Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder how many women are in respectful marriages?

116 replies

Gingernat · 30/12/2022 15:00

I am not researching for anything, I am just nosey! If this question offends anyone, I'm sorry. Please just ignore this thread if so.

I've asked about married couples because finances are different in a marriage setting. But of course if your non-married relationship is a marriage in all but name, fire on and vote!

Sorry it's long! There are a lot more things I could add but I don't want to keep you all day 😁

Does your marriage tick ALL these boxes:

  • we consider each other's needs equally important to our own
  • we have a fair split of paid work, house work, and caring work, and value each other's contribution
  • we both have access to all the money. We either both spend freely from the same pot, or we take out equal spending money each for non-essentials. (I realise this is complicated if you have stepchildren - if so, just consider the essence of the point).
  • we (and our children) are the most important thing in each other's lives and our actions show this. We always prioritise our marriage/family in every situation.
  • we have each other's backs. We would defend each other against anyone who wrongs us, including our own parents etc.
  • we don't engage in any non-monogamous behaviour. We trust each other not to cheat.
  • when we disagree, we talk about the problem respectfully. Voices may get a little raised, but we never shout violently at each other. We never trade insults.
  • we never abuse each other in any way, even in 'mild' ways, such as giving each other the silent treatment.
  • we never lie to each other.
  • when times are hard and the relationship is more of a struggle, we both make the effort to spend time together and support each other.
  • we always talk about how we're feeling and don't let things fester. If we say 'XYZ is bothering me', the other person makes efforts to change (assuming request is reasonable).
  • if we do something wrong, we apologise and try to make changes.

YANBU - my marriage ticks all these boxes.
YABU - my marriage does not.

OP posts:
Phos · 30/12/2022 20:38

I'd say we tick every box except the one about taking equal spending money from the pot. He earns more than me so he has more spending money. However he also puts more into the joint account that covers mortgage, bills, food etc.

SomeCommonThing · 30/12/2022 20:36

Your list over simplifies.
But more or less, yes that's my marriage.
However it's absolutely not always 50/50, sometimes I'm putting in 80 to his 20, sometimes he's putting in 90 and I'm only giving 10. It flows.

I also disagree with the need to have complete access to all money, I think it is more important to have a respectful agreement as to finance that works for the couple.

And I don't agree that always putting each other /the marriage first at all times (paraphrasing) is strictly healthy or necessary. There's a middle ground.

swipe · 30/12/2022 20:34

Marriage ticks all these boxes except we keep our finances separate apart from mortgage, bills and essentials which we pay together proportionate to earnings. It works for us.

Nearlychristmas123 · 30/12/2022 20:31

Going by the number of threads on here with people complaining about their marriage, ‘d’h, unequal housework, childcare etc….I think some people were telling porky pies when they voted

Chazx · 30/12/2022 20:25

Oh but if DH was in the wrong and it was clearly wrong, depending on the circumstances and facts, I might not defend him.

Chazx · 30/12/2022 20:19

Yes to everything apart from financial contributions - I earn very little (not enough to be taxed) while DH earns a lot more (45% tax).

It's not a walk in the park and not entirely effortless easy but it's not ultra hard graft either.

We work at it, regulate our emotions mostly and treat each other with respect.

We don't harbour grudges and we communicate appropriately and proportionally.

We've definitely had our ups and downs. We work at it though and don't take things for granted.

amigababy · 30/12/2022 20:12

Yes to all of these. He's my dh2. Married 30 years.

Oblomov22 · 30/12/2022 20:12

Yep. Tick all the Boxes mostly.

BMrs · 30/12/2022 20:08

Yep except box 2. But that doesn't mean our marriage isn't respectful. We work as a team and our careers, work at home split is how we want it to be agreed between us so very respectful.

My husband has a great career and works long hours, I work part time (2 days) and care for children and do majority of housework (we also have a cleaner 1 day a week). I/we are both happy with this arrangement.

TheABC · 30/12/2022 19:21

We have separate bank accounts, BUT we discuss money regularly and we both have access to them. It's done because DH is salaried and I am self employed, so it's easier to track.

DH does more housework, I do the cooking and kids organisation. It suits us.

Forgiveness is important in a relationship, as is humour. We have foibles but equally we need the space to speak up when something is wrong and know the other person will listen.

Finally, I think sex counts. Flirting with your partner, appreciating them...I love watching DH swagger around the place after a well-timed compliment. It takes thought and work but the payoff is huge..

HalfLass · 30/12/2022 19:20

My 18 year marriage is like this. I don’t underestimate how lucky I was to marry the right person, but we've also supported each other through difficult times.
At the moment our teenagers are more of the focus, as they begin to spread their wings before heading off to uni. We do a lot of running them to their various activities, but also get lots of time alone together as a result of their busy lives.
We're quite different people so make sure we have time to pursue our interests separately too, so sometimes separate holidays etc. Without a bit of space to myself I'd probably not still be married.

Mrsuntidy · 30/12/2022 19:17

Yup- all boxes ticked. Married for 10 years together for 15.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 30/12/2022 19:14

Mine ticks all of the boxes, some of the time, and some of the boxes all of the time.

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 30/12/2022 19:09

Ours gets better and more fair as the years go on. It's not perfect but we are happy

Pothoswithasparkle · 30/12/2022 19:06

The money sharing one I probably phrased badly. I didn't mean it all necessarily had to be in a single joint account, that's very specific! I meant that it's all considered joint money in the sense that it all belongs to both of you and you decide together how to spend it. Not "I'm the one earning so I'll give you an allowance while you're at home looking after our joint children. And yes you will need to buy the nappies from that."

We don't have children and we spend our money as we want to.

Though with other stuff I am bit of a USSR.
What's his is mine and what's mine is none of his business.

Joking😁

ringoutsolsticebells · 30/12/2022 18:47

My marriage ticks all of the boxes. BUT we have been married for 36 years and have had to work hard on occasion to get things right

Gingernat · 30/12/2022 18:46

And no, I don't think you should defend your OH when they're in the wrong! I didn't say that. I said defend when someone wrongs us. I'm thinking when your FIL is being nasty/controlling or whatever, then your OH should stick up for you. If your FIL is a darling but you're being nasty to him, of course your OH shouldn't defend your behaviour.

OP posts:
Gingernat · 30/12/2022 18:44

Yes, my marriage is like this. We've only been married five years (known each other very well for twenty years though) but we've had plenty of difficult life events in that time to test us, including a stillbirth. I fully expect there to be hiccups in future, but I hope we will continue to communicate well and generally handle problems without being nasty to each other.

The money sharing one I probably phrased badly. I didn't mean it all necessarily had to be in a single joint account, that's very specific! I meant that it's all considered joint money in the sense that it all belongs to both of you and you decide together how to spend it. Not "I'm the one earning so I'll give you an allowance while you're at home looking after our joint children. And yes you will need to buy the nappies from that."

I guess some of the disagreement probably comes from differing definitions of marriage. I think marriage means a promise to sincerely attempt to stay together for life, to share everything (life, love, hopes, dreams, money (which is the least important of these)), to put the family first, to be a safe space, among other things. That's why I mentioned marriage rather than LTRs... I think there is a difference between the two. I wouldn't share my money unless I was married either!

If you are not in a marriage which is a kind of joining of two people, and sharing everything, then yes, some of my points may not apply fully. No judgement at all! There are many reasons for getting married for sure, and the age at which you marry may also change things. I could have written all this in my OP but I didn't want anyone to grow old and die whilst reading it...

I don't think anyone needs to tick all the boxes perfectly to have a solid, functioning marriage, no. Yelling at each other occasionally can be forgiven and forgotten. Lying about some things. Communicating poorly and letting resentment fester. Etc etc. All perfectly workable if you're prepared to work at it. BUT I don't think they're the ideal, that's all.

I just wondered roughly how many people had a marriage which is (very roughly, simplistically) close to the ideal. I know there's a lot more to it than that, such as feelings fun and sex and loads more, but it was too much for a post on Mumsnet!

OP posts:
featheryfancy · 30/12/2022 18:43

Yep but everything other than 3. We pay proportionally to bills and shared expenses so it's fair but keep spends separate aside from that.

HowCanIPayItForward · 30/12/2022 18:35

Yes this is us

AChristmasCaro · 30/12/2022 18:28

This describes our marriage. However I’d quibble a bit on the criteria-

we both have access to all the money

Yes for us, but I think there are plenty of other fair ways to arrange finances.

we (and our children) are the most important thing in each other's lives and our actions show this. We always prioritise our marriage/family in every situation.

Hmm, yes but I think parents should be able to thrive as individuals not just as part of a family- time for hobbies, friends, personal achievements etc is important (although of course this also contributes to family life)

we have each other's backs. We would defend each other against anyone who wrongs us, including our own parents etc.

Found this one a bit odd. Yes, my dh would defend me if necessary but he’d also support me to resolve things myself. Neither of us has a life where people habitually “wrong” us- sounds like hard work- and we’re both more likely to try to find peaceful resolution to conflict and misunderstanding rather than the approach this implies.

Mountainpika · 30/12/2022 18:19

Yes. We complement each other well, having different skills. Trust each other in everything. Been together since 1971 and still happy together.

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 30/12/2022 18:19

Your second point might not be met but I would still consider a relationship potentially respectful.
Like if one person (a mother) is breastfeeding they might be doing more of the childcare and the other partner might do more housework or paid work at that point.
And if someone has a chronic illness or is disabled, that has to be accounted for - people can put in an effort appropriate to their abilities and energy levels which is respectful, I think.

I think it's mainly about you both aiming to improve one another's lives, enjoy time together and work towards a stable and comfortable life that includes retirement.

FineBerol · 30/12/2022 18:18

We tick all the boxes. Except I get a bit shouty when I'm frustrated . not often

Whatyagonnadokatie · 30/12/2022 18:14

We’ve been together 20 years. I think we tick all of those boxes. But it wasn’t always the case.

when younger I was a lot more bad tempered and dh could be passive aggressive at times.

my family tend towards being shouty and dramatic (my mum always goes for low blows in an argument), and I was the same when younger.. but somehow i have grown up with dh

Swipe left for the next trending thread