Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend being CF or I’m tight?

286 replies

PandorasBoxers · 30/12/2022 22:16

I genuinely don’t know if IABU here. For context I grew up very poor and while this made my DB extra generous it made me really fearful of being cold or hungry again.

DB died 6 years ago with no partner or children and left his house to me, his only sibling. I didn’t want to live in it but couldn’t get rid of it and the things in it because I was so sad.

my friend asked to move in to it and she’d pay a small rent (£100 pm for 4 bed new build in SW England) in exchange for not touching the big pieces of furniture and this worked great for both of us. She cleared most things over time with my permission and really helped me. She has made it her own and it’s nice to see it as friends and not have sad thoughts attached to it.

in spring we decided to move house as we wanted to ttc and realised the extra property isn’t helping as second home stamp duty is expensive and my friends home/rental wasn’t being run as a money maker.

I said to my friend that by January 2023 I’d need to run it like a real rental and this gave her 6 months (when I found out I was pregnant). It’s on a ‘new’ estate - everything’s 8 years old but up to scratch, so this wouldn’t have been too much extra work for me as I already paid for things to be fixed if they broke. I was asking that she pay £600pm which is still below normal but massively more than she was used to. She knew the reasons I had to do this. It would also have been better for me to sell.

I received a text a couple of days ago from friend to say she’s moved out. She gave no warning and has taken the fridge, freezer, washer, drier and some furniture. None of those things were hers. The walls have been bashed due to the move too.

She’s left rubbish in every room and old things she didn’t want. The garden is strewn with rubbish she clearly couldn’t fit in the van she’s hired to move.

if I was BU I’ll listen but I am so upset that she did this and only let me know at the last minute.

I work full time and a part time job and was hoping to take a years maternity and had counted on the rent (about £450pm once fees/taxes come out) so I could go part time after.

OP posts:
CoraPirbright · 31/12/2022 07:41

So she has lived in a nice house for a minuscule rent for 6 years and now done a midnight flit, stealing goods from you ?? I agree with pp’s - she is not a CF, she is a thief and a liar and not a friend to you at all.

I would seriously be calling the police.

NorthAngel · 31/12/2022 07:38

Wow! She has really been taking advantage of you! £100 a month for a newish 4 bed house (and furnished). She has been taking you for a ride. You really shouldn’t have rented it out to a ‘friend’ for so little. Please sort this out properly. Rent for a reasonable price or sell.

bigdecisionstomake · 31/12/2022 07:32

You have been given really good advice by @Mummyoflittledragon so I would take that if I were you.

Unfortunately, whether you meant to or not, as soon as you accepted the first £100 payment from your friend you created a legal tenancy - you don't need a paper tenancy agreement to create a tenancy - the mere acceptance of payment in return for the keys (possession) does this. Given the situation you were in with the loss of your DB I'm guessing you almost certainly didn't have the necessary legal framework and certification in place for you to be letting the property legally, therefore if you try to pursue anything there is a possibility you may end up coming off worse if your friend takes advice and finds this out.

Assuming you have written confirmation that your friend has surrendered the tenancy it would be wise to be pragmatic about this and breathe a sigh of relief that you haven't had to take lengthy and expensive legal action to remove her from the property - that could easily have run to thousands of pounds. Change the locks and make your decision either to sell or re-let. As PP have said 8 year old white goods have very little residual value.

Clear the house and give it a lick of paint and move on. I know it sticks in the craw a bit after you have been so kind (and particularly under these specific circumstances) but it could actually have ended up being a lot worse.

Testina · 31/12/2022 07:26

She was wrong to take advantage of your grief to suggest £100pcm, but you’ve had 6 years in which to come to your senses on that, so her pisstaking became your choice.
She’s absolutely wrong for stealing things, leaving a mess and damaging walls.
I do think she’s also wrong for giving you a few days notice - but only in the sense that it becomes clear it was an obvious dig at you.

But you told her you wanted in back for Jan 2023, and she gave her very short notice in the last week of December. So nothing wrong there.

You could try to pursue the theft angle, but I expect you haven’t been declaring the £1200 income for 6 years… so I’d leave “official” revenge well alone, personally. But if you’ve included it on your tax return, and done landlord safety checks on boilers (I suspect but don’t know that you’ve created tenancy obligations) then go for it with the theft threat!

HomeTheatreSystem · 31/12/2022 07:08

OP, I'm so sorry this happened to you but for the sake of your sanity, pursuing the stolen white goods and furniture will only drag out the unpleasantness and is very unlikely to result in any kind of satisfactory resolution for you. It's hard to understand why your friend behaved like this but she's not the first and won't be the last. Perhaps she started to feel jealous that you have 2 homes, she had none and knew she'd never be able to afford your size of house off the bat. Perhaps she could bear the thought of down sizing and just couldn't bring herself to be civil to you about vacating the house.

I think you need to reframe it in your mind that now you know her to be a CF and no real friend, youve got off relatively lightly, given she could have dragged out her departure (as you had no formal lease agreement) and caused you significant financial loss beyond the monthly £100 and theft of furniture and white goods whose estimated resale value would probably be quite low by now. You would not want to have all this aggravation to deal with during your pregnancy.

In your shoes, I would not rent out the house but sell it. You can live off some of the capital whilst on mat leave and maybe pay off the mortgage on your current house. I'd seek legal advice though so you know what taxes to expect and how to go about ring fencing the inheritance to ensure it remains yours and isn't considered a marital asset, if that is at all possible.

Onwards and upwards! You've a baby on the way and much to look forward to.

anotheronenow · 31/12/2022 07:02

Poor you, OP. I also have been unable to do anything but store everything of my mum's, seven years nearly now. I am glad for you that you have come to the point where you can sell the house. Big hug for that.

The friend really isn't, is she? Like everyone else, I'd send her a message with a list of the things she took that weren't hers, plus the rubbish she left. I'd tell her to return the stuff (and reconnect it) and arrange and pay for cleaners/gardners and we'd be square. Failing that, she should transfer you the cost of these things, plus some extra for your own time in arranging it.

If she doesn't do either of those, forget the friendship and get a county court judgement. It's theft. And you can think of your DP being pleased you're standing up for yourself.

Good luck.

loislovesstewie · 31/12/2022 06:36

I mean this kindly but 2 things for others;

  1. Never make big decisions when you a are grieving.
  2. NEVER,EVER mix business with pleasure. Never rent to a friend, the relationship changes, and you will, inevitably, fall out over something and the other party nearly always becomes a CF. Change locks and tell her you are calling the police, and do it.
daisychain01 · 31/12/2022 06:14

You should never have let a friend stay there, not least of all for £100 /month. She was only ever going to abuse the privilege. And that she did, including theft and sustaining damage with no admission of liability,

she's no friend taking advantage of your generosity when she knew it belonged to your deceased DB, but these things happen, all you can do is move forward.

presumably you're no longer friends, as she doesn't deserve your kindness and needs to give you a grovelling apology.

kweeble · 31/12/2022 06:07

I agree you must change the locks in case she returns; I’d also insist she compensated you or returns the furniture.
She’s not a friend and I’d be glad she’s gone without having to evict her.
If you sell now it’s better than a year’s time as house prices will probably go down and it will support your maternity leave.
I hope you can develop better boundaries as you’ve really been taken advantage of - maybe have some therapy. Enjoy the next stage of your life and I’m sure you will find true friends amongst other new mums.

AmIbeingTreasonable · 31/12/2022 05:38

Change the locks immediately then threaten her with police unless she immediately returns the items she stole. Follow thru with police if she doesn't return the stolen items.

CallMeRachel · 31/12/2022 05:15

Yanbu!
No good deed goes unpunished. She saw an opportunity, took advantage of you when you were vulnerable and milked it for all she could.

Film all the damage and post it on socials and tag on the post. This is what you get for charging £100 pittance for rent to a greedy pig. She deserves shaming for that.

To not even give a thank you, just a kick in the teeth is disgusting.

You were so kind.

chipswitheveryting · 31/12/2022 04:51

CF!

Serialcatmum · 31/12/2022 04:00

Take joy in what a shock she will get when she has to rent under the current market OP. She will be KICKING herself when she realises that £600 was a ridiculous bargain. Talk about cutting her nose to spite her face.

Good luck with the sale and pregnancy OP X

Wdib78 · 31/12/2022 03:50

iamthesparrow · 30/12/2022 22:20

I'd tell her to put your fridge/furniture etc back within 48hrs or you're calling the police and reporting it as a theft.

This

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 31/12/2022 03:50

Your friend is definitely a CF. I was going to say to get the items back out of principle, but previous poster has many good points re being a landlord . I think for your mental well-being, put it all behind you as it will just cause you stress. Don't speak to her ever again and she has actually done you a favour by leaving.

Mummyoflittledragon · 31/12/2022 03:35

I’m a landlord op. You’ve done a very generous thing, you were exploited. However, it doesn’t sound as if you have proof you of the state of the property or the items inside the property when she moved in. You needed an inventory for this signed by the tenant acknowledging agreement and ideally photographic evidence. It doesn’t sound as if you have this. As a result, she can effectively take every item and pretty much trash the place with no recourse unfortunately and claim the house was in the same state when you first rented it to her.

Adding to this, I doubt you did the necessary and legal checks on your property ie annual gas safety checks, electrical compliance testing, PAT tested your appliances annually (moot point as she’s stolen them), legionaries testing, 10 yearly EPC. I don’t expect you installed mandatory smoke or C02 alarms either.

I think you will expend more energy on this vampire if you continue to try to pursue her for your things and may never get them back and by now they’re old and pretty worthless. You should cut your losses and rent the house at market rates or sell. You are sitting on a goldmine tbh and you can earn back the value of the goods taken and any damage in no time if you rent the house out.

Yes, set up costs need paying first and a full decoration but if you do decide to rent, I would do this unfurnished unless you’re looking to do short term / holiday letting and it is far less hassle to rent out a property without any white goods as they need to be PAT tested annually and replaced if broken and you really won’t get a substantial increase in income to offset this.

I get you were banking on the money but it sounds as if you have savings as you are looking to buy. I would use this cash to get the house in order, painted, cleaned including carpets etc. Or change the flooring if it is terrible. Then rent it out or sell it. Renting it, as already stated, you’re looking at a minimum of £1200 rent depending on location. You should use an agent, go full management and pay landlord insurance in case of non payment. You will have to pay tax on your income but you will easily be netting what you said you need to cover maternity.

House prices are set to fall so I would choose now whether to sell or rent. If you rent, the income can be used to bolster your earnings. If you buy, you will obviously have more money. If you’re married, this would then become a joint asset (which it currently isn’t), otherwise you ring fence the proceeds of the sale for the deposit.

Gooseysgirl · 31/12/2022 02:51

YANBU... 'friend' definitely being a massive CF!

Pemba · 31/12/2022 02:46

She has behaved badly and doesn't seem to appreciate the value of what she's had from you. £100 a month for a detached house! - it's almost nothing. I hope she's been saving furiously whilst living in your property for years, as her housing costs are about to increase dramatically.

It's really bad that she's not communicated clearly with you and given you proper notice, and disgusting that she's left it a mess with rubbish left. However I wouldn't get too worked up about the items taken, as white goods over 6 years old are virtually worthless anyway. The police won't be interested and you won't need white goods to attract a new tenant, many tenants prefer to have their own unless it's a flat or houseshare. Still entitled and cheeky of her just to take the stuff though.

As pps have said, at least she's gone now, which saves you a lot of hassle. She is so ungrateful though, I don't know if you'd want to continue the friendship after this.

Charlieiscool · 31/12/2022 02:13

Change the locks and you will probably have to write everything off that she has taken for your own peace of mind but then in future, operate with a rental agency on a proper business footing with tenancy agreements. I hope the utilities were in her name. Don’t let anyone make a mug of you again.

Schnooze · 31/12/2022 02:00

It’s worth decorating in a neutral colour to freshen it up to maximise your sale price. You’d need to do that anyway. The heavy stuff has gone so that’s saved you money. The only extra cost is the cost of a skip.

Goodbye to good riddance I say. She’s shown her true colours which whilst sad has shown you she’s no friend.

ortonym · 31/12/2022 01:58

Boulshired · 31/12/2022 01:44

Police and small claims are just going to prolong this person stay in your life for very little return. She’s going to deny taking or that they were ever in the house. Do as other have said in changing the locks, personally I’d send her a message that your thankful she shown you what a piece of scum she is. This is better for you, she’s gone and you can plan for your new future.

Yep. The pain that chasing your (ex) belongings is not worth the time and money wasted on it. Cut and run. Be thankful she's out of your life. Don't be soft when she asks to re-rent your house (hopefully she'll be long gone anyway).

Boulshired · 31/12/2022 01:44

Police and small claims are just going to prolong this person stay in your life for very little return. She’s going to deny taking or that they were ever in the house. Do as other have said in changing the locks, personally I’d send her a message that your thankful she shown you what a piece of scum she is. This is better for you, she’s gone and you can plan for your new future.

user1496262496 · 31/12/2022 01:08

Change the locks asap

Ivyonafence · 31/12/2022 01:03

Wow, she's a cheeky bitch. I'm so sorry OP. You've been incredibly generous to her and she's being hideous in return.

Give up on the friendship. Send her a letter saying she needs to clean the property, remove her belongings and return your brothers.

Outrageous behaviour. Did she expect you to subsidise her life forever?

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 31/12/2022 00:58

Think the small claims court route might work better than the police (in terms of both teaching her that there are consequences for her actions, and recompensating you for the costs).
Agree with PPs that in many ways this could be a really good opportunity for you to move on, and even sell the house, rather than continuing to be a landlord (potentially a lot of responsibility and stress on top of a new baby, even if you do use a lettings agency) - that would save you from buying replacement white goods.