Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for dependents or compassionate leave ?

94 replies

FishersGate · 30/12/2022 22:33

My MIL is dying given days on Wed. She has been unwell for 5/6 weeks. Last night DH came home from hospital as very unwell shivers temp etc. DS 6 threw up earlier in evening. All in one bed. DD is 10. Very little sleep. We also explained to both children re MIL dying.

Myself and DH have obviously had very little sleep over past few weeks.

I was due to work today however I just couldn't face it and felt needed to be with DC especially DS who wasn't well.

Spoke to manager who just left long silences on the phone. She knows mil has been extremely unwell and I haven't asked for any other time off.

She asked how I would like to take time off, I said I can holiday but wasn't sure whether dependents leave or compassionate leave would be appropriate. She replied she didn't know. She said also kept hammering home the point about letting them know when the inevitable happens. She asked when kids are back at school.

I work in emergency service non front line extremely busy but not core area and never take or ask for either. I work part time and 1 day at home. Working from home has also saved them time previously if DC have been ill etc not needing holiday etc

Was it unreasonable in the circumstances to be offered time off or told not to worry ?? I was a bit peed off and now really worried about needing time off going forward ?

How much time would I need to support DH. There is only him and SIL. My children were very close to their nan also. I have known mil 26 years.

OP posts:
DillDanding · 31/12/2022 09:52

I can understand you don’t want to take sick leave, but could you take annual leave or unpaid leave?

Where I work, you’d not be given compassionate leave other than for emergencies for a mother in law. It sounds tough, but some people unfortunately take the piss.

FishersGate · 31/12/2022 09:51

MagentaRocks · 31/12/2022 09:46

Dependants leave is short term in an emergency situation to arrange alternative care and not for more than a day, 2 at most. I am emergency services too. In this case it would be annual leave or sick if it is more than a day or 2. Dependants leave is an entitlement but does not have to be paid.

compassionate leave is for immediate family members, I am pretty sure MIL would count, but it is 5 days, which includes the day of the funeral.

I think you are going to have to go sick if you really don’t feel you are able to work. Yes it adds up to the trigger points, but again discretion can be used when deciding if you are progressed to the next stage in the attendance process. I am a manager in the emergency services and I have kept people on the informal stage when policy states they should move up to the next stage. I also refused to put someone on the attendance process when they had cancer as I would have been setting them up to fail and move through the process which I felt would have been unfair.

Thank you. I am going to policy then receiving advice from union

OP posts:
ManxRhyme · 31/12/2022 09:51

OP you have options. Paid options using dependent, annual or sick leave in varying amounts. Compassionate leave is for after the death and usually limited as well.

You are coming across as wanting additional paid leave on top of this that doesn't eat into your annual leave allowance or count as a sickness episode. That's not how the working world works.

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 31/12/2022 09:50

DomesticShortHair · 31/12/2022 09:45

No, I explained the situation to my line manager and requested that I put annual leave in, which they allowed me to do. I didn’t want to explore the option of compassionate leave in those circumstances.

I’d agree that most people will be affected more by the loss of a parent than a pet. But I’d also agree most people won’t be particularly affected by the loss of a MiL. I suppose the point is it’s not so much about the cause or the reason, but the effect that really is the impact. What’s is acceptable or important to one manager isn’t necessarily the same to another. Which is what makes it all very ambiguous, and potentially unfair.

This is where I find manager discretion an advantage - I gave 2 weeks leave to a woman in my team when her 3 year old dog had to be put to sleep. She was mid 40s, single and had been open about having therapy for feeling lonely in life. As her manager I knew how hard the death of her dog would hit her, and so allowed her that extra time off. She'd previously never had any time off other than annual leave and was a fantastic, dependable worker. It was at my discretion to give her that time off, and I'm glad I could do it for her. No one in the team complained, wouldn't have cared if they had.

Leakingtoilet · 31/12/2022 09:48

If you were on my team it would be dependent leave for yesterday and annual leave/sickness from now on + a days compassionate to attend the funeral. That would be fully supported by HR. We have a standard policy but allowed managers discretion. The only time I've had an exceptional circumstance was the death of a team members adult DC.

I'm sorry for your situation but like pp said sadly this happens to most of us at some point in our lives and it would be a nightmare to have everyone expecting chunks of time off outside of sickness and annual leave.

NEmama · 31/12/2022 09:47

@DomesticShortHair it's really hard. Especially in jobs where you don't get annual leave 🥺

MagentaRocks · 31/12/2022 09:46

Dependants leave is short term in an emergency situation to arrange alternative care and not for more than a day, 2 at most. I am emergency services too. In this case it would be annual leave or sick if it is more than a day or 2. Dependants leave is an entitlement but does not have to be paid.

compassionate leave is for immediate family members, I am pretty sure MIL would count, but it is 5 days, which includes the day of the funeral.

I think you are going to have to go sick if you really don’t feel you are able to work. Yes it adds up to the trigger points, but again discretion can be used when deciding if you are progressed to the next stage in the attendance process. I am a manager in the emergency services and I have kept people on the informal stage when policy states they should move up to the next stage. I also refused to put someone on the attendance process when they had cancer as I would have been setting them up to fail and move through the process which I felt would have been unfair.

DomesticShortHair · 31/12/2022 09:45

NEmama · 31/12/2022 09:35

@DomesticShortHair did you get signed off?
You should have. Reaction to bereavement is a valid reason to be off.

In general though most people will cope more with losing a pet than a parent. This is not unreasonable, it is true.

No, I explained the situation to my line manager and requested that I put annual leave in, which they allowed me to do. I didn’t want to explore the option of compassionate leave in those circumstances.

I’d agree that most people will be affected more by the loss of a parent than a pet. But I’d also agree most people won’t be particularly affected by the loss of a MiL. I suppose the point is it’s not so much about the cause or the reason, but the effect that really is the impact. What’s is acceptable or important to one manager isn’t necessarily the same to another. Which is what makes it all very ambiguous, and potentially unfair.

FishersGate · 31/12/2022 09:45

crisscrosscringle · 31/12/2022 09:39

I don't see any evidence this isn't the case. Managers discretion was applied in a case of a colleague losing a grandchild which Id consider to be an outlier and exceptional circumstances.

I work in HR. This isn't an uncommon situation- PILs die all the time. Staff take annual leave if it's absolutely immobile the, compassionate leave for a few days after the death or they get signed off sick with stress as they are not mentally fit to work. Counting toward absence triggers is a moot point if you're genuinely not well enough, or in the right headspace, to work. OP, I feel for you but you have options- don't be a martyr for the cause.

It's not a moot point for people in my organisation who swiftly moved up on attendance policies - again at managers descretion

OP posts:
gogohmm · 31/12/2022 09:44

In these circumstances usually the first day is emergency dependants leave (to allow you to make provision) but subsequently days are normal annual leave. Compassionate leave is typically the day of the death and the day of the funeral automatically then on a discretionary basis depending on relationship eg most companies would allow between the death and the funeral for a parent but for a grandparent (where you aren't in charge of the arrangements) you would be expected in, for a partner or child most companies allow a lot more time. For a mil I wouldn't expect time other than the funeral as compassionate leave.

It's very tough, hope your dc and dp are feeling better soon

FishersGate · 31/12/2022 09:44

MavisMcMinty · 31/12/2022 09:41

However internally irritated or panic-stricken I might have felt as a manager, I’d ALWAYS be kind and super-supportive when stuff like this happened to my staff, as people are far more inclined to be loyal and hard-working for a sympathetic boss.

Thank you I think you understood my point which I wasn't getting across perhaps. Both managers have form for huffing and puffing when people have called in sick etc.

OP posts:
MavisMcMinty · 31/12/2022 09:41

However internally irritated or panic-stricken I might have felt as a manager, I’d ALWAYS be kind and super-supportive when stuff like this happened to my staff, as people are far more inclined to be loyal and hard-working for a sympathetic boss.

cansu · 31/12/2022 09:41

It sounds awful OP. FwIW I agree. You should be able to take a few days off here but it sounds like they won't give it. Take annual leave.

crisscrosscringle · 31/12/2022 09:39

katmarie · 31/12/2022 09:34

Managers discretion is a sure fire way to ensure discrimination in hr policy in my opinion. It's not difficult to write policies with clear parameters that cover most eventualities. Managers discretion should be reserved for absolute outlier situations and I don't think this is one. There must have been other times in the past where an employee has had to care for children due to another relative being indisposed. Sorry that doesn't help you op, I just hate seeing hr policies which are setting employees and employers up for problems. It's unnecessary and distressing for employees particularly.

I don't see any evidence this isn't the case. Managers discretion was applied in a case of a colleague losing a grandchild which Id consider to be an outlier and exceptional circumstances.

I work in HR. This isn't an uncommon situation- PILs die all the time. Staff take annual leave if it's absolutely immobile the, compassionate leave for a few days after the death or they get signed off sick with stress as they are not mentally fit to work. Counting toward absence triggers is a moot point if you're genuinely not well enough, or in the right headspace, to work. OP, I feel for you but you have options- don't be a martyr for the cause.

FishersGate · 31/12/2022 09:37

katmarie · 31/12/2022 09:34

Managers discretion is a sure fire way to ensure discrimination in hr policy in my opinion. It's not difficult to write policies with clear parameters that cover most eventualities. Managers discretion should be reserved for absolute outlier situations and I don't think this is one. There must have been other times in the past where an employee has had to care for children due to another relative being indisposed. Sorry that doesn't help you op, I just hate seeing hr policies which are setting employees and employers up for problems. It's unnecessary and distressing for employees particularly.

This is my bug bear too and you have put it much more sucintly than me

OP posts:
FishersGate · 31/12/2022 09:36

TrashyPanda · 31/12/2022 09:34

Have you spoken to your union?

mine were very helpful in a related situation and got things sorted out the same day.

I will be asking them yes on Tuesday. Just for any advice going forward thank yiu

OP posts:
NEmama · 31/12/2022 09:35

@DomesticShortHair did you get signed off?
You should have. Reaction to bereavement is a valid reason to be off.

In general though most people will cope more with losing a pet than a parent. This is not unreasonable, it is true.

FishersGate · 31/12/2022 09:35

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 31/12/2022 09:25

If you were in my team I'd offer to let you take annual leave at short notice without the 2 weeks notice requirement, but not compassionate leave. I had a team member with a relative dying "imminently" but it took 5 months for them to die. She was offered 2 days CL (one to arrange funeral, one to attend funeral) and the rest had to be annual leave.

I appreciate things are difficult, but it's not your employer's responsibility to fix things for you, they just pay you to do a job. If taking sick leave will trigger disciplinary proceedings, then you need to get through it and tough it out.

Sorry you're going through a tough time, it happens to everyone though, employers can't have everyone taking chunks of time off on top of annual leave everytime they want to.

Unfortunately it's not really because I want to. I won't need the time off again for MIL. I haven't had dependency leave for over 3 years and that was 1 day. I am going through peri menopause and have only had 2 weeks off as GP saw I was struggling that was in March. Sometimes life events aren't choices

OP posts:
katmarie · 31/12/2022 09:34

Managers discretion is a sure fire way to ensure discrimination in hr policy in my opinion. It's not difficult to write policies with clear parameters that cover most eventualities. Managers discretion should be reserved for absolute outlier situations and I don't think this is one. There must have been other times in the past where an employee has had to care for children due to another relative being indisposed. Sorry that doesn't help you op, I just hate seeing hr policies which are setting employees and employers up for problems. It's unnecessary and distressing for employees particularly.

TrashyPanda · 31/12/2022 09:34

Have you spoken to your union?

mine were very helpful in a related situation and got things sorted out the same day.

FishersGate · 31/12/2022 09:32

LovedFedAndNoonesDead · 31/12/2022 08:44

I wonder if the países/silences by your manager we’re her giving you the opportunity to say whether it was compassionate/dependants/carers/sickness (for yourself) or annual leave that you were going to ask for?

when my mother was dying and in intensive care for 2 weeks I rang work and explained the situation and explained I would not be back until we knew what was happening. In the end I was actually off for 6 weeks from the day she was admitted to hospital until 2 days after her funeral. I wasn’t paid at all during that time so had to take what annual leave I had available (about 9 days) and work a couple of weekends ‘on-call’ from home so that I wasn’t completely penniless.

So sorry for your loss. Dreadful situation

OP posts:
DomesticShortHair · 31/12/2022 09:32

NEmama · 31/12/2022 09:28

@LovedFedAndNoonesDead that's awful. You should have been signed off.
Bereavement policies are in the dark ages.
My DF died suddenly and unexpectedly. I was off two weeks and made to work back every single hour in overtime. (In my 20s)
When another young member of staff lost their dad they got signed off and paid. I processed the timesheets so checked what to put his through as "yes I supposed it will have to be "
That was the trigger I needed to leave and retrain.

When my DM died suddenly I was signed off for a month. (Different employer but didn't want that to worry about too)

I can understand people being sad when a pet dies but please stop comparing animals to people it's really disrespectful.

The loss of my cat affected me much more tan the loss of my parents. My animals are much more important to me than the humans in my life. Please stop comparing how my grief affects me compared to your own. It’s really disrespectful.

NewYearNora · 31/12/2022 09:31

Quite apart from the MIL, your child is sick so you need to take time off to care for them (given than DP is unavailable to do so).

FishersGate · 31/12/2022 09:29

DomesticShortHair · 31/12/2022 09:26

As it’s the managers discretion, perhaps the silence was where they were expecting you to make your case? As you identified, there’s no automatic policy for leave in your circumstances, so you need to explain why leave should be granted. How can they respond what your options are, when you haven’t convinced them what they should be looking at and why?

As it’s down to their discretion, your manager can’t just give out leave without justification. Not only do they have their own management to answer to, but also your colleagues who will have to pick up the slack. So it’s not a decision that should be taken lightly. If you wanted discretionary compassionate leave, and there may well be very good reasons for it, then I feel the onus is on you to provide the compelling reasons to the manager. As I say, this is why I’m not a fan of management discretion in these circumstances, it often causes more problems than it tries to solve.

I stated all the facts in the conversation about why I would not be in work. They were aware MIL was gravely ill before Christmas. I have kept them updated the whole way through to minimise disruption

OP posts:
NEmama · 31/12/2022 09:28

@LovedFedAndNoonesDead that's awful. You should have been signed off.
Bereavement policies are in the dark ages.
My DF died suddenly and unexpectedly. I was off two weeks and made to work back every single hour in overtime. (In my 20s)
When another young member of staff lost their dad they got signed off and paid. I processed the timesheets so checked what to put his through as "yes I supposed it will have to be "
That was the trigger I needed to leave and retrain.

When my DM died suddenly I was signed off for a month. (Different employer but didn't want that to worry about too)

I can understand people being sad when a pet dies but please stop comparing animals to people it's really disrespectful.