, I'll get back to her'. Me and my sister speak on the phone everyday, and she hasn't had an operation for anything to my knowledge
  7. She booked a make up artist for about 5 separate occasions over the summer but lied to her about being in hospital. I bumped into the make up artist whilst shopping and she asked if my sister was out of hospital. I was with my sister the entire week and she wasn't in hospital.

So, I feel like something is up or her lies are just getting worse but I don't know how to confront her about it without making her feel bad about herself. But I'm also getting fed up of covering up her lies to random people. Am I being unreasonable about her being weird?

OP posts:
onionringcheeseypuff · 31/12/2022 12:03

My mum and my sister are like this. My mum once told someone my disabled brother had died, my dad found out when he bumped into the person she told.

My mother and sister both have borderline personality disorder and my sister especially is difficult because she will actually not lie, she couldn't conceal a truth. When she lies she actually believes it in that moment or she has over time convinced herself these are true things.

We have been told not to confront the lies as this disrupts their take on reality and they become abusive.

MintJulia · 31/12/2022 11:54

BadNomad · 31/12/2022 03:12

A lot of that sounds like insecurity and a need for validation through attention and sympathy. What is she like apart from the lying?

This. She sounds desperately insecure and in need of constant reassurance.

If she's lost her job, no partner, no child, little money, and trying to keep up with more successful siblings, I'd imagine she's not having a great time and it's all getting out of hand.

Is she younger than you and your brother? Has she spent a lifetime trying to live up to you?

Simpkiin · 31/12/2022 11:47

Finding these posts interesting. Seeing a lot of similarities. Seems like they fake illnesses so they get special sympathetic treatment despite their self absorbed behaviour. Also seems like they throw tantrums when people don’t buy into their narratives to force them to go along. And the tall tales and embellishments, to remind people how special they are. Mine also constantly outdoes anything and everyone. Bring up anything, and they have a story up their sleeve outdoing it. I find it exhausting and boring. Low to no contact with most of them. Sometimes I think maybe I should be the bigger person but then I remember how they behave

shesabitofastrangeone · 31/12/2022 09:13

I had a friend who started out by exaggerating stories and eventually progressed to building a complete fantasy life where he 'persuaded' quite a few people to give him money for a business venture that never happened.

Whenever anyone was on his trail, his fallback position was to invent an illness as a way of distraction. Thankfully he was later exposed but pretty sure he never got any kind of treatment. I am absolutely sure he'll pop up again one day!

That's an extreme example but that's where this kind of behaviour can lead. Wonder if it's some kind of personality disorder?

Doyoumind · 31/12/2022 09:10

She does sound similar to someone I know who was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder.

Nothing you say will change the way she behaves.

5128gap · 31/12/2022 09:09

There's two things here. Her SM behaviour and her outright lies.
The first is fairly typical of people on SM, portraying the perfect life, photos that make you look better, loads of people do that. It's not for me, but is so common I don't think it falls into the 'weird' category.
The other lies seem like they are generally self serving rather than 'pathological'. Book a make up artist you can't afford or change your mind about, so fob them off with a lie about an operation. Want to make someone feel extra sorry they left you alone, embroider your tale of the evenings events to make them feel guilty.
Somewhere along the way your sister has learned that there is more benefit to her from telling stories than from portraying herself authentically, and I very much doubt she'll change. She's not alone, loads of people do this, you just don't tend to know most of them well enough to know it.
You can challenge her on it if you like, but it won't go well. She'll just deny it and become upset/angry with you and you'll gain nothing.

NOTANUM · 31/12/2022 08:59

Why is she off work sick for a year? Is it mental health issues? Does she get counselling for it?

I have known people who exaggerate but only two fantasist. One had serious mental health issues and eventually had a huge breakdown and a spell in hospital. The second lied about lots of silly stuff. They had huge houses in prime locations they rented out but lived in their 2 bed house in a normal/slightly run down street, she co-owned her company, she knew lots of famous people who were always calling her up. None of it stacked up. Thankfully she was an acquaintance so I could distance.

Snoopystick · 31/12/2022 08:54

I used to work with people with learning difficulties and it sounds very similar to one lady who was diagnosed with ‘borderline personality disorder’.

Worldpeaceandallthat · 31/12/2022 08:48

Sounds like a personality disorder. Narcissism is rife in my family (grandparents were and it's infiltrated each generation). My father just lies (anger issues, serial cheater too) and some more. He has to move house (county to county) because he pisses people off with it.
FB is toe curling embarrassing (daily) where they all comment on each others pics and ignore mine (not that I give an actual fuck). They don't like me because I don't play the silly game. I'm sorry you are going through this with your sister.

It's ok to step away and let her deal with the consequences. It sounds very stressful and they make it your problem when it's theirs. I'm completely the opposite and like Jim Carey in that film, the bit where he can't lie. I have no filter. My DD is the same and I much prefer our frank discussions, where we don't fall out because we both say it how it is and it's ok. DH is the same, lies are called out in our house.

Onefootinthegroove · 31/12/2022 08:36

Cluster B personality disorder maybe?

TinselSniffer · 31/12/2022 08:27

My dad was like this Sad

He definitely didn't lie as much to me as he did to other people but it still makes me question anything he told me. I had the same embarrassing conversations with people he knew who asked me about broken legs (excuse for not doing things), fantasy jobs etc. The worst was at his funeral when his partner asked me why his army service wasn't mentioned in his eulogy, well that would be because he was never in the army.

He told my mom his real father was killed in the Spanish civil war and that he had twins with an Irishwoman, also lied about his age which she only found out at their wedding. All fantasy.

The one that hurts me most was he used to sing me a song when I was a child that he claimed to have written as a young man. I loved the song and its connection to him. I googled the lyrics decades later and it was a song by quite a well known band and not written by him at all.

LaLuz7 · 31/12/2022 08:11

Plain old narcissism

Duckskitbank · 31/12/2022 08:00

YANBU except for point 3 which is really just a description of social media.
Why do you tolerate all of her lies?

ScarlettSunset · 31/12/2022 07:36

I have a family member like this. They have got worse and worse over the years. I try to avoid contact with them as far as I can now.
It's reached the point where I am also having to cut contact with other family members who blindly believe them too.

Sugargliderwombat · 31/12/2022 07:35

What is she off work with ? Your sister sounds like she has real issues, the lies around illness and hospital are particularly strange.

W0tnow · 31/12/2022 07:30

Do you get along with her husband? Could you talk to him?

catsnthat · 31/12/2022 07:27

I know someone like this. She leads a complete fantasy life on social media, and has blocked her own family on there so they don't see what she puts on. Anyone who questions or calls her out on her posts gets blocked as well. She clearly has some kind of personality disorder.

ThinWomansBrain · 31/12/2022 07:23

A close friend has a sister like this - she just accepts that she's a fantasist, has minimal contact with her and supports her adult nieces (who are NC with the mother) where she can.

daisychain01 · 31/12/2022 07:22

Hence why I dereg'd from Fb within a year @MilkyYay it absolutely plays into that behaviour, I can't stand all the phoney bullshit, drives me nuts Grin

MilkyYay · 31/12/2022 07:19

Loads of people i know are like this tbh. Social media brings out the worst in most people, the lies, embellishments & edited photos on there are commonplace.

daisychain01 · 31/12/2022 07:18

@Ginnyfromtheblock another one here "with one of those". Unfortunately I've had to go NC as I can't bear all the absolute shit she comes out with and I know she's so set in her ways it's impossible to get through to her. Everything always has to be about her, it's tedious.

daisychain01 · 31/12/2022 07:14

Rainbowsparkles29 · 31/12/2022 06:16

Diagnosed with what exactly? Why do we insist on medicalising personalities and behavioural problems? She's a liar. She needs to cut the bullshit or suffer the consequences. No diagnosis required.

Personality traits which are often rooted in childhood, for example feelings of abandonment, poor attachment, sibling rivalry leading to low self-esteem, absolutely benefit from diagnosis, because it helps to understand underlying causes and reduce the reliance on the maladaptive behaviour the person uses as a coping strategy.

it doesn't necessarily need to involve medical intervention, as in "medicalised" prescription drugs for anxiety, depression etc, but the understanding can definitely enable the person to become 'unstuck', through acknowledgment if they decide their behaviour is detrimental to relationships around them. As with everything it needs the motivation from them to acknowledge it.

Redebs · 31/12/2022 06:34

AcerbicColleague · 31/12/2022 05:44

Oh, she sounds very troubled.

No point in confronting a compulsive liar, it will only drive them into defensive mode. Your sister needs professional help... unlikely she will seek it for compulsive lying, but she may for anxiety or insecurity which clearly are hindering her.

Everyone needs to feel loved and accepted by those closest to them and for some reason, your sister does not.

I understand that you feel very frustrated with her. I wonder if you would seek professional advice on managing your interactions with her?

Yes this
Desperately sad situation

Virginiaplain · 31/12/2022 06:27

She's a liar but it seems to be to make herself more interesting, is she attention seeking? It must be exhausting for her. She needs to speak to a counsellor for anxiety or anything that will get her to a counsellor. Sad. Does she have a partner?

Jimboscott0115 · 31/12/2022 06:27

My former sister in law was identical to how you describe OP. The exaggeration, the lying, the tears and tantrums when called out It - all of it the same.

Unfortunately, I put it down to narcissism and was one of the biggest gains of my divorce was no longer having her in my life because without significant therapy (and even with it) people like this only seem to get worse in my opinion.

They expect everyone to orbit around them exactly how they want, but their lies always become unstuck, hence they struggle to maintain friendships, relationships tend to be either them treading over a partner or partners running a mile after a while, they often don't work (because jobs require stability, work ethic and performance is based upon facts, not how amazing you tell people you are) and their social media profiles are nearly always laughably false.

Unfortunately I can't see her changing OP and I'd be very wary of her moving forwards because I'm. It sure you can believe a word she says.