Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men in women’s spaces

860 replies

BrightSaturn · 30/12/2022 02:22

Just using this to rant really…

2 times in the past month I have encountered men in women only spaces.

  1. I went to a feeding room to breastfeed my daughter in a shopping centre. I walked in and there were two young women in there changing their babies and one of their boyfriends just taking up one of the only chairs just sitting there, sitting using his phone. It’s a small room with 3 chairs in. I didn’t know what to do so I thought I’ll just sit down and get ready slowly and hopefully they’ll leave. I have fed in public but this was a small room so I felt vulnerable and like he shouldn’t be there and I didn’t want to lift my top up whilst he was sitting basically opposite me so I eventually asked if he could leave the room, they looked annoyed but thankfully he did go, after she looked at him and said “it’s up to you”…
  2. I went into a changing room in a shop the other day with my mum, imagine a big room with seats in the middle and curtained dividers all round the outside. My mum was only trying on cardigans so really she just needed a mirror but in the middle on a seat was a boy about 17/18 years old. His girlfriend was trying on clothes. I couldn’t believe it! It wasn’t even doors on the changing rooms, just curtains. Why he thought this was acceptable I have no idea. Again I felt vulnerable and this time I didn’t have the confidence to ask him to leave. If my mum had been actually changing I would have probably found a shop assistant but still it’s not fair that we have to ask them to leave, he should not have been there in the first place!

aibu to think women’s spaces are being invaded more and more? How can we stop this from happening?

OP posts:
orchid220 · 02/01/2023 10:00

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/01/2023 05:35

And I suspect those who think women don't deserve their own feeding rooms also don't think Stonewall had anything to do with these facilities being renamed or our changing rooms and facilities in general erased. It's just all one big coincidence. Am I right?

No one has said men shouldn't be more involved in parenting. That is your hyperbolic and rather desperate leap. We are saying, that there should be womens feeding rooms, AND mens feeding rooms. Have TWO lots of feeding rooms.

They don't need to say that men shouldn't be more involved in parenting. My point is that if nappy changing changing facilities are only in women only rooms it will reduce men being as involved in childcare. I don't think anyone has actually said that there should be men’s feeding facilities, women's feeding facilities actually. If there is also separate nappy changing facilities that would be three separate rooms which would be great but don't you think the lack of three or even two rooms in commercial premises is to do with cost rather than the influence of an LGTBT organisation such as Stonewall?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/01/2023 05:35

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 13:42

I suspect that most of the posters arguing that feeding/changing facilities are
or should be “women only” spaces have not had children for a very long time or breastfed, if at all including OP. The fact that many are also on threads regarding trans issues and are blaming Stonewall for the fact that changing facilities are “family rooms” rather than recognising that women themselves want men to be involved in childcare and have campaigned for this to happen says it all.

And I suspect those who think women don't deserve their own feeding rooms also don't think Stonewall had anything to do with these facilities being renamed or our changing rooms and facilities in general erased. It's just all one big coincidence. Am I right?

No one has said men shouldn't be more involved in parenting. That is your hyperbolic and rather desperate leap. We are saying, that there should be womens feeding rooms, AND mens feeding rooms. Have TWO lots of feeding rooms.

Rollingaroundinmud · 01/01/2023 20:35

Trez1510 · 30/12/2022 03:05

The OP appeared to have been making the case, and backed up by you, that fathers should not be in feeding/changing rooms.

That would be discriminatory in my opinion.

Your response is funny I should ask dp how he feels next time.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 01/01/2023 20:04

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 18:13

A if a woman states she's breastfed then why disbelieve her experience?

I'm not sure that any of the posters arguing that feeding/baby changing facilities should be women only have said they breast fed actually. Did you?

Yes I did - and used the recently installed breastfeeding room in my local John Lewis which is why I know they existed. Although I didn't personally get involved there were lots of women in the 80s / 90s who campaigned to remove the stigma from breastfeeding in public and to stop women being routinely asked to leave places - both by normalising women feeding in public and by getting larger businesses to meet their needs with private spaces.
Back then few employers / businesses made accommodation for breastfeeding women and it's taken a lot of effort over the years to get women's needs identified, spoken about and met.

ClitoralViolence · 01/01/2023 19:59

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 19:52

@ClitoralViolence quite happily, the day I don't have to wait longer than DH for the fitting room or toilet will be a good day.

Enjoy the leers, sneers, "accidental" curtain pulling and outright assaults then. The rest of us prefer safety and dignity.

DdraigGoch · 01/01/2023 19:54

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 16:27

If it was just a breastfeeding room and there were no nappy changing facilities then how were two women changing their babies?

I'm not scrolling back through the entire thread to check but I'm pretty sure that the OP said that a separate nappy changing room was provided.

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 19:52

@ClitoralViolence quite happily, the day I don't have to wait longer than DH for the fitting room or toilet will be a good day.

ClitoralViolence · 01/01/2023 19:50

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 18:51

But we all pay for that through increased costs which will be recouped by whoever builds them. If their wasn't another way to feed a baby it would be a necessity,
but what your asking for is in a cost of living crisis to spend more money that isn't needed.

Any single sex facilities increase costs. Are you going to argue against those too?

Whatsnewpussyhat · 01/01/2023 19:14

In addition, many women who bottle fed felt that breastfeeding rooms were unfair to their babies and they have a point

Unfair to their babies? What is this point?
The rooms are their for the women who feel uncomfortable and vulnerable potentially exposing their breasts in public whilst trying to feed their babies so why on earth would this be 'unfair' to bottle fed babies.
It's about the women not the babies.

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 18:51

ShrillBill · 01/01/2023 16:23

Because you know anyone who isn't breastfeeding is not supposed to be in a room dedicated to breastfeeding.

So what we need is;
Breastfeeding room (single sex, single purpose) and
mixed sex family room. We all win.

But we all pay for that through increased costs which will be recouped by whoever builds them. If their wasn't another way to feed a baby it would be a necessity,
but what your asking for is in a cost of living crisis to spend more money that isn't needed.

ClitoralViolence · 01/01/2023 18:37

In addition, many women who bottle fed felt that breastfeeding rooms were unfair to their babies and they have a point.

Its not about the babies though is it? Its about the women who don't aren't confident enough to or just dont want to get their tits out in public.
If you suddenly say these rooms are all mixed sex, whats the difference between these rooms and a quiet corner in a coffee shop? And then the women who can't get undressed in mixed sex areas are suddenly excluded from spending any length of time in public life until they stop breastfeeding. I know who's being discriminated against here and its not the babies.

ClitoralViolence · 01/01/2023 18:32

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 16:34

I'm not sure there are any rooms dedicated just to breastfeeding. Women who bottle feed their babies would argue that discriminated against their babies. I think it would be good to separate feeding from nappy changing but I suppose that would be up to the shops etc providing the facilities.

I maybe slightly shortsighted, but I didn't realise I was actually blind. So the Breastfeeding rooms (there were 2 lockable individual rooms) at the Children's hospital dedicated to breastfeeding just didnt exist and the signs didn't say breastfeeding?
Thanks for clarifying that to me.

ClitoralViolence · 01/01/2023 18:26

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 16:21

Because they are usually in the same room including in OP's example.

Well thats disingenuous isnt it.

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 18:13

A if a woman states she's breastfed then why disbelieve her experience?

I'm not sure that any of the posters arguing that feeding/baby changing facilities should be women only have said they breast fed actually. Did you?

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 18:06

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

I didn't say anything about campaigning "successfully" for breast feeding spaces actually. The main focus of campaigns (which I was involved with along with a lot of other women) was on being able to breast feed anywhere without being told to leave the premises or being discriminated against and that has happened. The focus wasn't on having single sex breastfeeding spaces. At the time I personally thought that it would be good if there were breastfeeding spaces that were separate from nappy changing but the most important thing were baby changing facilities that both men and women could use or family rooms . In addition, many women who bottle fed felt that breastfeeding rooms were unfair to their babies and they have a point.

Your use of "unintentional consequence" suggests that most women with babies/toddlers would like the nappy changing rooms to be single sex rather than family but I don't think so.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 01/01/2023 17:27

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 13:42

I suspect that most of the posters arguing that feeding/changing facilities are
or should be “women only” spaces have not had children for a very long time or breastfed, if at all including OP. The fact that many are also on threads regarding trans issues and are blaming Stonewall for the fact that changing facilities are “family rooms” rather than recognising that women themselves want men to be involved in childcare and have campaigned for this to happen says it all.

Apologies - my previous post was in response to this post from Orchid.

orchid220 claimed upthread to have campaigned back in the 90s for "breastfeeding facilities and for women to be able to feed anywhere" 😂
Stating that they "suspect that most of the posters arguing that feeding/changing facilities are or should be “women only” spaces have not had children for a very long time or breastfed, if at all including OP" is somewhat ageist. And if a woman states she's breastfed then why disbelieve her experience?

When they say "The fact that many are also on threads regarding trans issues and are blaming Stonewall for the fact that changing facilities are “family rooms” " again misses the points repeatedly stated earlier:
Wanting men involved in childcare is a good thing. It has led to the unintentional consequence of breastfeeding spaces (that orchid220 campaigned so successfully for in the 90s) morphing into parent rooms etc.

Stonewall would of course deem orchid220's language transphobic for using sex based language like women and breastfeeding which demonstrates the problem with Stonewall's approach to women,

MrsOvertonsWindow · 01/01/2023 17:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 16:34

ShrillBill · 01/01/2023 16:23

Because you know anyone who isn't breastfeeding is not supposed to be in a room dedicated to breastfeeding.

So what we need is;
Breastfeeding room (single sex, single purpose) and
mixed sex family room. We all win.

I'm not sure there are any rooms dedicated just to breastfeeding. Women who bottle feed their babies would argue that discriminated against their babies. I think it would be good to separate feeding from nappy changing but I suppose that would be up to the shops etc providing the facilities.

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 16:27

Clymene · 01/01/2023 16:24

It was not a baby changing room. It was a breastfeeding room.

No men should be in there. None. Zero. It is for women and breastfed babies. No one else.

If it was just a breastfeeding room and there were no nappy changing facilities then how were two women changing their babies?

Clymene · 01/01/2023 16:24

It was not a baby changing room. It was a breastfeeding room.

No men should be in there. None. Zero. It is for women and breastfed babies. No one else.

ShrillBill · 01/01/2023 16:23

Because you know anyone who isn't breastfeeding is not supposed to be in a room dedicated to breastfeeding.

So what we need is;
Breastfeeding room (single sex, single purpose) and
mixed sex family room. We all win.

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 16:21

ClitoralViolence · 01/01/2023 16:14

How have you jumped from single sex feeding rooms to single sex nappy changing facilities? Hmm

Because they are usually in the same room including in OP's example.

ClitoralViolence · 01/01/2023 16:14

How have you jumped from single sex feeding rooms to single sex nappy changing facilities? Hmm

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 16:08

ShrillBill · 01/01/2023 15:50

@orchid220 Yes, I didn't think you knew anything about coercive control and your comment just confirms it.

How does my comment confirm it? How would single sex nappy changing facilities help rather than hinder women's rights and freedoms?

orchid220 · 01/01/2023 16:01

DdraigGoch · 01/01/2023 15:49

If the man was sat there on his phone, just how involved with childcare was he at that moment? I understand that there was a separate changing room available anyway.

At the very least he should have proactively offered to leave the room when the OP came in (given that he wasn't actually doing anything that needed him to be there). I also doubt that he got anyone to check that the room was clear before going in. I'm sure that had he actually been feeding or changing a baby the OP would have been more accommodating, either getting on with it herself or being prepared to wait until he had finished. As it was though, he was just hanging around like a spare part.

He might not have been involved at that moment in time and it was rude to sit there. However it isn't an argument to make the changing rooms single sex. It is an argument to make them one parent at a time if anything. It would be unusual if there were effectively two changing room available next to each other but if that is true then perhaps OP should suggest that all the changing facilities are in one room and the other is for feeding. Apart from anything else it will be more hygienic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread