Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take DS out of school for last 2 terms of GCSE year

256 replies

Feckthelotofthem · 30/12/2022 12:18

Have spent life's savings sending DS to small local fee paying school (long story re bullying at other school, he wanted to change schools etc so we did it for last few years of secondary even though a massive stretch for us). He is doing zero work for his mocks which start next week, and also does zero to help at home. Out of home with other people he's brilliant, helpful and makes lots of effort. I'm getting increasingly resentful which is eating me up, that I'm working my arse off on long shifts at work (his Dad works hard in a job he doesn't enjoy too) me and his Dad doing everything at home in terms of house work, cooking etc, and doing lots to help with DS being supportive with studies, taking him to extra curriculum activities he enjoys etc,. It just gets thrown back in our faces. I feel like its coming to a head and I just can't stomach the ingratitude and wasted opportunities he is throwing away any more. Fair enough its his life and all that, but these things are being paid for through our labour and sacrifices not his. I'm thinking of making him move out at 16 which is in a few weeks time, not paying for his GSCEs (we have to pay at his school) and not paying for the school for the rest of this year. I know its not really the answer and it will make everybody unhappy but it feels like we're being taken for mugs and its time for some tough love. Am I being totally unreasonable? What else can I do? (Have already tried talking to school, btw).

OP posts:
samqueens · 30/12/2022 15:37

There seem to be two separate issues here which, because of the stress you are under, have become fused together in your mind.

  1. Your financial struggle to pay for the school and how that makes you feel via a vis your own life choices. This is being compounded by what everyone has identified as his entirely standard teen attitude. It is horrendous living under that kind of pressure, but as pp have said - it was your choice and sadly he is not under any obligation to make you feel better about it (however lovely that would be)
  2. His educational achievements. Most independent schools would have come to you and flagged any issues which they felt might result in below par exam results. Doesn’t sound as though that’s the case here. You may not see him working as you would like/expect, but if the school haven’t raised this as an issue with you then it is quite possible he is doing well and will be absolutely fine come exam time. He may even be really good at exams and surprise you/pull socks up after mocks etc. Essentially, his performance is really between him and the school at this stage. It is clearly adding to your stress to engage with it, youre paying for his education, so ask school questions about his performance and leave it in their court.

Honestly, you’re creating a conflict where there doesn’t necessarily need to be one, by getting in a panic about exams which, as he won’t engage with your help, you can’t actually help him with.

Try to make your peace with the choice to send him private, and just see it as an investment in his future which you/he may not see direct rewards from immediately but will hopefully have a positive impact on his future (not because it was private school, but because it was a positive school experience).

Stop undercutting whatever is good about that experience by nagging and effectively telling him he is undeserving of it - this will only impact his well-being and your relationship. It will have zero effect on improving his academic outcomes.

Focus whatever energy you have first on trying to improve your own wellbeing (you sound totally burnt out and in need of being kinder to yourself).

Ask DP to help, create a set time weekly to do something which might positively impact your well-being. Eg. Sunday afternoons you go for a three hour walk/cinema trip/swimming/coffee with a friend. While you’re out he and his dad do one useful thing (make a meal/run some laundry/clean the bathroom). Let your DP manage this and organise it/reward him within that time as he sees fit. Just remove yourself from parts of this equation and try to refocus your energy on you prod using yourself with what you need emotionally, so there is less burden on the feeling that if he doesn’t keep his end up he is letting you down and impacting you.

I know it’s really hard - burn out is real. If you’re feeling this bad I do think you seriously need to disengage from your DS and his schooling and instead engage with what you can do to feel better in yourself. You can just say - “I’m done nagging you, I’m here to help if you want it, otherwise it’s between you and school and I’m going to use my energy on myself!” That models a much better situation for him (and for your younger child).

JJ8765 · 30/12/2022 15:35

Loads of students move from private to state post gcse to take more vocational subjects. He’s well behaved out of the home. He does extra curricular so has some interests. So all is not lost. The rest of it sounds like a typical 16 year old boy. Mine didn’t revise (they pretended to) and did well. Private schools cover alot revision in class so he may be ok. No one will rent to a 16 year old. I remember the frustration (mine had free places so I wasn’t even paying!) but the nagging doesn’t work. Most do revise for real thing and peer pressure does kick in. GCSEs are ridiculous a huge number of subjects with lots material which they may not even be tested on. Most other countries don’t make 16 year olds sit life changing exams. They are known to cause huge stress and MH problems. Some just feel overwhelmed and not know where to start. Wait until mocks are out way and then get him visit Alternative / vocational providers and state colleges. Your council should have a list of alternative education providers on website. Show him the classes where they do English and maths retakes (as this is compulsory). Take him to job or apprenticeship fairs. Then let him figure it out. At home get him to cook one meal a week for the family so he can start to learn how to look after himself when he moves out and to do his own laundry. Find a way to deal with your stress. However horrible they are you have to make clear you love them and care for them, but it is ok to say you are disappointed in the way they are behaving and the choices they are making. Separate the behaviour from the person. How he presents himself to the outside world is a better indicator of how he will turn out than how he is at home. My dc did well academically but behaved similarly 15-18. It’s like their own brains are working against them. I used to wonder how they could be so bright and so stupid at the exact same time. If they come out the other side without a drug or alcohol habit, unplanned pregnancy, criminal record or permanent injury then that’s a parenting success in my book. It is just a case of stepping back and hoping that all the work you put in and advice you gave them before age 15 was enough because they def stop listening after that.

givemesomecandy · 30/12/2022 15:34

You cannot blame your child for your life choices.
You chose to send him to a fee paying school.
Your husband chose to stay in a job he doesn't enjoy.
If you want your child to help around the house more you should've set those motions in place and stuck to them.
Own your choices, support your son and don't mess up his future. You can't just wash your hands of responsibility because it's got a bit hard.
As for even considering throwing him out... I've no words. Give your head a wobble.

Rushingfool · 30/12/2022 15:27

Highlyflavouredgravy · 30/12/2022 12:35

You chose to send jim tovthe school! You! Not him.
This is down to you.

^ This.

It would be unforgivable to take him out of the school you chose to send him to because you don't feel he's grateful enough. At least see him through his GCSEs, then he can go to a state sixth-form, and social services will find accommodation for him - the school/sixth-form will open a safeguarding/child at risk case for him - if that's what you want.

Threatening him with taking him out of school is unkind and unfair. He must feel so unsafe - as though the ground could collapse under his feet at any minute - that subconsciously he probably thinks there's no point working hard or revising because he might not get to take the exams.

Children do well from a position of safety.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 30/12/2022 15:24

@weleasewoderick23 get in touch with your local college, my dd is retaking GCSEs, plenty of students there have 'gone wrong' but can be helped to 'go right' again, and they tend to be very supportive about MH problems as well, perhaps more so than school.

I still don't get what the OP's son is doing which would warrant phone removal or Wifi removal or never going out til June, let alone what the Op has suggested- that's the bit I'm missing. That would be a recipe for isolation and MH issues, is he out excessively, rude, doing drugs? I just don't think the whole story can be here.

Fruitsalaaad · 30/12/2022 15:24

User57713 · 30/12/2022 12:34

I would not damage his gcse chances but I would cut back on the extra things if you feel he's majorly taking advantage, bearing in mind that most teenagers are pretty self-centred anyway.
Stop driving him to extra activities, stop paying for his Internet, make him earn those privileges by pulling his weight around the house.
Don't pick up his dirty clothes, make him wash them himself. Stock the cupboard with basics and not necessarily the things he particularly likes.
But don't mess up his schooling, that really is the nuclear option

This sounds like great advice, I think.

weleasewoderick23 · 30/12/2022 15:19

trulyunruly01 · 30/12/2022 13:12

I've paid privately for GCSEs. I've taken her out of school as she said she couldn't bear to be there. I've paid privately for A levels. I've subscribed to online schools so she could study from her bed if needs be. I've arranged tutoring. I've trekked the country looking at unis and smiled and nodded as she changed her mind about degree courses every other day. Locked myself in the bathroom and cried many times too, worrying about her future. (But never contemplated chucking her out.)
Made no difference. She fucked up her A levels, didn't go to uni, got the sort of job her grandma would have frowned at and now, at 21, earns more than I do, has a better car, better holidays and is happy as Larry, putting £1k a month away for her house deposit.
We have a great relationship and I think that's because I never gave up on her. "Never mind, there's more than one way to skin a cat" was my motto for years (apols cat-lovers). Sorry, but the money is sunk costs. Best forgotten about. Lots of talk about the future. Lots of options mentioned, but don't turn it into a laying down of the law. A bit of 'let's get through the next six months and see where we are'. Because really that's all you can do, hope for the best with GCSEs and hope that his results help him work out the next bit of the path.
I think you just have to keep on keeping on.

Thankyou for posting this. I've had to pull my 16 year old ( yr 11) ds from school because it was destroying his mental health. I too have cried in the toilet because I feel like I've failed him.
You have given me some hope Flowers

Schnooze · 30/12/2022 15:19

My ds didn’t work throughout school but he did put a little bit of effort in immediately before his gcses. Enough to get mediocre results. He actually realised he needed to pull his finger out in the last year of college and is now in his third year at uni.
Boys often develop later and he has to want to do it for himself. No amount of nagging will make him and it might actually have the opposite effect. Back off. He will pull his socks up when and if he wants to.

As a pp said if he messes up, that’s on him. If you pull him out of his exams, that’s on you and he’ll never likely forgive you in the future.

Newmum0322 · 30/12/2022 15:17

I really honestly hope you’re just venting and not being serious. He’s what 15!? And you’re talking about taking away any and all future opportunities, on top of making him homeless, because he doesn’t help around the house! Please take a step back, reevaluate and breath. You’re being absolutely unbelievably unreasonable.

Only proceed if you want nothing to do with him moving forward, because in his shoes you would be dead to me. Truly.

wingsandstrings · 30/12/2022 15:17

He sounds absolutely infuriating and I understand why you are at your wits end . . . . but you need to push on and get through the GCSEs. You might be burning your bridges with him forever if you pull him out of school now and he fails - I suspect that you'd regret it in a few years and he may never want a relationship with him again. I would try bringing him into line by cutting off all money and tech - lock him out of the WiFi, if you pay his phone contract or data stop doing so, not a penny to go out, don't put money on his school canteen account and make him make pack lunches, lock his bank account if possible etc, that might focus his mind a bit.

Whyjustwhy123 · 30/12/2022 15:16

Jesus you sound horrible. Hope that helps?

Seriously what did you expect being a parent involved?

Can you not even fathom the damage such actions would do to your son at this age? It will destroy your relationship for ever.

TellMeWhere · 30/12/2022 15:13

You seem to be blaming your son for the fact that you hate being a parent. It's not his fault. Nor is it his fault you've opted to send him to a school you can't afford.

You say he's a nice kid so I don't understand why fucking up his GCSEs = being thrown out? He's not being violent, aggressive, drug taking, committing crimes from what you've said? My stepkids aren't academic and won't be going to uni. They are aware that if they get shit GCSE results then it limits their college and job choices. They are also aware that we don't operate a doss house, so if you aren't in education/apprenticeship, you're expected to be working and contributing to the house. They'd have to be giving us serious problems to kick them out, I really don't understand how you've landed on that as a solution.

ConsuelaHammock · 30/12/2022 15:12

You’re being too hard on him and yourself.
You have two options

  1. Keep pushing him and he could have a breakdown, fail his GCSEs, hate you , move out, you could have a breakdown.
  2. Ignore the crap. Tell him you love him. Send him to school and cook a meal for the whole family in the evenings and invite him to join. Other than the meal let him stay in his room if he wants. Don’t push revision , don’t push participation in anything he doesn’t want. If you need him to do some chores around the house then give him a list with weekly chores to complete.
You signed up for the private school so don’t dwell on that . The money is gone. He will either sink or swim but it’s only GCSEs and not the end of the world if he fails . Perhaps he needs to fail so he can realise what he wants to do with his life. Do remind him that it’s education or work. Doing neither isn’t an option.
sheepdogdelight · 30/12/2022 15:11

I can't actually see what he is doing to prompt such a massive reaction

OP says he is not revising for his mocks and he doesn't help with chores.
A quick perusal of MN will reveal he is in good company for both these things.

On the plus side he does well with other people, so not all bad.

This feels entirely like OP's issue - she is clearly resentful at paying for a private school and expects DS to appreciate all the sacrifices she is making. And yet this is something she chose to do.

Tough love is withdrawing privileges (e.g. extra curricular activities; lifts to see friends) if he won't do a minimum of chores each week.
Failing his GCSEs is the consequence of not working. Although he still has plenty of time and they will be working at home, so he may do pretty well even with no revision at home for mocks.

GloomyDarkness · 30/12/2022 15:09

Shelefttheweb · 30/12/2022 15:00

No state school would take mid Y11 probably not in Y10

Not true - if a child of school age is not enrolled at school (and not home educated) then the local authority are required to ensure a school accepts them. Whether that school is happy or enters them for many GCSEs, or whether you like the school, is another matter.

I assume there are always exceptional circumstances that LEAs have to step in - but yes I should have made it clear I was talking more generally ie any schools the OP talked to would never be very keen to take students mid two year courses.

Grobblydog · 30/12/2022 15:08

This is my first ever post so apologies if I’m not familiar with correct terms etc. I was moved to post a reply op for three reasons - first, you’re the adult here, not him. So however hard it is to do, act adultishly. Which means trying to be calm when everything is going to shit, and trying to be rational when nothing makes sense. Second, you’re his parent, so however much it sucks to be the parent of a fiendishly horrible child, act like a parent. Which means being kind and endlessly patient when all you want to do is to be vengeful and hurt him as much as he’s hurt you. And third, and I apologize for the length of this, but it’s important, I speak as the mother of a child who started taking Xanax at age 14 and by the time he was 17 was a full blown drug addict who was taking skunk, crack, bla bla bla. He became psychotic, tried to kill someone and was sectioned. Every single bone in my body was angry, my heart devastated and desolate. Me and DH had to reinvent ourselves daily and cling on to hope that one day things would be better and that if nothing else, that was our only role as his parents, to keep on keeping on for him, when he just couldn’t. Now 10 years and three sections later, he’s in his second year of a degree. That’s it really. Just hang on and be there for him, no matter how hard it gets. You’re more resourceful and creative than you think.

itsgettingweird · 30/12/2022 15:04

RoseAndRose · 30/12/2022 13:06

I think it would be utterly wrong of you to fuck up his GCSEs for him.

For what - the saving of one term's fees plus exam fees (it won't be two terms, unless you gave notice a whole term ago ie before the September start)

He won't be able to find somewhere to live, as u18s can't sign binding contracts, so you'd be footing the bill (directly or as guarantor) or there would need to be significant Social Services involvement to find him a placement. And heaven only knows what they'd make of a choice to scupper his exams.

Think again.

He has to remain in education, training or employment with a training component until 18. What is he going to do?

Make sure you give notice to the private school now that the won't be continuing there for 6th form.

Apply to state school/6th form colleges - doesn't have to be final choice, but it gives an option.

Work with him to apply for apprenticeships (might be too late for many, but you won't know until you try)

Go to military recruiting offices - u18s cannot be sent on active operations, and the military is the largest provider of adult training and education in the UK.

Completely agree with this.

You need to focus on what he does after school.

I'd also speak to school as is only be willing to pay and out in him for GCSEs he will pass or must take.

Testina · 30/12/2022 15:03

@Feckthelotofthem where does he think he’s going in September?

That could be really unsettling for him now… you took him out of state due to bullying, and now he’s going back. It’s different of course, as you get older - but he doesn’t know that for sure. He can’t stay in his current school - does he have any idea at all what he’ll be doing in Y12? Quite possible that whatever, “next steps” info he’s getting at school won’t be helpful to him, and will make him feel more left out.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 30/12/2022 15:02

He could definitely get a part-time job though in sixth form or college, either doing A levels or apprenticeship or other qualifications. Don't write anything off til he's done mocks and then GCSEs.

Nacknick · 30/12/2022 15:02

@Feckthelotofthem My DPs mum made him move out at 16. It has affected the whole of his life and their relationship badly. He is in his 50s now and it’s the main reason they don’t really get along at all. Don’t do that to your son.

Sabrinasouffle · 30/12/2022 15:02

Have a think about possible ADD and/or Executive Functioning disorder.
Turns out that my DS had both all along, with Bipolar. Diagnosed much later but presented as though he didn’t care, couldn’t be bothered to study etc.
There are many reasons why a young person can’t/won’t apply themselves.
You are the best friend he has. Don’t let him down. He’s yours whether you like it or not.
Yes, parenting young people can be very very tough.

Im not judging, but please be open to other reasons as to why he’s struggling. Sometimes struggling can be masked as “don’t care”

Buzzinwithbez · 30/12/2022 15:01

I went to private school under similar circumstances and came away with a good batch of GCSEs. I have a son the same age as yours who looks set to throw his away.
I have thought about what if we were in a similar situation and how much more stressful it would feel.

Think back to your original decision and what a difference it must have made to his happiness and confidence. Without having that chance to recover from the bullying situation he might be a different child now. They to focus on that. Once he's through this phase he'll hopefully be back to his previous reasonable self. Being a teenager is hard!

It's two more terms and then he can go to a state college. I absolutely loved state sixth form and nothing would have kept me at that school a second longer though it served its purpose.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 30/12/2022 15:01

Sorry, my message cut off- the min wage is only adult rate (and not even the Living Wage) at age 23, so the chances of him living independently and in a flat self-supporting at 16 is basically nil, he would be homeless/sofa-surfing unless you wish to pay for him to live elsewhere.

Shelefttheweb · 30/12/2022 15:00

No state school would take mid Y11 probably not in Y10

Not true - if a child of school age is not enrolled at school (and not home educated) then the local authority are required to ensure a school accepts them. Whether that school is happy or enters them for many GCSEs, or whether you like the school, is another matter.

Thymely · 30/12/2022 14:59

I wouldn't expect a 16 year old to be much help at home, and staying up late and sleeping in at weekends seems a pretty universal teenage thing. But Is he really out of his depth and struggling at school? Maybe you have high expectations having spent so much money and he's afraid he can't live up to them? Can he get extra help at school if he's falling behind? Is he depressed and stressed out about the up coming exams? For some people It's easier to pretend not to care about education than to show how much it matters to them.

Don't give up on him now, he needs you, although he may not be showing it. Chill out until after the GCSEs and then figure out where to go from there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread