Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men in women’s spaces

860 replies

BrightSaturn · 30/12/2022 02:22

Just using this to rant really…

2 times in the past month I have encountered men in women only spaces.

  1. I went to a feeding room to breastfeed my daughter in a shopping centre. I walked in and there were two young women in there changing their babies and one of their boyfriends just taking up one of the only chairs just sitting there, sitting using his phone. It’s a small room with 3 chairs in. I didn’t know what to do so I thought I’ll just sit down and get ready slowly and hopefully they’ll leave. I have fed in public but this was a small room so I felt vulnerable and like he shouldn’t be there and I didn’t want to lift my top up whilst he was sitting basically opposite me so I eventually asked if he could leave the room, they looked annoyed but thankfully he did go, after she looked at him and said “it’s up to you”…
  2. I went into a changing room in a shop the other day with my mum, imagine a big room with seats in the middle and curtained dividers all round the outside. My mum was only trying on cardigans so really she just needed a mirror but in the middle on a seat was a boy about 17/18 years old. His girlfriend was trying on clothes. I couldn’t believe it! It wasn’t even doors on the changing rooms, just curtains. Why he thought this was acceptable I have no idea. Again I felt vulnerable and this time I didn’t have the confidence to ask him to leave. If my mum had been actually changing I would have probably found a shop assistant but still it’s not fair that we have to ask them to leave, he should not have been there in the first place!

aibu to think women’s spaces are being invaded more and more? How can we stop this from happening?

OP posts:
IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 07:28

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:57

I haven’t said anywhere that I don’t understand the difference. No ones right trumps anyone elses if they need to use a parenting room.

No ones right trumps anyone elses if they need to use a parenting room.

That, is where you're wrong. The rights of a vulnerable semi-naked woman breastfeeding, trumps the 'rights' of a male to go there just to bottle feed. This should not need explaining.

FurAndFeathers · 30/12/2022 07:27

Trez1510 · 30/12/2022 02:59

If it's a feeding room, surely that is not restricted to lactating.

Surely that doesn't need to be spelled out?

Does baby feeding include non lactating people sitting and playing on their phones? Or have I missed a key element of childhood nutrition?

if not then what’s your point?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 07:26

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:50

A parents room isn’t a single sex space, as I have clearly explained to you twice, single sex spaces will have either women or men on the door/entrance.

It is generally accepted that they are 99% predominantly used by women.

This is the thing:

women who breastfeed need these spaces.
Men who bottle feed DON'T need these spaces.

So instead of barging in with your 'I'm entitled to be here' attitude, why not show some common human decency for women, and refrain from those spaces.

Just because you legally can go there, doesn't mean you should. Any man with human decency and respect for women would understand that fundamental point.

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 07:26

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 07:23

Why does your daughter not being able to take a bottle in a supermarket or somewhere, trump the needs of vulnerable women who need spaces away from men?

I’m not sure where you have seen me write that pulling a breast out and pulling a bottle out is the same?

You seem to think it is, because you think bottle-feeding your daughter gives you the same right to access spaces where vulnerable women have a breast out. You simply can't seem to see the difference.

A parents room isn’t a space for women, its a space for parents, thats why it says parents room on the door, not parents room for women. Every parent (nanny etc) has a right to use parenting rooms, thats literally what they’re for.

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 07:24

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 07:20

Surely a disabled woman would have a woman carer? You are desperately stretching in your whataboutery to excuse your male privileged thought process that men have a right to be in womens spaces.

Lots of people have opposite sex carers, lots of disabled people also leave the house with their partners, if they’re heterosexual, thats going to be an opposite sex carer who can already go into a parents room anyway.

A space for parents isn’t a womens a space, a womens space would have women on the door/entrance.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 07:23

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:49

Care to explain that to our daugher who wouldn’t feed anywhere noisy? I’m not sure where you have seen me write that pulling a breast out and pulling a bottle out is the same?

Why does your daughter not being able to take a bottle in a supermarket or somewhere, trump the needs of vulnerable women who need spaces away from men?

I’m not sure where you have seen me write that pulling a breast out and pulling a bottle out is the same?

You seem to think it is, because you think bottle-feeding your daughter gives you the same right to access spaces where vulnerable women have a breast out. You simply can't seem to see the difference.

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 07:23

@Simonjt lol! You’re a laugh. Anyway, women are allowed to have spaces men aren’t permitted access to - feeding rooms or otherwise. For what it’s worth maybe consider reflecting on the posts of other women on this thread. To me you come across as very mansplainey.

DdraigGoch · 30/12/2022 07:22

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 07:17

You seem to be making things up, where I have a written that there isn’t a difference between them? For maybe the fourth time a single sex space would have women/men on the door, I don’t understand how thats confusing?

You haven't denied that there is a difference. But you are very doggedly avoiding acknowledging that there is one.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 07:20

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:48

So you’re confirming that disabled mums are only allowed in parents rooms (which are for parents, not just mums) if she has another women who is free and available to meet her access needs. Lovely ableism.

Surely a disabled woman would have a woman carer? You are desperately stretching in your whataboutery to excuse your male privileged thought process that men have a right to be in womens spaces.

goodmorningsunny · 30/12/2022 07:20

Had the first situation happen to me and I really didn't care. I've breast fed my baby but also occasionally give her expressed milk so know that sometimes even bottle fed babies need quiet rooms for feeding (mine will not take a bottle out in public! Too much going on!) Not that that was what this guy was doing, but just pointing out that a bottle feeding dad has just as much right to use a feeding room IMO. So not really a womens only space.

Never had the changing room thing happen to me but again I wouldn't have bothered me. Boys sit places too, I'm afraid it happens. If it was a strictly womens only changing room then fair enough but it sounds like you're talking about a unisex changing room? Which is fair for boys to be in too, I'm afraid.

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 07:17

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 07:13

Hi @Simonjt do you in general think there are spaces that should be reserved only for women? Is that clearer for you? Not specifically in terms of parent’s rooms, in general.
I don’t know why you have a problem acknowledging the difference in bottle and breast feeding in public but you still haven’t answered the question. It’s a bit odd

You seem to be making things up, where I have a written that there isn’t a difference between them? For maybe the fourth time a single sex space would have women/men on the door, I don’t understand how thats confusing?

Messyhair321 · 30/12/2022 07:15

Mixed gender spaces are becoming the norm I don't think it's an issue but I'm sorry that some do. I do get it but for me I don't feel it.

Dd's uni has mixed toilets I sat outside waiting for dd & watched all the dads going in & swiftly coming out. It was them that were uncomfortable the young people didn't seem to care. Twas interesting & comical at the same time

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 07:13

Hi @Simonjt do you in general think there are spaces that should be reserved only for women? Is that clearer for you? Not specifically in terms of parent’s rooms, in general.
I don’t know why you have a problem acknowledging the difference in bottle and breast feeding in public but you still haven’t answered the question. It’s a bit odd

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 07:08

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 07:04

@Simonjt no you haven’t said it, but all your posts including your most recent, to me, seem to indicate you have difficulty accepting that there is a difference between producing a bottle and producing a breast in public. Or at least you have a difficulty stating that. I’m sure in the real world you are quite aware of the difference. You still haven’t said if you accept that women are entitled to safe same sex spaces, but I think your reluctance to do so speaks volumes. I am assuming you are a man from your previous posts.

I don’t understand why you have ignored (three times now?) where I have clearly said a single sex space would have women/men on the door? The OP called it a feeding room, she hasn’t suggested anywhere that it said women on the door/entrance. Why would I have any difficulty in accepting that taking a bottle out of a bag is different to ‘taking’ a breast out?

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 07:07

PortiasBiscuit · 30/12/2022 07:01

I get awfully fed up of the trope that we are all potential victims, all the time.
If the feeding area was being used, then wait ten minutes until it’s empty. Didn’t sound like they’d be long. Of course men can go somewhere and feed/ change their children.
Men in totally communal changing room would be an issue, where there are curtains and he is obviously focussed on one woman trying on clothes then it is a non-issue.
There are times when men in a women only space is a genuine problem, these are not good examples OP.

Sorry @PortiasBiscuit what is the need for talk of tropes and victims? Are women not allowed to simply say they don’t want men around when their bodies are exposed? Very odd phrasing and reasoning from you tbqh. A woman’s right to privacy is not based on being a victim or otherwise, it’s based on privacy? Same as a man’s??

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 07:04

@Simonjt no you haven’t said it, but all your posts including your most recent, to me, seem to indicate you have difficulty accepting that there is a difference between producing a bottle and producing a breast in public. Or at least you have a difficulty stating that. I’m sure in the real world you are quite aware of the difference. You still haven’t said if you accept that women are entitled to safe same sex spaces, but I think your reluctance to do so speaks volumes. I am assuming you are a man from your previous posts.

PortiasBiscuit · 30/12/2022 07:01

I get awfully fed up of the trope that we are all potential victims, all the time.
If the feeding area was being used, then wait ten minutes until it’s empty. Didn’t sound like they’d be long. Of course men can go somewhere and feed/ change their children.
Men in totally communal changing room would be an issue, where there are curtains and he is obviously focussed on one woman trying on clothes then it is a non-issue.
There are times when men in a women only space is a genuine problem, these are not good examples OP.

DdraigGoch · 30/12/2022 07:01

MelchiorsMistress · 30/12/2022 06:38

He was doing nothing wrong by being in the parenting room with his baby and partner, but he should have left graciously when asked.

Ideally he should have offered as soon as the OP walked in. That saves any awkwardness on the OP's part.

I don't suppose that his partner checked whether the room was clear before he followed her in.

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:57

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 06:53

I think people are having a difficulty with your posts because you appear to being deliberately obtuse. You do understand, don’t you, that there is a huge difference between pulling out a breast and a bottle to feed a baby?
Also because your baby did not prefer feeding in a less than silent environment you do understand that does not necessarily trump women’s rights to privacy when breastfeeding or no?

I haven’t said anywhere that I don’t understand the difference. No ones right trumps anyone elses if they need to use a parenting room.

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 06:55

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:50

A parents room isn’t a single sex space, as I have clearly explained to you twice, single sex spaces will have either women or men on the door/entrance.

Ok, but do you think women are entitled to safe single sex spaces?

DdraigGoch · 30/12/2022 06:54

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:17

Is it deluxe? I’m yet to find a parents room that isn’t like that, some also have toilets in with the wall harness so you can have a wee in relative peace with a toddler. A parents room isn’t primarily for breastfeeding babies, its for parents (or nannies, childminders, grandparents etc) to use when they are out and about with children. Unless it says ‘breastfeeding women’ on the entrance, then it isn’t just a space for women, it would also either lead to mums with access issues only being able to leave home with another woman, or forced to feed their children in a toilet. Disabled mums do exist you know, why should they be excluded from a breastfeeding room?

The OP was quite specific that her experience involved a small room with only three chairs. So nothing like the JL ones you describe.

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 06:53

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:49

Care to explain that to our daugher who wouldn’t feed anywhere noisy? I’m not sure where you have seen me write that pulling a breast out and pulling a bottle out is the same?

I think people are having a difficulty with your posts because you appear to being deliberately obtuse. You do understand, don’t you, that there is a huge difference between pulling out a breast and a bottle to feed a baby?
Also because your baby did not prefer feeding in a less than silent environment you do understand that does not necessarily trump women’s rights to privacy when breastfeeding or no?

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:50

Eyerollcentral · 30/12/2022 06:49

@Simonjt its also not difficult to answer this - do you think women are entitled to have safe single sex spaces? That’s a yes or no.

A parents room isn’t a single sex space, as I have clearly explained to you twice, single sex spaces will have either women or men on the door/entrance.

CysticMeg · 30/12/2022 06:50

Blackandwhites · 30/12/2022 04:19

What about in post-Labour wards in hospitals? Men are allowed there. Because they are parents and as a society it’s in our interests that both parents are equally involved in the upbringing of our children. It’s a good thing for women if the dads are involved too.

We cannot say that we want men to be fully involved with their children and then exclude them from the areas places like John Lewis set aside for parents of babies. If you want a separate area for breastfeeding then argue for that, but you can’t exclude dads from ‘parental’ areas then moan about their lack of involvement with their kids.

most of my views are fairly terfy-transphobe, but on this I say you are wrong.

The distress caused by men on maternity wards is not inconsiderable.

I still, many many years on, remember how I felt being asked questions about my lochia and stitches, and trying to get a sleepy DS to latch, protected only by a thin curtain from random male strangers who showed zero consideration for my needs or comfort.

Simonjt · 30/12/2022 06:49

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 06:43

A bottle fed baby can be fed literally ANYWHERE. The same is not true for a breastfed baby. If you can't see the difference between pulling your boob out, and a bottle, you are beyond reasoning with.

Care to explain that to our daugher who wouldn’t feed anywhere noisy? I’m not sure where you have seen me write that pulling a breast out and pulling a bottle out is the same?

Swipe left for the next trending thread