Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder how many women are in respectful marriages?

116 replies

Gingernat · 30/12/2022 15:00

I am not researching for anything, I am just nosey! If this question offends anyone, I'm sorry. Please just ignore this thread if so.

I've asked about married couples because finances are different in a marriage setting. But of course if your non-married relationship is a marriage in all but name, fire on and vote!

Sorry it's long! There are a lot more things I could add but I don't want to keep you all day 😁

Does your marriage tick ALL these boxes:

  • we consider each other's needs equally important to our own
  • we have a fair split of paid work, house work, and caring work, and value each other's contribution
  • we both have access to all the money. We either both spend freely from the same pot, or we take out equal spending money each for non-essentials. (I realise this is complicated if you have stepchildren - if so, just consider the essence of the point).
  • we (and our children) are the most important thing in each other's lives and our actions show this. We always prioritise our marriage/family in every situation.
  • we have each other's backs. We would defend each other against anyone who wrongs us, including our own parents etc.
  • we don't engage in any non-monogamous behaviour. We trust each other not to cheat.
  • when we disagree, we talk about the problem respectfully. Voices may get a little raised, but we never shout violently at each other. We never trade insults.
  • we never abuse each other in any way, even in 'mild' ways, such as giving each other the silent treatment.
  • we never lie to each other.
  • when times are hard and the relationship is more of a struggle, we both make the effort to spend time together and support each other.
  • we always talk about how we're feeling and don't let things fester. If we say 'XYZ is bothering me', the other person makes efforts to change (assuming request is reasonable).
  • if we do something wrong, we apologise and try to make changes.

YANBU - my marriage ticks all these boxes.
YABU - my marriage does not.

OP posts:
unlimiteddilutingjuice · 30/12/2022 16:09

Some but not all of that. Perhaps 70%
You set a high bar.

gogohmm · 30/12/2022 16:09

When I was married we ticked these boxes, we certainly were far happier even when we split than many, just no longer were in love, still friends.

yaflouloci · 30/12/2022 16:09

Guilty of silent treatment very occasionally.

We don't share money. We both contribute equally to a joint account for everything we share.

What's left in our private bank accounts is private and spent how we like.

Mamamia32 · 30/12/2022 16:09

Yes but we have separate bank accounts and just pay for different things to share rent/bills.

MakeMineALarge1 · 30/12/2022 16:07

DuplicateUserName · 30/12/2022 16:01

I don't understand this?

Are you saying the list is boring because the OP hasn't included questions about having fun, or that you believe a marriage that ticks all the boxes can't possibly have any fun in it?

I think the list does sound boring
I think I have a bloody good marriage, yes we disagree re housework and we have different views on a lot of things, we snap when we're tired, but we're human, but we have a hell of a lot of fun together.

SwordToFlamethrower · 30/12/2022 16:06

My marriage ticks all these boxes. I've never felt happier in my life. Married 2 years, together 8 years.

My husband waited on me hand and foot in pregnancy and post partum and as a result, I have healed well from an episiotomy and very difficult and long labour, our daughter is thriving and I didn't get any baby blues.

We communicate really well, prioritise each other and are best friends. We also have a really fantastic sex life 😍

Hbh17 · 30/12/2022 16:06

Why is sharing all money on the list? Married for 32 years and never had a joint bank account; never will. So I would rephrase this item to "Agree on financial priorities but respect each other's need to have some independence".

Aquarius1234 · 30/12/2022 16:04

If say 95% marriages have issues and inbalance and not ideal.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 30/12/2022 16:03

Some but not all of that. Perhaps 70%
You set a high bar.

NewMoonPhase · 30/12/2022 16:02

Married. I'd say we tick all the boxes, but we do shout on occasion. But then we apologise.

user1474315215 · 30/12/2022 16:02

Married for over 40 years - tick all those boxes

DuplicateUserName · 30/12/2022 16:01

MakeMineALarge1 · 30/12/2022 15:48

Sounds pretty bloody boring to me
Where's the fun element

I don't understand this?

Are you saying the list is boring because the OP hasn't included questions about having fun, or that you believe a marriage that ticks all the boxes can't possibly have any fun in it?

HashBrownandBeans · 30/12/2022 16:00

That is 100% my marriage

notacooldad · 30/12/2022 15:56

We have been together 32 years.
My marriage ticks every single box. However I would say that DH does more chores than me. Over the years I have earned more money than him and other years he has earned more than me but there has never been any resentment.
Our children are adults now but still a big priority and it is important that we all spend time together eg the six of us ( including their partners) all go out for meals, we socialize with their partners parents frequently and so on.
I am made to feel like I am the most important person in the world by DH by what he says and what he does.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 30/12/2022 15:55

In essence yes, but not necessarily to your criteria

We can be equally rude and short tempered with each other. He is reticent to communicate and I over analyse a lot of crap. But we work through the sticky bits and have, after some years of working through family FOGs, always got each others backs.

Tempyname · 30/12/2022 15:53

99%, except (like most people posting) number 3. We are both well paid so no real need to, we do have a shared account for household stuff. Whilst not screaming and shouting, I think it’s healthy to have a constructive disagreement from time to time unless you are clones and genuinely see eye to eye on everything! I’ve def met people whose mums clearly compromised or agreed with everything to avoid a conflict, producing an adult kid that can’t deal with differences of view constructively.

richlydetailed · 30/12/2022 15:53

We aren't perfect but we do most of these things most of the time. I can't say I've never told him a white lie and I've done the silent treatment when I was much younger but it never lasted long. We have been married for 15 years and together for 22 years, since I was 17.

Finances are slightly different from how it is described in the op but essentially we share.

FallopianTubeTrain · 30/12/2022 15:50

we (and our children) are the most important thing in each other's lives and our actions show this. We always prioritise our marriage/family in every situation.

I disagree that this is always a good thing, I think it can lead to people in relationships becoming isolated and finding their friendships have dwindled over the years because less important family things have been prioritised over things that were important to someone else you purported to care about outside your immediate family.

Ponderingwindow · 30/12/2022 15:50

takealettermsjones · 30/12/2022 15:42

I'm not sure I agree with all your criteria for a respectful marriage. My marriage is very respectful, but things are not always black and white.

For example, our needs won't always be the same. I am currently pregnant and sick, so my needs (at least my physical ones) are more important right now. He worked and looked after our child for a week straight while they both had RSV, without a break, because it was important for me not to get it. He was on his knees by the end but wouldn't have it any other way.

Your finances situation also doesn't apply to everyone. Lots of people have separate finances, but share payment of bills etc. I also wonder what you mean by non-monogamy? Does that mean a marriage with (agreed) FWBs on the side, for example, cannot be respectful?

Never lying or letting things fester are also nice ideals, but don't always work in practice. I've lied to my husband and told him I like his (hideous) jumper, or that I didn't already know what gift he got me for Christmas. Does that mean I'm disrespecting him? Equally I've decided to let things go to avoid an argument, which means yes, sometimes I seethe quietly to myself (but I know I'll get over it).

Maybe I'm taking your list too literally! (And I'm not coming for you, just aiming to discuss 😊) But my point is that respectful marriages can look very different to different people.

i took the list to mean that you would balance needs as they need to be, not that things would be split 50:50.

pregnancy is a good example. I had hyperemesis . DH went above and beyond to take care of me and shift as many responsibilities to himself. To me that is a perfect example of a respectful marriage.

we don’t split each task 50:50, we play to our strengths and aim to have the overall burden shared equally.

MakeMineALarge1 · 30/12/2022 15:48

Sounds pretty bloody boring to me
Where's the fun element

imisscashmere · 30/12/2022 15:48

Almost all of those.

  • Not an “equal” split of paid/unpaid work as I am a SAHP and DH is the breadwinner. So we have different roles
  • We can have ugly fights. We always repair afterwards and these are becoming more and more infrequent as we are both committed to avoiding this kind of conflict.
  • DH “lied” to me recently in hiding the fact that he had allowed the dog upstairs - dog had vomited - DH tried to clean it up. This all unravelled when he couldn’t get the stain out or cope with the pressure of hiding it from me 😂
  • DH is not the best at sharing feelings, but he has come a long way.
Lcb123 · 30/12/2022 15:47

No - because we have our own money (equal income). Split everything 50/50 for essentials but otherwise can do as we like with our money. And I don’t think ‘we’ should always come first (no kids). I value my own family and friendship as much. You need to maintain a life outside your marriage

The6thQueen · 30/12/2022 15:47

I’ve said YABU not because my marriage doesn’t necessarily tick all these boxes, more because your criteria are over simple.

For example your 6th point and your final point are conflicting. I believe we can make mistakes in a marriage (pretty awful
ones), but it is up to each individual what they can live with and forgive. My husband has needed to forgive me for a lot and I him. Do our past transgressions make our marriage lack respect, does our forgiveness now make us respectful, or have we lost our self respect?
Im not looking for answers to these questions (at a personal level, I’m quite satisfied with my own answers), more that I want to point out your list is not exhaustive, nor will it be relevant to each individual.

In the essential theme I think you’re going for, yes my marriage is one of respect. Does my marriage meet all your criteria - no it does not.

Redannie118 · 30/12/2022 15:46

Yeah this is us. Im disabled due to a long list of chronic illnesses and dont work. I do what i can on a good day and sometimes nothing on a bad day, when he will step up and cover everything without complaint or me even asking, even though he works F/T.

I look after finances because he( in his own words) is useless and has bipolar which in the past has caused him to spend money we dont have and get us into debt. Now if he wants something( outside of normal day to day spending), he will ask, and I will either say yes or no, but if I say no i give a reason ie " No, money is really tight this month as car is due MOT ect"

This works well for both of us, but we do talk about it regularly. We both came from bad previous marriages and have learned a lot of lessons !

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 15:46

I’d question whether some of these are actually signs of a respectful marriage. Especially this one ‘we (and our children) are the most important thing in each other's lives and our actions show this. We always prioritise our marriage/family in every situation.’

if anything that would be a red flag for me, marriage isn’t about putting yourself last.

Swipe left for the next trending thread