Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For my arguing with my MIL on Christmas Day?

259 replies

MamaCathy73 · 30/12/2022 19:40

Hi everyone,

My DC came out as non-binary last year and now asks that they be referred to by they/them pronouns. I do not think this is a big deal, and so I happily oblige even if I do not fully understand. My MIL is a strong Christian, and despite knowing that DC does not want to be referred to as he/him, does it anyway. She often says things like "gender is what's in your pants, not your brain", amongst other clichés. On Christmas Day, she was particularly bad, and she was clearly going out of her way to invalidate DC's gender identity as much as possible. After I corrected her (because DC was visibly uncomfortable), she began to rant about how much he hates Stonewall and this "transing" business right in front of them. This did not sit right with me at all, so I got very angry with her (lots of expletives). Anyway, DH did not like how I reacted, saying that I ruined Christmas, and that I shouldn't have spoken to his mother like that. I see his point, but I am upset that he didn't want to defend our child from MIL.

Interested to know how others would have reacted in that situation.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Deathclaw · 31/12/2022 15:37

Also, so many people having a very difficult time telling the difference between sex and gender and knowing that gender dysphoria is a real thing.

@NRCOA If that is the case (i.e. being trans has nothing to do with biological sex, as we are told often) why the need for cross sex hormones/surgery at all?

I completely understand the 'old fashioned' description of gender dysphoria, a very rare condition, where someone believes they are/wants to actually be the opposite sex, hence why in some cases surgery/hormones were thought to be helpful, though not for many.

But with the recent rhetoric attempting to frame this as a far more common and almost mystical feeling of being a 'woman' etc. I can't quite understand why it always seems to involve attempting to mimic the biological sex of what they want to be. And, even more offensively, conforming to some bizarre and rigid gender stereotypes that they seem to want to imply are a spiritual and inherent state of being a certain sex, and not just personal likes/dislikes.

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 31/12/2022 10:40

My mother taught memto ignore anything before but, as it's essentially worthless buffer so excuse me if I totally ignore any posts that start with a version of 'I am as GC as they come, but...'

By mother I mean the parent who birthed me, just for those who seem unable to identify sex without a genital check.

purpledalmation · 31/12/2022 04:48

She was wrong to rant about trans people but you were equally wrong to get angry and swear.
FWIW I totally agree with her, but I am a trans sceptic feminist.

I still wouldn't rant in front of children who have been influenced by fashionable trends and are in a confused state.

I'm 60% with your DH here as you should have shown more restraint in public. A quiet word in grandmas ear later would have been appropriate

FrostyFifi · 31/12/2022 01:24

Trying not to type something that will get me accused of something that rhymes with droll bunting.

NRCOA · 31/12/2022 01:18

Mil was spoiling for a fight and you all know it!

It wasn't necessary on Christmas day, or any other day. She clearly had nothing nice to say so she should have kept her comments to herself.

Well done for sticking up for your child, OP.

Also, so many people having a very difficult time telling the difference between sex and gender and knowing that gender dysphoria is a real thing.

You might want to do some reading up on this.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/gender-dysphoria/#:~:text=Gender%20dysphoria%20is%20a%20term,harmful%20impact%20on%20daily%20life.

CorvusPurpureus · 31/12/2022 01:12

Dibbydoos · 31/12/2022 00:04

OMG I can't believe the number of posts by bigots!

It was not opinion that OPs MIL spouted but discrimination and it's not acceptable in front of someone who is NB or in any polite society.

OP if this type of bigotry happens around me, I am very firm about it and if it continues, I too would make the air blue.

It always makes me laugh when people get upset about swearing - you do all realise tge only reason it's classed as swearing is because the French who had invaded wanted to force brits to stop using Anglo Saxon words.

Well done for telling her in no uncertain terms she is OOO. If her son doesn't have the balls to do it, that's his problem.

Your DC knows you're a warrior now ;)

.

It was neither opinion nor discrimination 'spouted' by grandma. Facts. Possibly tactlessly expressed & a tad unChristmassy to pick the fight over the turkey.

I'm mostly here to learn more about the suppression of Anglo Saxon swearing by the Normans, though. Can we have some etymology to back this up, please?

I like to discourage my dc from swearing horribly fluently in several languages. I'm well up for blaming it all on the French 🤣🤣🤣

anotheruser173 · 31/12/2022 01:08

Sounds like MIL actively went out of her way to pick a fight with your DC on Christmas Day, making her the one in the wrong.

It would be different if she'd accidentally slipped up a few times - but she went out of her way to make hurtful comments.

People always know when you've made a genuine mistake, and when you're trying to taunt them.

Boringcookingquestion · 31/12/2022 00:36

SSDDagain88 · 30/12/2022 19:47

Surely she is allowed her opinion on things like this as much as you and you DC and just because you don’t agree doesn’t make her opinion any less wrong

Of course she can have her opinions… Some people think following a religion is stupid. Or that eating meat is disgusting. But that doesn’t mean you can be rude to an individual who isn’t voluntarily engaging in a discussion about the issue.

MIL was being awful. Her opinion on gender is irrelevant, she was purposely upsetting her grandchild. I wouldn’t have sworn but I would probably have kicked her out 🤷‍♀️.

Soothsayer1 · 31/12/2022 00:24

Even though I think the MIL was way outta line I am also in the 'gender critical' camp.
I'm for civilized debate, not mocking goading & deriding

Crackof · 31/12/2022 00:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PineCone74 · 31/12/2022 00:15

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 30/12/2022 19:59

And when those feelings lead to men in women's single sex spaces, sports, prisons and children being rendered infertile are we allowed to care?

The people who object to this are protecting children from a lifetime of female exposure to male wants and desires and damaging surgery.

Go and look up at the effects of testosterone on healthy female bodies before you start spouting bekind nonsense.

I feel your post is a disproportionate reaction, in view of what MagentaRocks actually said!

Dibbydoos · 31/12/2022 00:04

OMG I can't believe the number of posts by bigots!

It was not opinion that OPs MIL spouted but discrimination and it's not acceptable in front of someone who is NB or in any polite society.

OP if this type of bigotry happens around me, I am very firm about it and if it continues, I too would make the air blue.

It always makes me laugh when people get upset about swearing - you do all realise tge only reason it's classed as swearing is because the French who had invaded wanted to force brits to stop using Anglo Saxon words.

Well done for telling her in no uncertain terms she is OOO. If her son doesn't have the balls to do it, that's his problem.

Your DC knows you're a warrior now ;)

.

blubberyboo · 30/12/2022 23:39

I think the best thing you can do for you child is use the pronouns he wants to use yourself but manage his expectations that others around him won’t always do so.

If your MiL wasn’t using them you shouldn’t have drawn attention to it directly, merely answered by using the preferred one. You can’t impose language changes on anyone else. Many languages are built around having masculine/feminine forms. Christmas Day over the dinner table is not the place to be starting arguments about it.

Redebs · 30/12/2022 23:38

Newtonsnipple · 30/12/2022 23:01

Shhhhhhhhhh!

We don’t talk about any of the negatives behind this distorted ideology. Only think of the warm fuzzy feelings and glow of being ‘right’.

Don’t ask why some non-binary girls are feeling the need to change their sex characteristics (though we are told it has nothing to do with biological sex) by removing healthy breast tissue. Or taking puberty blockers/cross sex hormones which cause permanent and sometimes horrific health issues. Or why doctors whistleblowing on this were silenced.

And definitely do not question why so much of this ideology requires a quasi-religious belief in stereotypes we thought we’d destroyed in the 90’s.

Just shut up. Be nice. It won’t hurt. Look elsewhere.

Absolutely this

Haffiana · 30/12/2022 23:35

If everyone just accepted their child and went along with what they wanted there would be no chaos. The chaos and hurt is caused by people being narrow minded and pushing back against their child - ie the MIL in this situation.

Why should everyone just accept it? WTAF are you on about??

If your child stated that they were Royalty and you had to call them 'Your Majesty' would you insist that everyone goes along with it? Would you avoid their 'hurt' and curtsy to them 'cos you kind and not narrow-minded?

Or is this somehow 'different' according to The Magical Thinking Rules?

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 30/12/2022 23:30

@Carlycat .
That article is so incredibly important and not just for this issue but so many things like it.

It should be taught in schools.

Carlycat · 30/12/2022 23:29

It's the latest social contagion for insecure, naval gazing individuals desperately in need of being ' special ' Grin

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 30/12/2022 23:25

Afterfire

Unfortunately this was the absolute rage just as DD hit secondary school and all her friends started to be called bob and Pete and declared they were going to transition.

I'm more than happy for my DC to do whatever they want when they get to 18 with a teeny bit of life experience under their belt.

What I don't like is this ideological forced on vulnerable youngesters by people with sinister motives, when they are too young to know anything.

In my day it was take that or bross and dying your hair too blonde with sun in.

ganachee · 30/12/2022 23:25

poefaced · 30/12/2022 23:13

Right, and that’s why hundreds adults are now wishing they had been encouraged not to have gender transition surgery they were young.

Parents shouldn’t ‘just accept’ anything,

Could there not be a middle way? If your child under 18 says they wish to undergo surgery you make it clear you do not support such a move, but use the pronouns they request?

Carlycat · 30/12/2022 23:23

I'm with your MIL
Her timing wasn't brilliant though
fairplayforwomen.com/pronouns/

mellicauli · 30/12/2022 23:21

It seems to me that she tackled an emotive subject, where she knew there were irreconcilable differences on Christmas Day. She can't be surprised at the outcome.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 30/12/2022 23:17

Mil shouldn't have pushed her point maybe but shouting and swearing isn't a good look. Your dh is right to be miffed with you but he should be with his mum too for being argumentative with your dc.

poefaced · 30/12/2022 23:13

Afterfire · 30/12/2022 22:47

If everyone just accepted their child and went along with what they wanted there would be no chaos. The chaos and hurt is caused by people being narrow minded and pushing back against their child - ie the MIL in this situation.

If the MIL had just accepted the pronouns and gone along with it there would have been no issue. No anger, no chaos. Just a happy Christmas.

Right, and that’s why hundreds adults are now wishing they had been encouraged not to have gender transition surgery they were young.

Parents shouldn’t ‘just accept’ anything,

Haffiana · 30/12/2022 23:09

Light touchpaper and retire back to Reddit.

Zwicky · 30/12/2022 23:09

My mother voted for Brexit. We don’t bring it up over Christmas diner because sometimes with family you need to not deliberately instigate a row. I don’t do compelled speech though so if she did bring it up, well, “I’d rather be rude than a fucking liar”.

Part of parenting is teaching your dc how to deal with other people being of a different faith or no faith at all. Not everyone is a believer and they need to understand that evangelicalism is oft not well received. When you say to someone, particularly an older women with several decades of misogyny under her belt, “well, akkshully, I’m non binary, akshully”. What you are really saying is “I’m not a walking stereotype like you, you boring old housfrau who knows nothing about anything”. What you are saying is “you identify with your oppression in a patriarchal society, I don’t because I’m am better and smarter and will never be boring like you”. It’s what Victoria Smith describes as “waves of feminism” - we distance ourselves from our mothers in the hope that we won’t be crushed by the same misogyny. It fails, and our daughters and our daughters daughters repeat it, thinking it’s something new. What you are asking doesn’t “cost nothing” so sit down and expect some pushback. Nobody is going to pave the jungle for you.