Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be considering Ferber in these circumstances?

105 replies

HumanDummy2022 · 30/12/2022 23:07

Bit of a shameless AIBU for traffic, sorry! It’s more of a WWYD?

10.5 month DS. Exclusively breastfed, currently on three milk feeds a day, eats solids well - three meals a day.

For several months now he hasn’t been able to sleep for me unless he’s feeding. Attempts at swaying just result in thrashing about and shouting. He has on occasion self settled (we used the Lucy Wolfe gentle sleep solution approach) but recently teeth, colds, stomach bugs etc have gotten in the way of that.

DH can sway & sing him to sleep 90% of the time. My mum can read him books until he falls asleep on her.

I’ve tried everything but he absolutely won’t settle for me. We think it must be because I breastfeed him. He doesn’t even want a feed I don’t think, but it’s the only tool I’ve got to relax him.

Problem is he doesn’t unlatch so I have to feed him into a complete milk coma, pull him off the boob then pray he doesn’t wake on the transfer to the cot. It’s 50/50 whether he wakes and it usually takes 2-3 attempts over the course of an hour or so or feeding.

BUT, once he’s down he will generally sleep through the night. Doesn’t matter whether he’s been swayed by DH, self-settled, or has been fed.

It really gets me down that I can’t soothe my own baby to sleep. Also DH is going to go away for work for a week soon and I’m going to be screwed!

We’re considering introducing formula (as it’s too early for cow’s milk) for one feed initially to try to accelerate dropping breastfeeding. This makes me a bit sad and I’m aware if it doesn’t work I’m removing the only tool I’ve got to get him to sleep!
And/or we do Ferber. But this also seems cruel and disproportionate for a baby who sleeps through the night! But nap and bedtimes are now such an exhausting struggle.

WWYD?

OP posts:
HumanDummy2022 · 31/12/2022 20:06

And to clarify - by temporary intervention I don’t mean Ferber. As mentioned earlier, we’ve decided we couldn’t do that. Things are tricky, but not desperate.

OP posts:
HumanDummy2022 · 31/12/2022 19:54

A few people have mentioned “gentle” sleep training methods. Please could someone recommend one that they’ve used with success?

Sorry to anyone who is horribly offended by the mere mention of sleep training... I’m sat feeding at the moment, as I have been for the last hour apart from the two failed transfer attempts where my beautifully sleeping baby woke up, cried and pushed me away when I tried to cuddle and away him.

I’m tired, hungry, need to pee and would like to go downstairs and have a glass of bubbly with my husband for NYE. I’m also struggling to see how it’s kinder to DS to do this silly broken sleep & unnecessary extra feed dance every other evening rather than do a temporary intervention of some kind that will help him settle down in the cot (the one he is perfectly happy to be in for 10 hours a night!).

Sorry, emotional this evening..!

OP posts:
HumanDummy2022 · 31/12/2022 19:30

Thanks @Rowen32, I wouldn’t bother with a bottle. He drinks water well from a munchkin cup so we would probably just use that for formula then switch to whole milk at 1 year.

That said, I only want to try it when I’m confident he doesn’t have a cold or bug, so he doesn’t fill up on formula instead of having breast milk with all the antibodies etc, but with the amount of viruses going round atm that may be months away!

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 31/12/2022 19:25

@Pyri

The Ferber book says very specifically how to deal with babies vomiting on themselves as it’s a common outcome of leaving them to cry (which is what the Ferber method is).

And I said THREADS, not POSTS.

In the sections regarding looking after babies there are loads of threads with people recommending it. There are 5 listed in ‘similar threads’ alone.

Rowen32 · 31/12/2022 19:09

HumanDummy2022 · 31/12/2022 13:49

@Mummyof287 Maybe I need to adjust my thinking around it. As I know he’s perfectly capable of self settling (babbling to himself in his cot then drifting off) because he’s done it before, and will also sleep with swaying or being read to by someone other than me, I see it as some kind of failing that I have to “resort” to feeding to sleep.

PPs have talked about taking away his comfort by not bf, which I find quite unfair - its not really a sleep association for him because when DH settles him his last feed is around 45 mins before they go into his bedroom. He doesn’t need it to be relax and comforted to sleep. So why does he need it with me? Why is it absolutely impossible for me to comfort him any other way? It’s maddening!

I should also clarify there is no such thing as “gently” unlatching anymore with my DS. Even when deeply asleep I can’t gently break the seal and prise him off - he roots like a newborn in his sleep and if he doesn’t get the boob back he whinges (and I don’t mean that in a harsh way, it’s just not crying or shouting but something inbetween!).

So these days I have to very carefully stand up while still feeding him (killing my back / he’s huge!), wait for a brief pause in his suckling then literally drag him off the boob (my poor nipples must be getting stretched 😂) and put him on my
shoulder and start swaying like crazy for a few minutes then put him in the cot. A lot of the time though he’ll wake on my shoulder and the only option is either calling DH to step in while he’s still sleepy or starting the feeding process again.

If I could feed him to sleep, unlatch him and pop him in the cot like I used to, I’d be fine with it. It’s the human dummy and lengthy process that’s the issue.

We also hoped this was a short phase but it must have been at least 4 months of him not settling for me any other way, which is why it’s getting a bit trying.

Another clarification - he’s never had formula. That’s just something I’m considering in order to gently move him away from bf and hopefully it will help him relax with me other than by feeding.

Anyway, DH and I discussed this morning and we just can’t get on board with doing Ferber but once he gets over his latest cold we might introduce him to formula.

@Postapocalypticcowgirl Good idea but I’m reluctant to ask DH to do that. He never goes away with work and works from home 5 days a week (I know - I’m very lucky!) so actually barely sees his colleagues or leaves the house. He is absolutely a 50/50 parent the rest of the time and this is a great opportunity for him so I’m keen for him to go. DS and I will survive! My parents may be able to stay a few nights and work their magic too hopefully!

Considering babies aren't meant to be taking a bottle after 12 months and are able to drink cow's milk from that time too I'd wonder about putting yourself through weaning to a bottle and onto formula when you're almost at the time to be stopping it all?

Pyri · 31/12/2022 19:03

Merryoldgoat · 31/12/2022 17:46

@RoomOfRequirement

And yet there is thread upon thread telling people to try it.

Could you please point out any post that says it’s ok to leave your baby to the point they vomit on themselves? Most children who have had ferber sleep training most certainly do not vomit on themselves nor would their parents say it’s ok

Merryoldgoat · 31/12/2022 17:46

@RoomOfRequirement

And yet there is thread upon thread telling people to try it.

RoomOfRequirement · 31/12/2022 17:05

Merryoldgoat · 30/12/2022 23:41

The Ferber book has a paragraph which talks about what to do if your child vomits on themselves from being distressed. Clean them, no eye contact or comfort, change bedding and put them back down.

I think one has lost sight of what’s reasonable if willing to allow a baby to be one so distressed they are sick in themselves.

Wtf did I just read?!

If you can do this, just give your child to SS now.

Merryoldgoat · 31/12/2022 17:01

@amoobaa

It’s frankly vile.

I have two babies who were patchy sleepers.

Older just needed more reassurance and woke frequently but was broadly fine by 3. Still needs less sleep than his peers aged 10.

Second has a lactose intolerance and once that was resolved he slept like a champion and still does. Will go upstairs and put himself to bed if he’s tired.

I just don’t think leaving anyone to cry is the right thing to do.

BiasedBinding · 31/12/2022 14:58

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/12/2022 14:47

Of course, children like all of us have good nights and bad nights- feel ill, teeth, etc- but if you are rocking your toddler to sleep for hours near on every night I don’t think it’s a sign of superior parenting

I didn’t say anything about superior parenting. Just that there’s no guarantee either way, if your measure of parenting success is a >3yo who doesn’t need stroking to sleep and doesn’t wake several times a night. IME most older children are sleeping through whatever their parents did, and the ones who don’t likely would have been like that whatever you did. What parents choose to do when they are babies wrt sleep is up to them and I don’t have any opinion on it

amoobaa · 31/12/2022 14:57

Merryoldgoat · 30/12/2022 23:41

The Ferber book has a paragraph which talks about what to do if your child vomits on themselves from being distressed. Clean them, no eye contact or comfort, change bedding and put them back down.

I think one has lost sight of what’s reasonable if willing to allow a baby to be one so distressed they are sick in themselves.

Fucking hell. That’s absolutely heartbreaking. How could anyone justify something like that. Barbaric. And I’m someone who ended up hallucinating with sleep deprivation. It was dreadful and I’m afraid to go through it again, if I’m lucky enough… but it could never have justified such a cruel response from me.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/12/2022 14:47

BiasedBinding · 31/12/2022 12:05

I don’t care about sleep training either way, but I know loads of older children who have been like this at some points whether they were sleep trained or not

Of course, children like all of us have good nights and bad nights- feel ill, teeth, etc- but if you are rocking your toddler to sleep for hours near on every night I don’t think it’s a sign of superior parenting

Pyri · 31/12/2022 14:01

NoelleSnowman · 31/12/2022 11:44

Incorrect. But that is of course what you have to believe so you don’t feel guilty about neglecting your child and ignoring them when they need you.

Lol ok

Out of interest, do you think ferber babies never ever cry about anything again, given they think their care givers will just ignore them?

HumanDummy2022 · 31/12/2022 13:49

@Mummyof287 Maybe I need to adjust my thinking around it. As I know he’s perfectly capable of self settling (babbling to himself in his cot then drifting off) because he’s done it before, and will also sleep with swaying or being read to by someone other than me, I see it as some kind of failing that I have to “resort” to feeding to sleep.

PPs have talked about taking away his comfort by not bf, which I find quite unfair - its not really a sleep association for him because when DH settles him his last feed is around 45 mins before they go into his bedroom. He doesn’t need it to be relax and comforted to sleep. So why does he need it with me? Why is it absolutely impossible for me to comfort him any other way? It’s maddening!

I should also clarify there is no such thing as “gently” unlatching anymore with my DS. Even when deeply asleep I can’t gently break the seal and prise him off - he roots like a newborn in his sleep and if he doesn’t get the boob back he whinges (and I don’t mean that in a harsh way, it’s just not crying or shouting but something inbetween!).

So these days I have to very carefully stand up while still feeding him (killing my back / he’s huge!), wait for a brief pause in his suckling then literally drag him off the boob (my poor nipples must be getting stretched 😂) and put him on my
shoulder and start swaying like crazy for a few minutes then put him in the cot. A lot of the time though he’ll wake on my shoulder and the only option is either calling DH to step in while he’s still sleepy or starting the feeding process again.

If I could feed him to sleep, unlatch him and pop him in the cot like I used to, I’d be fine with it. It’s the human dummy and lengthy process that’s the issue.

We also hoped this was a short phase but it must have been at least 4 months of him not settling for me any other way, which is why it’s getting a bit trying.

Another clarification - he’s never had formula. That’s just something I’m considering in order to gently move him away from bf and hopefully it will help him relax with me other than by feeding.

Anyway, DH and I discussed this morning and we just can’t get on board with doing Ferber but once he gets over his latest cold we might introduce him to formula.

@Postapocalypticcowgirl Good idea but I’m reluctant to ask DH to do that. He never goes away with work and works from home 5 days a week (I know - I’m very lucky!) so actually barely sees his colleagues or leaves the house. He is absolutely a 50/50 parent the rest of the time and this is a great opportunity for him so I’m keen for him to go. DS and I will survive! My parents may be able to stay a few nights and work their magic too hopefully!

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/12/2022 12:38

Potentially controversial, but does your DH absolutely have to go away next month? Because that seems like the major issue here, and if he wasn't going, it would be okay?

You wouldn't be able to go on a work trip (if you were back at work) presumably, so is there no scope for him to say his child is too young, and he can't go, yet? Or at least shorten the duration of the trip?

Does he have to go away with work often?

Mummyof287 · 31/12/2022 12:27

Ferber is cruel and i'm suprised people still consider using it tbh, and how much it is discussed on here with all that is known about babies emotional needs.

You feeding him to sleep is how he settles with you, so i'm confused why you say you 'can't settle him to sleep'.My 14mo DD is the same, she will go to sleep with dad/grandma/childminder most of the time for day naps bedtine and night wakings (of which there are usually 3 on average) i have to feed her to sleep then gently unlatch her too, which usually takes afew attempts.She has never taken formula/bottle.

I think YABU as you have 3 major pluses already compared to many in that he sleeps through the night, your DH can settle him, and that he takes formula!

The best way is to carry on the gentle approach your doing and if you want stop b/f just get DH to give the formula replacements, gradually increasing these.

Babies will always have more clingier patches, where they need more intensive settling and increased closeness for various reasons, but many times its a phase that passes.

BiasedBinding · 31/12/2022 12:05

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/12/2022 09:19

You cannot sleep train and yet so many of us have and don’t post “my 3 year old needs me to rub her back to sleep and is up 4 times a night” in later years.

I don’t care about sleep training either way, but I know loads of older children who have been like this at some points whether they were sleep trained or not

TightFistedWozerk · 31/12/2022 11:57

I never felt guilty about shh pat, should I? 🤔

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/12/2022 11:48

NoelleSnowman · 31/12/2022 11:44

Incorrect. But that is of course what you have to believe so you don’t feel guilty about neglecting your child and ignoring them when they need you.

Proof? If that was the case there would be millions of children who never seek their parents comfort at all- it’s bs!

NoelleSnowman · 31/12/2022 11:44

Pyri · 31/12/2022 10:50

No, you’ve “trained” them that they don’t need the comfort because they’re secure and comfortable to put themselves back to sleep in their environment

Incorrect. But that is of course what you have to believe so you don’t feel guilty about neglecting your child and ignoring them when they need you.

Pyri · 31/12/2022 10:50

NoelleSnowman · 31/12/2022 09:22

No. You may call it “sleep training” all you wish, but you haven’t actually trained your child to sleep. Sleep is developmental and cannot be taught.

All you have trained your child to do is not to seek comfort or help from the people supposed to give it.

No, you’ve “trained” them that they don’t need the comfort because they’re secure and comfortable to put themselves back to sleep in their environment

NoelleSnowman · 31/12/2022 09:22

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/12/2022 09:19

You cannot sleep train and yet so many of us have and don’t post “my 3 year old needs me to rub her back to sleep and is up 4 times a night” in later years.

No. You may call it “sleep training” all you wish, but you haven’t actually trained your child to sleep. Sleep is developmental and cannot be taught.

All you have trained your child to do is not to seek comfort or help from the people supposed to give it.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/12/2022 09:19

You cannot sleep train and yet so many of us have and don’t post “my 3 year old needs me to rub her back to sleep and is up 4 times a night” in later years.

imalreadygone · 31/12/2022 07:55

It sounds like you're doing pretty well to me! It wasn't until 1.5years my LO would go to sleep "easily".

Have you tried giving something to eat before bed? I found some baby porridge about an hour before bed helped.

DashboardConfessional · 31/12/2022 07:54

We introduced a last-feed formula bottle when I was sick of lying on our spare bed for up to 90 minutes breastfeeding to sleep, but DS was about 5 months. It took DH only 15 minutes with a bottle. He still had to transfer to cot and hope for the best though - I guess you could give the bottle when already in the cot.

I didn't "lose" being able to feed to sleep as I continued breastfeeding until he was 2.