Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take DS out of school for last 2 terms of GCSE year

256 replies

Feckthelotofthem · 30/12/2022 12:18

Have spent life's savings sending DS to small local fee paying school (long story re bullying at other school, he wanted to change schools etc so we did it for last few years of secondary even though a massive stretch for us). He is doing zero work for his mocks which start next week, and also does zero to help at home. Out of home with other people he's brilliant, helpful and makes lots of effort. I'm getting increasingly resentful which is eating me up, that I'm working my arse off on long shifts at work (his Dad works hard in a job he doesn't enjoy too) me and his Dad doing everything at home in terms of house work, cooking etc, and doing lots to help with DS being supportive with studies, taking him to extra curriculum activities he enjoys etc,. It just gets thrown back in our faces. I feel like its coming to a head and I just can't stomach the ingratitude and wasted opportunities he is throwing away any more. Fair enough its his life and all that, but these things are being paid for through our labour and sacrifices not his. I'm thinking of making him move out at 16 which is in a few weeks time, not paying for his GSCEs (we have to pay at his school) and not paying for the school for the rest of this year. I know its not really the answer and it will make everybody unhappy but it feels like we're being taken for mugs and its time for some tough love. Am I being totally unreasonable? What else can I do? (Have already tried talking to school, btw).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GloomyDarkness · 10/01/2023 10:40

And he may well surprise you by doing more work for the actual exams. It’s all a bit far off still in his mind. Mocks aren’t important to him.

I'd agree with this - and frankly poor mocks and good exams results are better than the other way round.

Schnooze · 10/01/2023 10:35

And he may well surprise you by doing more work for the actual exams. It’s all a bit far off still in his mind. Mocks aren’t important to him.

SmartWatch · 10/01/2023 10:13

Great news Feck hopefully a kick up the bum is all he (and my own teenage sons) needed. It's not easy being a teenager of course but it is also not easy being a teenager's parent! Good for you for taking a step back.

If its any help an educational psychologist I know says it's important to 'allow kids to fail' as it builds resilience etc.

Coyoacan · 10/01/2023 04:55

Oh I'm so glad, OP.

RampantIvy · 09/01/2023 17:26

@EndlessRain1 the OP udeated an hour before your post. Her DS is remaning in school.

Well done OP. It's hard to admit you are wrong sometimes. Good luck to your DS.

Clymene · 09/01/2023 16:18

Thanks for the update. It's brave if you to come back and I hope your DS pulls his finger out (I hope mine does too!)

Shelefttheweb · 09/01/2023 14:25

Well done OP. You will find life a lot less stressful in your house without feeling you need to push him all the time. If he doesn’t respond and fails everything then that is a problem for another day.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 09/01/2023 14:21

Great update and best of luck to your DS. DS2 has his mocks this week and I am hoping that will give him a bit of a nudge. He has a habit of focussing on the subjects he likes rather than the one's that need revision.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 09/01/2023 13:43

@Feckthelotofthem well done for listening after your rant, and I think you've done the right thing. you did come in for a lot of flak and took it well.

EndlessRain1 · 09/01/2023 13:36

yeah, you would be massively unreasonable to do that.

It's not his fault you chose to send him to a school you can't really afford. That's something seperate to his attitude, so it's unfair to him to punish him for that by even giving him the chance to sit them.

Is this usual for him? My DH failed every single GCSE, turned out he was dyslexic and it had been missed his entire life. He later did an access to uni course, then a degree and is now doing an MBA. There is much to life after 16, so perhaps don't burn all your bridges with your DS now.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 09/01/2023 13:30

Nice update, don't be too hard on him, he might surprise you re his exams anyway.

Grobblydog · 09/01/2023 13:22

Hi there @Feckthelotofthem
thanks for the update and I could hug you☺️
good for you in having a rethink, and that’s brilliant that you’re going to carry on supporting but also zipping it! We’re all impatient tw**s who make mistakes some of the time, so don’t be too hard on yourself in future. Good luck and take care.

Feckthelotofthem · 09/01/2023 12:26

Thought I would return with an update.

Thanks for the responses, many with useful practical tips. Me (and DH as I shared with him) have read them all. I've had a hard think and released I was being very unreasonable making those threats to DS - even though I could strangle him of course. We've had a family chat and passed it over to DS re what he does/doesn't do re revision over next few months and assured him we won't take him out of school. Did of course remind him we'd like him to do his best, and implications if he does no work re his final grades etc. and keeping his own short/medium term options open by not goofing up his exams. Offered support to help him as much as we can but otherwise DH and I are going to 'sit on our hands' re daily castigating him for doing k all school work most of the time. We can't make him do it is the bottom line, painful though that is to see him squandering chances but so be it.
Thanks for helping me realise I was being a twt Mumsnett x

OP posts:
Wisenotboring · 01/01/2023 09:15

It sounds frustrating. Y 11 boys can be feckless, ungrateful pests. It does sound like you have done a good job as his fundamental character sounds nice and he can communicate. If it's any consolation, there will be lots of boys his age who have done no revision and don't really care. Could he secretly be feeling the pressure?
You just need to suck up the frustration and finish what you started and keep going. You are also very likely to be liable for fees anyway even if you pulled him out.
It sounds also as if you are feeling unhappy with where parenting leaves you at this particular point in life? You have been going a long time and the end is not yet in sight! Maybe do some self evaluation and make some plans to find some new ways to make you feel.more like you. I can relate as one of my children just makes me feel like a horrible person much of the time! I'm working hard to make sure that I have moments to give myself a chance to stop being a moany mum. It's hard though and I feel for you.

RSintes · 01/01/2023 09:10

FGS taking a stroppy teenager out school in the most important remaining terms of his secondary education is downright mean and negligent.

You don't get to squander his life chances now with his GCSEs even if he is difficult at home. If he fucks them up then that's on him but you don't need to add to the mess.

You do realise don't you that his behaviour isn't suddenly going to improve if you take him out of school? In fact it's likely to get (far) worse as he'll use your actions against you for years to come and quite rightly will blame you for all the consequences.

If you fancy driving a permanent wedge between you and your child then crack right on.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 01/01/2023 09:02

It was your choice to send him to a fee paying school, if you couldn't afford it you shouldn't have done it. Teenagers aren't the best at being grateful at the best of times.

To threaten to take him out of school I imagine would be massively contra productive, he will hate you and will probably fail his GCSEs 🤷‍♀️

He will thank you one day but you're expectations for gratitude now are unrealistic imo.

RampantIvy · 01/01/2023 08:50

I don't think your DD's achievements are relevant here @Malbecfan. Your not so stealthy boast about her GCSEs just indicates that she is extremely bright.

Grobblydog · 31/12/2022 17:25

3luckystars · 31/12/2022 10:06

@Grobblydog I loved your post. Thank you for sharing your story here and I hope your son continues to do well and well done x

Thankyou @3luckystars - that’s very very kind of you. 😊

Malbecfan · 31/12/2022 14:56

I agree with @redskydelight . My 12 A stars DD1 mentioned earlier in the thread definitely didn't do 3 hours' revision per night. She carried on her dancing lessons and music groups throughout her GCSE year (and for most of her A levels too).

As I stated yesterday, you are pretty much stuck with paying for the next 2 terms. See what the mocks results are and give notice anyway. Use the time to suggest your DS looks at courses to take post-16. Drop the rope; you are way too invested in micro-managing him and he knows it.

redskydelight · 31/12/2022 13:27

Murdoch1949 · 31/12/2022 06:46

Short, sharp shock needed. Family meeting, lay down the rules after trying to find out what the problem is. Take his phone. Turn off the WiFi. Stop his allowance. UNLESS on his return to school he works in class and does 3 hours of study per night. Give it until half term, get a report from school. If nothing has changed withdraw him, save your money. Local authority will have to find him a school place, as he's got a while before he can legally be out of education. He's taking you and your husband for mugs, and things either change or get much worse.

Bonkers advice. I assume you don't actually have a child of this age? All DC has actually done is not revise for mocks. Maybe wait and see how he does in them first?

My extremely studious DD was not working 3 hours every night from January of Year 11. He will burn out if that is imposed. And he will struggle to do very much at all if the WIFI is switched off.

As others have said, if OP leaves it till half term she will be too late to give notice for this term and won't save a single penny.

The LA may have to find him a place, but it won't be straight away and it's highly unlikely syllabuses will match so he will be sitting and having to revise by himself in most subjects (and if he hasn't finished syllabuses, he'll have to self study to the end). Why on earth would OP do this rather than leaving him in school where he'd at least have to sit through completion of course and any of the revision work they do there?

3luckystars · 31/12/2022 10:06

@Grobblydog I loved your post. Thank you for sharing your story here and I hope your son continues to do well and well done x

meditrina · 31/12/2022 10:00

Testina · 31/12/2022 09:34

@meditrina back in the real world though, that just doesn’t happen in 3 weeks.
And even if it did… 3 weeks is actually more than 10% of his remaining school time. Even if you don’t count state school early finish for Y11 after exams.
It’s just a non starter for that poster to blithely say, “the LA will find him a place”.

They will. Probably not in 3 weeks. And if and when they do it will quite possibly be a difficult commute, low achieving school that doesn’t follow the same GCSE syllabus. When the LEA follow their obligations, finding a school that does Edexcel history not AQA is really not going to be their priority. This is what I mean by @Murdoch1949 not understanding the in year transfer process. It’s really not as simple as you suggest.

Yes, I know it may well take longer

And that it won't make the syllabuses match (though I hope LA, in activating FAP would look at best match of subjects/syllabuses as part of selecting which school to go for - but in reality it'll probably be the undersubscribed school with reasonable journey time (up to about an hour))

And of course none of that is allowing for time to settle and literally find way round the new school, where one hopes the other pupils will be nice to him, but where he'll have no friends.

Tooshytoshine · 31/12/2022 09:52

Tooshytoshine · 31/12/2022 09:51

I feel for you. My son is also a particularly dickish teen to us but lovely elsewhere.

Let him catastrophically fail his mocks and then see how he reacts. I am a teacher and kids mature at different rates - kids who tank their mocks often do enough to scrape decent enough GCSEs.

Average GCSEs and a good school are often enough to get onto a lot of further education courses once he has matured.

If you move his school, he will always blame you for his failures in life. Keep him their and the narrative is you have him all the tools to succeed. Don't give him a stick to beat you.

*there

Tooshytoshine · 31/12/2022 09:51

I feel for you. My son is also a particularly dickish teen to us but lovely elsewhere.

Let him catastrophically fail his mocks and then see how he reacts. I am a teacher and kids mature at different rates - kids who tank their mocks often do enough to scrape decent enough GCSEs.

Average GCSEs and a good school are often enough to get onto a lot of further education courses once he has matured.

If you move his school, he will always blame you for his failures in life. Keep him their and the narrative is you have him all the tools to succeed. Don't give him a stick to beat you.

MrsSkylerWhite · 31/12/2022 09:39

JudgeJ · Yesterday 16:12

Lots of support for the lazy, ungrateful brat here. It isn't his parents' fault he is tanking his exams, he is choosing to do so. The little green monster is running around, I get the impression that some posters are enjoying the Schadenfreude of a student at an independent school choosing to fail.”

Nonsense. Ours attended independents. OP is completely unreasonable. Lots of kids don’t study for mocks. The results are what make them crack on and study for the actual exams.

Poor kid.