Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to smack my mother in law

83 replies

yummymummyismyname · 30/12/2022 19:25

Joking obviously 🤣🤣

My MIL has been staying with us since the 18th and isn't leaving until Monday as she lives in the UK so it is a long way to come (we live abroad). Frankly, she has been nothing but difficult since the day she arrived (3 days early!) and has spent the entire time critiquing my parenting skills whilst not offering to help with anything, she has not even offered to cook one meal or help wash up in her whole time here and I am thoroughly sick of it. My DH is out at work most days as he's a doctor so it is left up to me to host her as i'm a SAHM and I am sick to the back teeth of her. Naturally, DH thinks she's amazing and can do no wrong as he is a proper mummy's boy but he does not hear the rude way in which she speaks to me. What should I do to address this as DH won't listen to me when I complain to him and I can't have this again.

Thanks x

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LimeTwists · 31/12/2022 16:25

I’d present her with concrete facts. “MIL, I don’t want to fall out with you but so far you’ve criticised a, b, c, d and e. I can’t keep on feeling on edge in my own home. Please could you not keep talking to me like this?”

Then, every time she criticises you, say “You’re criticising my parenting again. Could you not?” If she’s rude, say something like, “Please don’t instruct me like that.”

She’s a guest. She’s not your mother and you’re not a child. She doesn’t get to give to you continual unsolicited ‘guidance’. Be very clear about what’s not okay but keep it factual.

cunningartificer · 31/12/2022 16:15

I find it helps with rude adults to treat them as you would rude toddlers. Explain slowly and carefully why what they said was rude or unkind. Repeat until subject gets fed up of the constant helpful explanations. They find this really annoying in my experience so it is strangely satisfying but it is also helpful for those such as your DP for example who stand by and affect not to realise the impact of bad behaviour. Ultimately if you regard your DP as the arbiter of her behaviour and complain to him then it's not surprising she doesn't take you seriously. Talk to her, be polite but ruthless. Leave your DP out of it or it gives him more power and diminishes yours.

britsabroad · 31/12/2022 15:05

I should also add u put up with MIL bad behaviour for 10 years before I decided enough was enough. Now I call her out on it. I live abroad too so fortunately don't have to see her often but when I do I pull her up on it. Most of the time she is very ignorant, says she doesn't understand my problem so then I explain it to her and tell her exactly what is not OK.

britsabroad · 31/12/2022 15:02

You have my sympathy. I've been at my MIL for 3 days with her critiquing my parenting. In the end I said, hey you know what you're obviously so much better at this parenting lark than I am, why I don't leave DS here with you for a week so you can potty train him in your house with all your cream carpets, whilst I spend a week away. That soon shut her up.
I find the best way to deal with it, is to give as good as you get. Let her know you won't tolerate rudeness. I've also made lots of plans to have time visiting my friends and then lots of time for my DH to have quality time with his mum and DS, whilst I have child free time. It's worked well. But we still have 3 days to go so who knows how that will go. I'm so so ready to go home.

Squeakybits · 31/12/2022 14:49

Encourage one of your SIL's to get pregnant. She can go there then and "help"

Bonheurdupasse · 31/12/2022 14:44

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 30/12/2022 19:37

I'd record every interaction with her. And call her out politely every single time she says something unkind. Note all the comments over a single day. Sit her or him (or both) and say this is what you've said to me over the entire day, and its unacceptable to act like this to me in my own home and I won't put up with it, you are either civil or you stay elsewhere when you visit. If she denies it you have proof. Also this is very petty but I'd also start acting this to your husband, all the little snarky remarks she makes, make them right back at him so he can see how you feel.

It's not on OP having to host someone who can't even be polite

This OP.

youshouldnthaveasked · 31/12/2022 14:41

I would want to punch her too, she sounds vile. Don’t cook for her or clean for her. Let husband do it all. She is not your responsibility daft wench

StillMourning · 31/12/2022 14:30

This sounds like a great opportunity to use this polite phrase to your MiL when DH is there. (learnt on a thread a couple of years ago)
”Did you mean to be rude, or was it a mistake?”
😁

Stickytoff · 31/12/2022 14:29

Speak up for yourself. If she is upsetting you and crossing your boundaries say something. Deal with it at source. People who are doing that require you absorbing it to keep it up. Genuinely comment in the moment.

Brefugee · 31/12/2022 14:28

Am disappointed to see the title still stands, after reporting it and getting the feedback that it's being looked into. Anyone else?

MintJulia · 31/12/2022 14:26

Take your dcs to see your parents next year. It's your turn to decide, and a perfectly legitimate choice. Don't your parents get a look in?

And if he throws a fit, so what? Why does he get to decide? If he gets really ratty, just go without him.

Ladyof2022 · 31/12/2022 14:21

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 30/12/2022 19:37

I'd record every interaction with her. And call her out politely every single time she says something unkind. Note all the comments over a single day. Sit her or him (or both) and say this is what you've said to me over the entire day, and its unacceptable to act like this to me in my own home and I won't put up with it, you are either civil or you stay elsewhere when you visit. If she denies it you have proof. Also this is very petty but I'd also start acting this to your husband, all the little snarky remarks she makes, make them right back at him so he can see how you feel.

It's not on OP having to host someone who can't even be polite

^ This!

Thingslookdifferentfromthere · 31/12/2022 14:17

Don't do what I did - I tolerated over 20 years of rudeness from FIL... (Disclaimer - I put up with because I am a bloody idiot and brought up to expect crap). Anyway I flipped after a fairly nasty but standard comment about my appearance. It was a fairly momentous flip and I called him nasty and selfish (both true btw), and told him to get out. He tried to ride the victim status for a while but I was miraculously cured of my habit of accepting nastiness and just did not care anymore. My DH knew I had reached the end of acceptance and was supportive.

I was lucky though - my FIL was clearly nasty... it's the slyer and quieter nastiness that can do the most damage. At least she lives in another country!

BrassMarbles · 31/12/2022 13:59

Is your husband abusive? You sound a bit scared of him. 'throw up a huge fit', what does that look like? Shouting? Verbal abuse directed at you?
You need to think about what this woman's behaviour is teaching your kids. They're watching mum being criticised and tolerating it.
Time to stand up for yourself. This is your home and you should have a say in who stays in it, and that shouldn't include people who are rude and disrespectful to you.

Dragonskin · 31/12/2022 13:56

How! She has to stay for the entire duration of a religious festival (8 days) and then wants to stay for my eldest DC's bday which is the end of december so it's very tricky

Perhaps she could go to one of the daughters in between? Or she gets to do one or the other but not both.

purser25 · 31/12/2022 13:55

In front of your husband ask her to help with the washing up or clearing away.

emilyelf · 31/12/2022 13:53

Also overtime I've learnt great comebacks thanks to all the nasty, sly and snarky comments I've received from them. Before I had these comebacks in my head but was afraid to say it in case I hurt them but now I don't give a shit about their feelings as they should have thought about mine in the first place.

emilyelf · 31/12/2022 13:51

We have a similar problem as my in laws are due for a visit in the next couple of months. 1) they stay in a hotel 2) I'll go off and do my own thing and leave ds with them as they are visiting to see gc right? So what better way for them to spend quality time! 3) Do my own thing, speak on the phone to friends family, order take outs, stay in your room, do laundry, paint your bedroom, do your garden and literally anything you wouldn't do as long as you don't spend one on one time 4) make sure they have a return ticket before visiting.

I live in a 2 bed flat so this helps but also despite planning to expand, I've put that off as one bed is for me and dh and the second is for ds leaving them no space to stay. Which is sad for delaying something due to my in-laws and it affecting the way I want to live my life freely. I have a DH problem too but we manage it like this and he makes it a bit easier for me when they are around by booking the hotels which have breakfast, taking them out etc so I will have less to complain about etc.

The problem is, I'm a kind and thoughtful person and when you host people who bitch behind your back and are nasty then I'm no saint and I can't put on a mask with a smiling face being kind. Relationships work both ways.

ThreeblackCats · 31/12/2022 13:50

You seem to have an excuse for every but if shitty behaviour that you’re putting up with.
Either grow up and act grown up, or put up with her shit. We all know you’d never slap your mil.

Nibidy is making you behave so pathetic l that’s a choice you are making,

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 31/12/2022 13:47

"she stays in a hotel or I do" and mean it - (I know it's very difficult as a sahm) be perfectly happy to move out into a hotel for 4 weeks (you may need to take tiny children with you) . "I can come over to visit 😀"

different family member but did work for me, suddenly them staying in a hotel doesn't seem so unreasonable well if they come you're forking out for a hotel either way either she stays in it or I do.

PatientZorro · 31/12/2022 13:46

Mumsanetta · 30/12/2022 19:50

Sorry @yummymummyismyname but this isn’t a MIL problem or a DH problem, this is a you problem. You understandably do not want your MIL to visit but you either do not have the back bone or do not dislike the visits enough to stop them happening. Why do you allow your DH to get his way by either pestering you or having a hissy fit? Why are you agreeing with him that his feelings matter more than yours? I’m sure this isn’t how you parent and you are able to impose boundaries. Definitely a you problem. But the upside to that is you have the power to change it.

This. Reading through your posts I’m not sure you really want solutions as you reject all suggestions and act like you have no free will. If you do nothing then this will just continue.

Brefugee · 31/12/2022 13:42

I did try that this year as we had exactly the same situation last year and I said never again, but i ended up giving in as he wore me down.

that in response to saying "no" to future visits. You're British? Just say if she's coming for 2 weeks, that he needs to be there because you will be in UK visiting your family. Or other version of this.

stealthninjamum · 31/12/2022 13:39

I’m assuming it isn’t as easy as ltb if op is abroad and maybe can’t just get a job or take the dc ‘home’?

Op, I agree about recording her so your ‘d’h can see what you put up with.

Also could you just focus on going out with dc / or even just the younger one as the oldest one is old enough to look after the second oldest. I would just choose activities that she dislikes - noisy like soft play, children’s films at the cinema, swimming, climbing. So spend as much time away from her.

SeasonFinale · 31/12/2022 13:32

It is not illegal to record her so fill your boots and let him hear. If he chooses not to hear and deal with it play it back to her and ask her whether she thinks what she is saying is appropriate. It won't get addressed unless you address it.

Marigoldandivy · 31/12/2022 13:29

Definitely the ‘record her’ advice. If it is just shared between you and your DH, she won’t know anything about it, but it might give him a different perspective!