Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Mum or Sister unreasonable?

90 replies

Stuckinmiddle22 · 30/12/2022 17:20

This year we were all apart for Christmas but Zoomed on Christmas Day. My sister is pregnant and at her in laws, I’m with DH family and my mum and step dad are home alone (we alternate) but plan to see each other New Years Day.

Before sister went, there was talk of which room they’d end up sleeping in as her in laws are tight for space and so she took her own pregnancy pillow (it’s huge) so she’d be more comfortable if she got a bad room pick.

On our Christmas Day call, my Mum started enquiring with sister whether she’d gotten the ‘good’ room and if she’d had to ‘pull the pregnancy card’. BIL look horrified and they left the call not long after. DH and I awkwardly chatted for a little while.

My sister messaged my Mum and I to say that her in laws had heard this conversation and we needed to be more respectful as they were guests and didn’t want to seem ungrateful. It’s fine to discuss it privately but not on a call when they are staying with them.

My Mum has taken it very badly and can’t believe anyone would think she would ever be rude and is ‘crying’ and disappointed BIL and in laws think so little of her that they couldn’t tell it was a joke. And how was she to know they could hear the call.

My Mum is now refusing to speak to my sister and both have complained to me separately about the others reaction.

YANBU - sister was fine, Mum is overreacting
YABU - sister overreacted at the time

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jannier · 30/12/2022 22:43

saraclara · 30/12/2022 17:49

They weren't even in the room! So how was she to know they were eavesdropping on her conversation with her daughter?

People walk into rooms especially in their own homes.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 30/12/2022 22:22

Your mum sounds more in the wrong to me. She did something that upset your sister (and BIL). Whether it was wrong or not I would have thought she could appreciate their perspective and how always it might have been.

Also your mum crying and refusing to talk to your sister scream of emotional immaturity.

This has been made into a bigger deal than it needed to be.

Mum - ”sorry I didn’t realise it would be offensive it was meant light heartedly. I didn’t mean to upset anyone. I apologise”

sister- “that’s ok. I just told you but didn’t think you would repeat it while they could hear. They’re a little miffed but I’m sure it’ll be forgotten soon”.

could have literally been that easy

IDontWantToBeAPie · 30/12/2022 22:21

Neither of them and both of them. I think your mum is playing the victim, your sister is being precious and your in laws are thick if they don't realise there's a good room.

They all need to chill out

Thedoglovesmemore · 30/12/2022 22:04

Your mum put her foot in it and not surprisingly your sister was embarrassed

Your sister’s subsequent text was a bit sniffy and formal when a simple ‘omg well that was embarrassing when they all overheard thanks for dropping me in it mum!’ would have done.

Your mum should then have replied ‘shit I know me and my big mouth so sorry hope it’s not been too awkward’

And then everyone should have moved on.

Ultimately I think your mum is at fault as she could have just held her hands up and said sorry and then it would be up to your sister to drop it. Your mum crying and claiming victim status is a bit off really.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/12/2022 21:56

What she said wasn’t that awful, but it was worth a text from your sister just to point out she needs to think. The making a fuss and turning all around so she’s the victim is the worst bit. Just to clarify.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/12/2022 21:55

Your mum sounds like a great many people in the world who think they are absolved from thinking before they speak. She’s not, no one is, and she’s in the wrong. She should have just taken your sister’s reproach and apologised.

RedRed20 · 30/12/2022 21:50

Mums reaction is a bit much but don’t think she really did anything wrong. Your sister seems embarrassed to be caught out and I imagine her DH has said something to her as sounds like he was the one upset by it.

Hankunamatata · 30/12/2022 21:46

Your mum needs to acknowledge that her joke backfired and embarrassed her dd and sil. Even if she didn't mean to she caused hurt and embarrassment, she did and needs to own it and apologise.

DreamingOfAGreenChristmas · 30/12/2022 21:39

Your Mum was thoughtless and tactless.

And when your sister told her she should have said ‘OMG, I’m so sorry, I didn’t think! I would never wish to disrespect your ILs and please tell them I know how spoilt you are when you go there. So sorry if I made it awkward for you’.

She made it worse with her drama Queen histrionics.

EmmaDilemma5 · 30/12/2022 21:35

Neither were rude. Your mum didn't intentionally offend or embarrass anyone. Your sister should have mentioned you were with the in-laws. Why did your sister call everyone in front of everyone but not introduce? Bit weird.

Your mum is overreacting but is probably mortified.

All round, it's an awkward situation but hardly the end of the world. She only asked about a bedroom, she didn't call anyone any names. Your sister surely could have explained that she's not sleeping well due to the pregnancy so had some worries about sleeping somewhere new but actually was perfectly comfortable? No big deal.

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 30/12/2022 21:28

DarkDarkNight · 30/12/2022 20:12

Very rude of your sister and BIL to not make it very clear there were other people in the room who could hear. If I phone/zoom someone I would expect the courtesy of them saying ‘you’re on speaker’ or ‘we’re in the kitchen with MIL and FIL’ so I know.

How on earth would you be speaking to two separate people on a zoom call, be able to see that they weren't wearing headphones and not realise you were on speaker? Most people would be offended if you pointed out something so obvious as if you were a complete idiot! OP has said the in laws weren't in the room but overheard as it's a small house - something her mum knew so should have been more discrete!

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 30/12/2022 21:26

saraclara · 30/12/2022 17:46

i am on your mums side here. Why should what really is a private conversation with your family be done so it’s overheard?

Yep. Unless OP comes back and said that the PILs were actively and work everyone's full knowledge, part of the call, I agree with you.

I hate that calls of any kind can no longer be assumed private. The use of speakers had ruined the chance of me ever being able to assume that I'm talking to just the person I intend to hear me. It's impossible to have any kind of private conversation these days.

I think it's incredibly rude to allow others to listen in to a call without the knowledge of the person/people on the other end of the call.

This is incredibly daft. Of course you can have a private conversation but since OP's mum was speaking to two people it would have been obvious they weren't wearing headphones and she also knew they were staying in someone else's home and might have been overheard. If you want to have a very private conversation that's fine but say so.

diddl · 30/12/2022 21:02

BIL was also on the Zoom call-you'd think that that was enough for Op's mum to not say anything!

DarkDarkNight · 30/12/2022 20:12

Very rude of your sister and BIL to not make it very clear there were other people in the room who could hear. If I phone/zoom someone I would expect the courtesy of them saying ‘you’re on speaker’ or ‘we’re in the kitchen with MIL and FIL’ so I know.

Stripedbag101 · 30/12/2022 20:06

You mum sounds
like my mum.

she said something really rude and unkind to my cousin on Christmas Day. U saw my cousin’s face and said ‘mum’ in a surprised voice. My mum is now very cross with me and claims her nasty comment was only a joke and I embarrassed her. She has twisted it into taking no responsibility for her nasty comment and is now the victim.

infuriating.

billy1966 · 30/12/2022 19:53

Difficult one.

Your mother meant nothing by it but she was on speaker and that should have been warned as a courtesy by your sister.

I can understand your sister's embarrassment but also the innocence of your mothers remark.

Have a word with your mother and tell her that her dramatics will exacerbate this situation and she may well regret it.

There is a reason you hear people screech that they are on speaker phone as soon as they pick up😁

Shoecleaner · 30/12/2022 19:39

Your mum was a dick for both the comment and then the following drama.

strawberry2017 · 30/12/2022 19:38

Your mum shouldn't have said what she did and she needs to stop reacting like a child.
Your sister approached the situation in an appropriate manner.

Starseeking · 30/12/2022 19:34

It's the kind of thing my Mum would do, and in this case it is the Mum who is completely in the wrong. She should apologise to your sister for not thinking and putting her in an awkward situation with her in-laws.

I'm betting your Mum is the type who never says sorry though, and with all the tears, tantrum and deflection, it's unlikely that she'll turn a new leaf on this occasion.

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2022 19:29

Your mum was horribly indiscreet and someone needs to tell her that she was out of order and she needs to apologise.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 30/12/2022 19:23

Your mum is in the wrong.

She made a bit of a faux pas, bringing up a private conversation on a zoom call as if they're not wearing headphones then clearly anyone can hear.

Your sister was a bit embarrassed. "My sister messaged my Mum and I to say that her in laws had heard this conversation and we needed to be more respectful as they were guests and didn’t want to seem ungrateful. It’s fine to discuss it privately but not on a call when they are staying with them."

What your sister said is fine, she just wanted to make clear why she was a bit annoyed. She has been respectful and logical and just wanted to ensure that didn't happen again. Far better to do this than for example avoiding your mums calls in case she did something similar. She was honest and straightforward.

Is your mum thats making it into a massive deal. Crying?? All she needed to say was 'sorry I wasn't thinking, it wont happen again'. Joke or not, if she wouldn't say it infront of your sisters PiL directly then it wasnt appropriate. She needs to own that instead of deflecting the blame onto someone else like a child

AnonyMum21 · 30/12/2022 19:20

Mum didn’t do anything that awful (just tactless, but how was she to know she could be overheard?) and sister reacted appropriately.

However, mums subsequent over-reaction is ridiculous… Hope if you show them this thread - currently approx 87% of nearly 400 votes - mum will see she should calm down and they can move on. An apology isn’t really needed for the Zoom call, but possibly is for her childish refusal to speak after?

Either way they are both wrong to try and involve you OP - good luck staying out of it

Hope you can all have a happy New Years get together…

ALongHardWinter · 30/12/2022 19:14

Your mum was rude. You know the old saying,'Many a true statement is made in jest'. I hate it when people say nasty things but then try to pretend it was just a joke.

clairelouwho · 30/12/2022 19:04

Put YANBU, but really, this is an overreaction from both of them.

It was a pretty thoughtless joke-but obviously a joke-and your sister took it too seriously. She could have just laughed it off with her ILs. Your mum is acting like a child refusing to speak to her for being called out on it.

Both of them are BU.

Gerwurtztraminer · 30/12/2022 19:02

Whatever your opinion, fgs don't let them suck you in to taking sides or trying to mediate. It will end with you in wrong whatever you say.

I learnt that lesson with my mother and siblings very early on. I was always trying to try and he;pt hem see each other#s point of view or smooth things over. Eventually they'd forget the squabble between themselves and ALL turn on me as the bad guy! Stay Switzerland and don't get involved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread