Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not ready for a child (warning: long rant!)

240 replies

Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 13:13

I'm 26 and my DH is 30. We got married a year ago and have lived with in-laws ever since whilst our house is being renovated. It should be complete within the next few months. Things haven't been easy. The household became a very toxic environment and MIL and I have a hostile relationship. She is extremely critical and judgemental of everything I do, wear, the way I talk, where I go (everything) and resents me for not being as religious as she is and she showed it with many remarks. Her bullying and harassment towards me led to me feeling very isolated and I had breakdown after breakdown. Basically what I'm saying is I told DH there is no way in hell I'd have a child whilst still living with in-laws. If MIL is this critical of me just being ME, I can't imagine how controlling she would be if I had her grandchild in the house too. I can imagine being constantly berated for not being a good mother, told I'm not feeding him/her properly, not dressing them properly, judgement about sleeping routines.. you get the idea. I want space and freedom.

The other issue is I only started working a bit over a year ago and I'm still making money and adding to my savings. Having a child right now would put my career on hold for a bit and would make me financially dependent on DH as he'd like me to stay home for a few years to take care of our baby (or babies if I had another quickly). I'm not ready for that. It'd also be harder to go back to my career after a break as I'm out of the habit and my job is intense. I want to enjoy FINALLY having my own house and safe space, I want to enjoy my job and make more money to add to my savings before I end up staying home for a bit.

DH is becoming impatient and won't stop pressurising me for a child despite the reasons I've outlined. I've told him I 100% DO want a child in the next couple of years but I'm not in the right mental space for one right now.. I can't even consider it whilst living with in-laws. I'm sure I'll be ready once we have our own place but whilst we're still living with in-laws, my brain freaks out at the idea?

The last time DH pressurised me, he assumed I didn't want to be a mother. He was telling me the beauty of raising a child should outweigh my other concerns but I told him he's asking me to relate to something I have never done (raising a child).. I can only think about things I've experienced so far directly. I was in tears as I'm tired of being pressurised by DH and his mother for a baby when I keep expressing my feelings and how I'd be impacted the most by a child emotionally, physically and financially hence my decision should be respected at least a bit, surely? Clearly it isn't or I wouldn't be repeatedly asked again and again. When do you think is the right time to have a baby? After we move out and I've been working for another year at least maybe? Or am I just being selfish I don't know. If so, help me see sense. They make me feel like I'm doing something wrong and tell me that 26 is not still young whenever I still have time and am young.

OP posts:
Leaves1 · 30/12/2022 21:50

Might be worth informing yourself about Reproductive coercion/ control.
certainly good advice above about who’s going take responsibility for what if a baby is born and the financial stuff .

VivaVivaa · 30/12/2022 21:49

I would not in a million years even humour having your MIL provide childcare. If she’s coercive and bullying now she’ll be ten times worse as the ‘doting granny’. Stick to your guns. No baby now and, if you do eventually have one, get paid childcare so you can go back to work. Do not get even more entrenched with these awful people (that might even include your DH, only you can decide that).

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/12/2022 21:44

The only way I'd have a child with this man is if he doesn't mention it again for at least a few months and then only to ask your views, if he accepts that you will return to work and the baby will go to nursery and sees this as an equally good option to you staying at home, and finally, if you move several hours travel away from the in laws. I would also wait at least 4 years to ensure any changes are genuine.

Tell him you want to wait until you are 30. That will give him the concrete date you are being asked for.

CatsFreakingMeOut · 30/12/2022 21:38

Your MIL will be a nightmare once you have a child regardless of whether you're living with her or not.
But actually I think your weak husband is more of an issue.
If it was me, I'd be seriously thinking whether I wanted to stay in this marriage or not....

Damnautocorrect · 30/12/2022 21:35

The pressure is just very hard and uncomfortable to deal with. It plays on my mind for ages afterwards too and torments me.

he chooses to put you through that. To make you feel that way. To manipulate you into what he wants regardless of the impact on you.
that’s not love

Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 21:31

KettrickenSmiled · 30/12/2022 16:14

Good - other PP are urging you to book yourself a break away from these people OP. You have normalised their behaviour for so long that you cannot see how disgracefully out of line it is. You need a reality check. Can you book a solo holiday, or stay with a good friend for a while?

I've actually been staying with a friend this week so I've gotten that break thankfully. It's helped me to reflect on all of this and so I thought I'd post about it to get other opinions. When it was just me thinking about it, I had started to rationalise their behaviour and think of anything positive about it to make myself feel better and less stressed. DH told me MIL is just overexcited to have another grandchild (she has 3 already) and that he is just overexcited too. So, I thought maybe it was just me being selfish and putting my own desires above everybody else. I kept thinking there was something seriously wrong with me for not being ready yet and I kept trying to make myself ready for a child but it just wouldn't happen because it's still against my will.

However, I've now come to the conclusion that I'm not wrong for wanting to wait.. I am ALLOWED to have these wants and desires because it's MY body that's going to be impacted, my finances, my emotions and quite frankly, my entire life more than anybody else's. I think I just need to realise that I'm not so powerless and helpless, I'm the one with the uterus after all so really it does all depend on me. Nobody can force me to do anything against my will and I won't have a baby before I'm ready. The pressure is just very hard and uncomfortable to deal with. It plays on my mind for ages afterwards too and torments me.

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 30/12/2022 21:25

"Things like how I care about money and career, when a child is the most important thing and how I just don't value being a mother and I see being a mother as a CHORE"

It your husband feels like that then he can become a house husband surely. I'd be suggesting this to him and using all his own arguments against him.

Motorina · 30/12/2022 21:25

Things like how I care about money and career, when a child is the most important thing and how I just don't value being a mother and I see being a mother as a CHORE (DH's words which were really hurtful).

If he thinks parenthood is the most important thing, then why isn't he offering to give up his career for a few years to stay at home with baby?

Think about what that says about how he perceives the relative importance of his career, and yours. Because, much as he might protest otherwise, what he's communicating is that your academic and professional achievements aren't important.

That in itself would be game over for me.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 30/12/2022 21:22

I've read your updates OP and I have to say they're very worrying.

Your husband is very manipulative. Trying to say that being a mother should be a priority over a child as a reason to keep you at home...presumably he is going to keep his full time job unchanged? And therefore 'prioritise his job over his child'?

His one rule for you and one rule for him is indicative that his mums outdated views have rubbed off on him more than you think.

People in general revert back to the gender roles of their parents when they have children so his attitude is likely to just get worse.

When you say he would give you an allowance for kids stuff and shopping etc, this isnt enough. Mumsnet is full of women in similar positions who haven't had their hair cut in years and can't afford a coffee as all their allowance goes on children and their husbands are able to buy as many toys for themselves as they want. You need properly joint finances with equal access to money and financial decisions (eg either of you can spend what you like on a hobby, or both of you have to check in for spends more than £100, or whatever) without a cap.

Mumsnet is also full of women who bitterly regret having children with a man when they dont get on with his family as they are never free from them. Also women who gave up work for a short time and then their husbands have refused to pay towards their share of childcare and refuse to do any school pick ups or drop offs or sick days etc etc and the woman finds it impossible to get back into their career when they can effectively only work term time and school hours and are unreliable as their husband wont do their share of anything unexpected.

Lastly I think you're completely under estimating how much influence a MiL who has a child full time will have on that child. Children pick things up from toddler age, not school age. nasty grandparents are perfectly able to poison little minds against their own family to suit your own agenda. Don't under estimate how much a 3 or 4 year old could pick up after spending a few days a week with your MiL. Imagine a little 3 year old girl saying to you 'mummy you look like a boy, girls should wear dresses' or a little 4 year old boy saying to you 'I'm not picking my toys up, that's a job for girls' because grandma is filling their heads with sexist shit.

I'm not trying to freak you out or say you shouldn't stay with your husband or have kids...I'm saying that it does come accross like you think everything is going to be fine when you move out into your own place. But you will still be married to someone who doesn't listen to you, who wants a very traditional gender role set up, and you will still be part of a family who bully you and if you do have kids, clearly want to be close to them. People have conflict with reasonable mothers in law who are nice people when kids are involved.

Please just be aware of all the possibilities and protect yourself. In your shoes I would seriously consider insisting on returning to work and keeping financial independence and using nursery (at least some of the time)

theonlygirl · 30/12/2022 21:20

I've read your subsequent posts. PLEASE, PLEASE pack your things, and go home to your parents. I know this will be very difficult, shameful even but that will fad. Listening to you tieing yourself up in knots trying to make sense of it all is heartbreaking. You're being emotionally and mentally abused. This will only get worse if you have a child. Do not get pregnant and do not give up your job, it will be impossible to escape if you do.

billy1966 · 30/12/2022 21:15

Please ring Women's aid for support.

Do not get pregnant.

Stop having sex if necessary, but do not allow this man to get you pregnant.

You are in a highly abusive relationship.

You need to reach out for support.

Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 21:10

KettrickenSmiled · 30/12/2022 16:09

The other issue is I only started working a bit over a year ago and I'm still making money and adding to my savings. Having a child right now would put my career on hold for a bit and would make me financially dependent on DH as he'd like me to stay home for a few years to take care of our baby (or babies if I had another quickly). I'm not ready for that. It'd also be harder to go back to my career after a break as I'm out of the habit and my job is intense. I want to enjoy FINALLY having my own house and safe space, I want to enjoy my job and make more money to add to my savings before I end up staying home for a bit.
Where is your own family?
What other living arrangements could you make for yourself while your house is still being renovated?
You have so much ambition - why are you wasting it, trapped inside this controlling family?

DH is becoming impatient and won't stop pressurising me for a child despite the reasons I've outlined. I've told him I 100% DO want a child in the next couple of years but I'm not in the right mental space for one right now.. I can't even consider it whilst living with in-laws. I'm sure I'll be ready once we have our own place but whilst we're still living with in-laws, my brain freaks out at the idea?
Tell him you are not a hired uterus, & to STFU.
Use strong words. Get angry. How DARE he keep on at you like this - pressuring you until you cry?

The last time DH pressurised me, he assumed I didn't want to be a mother. He was telling me the beauty of raising a child should outweigh my other concerns but I told him he's asking me to relate to something I have never done (raising a child).. I can only think about things I've experienced so far directly. I was in tears as I'm tired of being pressurised by DH and his mother for a baby when I keep expressing my feelings and how I'd be impacted the most by a child emotionally, physically and financially hence my decision should be respected at least a bit, surely? Clearly it isn't or I wouldn't be repeatedly asked again and again. When do you think is the right time to have a baby? After we move out and I've been working for another year at least maybe? Or am I just being selfish I don't know. If so, help me see sense. They make me feel like I'm doing something wrong and tell me that 26 is not still young whenever I still have time and am young.
Note that he does not have a single thought in his head about the beauty of HIM raising a child.
He just expects you to do it for him, while he forges on with his career.
How on earth have you got to a point where you are worrying if YOU are the selfish one here? Your H & his ghastly mother are putting their own wishes above yours, every time. They are being horrible to you, you are getting nothing but criticism & pressure.
I seriously think you should move out, & see how you feel living without this constant negativity & harassment.

I'm at a bit of a loss. If MIL provides childcare, I am free to return to work and I can continue earning money. However, if I take on childcare myself, I become a SAHM. It's not the end of the world.. DH earns enough so that we won't struggle and I'm not a big spender. It's just not what I had in mind? I was at university for years earning multiple degrees and I enjoy earning money and being extremely productive - it's my passion I think. Being a SAHM, I don't know if it would fulfil my passion or if I would feel as though something is missing?
Do not have a child with this man.
Moving out into your own home with him will not feel as different as you are hoping it will. He believes exactly the same things as his mother does, & he & she are looking to rule your life.
You do not want to be a SAHM & sacrifice your career.
You do not want to hand your child over to your controlling MiL to infect with her stupid internalised misogyny, & you do NOT need to end up in a position where she weaponises your child against you (she will - & your H will back her).

When I told DH this, he gave me a lecture of how I'm prioritising my job over being a mother and how being a mother is more important than the passion working gives me - I think they aren't comparable? Both are important, but very different.
He is prioritising his job over being a father. He has no intention of taking a career break - but expects to be able to order you to.

FFS you've got 10 years before you need to get serious about having a child - if you even want to be a mother at all. It's not obligatory. Neither is marriage to a controlling arsehole who wants you to become dependent on him, do what he tells you to, & has no respect for your career, personal autonomy, or rights to your own body.

Your husband is a sexist dinosaur. I think you'd be well rid of him.
Try living apart from him for a short space of time. You might discover that you like it.

My own family are a couple of hours away so it's not as easy for me to get to them. I do try and use the holidays I get from work to see my own family however, so I do still see them fairly regularly and talk with them everyday via calls and messages. Honestly, I'm just keeping it together for the next few months until the house is done. I've made it this far for the past year and a bit, so I just tell myself to wait it out now until the finish line. In the mean time, I just put in long hours at work so I'm in very early in the morning and work until late evening. When I come home, I just eat and go straight to my bedroom to avoid any socialising (unless it's with DH). I totally stay out of MIL's way.

I do have a lot of ambition and I am extremely driven. I love being productive and I excel at my job. I've been to uni ever since I was able to go and have like 3 degrees now - the Masters I did it just out of enjoyment and boredom. I excel academically more than I do in pretty much any other area of my life and I told DH that giving up work is like giving up some of my personality - it's a part of who I am!

I think I worried about how selfish I was due to the things he and MIL were saying to me. Things like how I care about money and career, when a child is the most important thing and how I just don't value being a mother and I see being a mother as a CHORE (DH's words which were really hurtful). I tried to explain that I wasn't saying at all that a child or motherhood aren't important, because they are. I tried to explain how it's just not what I want right now, and all my words were being twisted so I ended up just welling up and crying as it all got very overwhelming for me at the time and I'd reached boiling point. I realised arguing with them was futile. At the end of the day nobody will make me have a child against my will and I knew deep down that I wasn't asking for anything unreasonable and there was nothing wrong with me wanting to have some time for myself to build myself up.

OP posts:
Riri24 · 30/12/2022 21:01

Of course YANBU. I'm so sorry you are in this situation, it sounds horrendous. Please do not let your husband and MIL bully you into having a child you are not ready for. Remind your dh that this is not the middle ages and women are human beings, not just baby machines.
It sounds like you will be doing most of the childcare too and your husband will not be required to give up anything in his life/ career.
Do you have any other support? Your mum or a sister maybe?

Ps. 26 is young...

billy1966 · 30/12/2022 21:01

Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 20:42

I just don't get it as before we got married, he told me the most attractive thing he finds in a woman is drive and ambition. I have that and it's just backfiring in every way imaginable, like it's a curse. I told him this too and he said he means drive and ambition in different ways too e.g. being a mother.

Like a lot of abusive men, he lied to you.

Told you what you wanted to hear.

You moved city to his family...another red flag for your future.

If you are silly enough to stay with him and get pregnant you will be stuck in this city.

No matter how badly they treat you, abuse you, bully you, once you have his child, even if you leave him and his awful family, they can insist you have to stay in their city.

You would be forced to stay where the baby was born and not allowed to move back to your family until your child was 18.

Have a child with this bullying liar and his psycho mother and your life will be hell.

Tell your parents the truth and pack your bags as fast as you can.

BadNomad · 30/12/2022 20:56

I just thought the baby will be too young to comprehend what MIL is saying anyway and by the time my child is old enough to understand, they'll be in school and then with me after that.

No, by the time your child is in school, they will have spent the majority of their awake hours with MIL. In her environment. With her routine. Obeying her rules. Under her influence. But you really should not give up work to be a SAHM. You said yourself how working saved your sanity during the dark times. Well, there will be more dark times. You need to keep that safe place somehow, that escapism, but MIL providing the childcare will not be the solution. I was going to suggest discussing nursery/childminders with DH now, but it's probably pointless. He wants you stuck at home.

Cluelessmouse · 30/12/2022 20:55

Ok but that sounds like his money is his to gift to you if he wants and really at his discretion.
then with that gift you have to buy everything.
if you want to go back to work you know he’ll probably tell you that any childcare needs to come out your allowance, which won’t be possible and will force you to stay at home or give the baby to his mum.
if you want to get out the house, it’ll be very easy for him to ensure you can’t really afford to go out and get coffees or take the baby places, and then suddenly you’re stuck at home, where you can’t get any perspective on things.

it’s not really about MIL putting ideas in the babies head, it’s about giving MIL a window to continue to abuse you and take ownership over you. To make you indebted to her, and for her to continue being the third person in your relationship. Or the second. It actually sounds like DH and MIL feel like they should make the decisions on how you should be treated and how you should live your life.

your family sound great and supportive so please do keep lines of communication open with them, maybe talk to them about the pressure you’re feeling

Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 20:42

DuchessofSandwich · 30/12/2022 16:08

You're going to end uo either divorced or miserable for the rest of your life. If you have a baby with this man it will be both. Men get more traditional als they get older or when they have children. Forget about your love for him at the moment and read all that we are telling you. You must realise somewhere inside you that he doesn't respect you and that he wants a different (traditional) life than you.

I just don't get it as before we got married, he told me the most attractive thing he finds in a woman is drive and ambition. I have that and it's just backfiring in every way imaginable, like it's a curse. I told him this too and he said he means drive and ambition in different ways too e.g. being a mother.

OP posts:
Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 20:37

Sonyrecording · 30/12/2022 16:07

You're being abused by your husband and his mother. He's pressuring you to have a child, but you are still young and it's not what you want yet. That's downright nasty. Tell him once and for all to stop or he is putting the marriage at risk. Be responsible for your own contraception. Give yourself some time - years, not months - to follow your dreams some more before tying yourself down. When/if you have a child never, ever, let that woman take on child minding responsibilities.

Honestly, just telling myself I have years to have a child and not a year, or a few months, makes my mind feel so at peace, in a way that I can't even explain. I feel no urge to have a child yet. Not when I have some other goals I still want to achieve. I've only just settled into my job (my first year in this career), I want to continue thriving in this area. I want to continue building my savings, should the need be for me to need them, and I just want to enjoy travelling with DH and finally enjoy living in our own home after desperately craving freedom from his restrictive household for so long. I have so much to look forward to yet, and I'm just not in a rush to start my motherhood journey yet. Not when I can CHOOSE when to start it.

I did tell him to back off. The last time he didn't drop the baby thing and I broke down and started crying without meaning to as the pressure had build up inside me for so long. I told him to stop it now and how I feel extremely pressurised, uncomfortable and backed into a corner and made to defend myself repeatedly and how I'd had enough now. I told him all of it how nobody had the right to tell me what to do with my OWN body seeing as I'M the one impacted the most emotionally, physically and financially - not him or MIL. He dropped it eventually.

I'm glad I spoke up as before without a thought, I was going to allow MIL all childcare responsibilities. I just thought the baby will be too young to comprehend what MIL is saying anyway and by the time my child is old enough to understand, they'll be in school and then with me after that.

OP posts:
Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 20:27

Cluelessmouse · 30/12/2022 16:01

Op you need to talk to someone outside of this 3 way relationship

In terms of me taking a big pay cut, I told him that if I have to take a huge hit financially, I expect him to give me a monthly allowance because how else can I grocery shop, baby shop etc without a wage? He said this was fine and we'd work it out.
an allowance? Like pocket money? That you can use to spend on joint groceries and joint baby needs? What will he spend his money on?

can either stay at home, raise the child and give up my job for a few years. Alternatively, I could allow MIL to take care of the child during the day
since when are these the only two options? I don’t understand why you would think it was an option. My MIL is like yours. I wouldn’t give my baby to her for 10 minutes unsupervised.

i feel like you can’t see the wood for the trees here. You sound intelligent but quite beaten down and a bit gaslit by the garbage they keep spouting. What do your family think?

Yes, the allowance would be for me to spend on grocery shopping, baby things and maybe if I need things for myself - that's what I intended to do with it anyway. I did tell him though, that what he gives me isn't going to be comparable to the monthly wage I earn at the moment working full-time.

I don't know, I just value my work. Over this past year, work has been my safe place. When I got married, I moved to a different city and away from my friends and family. Hence, when things got hostile with MIL, I'd just stay at work all day and distract myself with the endless tasks there instead, as I had nowhere else to go. It really helped keep my mental health in check, being in an environment with people who knew nothing about what was going on at home, and kept my mind occupied so much that I didn't even have time to think about the trauma at home. I don't want to be locked down at home with no intellectual stimulation as I know how vital going to work and keeping busy was for me when going through rough times. Or else, I just crumble.

I considered leaving the baby with MIL as I thought a baby is still very young so she can't have much of an influence in terms of putting things into the baby's head. By the time my child is a bit older and old enough to understand the things MIL is saying, they'll be in school anyway and with me after that so won't be spending much time with MIL once they're 3-4. That then allows me to go back to work as well. However, an issue is DH has openly told me multiple times how they'd like me to stay at home for a few years and raise the child rather than going back to work at the first opportunity.

You're right, I have been beaten down a lot about it recently and I have been gaslit. My family are the OPPOSITE and very supportive. Not a single word about me having a child and if I ever mention it, they'll just say 'oh whenever you're ready, ignore what everybody else says, it's your body so you have a child when it's right for you'. The pressure is from in-laws and DH alone.

OP posts:
Purplechicken207 · 30/12/2022 20:07

So someone else, who is supposed to love and respect you, and his mum, are both trying to make decisions about and control your body? In something which is one of the most life changing things you can do? No. And I wouldn't stay with someone who did this (including the, I believe, more common woman pressuring man for a baby). Leave. Move out for a bit, tell him it's all too much and you need some space. Move in with friends/family for a fortnight, and see how different your life is. I'm pretty sure you'll prefer it and want to permanently leave such a toxic situation and relationship. Both of them will only get worse if you have a baby.

I was married in my 20s, miscarried, divorced, single for a while. Now remarried and with 2 kids in my late 30s. I can look back now and easily see the man wasn't right, and mentally, emotionally, I was not mature enough (despite being mature for my age most of my life). From someone who's been in similar positions, don't do it. As much as I'm sad I lost that baby, in reality it would have tied me to that situation for longer, and that man for the rest of our lives, even if I left him. (He had a crazy MIL too, he was such a mummy's boy. I was never good enough and was brazenly and backhandedly insulted repeatedly, though they were never keen for me to have his child!). Thats a good point....she insults you, thinks everything you do/are is wrong...but wants a grandchild out of you? Something is really not right here

Paq · 30/12/2022 20:00

Honestly, don't have a child with this man in this family. Your husband doesn't respect you or see you as a full human being in your own right.

This has disaster written all over it.

Hankunamatata · 30/12/2022 19:55

Surely if he loved you he wouldn't criticise you for wanting to work and have children. Has he even discussed dropping hours to do a day of childcare? Or costing nannies or childminder or daycare to enable you to continue your career?

Elliania · 30/12/2022 19:52

Your husband and MIL are misogynistic bullies. I'd be rethinking the whole marriage and I'd certainly never leave a child with MIL. How would you like her teaching your son to act like your "D"H is doing or teaching your daughter that her only worth is having children as soon as she's married? Because she will. And don't think she won't be making snide little "jokes".
"Oh I know, Mummy is at work all the time"
"DIL, I know <child> better than you, you're never home are you?"
"Well we're taking <child> to the zoo for the first time, it's a shame you had to work and missed it all."

Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 19:50

MolliciousIntent · 30/12/2022 15:27

Why aren't you considering paying for childcare?

Honestly I didn't even consider it because I know DH will immediately say "why are we paying for childcare when you can just stay at home for a few years instead so you wouldn't important milestones like their first words (this has been said in the past)? Or, we could let our child spend time with their grandparents seeing as they're both home anyway and have offered."

OP posts:
Unsure1748 · 30/12/2022 19:47

VickyEadieofThigh · 30/12/2022 15:27

I was just about to say exactly the same thing.

OP if you think the situation is bad now, wait until you've had a child - you won't know what's hit you in terms of being coerced and controlled.

I agree and see exactly where you're coming from. I've become quite upfront with DH about my issues with MIL and I've told him already that she is already so heavily critical and judgemental towards me, it will only escalate when I have a child. I would never have a child whilst still living here and he knows this.

OP posts: