Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be uncomfortable with this? Dog related

87 replies

Doggiky · 30/12/2022 14:11

Fully prepared to be flamed be because I know dogs are a dangerous topic on here. I have dogs, I love dogs, I’ve always had dogs and DCs are both happy and comfortable with dogs.

DH’s best friend and DC’s godfather recently got a dog. This dog breed is one with a reputation for being dangerous and the dog weighs more than I do. I have nothing against the dog or its breed persé and my family actually had one when I was in my teens.

However, advice is very clear that this dog shouldn’t be owned by novice dog owners because they’re complex dogs and can be aggressive and difficult to control if they’re not looked after appropriately. On top of that, advice is very clear that you shouldn’t have a rescue of this breed as your first dog of this breed because they often struggle with rehoming due to the nature of the breed as a family/group oriented dog. This is the friend’s first dog and has been adopted from a shelter.

The Family Vets website says this breed are “not best suited to first-time owners”. PDSA says “they thrive in a home with someone who understands the breed” and “they are incredibly strong so shouldn’t be left unsupervised with children” and the breed “need an experienced owner”. Pet Place says this breed “may not be a good choice for first-time dog owners”. PetsMont says that, despite their reputation for aggression, “they are only aggressive under certain circumstances…if they are brought up in a home where they are mistreated or not introduced to early socialisation”.

I haven’t met the dog. They rescued the dog from a reputable shelter but it’s already come to light that there are a number of issues that they weren’t told about (nothing relating to aggression though) and they did consider returning the dog.

We’ve been told that the dog came from a family with children but no information on why it’s been rehomed. DH’s friend hasn’t had the dog around children before. DH wants to take our DCs over to his friends house to meet the dog and hang out, which I don’t feel comfortable with. The friend is very defensive of the dog and people’s assumptions that the dog could be aggressive so DH is concerned about offending him.

Am I being unreasonable to say DH can’t take them there until we know the dog is safe around children?

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 30/12/2022 15:14

We currently have our third successive (i.e. one at a time!) rescue dog; each has been a bullbreed/staffy.

It takes most dogs six full months to feel fully settled in a new home if they come from rescue and we have seen in each of ours that this is definitely the case in terms of them feeling relaxed when strangers come into the house.

When a friend visits - and we never have children visiting - we have a set routine. The friend is welcomed with dog in a different room; friend sits in a designated place and dog is brought in on harness and lead. Friend drops treats one at a time for dog.

That's it. We do not allow friends to put their hands on the dog on first meet. We did this even with our previous rescue, a Staffy who loved all humans without reservation.

I would not take children to visit this dog. Full stop.

SunshineAndFizz · 30/12/2022 15:13

Who cares if the friend is offended.

That's not your priority. Your kids are.

Imagine if something happened and you'd allowed it because you were worried the friend might be miffed.

Unananana · 30/12/2022 15:10

Its going to be a Bully XL. The traits you are describing are that breed to a T.

If its been rehomed from a rescue centre, there is a high chance it was given up for being a handful. Probably by another idiot like your DHs friend. Is he one for wanting a 'tough man' symbol because thats what this dog symbolises more like utter twat.

You are correct not letting your DC near it.

AlwaysLatte · 30/12/2022 15:09

What breed is it? It's not a revealing detail. In any case your instincts as a mum are powerful, and I'd stand by those. The children can see their godparent at your house.

Floralnomad · 30/12/2022 15:06

Why are you being so cryptic about the breed , it’s hardly outing .

Mirabai · 30/12/2022 15:05

It’s an XL Bully isn’t it? Even if not it’s still a hell no.

LunchBoxPolice · 30/12/2022 15:04

Sounds like a recipe for disaster, you’re right to keep your kids away from it

Theunamedcat · 30/12/2022 15:03

Umm no I wouldn't risk my child on an untested unproven dog (or anyone else's child just to be clear)

ohidoliketobe · 30/12/2022 14:58

My kids wouldn't be going to a home which has recently acquired a rescue of any breed. They need space to settle and for the owner and dog to fully build trust without over excitable children coming into their territory.
As PP has said a more neutral location like meeting for a walk would be a much better idea.
I would also have concerns wrt breed and novice owner.

Survey99 · 30/12/2022 14:57

DH wants to take our DCs over to his friends house to meet the dog and hang out, which I don’t feel comfortable with. The friend is very defensive of the dog and people’s assumptions that the dog could be aggressive so DH is concerned about offending him.

Your dh is seriously a fucking muppet to even consider his friends feelings over a very real risk to his dc's safety.

dustofneptune · 30/12/2022 14:57

^^ Meant to say, our Cocker hadn't been around kids before we adopted him (got him at 8 months old, with behavioural issues)

Hooverthestairs · 30/12/2022 14:57

I got a dog "not suited to first time owners" as my first dog and now I'm a clinical animal behaviourist. The Internet isn't the be all and end all, it really depends what type of care this family are going to give to this dog, and how much they are going to educate themselves on dog behaviour, body language, etc.

What breed? What you've described could be countless.
Where did they rehome the dog from?

But no, I wouldn't let my children the home of any dog I hadn't met before regardless of breed. First meets with children our and about, supervised visits to the home until I was comfortable.

dustofneptune · 30/12/2022 14:56

No. The general advice is that it takes about three months for a rescue dog to settle into a new home - has it been that long yet? If not, I'd be waiting until at least that time, probably twice as long.

Our dog is a Cocker Spaniel, had never been around kids before. He had some behavioural issues (reactive, anxious), and we didn't introduce him to any kids in the family for over a year. When we did, it was under really controlled circumstances, and he'd met the parents of the kids many times and trusted them (i.e. less stressful than meeting a whole new set of strangers, including kids). Because our dog is fear-reactive, we don't let him around kids at all, except for my niece and nephew - and he's never left alone with them, and they know to give him space (and they're older kids - 10 and 16 now). It's not worth the risk.

The dog you're talking about sounds bigger and potentially more damage-causing if things were to go wrong. I think your DH's best friend probably thinks the same thing most people do (including us) when they adopt a dog - aw, he's a big softie, no need to worry. But what we found with our dog is that it honestly took a good year to really fully understand his triggers and behaviours, boundaries, limits, etc. I'm not sure you can ever fully predict a dog's behaviour 100%.

In your shoes, I would ask that the dog has 6-12 months to settle in first before meeting the kids, if ever. I understand the perspectives of DH and his best friend, but for me it would be too risky.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 30/12/2022 14:53

Kids have flu/vomiting bug/ diarrhoea on this occasion. Let DH suss out the dog first. But I'd be very wary.
Some friends have bought a very large dog as a puppy with the potential to cause serious harm jf not trained well. They've called in a professional dog trainer after a year as despite their best training efforts they can't be sure of him around strangers especially visiting their house.

Blanketpolicy · 30/12/2022 14:51

There is absolutely no way I would have my dc in the same home as a rescue Rottweiler until I personally felt conformable around it (which would take months/years).

TheAngryFeminist · 30/12/2022 14:50

This reply has been deleted

We have concerns about this user so we have deleted their posts and threads.

Clarklette85 · 30/12/2022 14:47

Absolutely not. I am a dog person and have a rescue of my own, but there is no way id put my children in that situation.

FairyMarie · 30/12/2022 14:47

Listen to your gut

Merryoldgoat · 30/12/2022 14:44

I wouldn’t take my children to a home with a Rottweiler.

I’m not at all concerned about offending dog owners and neither should you be.

Palmfrond · 30/12/2022 14:41

The rescue center can’t be that reputable if they’re rehoming this breed with first time dog owners.
But to answer @Doggiky ‘s question, this fog and your kids , fuck no. And tbh that’s in part because owners who are so defensive of their dogs honour are being dickheads so the general prognosis is not good. I have dogs. I do not expect parents of children to be comfortable with their kids being around them, and am happy to put them away if visitors to my home so wish. They are dogs. They are not easily offended.

Meggymoo777 · 30/12/2022 14:39

No, you're NBU. I have and love dogs, my family have always kept Staffordshires who unfortunately are also 'known' as somewhat of a status dog and can be dangerous in the wrong home. We got our latest girl from a shelter 2.5 years ago, she's an absolute ball of love and fun but we still don't allow her alone in a room for a second with my soon to be 13yr old. As PP said, not fair on your children or the dog to be put in a position where something could happen, especially when the new owners can hardly know the dogs temperament | triggers etc at this stage.
Your DHs friend's feeling are not more important than your childrens safety. Be the bad guy

Hopeyoursproutsarealreadyon · 30/12/2022 14:38

No rescue ddog of any breed should be around unknown dc in the early stages of rehoming...
We had a Rottweiler for a decade. Also have a powerful breed now. Nobody's dc unless well known to our ddogs are around them even with us there.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 30/12/2022 14:38

No fucking way would I take my kids around it. He can test the dog out on someone else’s kids and take the consequences. From what you’ve said already it sounds like he has been irresponsible choosing this breed as his first pet, so I would have confidence in him in other aspects of his dog management.

Christmasnero · 30/12/2022 14:34

I think what all those websites are saying is irrelevant
when I got our dog I looked in some places and saw it was territorial, other places said it was friendly, other places said it was very intelligent, other places said it was a simple dog, some said it was quiet and some said it was loud
a lot of it is nonsense.
I think there are things more likely in certain dogs for sure, but that doesn’t mean anything about that particular dog.

however, I would not have my children be the Guinea pigs, and I certainly wouldn’t have them be the Guinea pigs for someone who’s priority is their own feelings and ego about the dog, rather than my DCs safety. That’s the real red flag here.
i would still be reluctant but more open if it was a friend who’s judgement I trusted, who was ready to ‘see the worst’ in their dog to mitigate as much risk as possible, and who I wouldn’t feel pressured by to put my dc in danger for. But your friend seems more bothered about proving he’s made a good decision on this dog

Bigdamnheroes · 30/12/2022 14:34

I wouldn't have children interacting closely with it anyway tbh. I'd want it on a lead. The problem with large dogs is that they don't know they are large. Especially when young, it's very easy for them to hurt a small child by accident, even if only playing.

It's the equivalent of a toddler pulling your hair, they don't know it hurts but toddlers don't have claws or bite when playing. (Mostly!)