Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help! AIBU to go horse riding WITHOUT a helmet?

228 replies

Horsequestion · 30/12/2022 16:27

Ok I know I sound completely stupid but please hear me out! I’m just posting here because I asked my friend and she said it would be a good idea to get some other opinions on this from people who aren’t biased or know me.

I've ridden horses for a long time and am an experienced (but far from perfect!) rider. Right now I’m trying to bring my horse on and hopefully event or showjump him (whichever he is better at!) this year.

ive got a condition that flares up sometimes and makes my skin extremely painful and sore. It’s all over my head, neck and ears and putting my helmet on is actually excruciating. I’ve tried covers, dressings and all sorts to stop direct pressure on my skin but nothing makes a difference and the contact on my skin is horrific. I’ve tried different helmet brands and had them all professionally fitted for me but unfortunately nothing helps because my skin is the problem.

When the flare up is under control it’s fine, but when it’s active it can last for weeks or up to months until we get the right treatment for it. I feel so much better riding without my helmet because it’s not nearly as painful or uncomfortable. I don’t fall off very often and I would obviously always wear my helmet when hacking, jumping or doing XC. But for general schooling and doing flatwork, would I be a complete idiot not to wear my helmet?

My horse is quite big (16hh) and with the added height of the saddle etc I would estimate I’m around 5 ft 6 off the ground so obviously it’s a long way to fall off and I know it’s dangerous, but if the absolute worst thing I’m doing is cantering and I’m not jumping I’m just wondering if it’s worth the slight risk because I’m not in agony with my helmet on and even with the helmet you could still have a bad head injury anyway.

worth mentioning there’s no kids at the yard so I wouldn’t be a bad influence on them to ride without a helmet

sorry that was really long, I’m probably being stupid about it all but I’m just not sure what to do😢

OP posts:
Horsequestion · 02/01/2023 18:56

Not sure if anyone’s still about but just wanted to post a little update.

after posting this I realised how stupid I had been to even consider not wearing my helmet.

I was schooling my horse yesterday (with my helmet on) and he spooked (at a squirrel!) whilst in canter and I was launched over his shoulder. I smacked my head off the gate post. As I said in my original post, I hardly ever fall off so I can’t believe I fell off just days after making this post! I was only doing flat work but it was a sore fall - no concussion but I was a bit dazzled after it. I’m now having to replace my helmet too. I actually feel sick thinking about how sore it would have been I’d I hadn’t worn my helmet, and I’m so glad I posted here first. I knew deep down it was a bad idea but I was desperate but thank fuck I was wearing my helmet or it could have been much, much worse with my head hitting that gate post. I feel sick even thinking about it.

thanks everyone x

OP posts:
2FelisCatus · 31/12/2022 16:21

I think it depends. If you have children then no I wouldn't. If you don't and this brings you joy and you understand the risk then why not? American western style riders almost never wear hats. Could you stand a bike helmet? Anything would be better than nothing.

BelleMarionette · 31/12/2022 16:13

www.condorcycles.com/products/hovding-3-airbag-helmet?variant=30292458766474

What about something like this?

Ninjapot · 31/12/2022 15:45

Newusernameaug · 31/12/2022 10:16

I’d do it - I wonder how ma y of these people actually ride horses?

I'm a rider and a trainer. I start young horses, re-start horses that have problems, teach at summer camps... wearing my hard hat. 😀

Greatly · 31/12/2022 11:43

Skinnermarink · 31/12/2022 11:29

So totally right to say most accidents happen in ‘safe’ situations where you feel secure and your guard is down, albeit subconsciously. I’ve ridden on lava flats in Iceland (it’s not flat, it’s like picking up and down Mount Doom in LOTR) galloped along beaches, through woods etc all manor of ‘dangerous’ terrain and my one horrible, could-have-been-deadly accident happened doing flat work on a ‘bomb-proof’ ex police horse in the bloody arena. He just got spooked and that was it. I still ride but I could cry at how I was before that accident compared to how I am now in terms of riding confidence.

I got kicked in the face bringing a normally angelic horse in. Luckily missed my skull as I put my arm up to shield myself so although I felt it in my face and broke my nose, I really broke my arm in 4 places. I've worn a hat ever since. I've lost most of my confidence since then 😭

Terven · 31/12/2022 11:41

You won’t fall off when working him lightly, but you will when he does something unexpected and throws you. That’s why you use a helmet, for the unexpected.

Sugarfree23 · 31/12/2022 11:30

Newusernameaug · 31/12/2022 10:16

I’d do it - I wonder how ma y of these people actually ride horses?

I rode occasionally as a child and rode regularly in my 20s (when I had time & money).
But you don't need to be an Olympic rider to know horses are big prey animals who get spooked occasionally and a fall could result in head injury.

Skinnermarink · 31/12/2022 11:29

So totally right to say most accidents happen in ‘safe’ situations where you feel secure and your guard is down, albeit subconsciously. I’ve ridden on lava flats in Iceland (it’s not flat, it’s like picking up and down Mount Doom in LOTR) galloped along beaches, through woods etc all manor of ‘dangerous’ terrain and my one horrible, could-have-been-deadly accident happened doing flat work on a ‘bomb-proof’ ex police horse in the bloody arena. He just got spooked and that was it. I still ride but I could cry at how I was before that accident compared to how I am now in terms of riding confidence.

Greatly · 31/12/2022 11:24

I actually wear a helmet when I bring in and turnout as well - that's when I've had horse related accidents!

Greatly · 31/12/2022 11:23

Skinnermarink · 31/12/2022 11:21

I wonder how often you do.

Quite. Although I think in the states its more socially acceptable to ride without one.

Skinnermarink · 31/12/2022 11:21

Newusernameaug · 31/12/2022 10:16

I’d do it - I wonder how ma y of these people actually ride horses?

I wonder how often you do.

Greatly · 31/12/2022 10:26

Newusernameaug · 31/12/2022 10:16

I’d do it - I wonder how ma y of these people actually ride horses?

I have ridden and owned horses for 50 years and I wouldn't do it - and more to the point I wouldn't encourage someone else to do it.

LindaEllen · 31/12/2022 10:26

Nope. If it hurts too much to put on, you just don't ride. Horse riding is not an essential activity.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 31/12/2022 10:17

Newusernameaug · 31/12/2022 10:16

I’d do it - I wonder how ma y of these people actually ride horses?

I ride weekly and would never, ever get on a horse without a helmet. It only takes a split second.

Newusernameaug · 31/12/2022 10:16

I’d do it - I wonder how ma y of these people actually ride horses?

Ninjapot · 31/12/2022 10:05

walkinthewoodstoday · 30/12/2022 20:10

Sorry, but I didn't even need to read the whole OP. Ffs, you need to wear a helmet and ideally a back protector. My relative was thrown off his horse, completely unpredicated due to being spooked. He was in a coma for months and although recovered, has not ever been quite the same. What stopped him from dying- his old riding hat. Might not have been the best, but surely saved him. Has a big crack in it now.

If you'd taken the time to at least read Op's posts you'd know that she's not going to ride without a hat.

LadyLolaRuben · 31/12/2022 10:03

Dont be a dick

Greatly · 31/12/2022 09:57

Astrak · 31/12/2022 09:06

I've ridden for 70+ years. Everything from daft Native ponies through Arabians to Thoroughbreds. I have always worn a riding hat. My current Arabian is 16hh of chestnut attitude, with an advanced sense of humour. Beautifully schooled and utterly responsive. Traffic and pheasant proof.
The last time I fell off was 40 years ago, showjumping a previous Arabian horse in a well-maintained sandschool. I was wearing a full-harness in-date riding helmet. I was temporarily knocked out and was slightly concussed. If I hadn't been wearing a hat, I would probably been seriously brain injured.
I wear a hard hat and gloves to lead my current horse. I know him backwards, but he's a flight animal, and as such unpredictable.

I'm impressed! I'm 56 but have recently lost my confidence after an accident on the ground. Used to ride dds horse but he has too much personality for me now.

Astrak · 31/12/2022 09:06

I've ridden for 70+ years. Everything from daft Native ponies through Arabians to Thoroughbreds. I have always worn a riding hat. My current Arabian is 16hh of chestnut attitude, with an advanced sense of humour. Beautifully schooled and utterly responsive. Traffic and pheasant proof.
The last time I fell off was 40 years ago, showjumping a previous Arabian horse in a well-maintained sandschool. I was wearing a full-harness in-date riding helmet. I was temporarily knocked out and was slightly concussed. If I hadn't been wearing a hat, I would probably been seriously brain injured.
I wear a hard hat and gloves to lead my current horse. I know him backwards, but he's a flight animal, and as such unpredictable.

Hellsmovie · 31/12/2022 08:48

Meh. Its your life do as you please

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 31/12/2022 08:27

Generally if you're riding within your skill level , especially in flatwork you're unlikely to have an accident. But it does only take one accident to ruin your whole life.

Well that's the thing, isn't it? I know people who've ridden for years and never fallen off, but it only takes one time.

I've only come off once and that was doing flatwork in a school on a "bomb proof" riding school horse. He did nothing wrong and I did nothing wrong - he just lost his footing and fell forwards and couldn't right himself until I went over his head onto the ground.

countrygirl99 · 31/12/2022 04:02

There is a top dressage rider who is blind in one eye after she came off schooling her horse.

Sugarfree23 · 31/12/2022 03:59

Op please don't. It just takes something daft to spook a horse and you know that. I was in an arena, the most bomb proof school pony was spooked by a daft 6mth old puppy. Threw my friend into the wall. She slid down it cartoon style. Luckily for her just a bit brused but...you just never know with horses.

I'd maybe try a fleece lined ski helmet or something.
Hope you get answers soon for your skin.

custardbear · 31/12/2022 03:56

Not worth the risk, a girl at my school died falling off her horse wearing a helmet (before the safer chin strap was mandatory) as it just had a stupid bit of elastic which people often had around the peak anyway ... she was very experienced too - just take a break til your condition sorts itself out