Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend being CF or I’m tight?

286 replies

PandorasBoxers · 30/12/2022 22:16

I genuinely don’t know if IABU here. For context I grew up very poor and while this made my DB extra generous it made me really fearful of being cold or hungry again.

DB died 6 years ago with no partner or children and left his house to me, his only sibling. I didn’t want to live in it but couldn’t get rid of it and the things in it because I was so sad.

my friend asked to move in to it and she’d pay a small rent (£100 pm for 4 bed new build in SW England) in exchange for not touching the big pieces of furniture and this worked great for both of us. She cleared most things over time with my permission and really helped me. She has made it her own and it’s nice to see it as friends and not have sad thoughts attached to it.

in spring we decided to move house as we wanted to ttc and realised the extra property isn’t helping as second home stamp duty is expensive and my friends home/rental wasn’t being run as a money maker.

I said to my friend that by January 2023 I’d need to run it like a real rental and this gave her 6 months (when I found out I was pregnant). It’s on a ‘new’ estate - everything’s 8 years old but up to scratch, so this wouldn’t have been too much extra work for me as I already paid for things to be fixed if they broke. I was asking that she pay £600pm which is still below normal but massively more than she was used to. She knew the reasons I had to do this. It would also have been better for me to sell.

I received a text a couple of days ago from friend to say she’s moved out. She gave no warning and has taken the fridge, freezer, washer, drier and some furniture. None of those things were hers. The walls have been bashed due to the move too.

She’s left rubbish in every room and old things she didn’t want. The garden is strewn with rubbish she clearly couldn’t fit in the van she’s hired to move.

if I was BU I’ll listen but I am so upset that she did this and only let me know at the last minute.

I work full time and a part time job and was hoping to take a years maternity and had counted on the rent (about £450pm once fees/taxes come out) so I could go part time after.

OP posts:
Puffin87 · 31/12/2022 13:06

She had already taken advantage of you while you were grieving with the £100 pm.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 31/12/2022 12:45

Finances aside, anyone who leaves a house in that state is a CF

Twiglets1 · 31/12/2022 12:36

PandorasBoxers · 31/12/2022 12:21

Thank you for your advice and opinions, it’s been really helpful to get an outside view.

DH and his friend are taking meter readings etc, clearing up the big stuff and changing locks. (In exchange for take anway and booze for tonight!)

Ive messaged ‘my friend’ to say that those possessions were missing and that I’m disappointed by what’s happened.

I won’t get anywhere with her because she’s already said my brother would have wanted her there / she thinks I’ve made her homeless. She’s apparently been to the council and is staying with family until she can get her own place.

Apparently her family are upset I’ve done this to her.
I did try to reason but she’s got an awful cold and found moving stressful so doesn’t want to talk to me. I’ve apparently put her under too much stress.

I think it’s best I draw a line under it all and block her on social media/ her number.

I think I would definitely have went along with everything because I hate conflict so much but I am working to be more assertive in general. Again, all of your kind comments and opinions have really helped too

I think that’s very sensible. Just draw a line under it and move on. She has shown her true colours unfortunately.

PandorasBoxers · 31/12/2022 12:21

Thank you for your advice and opinions, it’s been really helpful to get an outside view.

DH and his friend are taking meter readings etc, clearing up the big stuff and changing locks. (In exchange for take anway and booze for tonight!)

Ive messaged ‘my friend’ to say that those possessions were missing and that I’m disappointed by what’s happened.

I won’t get anywhere with her because she’s already said my brother would have wanted her there / she thinks I’ve made her homeless. She’s apparently been to the council and is staying with family until she can get her own place.

Apparently her family are upset I’ve done this to her.
I did try to reason but she’s got an awful cold and found moving stressful so doesn’t want to talk to me. I’ve apparently put her under too much stress.

I think it’s best I draw a line under it all and block her on social media/ her number.

I think I would definitely have went along with everything because I hate conflict so much but I am working to be more assertive in general. Again, all of your kind comments and opinions have really helped too

OP posts:
MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 31/12/2022 12:07

@NameChagaiiiin I think you've made your point, this is coming close to derailing now.

OP - please don't blame yourself. Grief does funny things to us all, and I think the 'solution' your CF presented probably was helpful in that it meant you just didn't have to deal with the practical, outward manifestation of your brother's death. I viewed a house from a youngish man who had lost both his parents and it was like an episode of hoarders, crammed with their stuff. Being unable to deal with the 'stuff' is not uncommon.

A good friend would have rented for a year then approached you and said 'right, let's get this on a more business-like footing'. The fact that she didn't speaks volumes to her character. Don't blame yourself.

bigdecisionstomake · 31/12/2022 11:48

@NameChagaiiiin In UK law a legal tenancy is created once rent and keys change hands i.e. possession of the property is given in exchange for a consideration (the rent payment). No paper tenancy agreement is required for a legal tenancy to be created.

I have every sympathy for the OP in this instance and they were acting entirely from the best of intentions but there was indisputably a tenancy in UK law and they by definition became a landlord. The OP didn't meet the legal requirements of that e.g. gas safety certificate, electrical installation report etc...

NameChagaiiiin · 31/12/2022 11:35

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 31/12/2022 09:50

www.lettingaproperty.com/landlord/blog/gas-safety-checks-landlords/

I wasn’t trying to be spiteful, I was trying to be factually accurate. No gas safety certificate? Unlimited fines and up to 6 months in prison.

no EICR? Fine of up to £30,000

she did have a tenancy agreement by virtue of paying rent. And the OP might have been doing her friend a favour but that doesn’t mean she hasn’t been breaking the law and, therefore, I wouldn’t be pushing the white goods too far…

You're still being utterly ridiculous.

These things would only apply as a landlord. With no tenancy agreement, there's no landlord. Not to mention no court in the world would see £100 PER Month as a rental amount. Unless it was a cardboard box.

I rented for a nominal fee, my parents home whilst they lived abroad for a few years. Should I sue them now as they didn't provide a gas certificate?

Stop being silly.

NameChagaiiiin · 31/12/2022 11:27

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 31/12/2022 08:18

Based on your updated:

you’ve not paid tax
youve not protected her deposit
you have none of the safely stuff you need to be a landlord

grief or not, you’ve been acting illegally for the last 6 years

Ridiculous.
Doing a friend a favour is not acting illegally. Give over.

This does not give the right to steal or damage property.

Togoodtobeforgotten · 31/12/2022 11:10

That is absolutely disgusting so she was paying £25 a week rent and she's treated you like this? I would never speak to her again.

Pearls1234 · 31/12/2022 10:58

Nasty F, not just cheeky F! You haven’t been tight at all, you’ve been very generous and when your situation changed you were more than reasonable.

canyouextrapol · 31/12/2022 10:50

She's a thief and has taking advantage of you in your grief. But I'd change the locks and try and move on. At least she's out and I would just never interact with her again

diddl · 31/12/2022 10:44

I think it might be hard to prove ownership of the things that were taken.

She hasn't entered the property illegally to take them.

Ritasueandwhatshisfacetoo · 31/12/2022 10:40

Your friend has her nose out of joint and is showing her true Colours. She’s used you for cheap rent when you were most vulnerable and repays you by stealing and leaving you in the lurch. Good riddance. She doesn’t deserve your friendship.

Darcy101 · 31/12/2022 10:34

Definitely get locks changed, what a nasty way to treat you, just wow!

TheDietStartsTomorrowOrMaybeTheDayAfter · 31/12/2022 10:33

I’d report her to the police as surely she’s burgled your property. You’ve got the text messages so it’s an admission of guilt.

blindfate · 31/12/2022 10:30

OP you could be eligible for maternity pay from your part time job too - https://workingfamilies.org.uk/articles/maternity-leave-and-pay-if-you-have-more-than-one-employer/#:~:text=You%20do%20not%20have%20to,claim%20it%20from%20each%20employer.

So sorry for the loss of your brother Flowers

Peony26 · 31/12/2022 10:28

Firstly I just want to say that I have lived this, I completely understand! I know it doesn’t feel like it now but this is totally for the best. If you needed to try and remove your friend it would have been a nightmare, courts and huge fees, which is so stressful as others said get the locks changed and house secure asap. Also I know that your brothers things have been taken but if they’re 8 years old then they’re nearly at their end of use, and if you rent it furnished then you would have been responsible for it all. And I understand your sentimental attachments and I did as you said and I sold the house as I just wanted rid of it, but in hindsight you were left that house by your brother so you could benefit from it he wanted you to have it. I wish I would have rented ours out, the rental market atm would make you a great income whilst raising a family, I’m now years later desperately trying to buy another rental for the extra income, and kicking myself for how much easier it would of been raising my family. Before you make a decision go to 3 estate agents and get figures from them, for a small fee you could have it rented out at nearly double what your friend was going to pay and they will do all the work so you don’t have to deal with it. Or if you can’t face it and the value will allow it sell the house and buy 2 smaller places to rent out. The property values will keep rising and you’ll have extra income every month which will allow you to raise a family in a much better position

SidTwaddell · 31/12/2022 10:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 31/12/2022 10:25

I'm assuming you're no longer going to want to be 'friends' with this woman who so blatantly used your grief?

I'm so sorry about your DB - I'm in the too early sibling death club... It's the pits isn't it. 💐

Unless you're DB house is in a very odd area.... A 4 bed house in South West would be a minimum of 1200£ monthly.

You've essentially saved this woman a minimum of £72k.

Od let the theft of white goods go.... It's morally wrong what she's done.... But they would now be classed as old and she's inadvertently done you a favour for your incoming tenants.

However, send her a mail /text saying how disappointed you are at the state she has left the house for which you were letting her stay at peppercorn rent.ask her for a minimum of 500£ to thoroughly deep clean and clear the house.

I would be very tempted to persue through small claims.

I can't see it not being found in your favour?

Testina · 31/12/2022 10:16

Indeed @StickyCricket

Can you imagine the first contact with police even if they were involved?

Tenant Friend: her brother had died, she didn’t want his things, that was hard for her. And of course, she didn’t need extra white goods anyway. We were friends too, me and her brother, so she said she wanted me to have them.

Police: well that sounds like bullshit, nobody is that generous are they? I mean - how much rent was she charging you? Oh.

StickyCricket · 31/12/2022 10:11

I would seriously be calling the police.

I’d love to know where posters live who are giving out this advice? It must be idyllic. I’d like to move there.

We couldn’t get the police to be interested in our stolen car 6 months ago, despite us having clear CCTV images and a piece of clothing that was left behind on our property, we didn’t get to even see a police officer in person, all they were interested in was giving us a crime reference number for our insurance, they didn’t want the CCTV footage, we insisted in sending it to them and it “went missing” at their end.

It’s astonishing to me that people think the police will be interested in the theft of an 8 year old fridge and washing machine.

merlotlover · 31/12/2022 10:08

Change the locks first
Rent out via agency for full amount.
She's a CF and has lived for pennies off your good nature.

KTheGrey · 31/12/2022 09:56

She's obviously been very passive aggressive and taking the white goods is theft, so a firm email /text arranging their return. Also she's been very unappreciative - she's helped you but she's had an unbelievably low rent in return and has chosen to end things in a really shabby way.

However, in some way she has done you a favour - you will be able to rent that for a much better rate, or sell it outright, and it will work out much better for you all in all.

Bleachmycloths · 31/12/2022 09:55

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 31/12/2022 09:50

www.lettingaproperty.com/landlord/blog/gas-safety-checks-landlords/

I wasn’t trying to be spiteful, I was trying to be factually accurate. No gas safety certificate? Unlimited fines and up to 6 months in prison.

no EICR? Fine of up to £30,000

she did have a tenancy agreement by virtue of paying rent. And the OP might have been doing her friend a favour but that doesn’t mean she hasn’t been breaking the law and, therefore, I wouldn’t be pushing the white goods too far…

Your “grief or no grief” phrase was unnecessary and nasty and has nothing to do with being “factually accurate.”

user58202018484482910ugog19293843910 · 31/12/2022 09:54

She took advantage op.

Echoing other people, 48 hours to return the stuff or police for theft and she will be billed for deep clean and for clearing of the property and garden. She will also be billed for repairs.