Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men in women’s spaces

860 replies

BrightSaturn · 30/12/2022 02:22

Just using this to rant really…

2 times in the past month I have encountered men in women only spaces.

  1. I went to a feeding room to breastfeed my daughter in a shopping centre. I walked in and there were two young women in there changing their babies and one of their boyfriends just taking up one of the only chairs just sitting there, sitting using his phone. It’s a small room with 3 chairs in. I didn’t know what to do so I thought I’ll just sit down and get ready slowly and hopefully they’ll leave. I have fed in public but this was a small room so I felt vulnerable and like he shouldn’t be there and I didn’t want to lift my top up whilst he was sitting basically opposite me so I eventually asked if he could leave the room, they looked annoyed but thankfully he did go, after she looked at him and said “it’s up to you”…
  2. I went into a changing room in a shop the other day with my mum, imagine a big room with seats in the middle and curtained dividers all round the outside. My mum was only trying on cardigans so really she just needed a mirror but in the middle on a seat was a boy about 17/18 years old. His girlfriend was trying on clothes. I couldn’t believe it! It wasn’t even doors on the changing rooms, just curtains. Why he thought this was acceptable I have no idea. Again I felt vulnerable and this time I didn’t have the confidence to ask him to leave. If my mum had been actually changing I would have probably found a shop assistant but still it’s not fair that we have to ask them to leave, he should not have been there in the first place!

aibu to think women’s spaces are being invaded more and more? How can we stop this from happening?

OP posts:
CountZacular · 30/12/2022 13:09

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 13:06

I have no idea of the history of something called a 'mothers room', personally I have literally never even seen a parents room like the OP describes, only baby change rooms. But if there was something called a 'mothers room' for general baby care purposes and it was changed to 'parents room' this is surely a progressive feminist step? Why should women always be expected to do all the parenting/be the only ones to take babies out?

It might be ‘progressive’ but progressive isn’t always positive. What’s positive about men taking over rooms designated for breastfeeding to bottle feed? Positive progression would be men having their own spaces or more neutral spaces on as well as private spaces for women to breastfeed.

I ask again - where do women unable or unwilling to breastfeed in public areas go when the private spaces are filled with men?

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 13:09

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/12/2022 13:07

Bottle feeding can be done anywhere, so a father bottle feeding a baby wouldn’t need the room.

Breastfeeding CAN of course be done anywhere, but the point of a breastfeeding room is to allow women who don’t feel comfortable bfing in public to have somewhere to go. Some women don’t feel able to do so for religious reasons, as well as many other reasons, so those women would otherwise have the choice of:

  1. never leave the house
  2. Not bf when they otherwise wanted to
  3. let the baby go hungry when out

None of which is a good option.

Some women are at risk of Dv if they showed their breasts or in some cases any part of their body in front of men.

Even if there was arguably a reason why a man needed briefly to be in their to assist his partner (or friend, relative, whatever) he should especially not be on his phone - his phone should be out of sight entirely. If phones can be out in a bf room there’s the possibility of photos being taken etc which is doubly uncomfortable.

You clearly haven’t had a baby who can’t focus on FF without being away from crowds.

Also family rooms are often where the changing and bottle warming facilities are located in most shopping centres and retail parks

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 30/12/2022 13:08

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 12:59

This is the result of the pressure from organisations like Stonewall determined to erase of the language of women - breastfeeding / nursing mothers, pregnant women etc are now seen as unacceptable.
Once you can't name a group, eg breastfeeding women, then their needs and rights become invisible. Any potential space for them must be renamed - made "gender neutral"
So another quiet private space that enables women to be out in society while breastfeeding is removed so that the Nigels and Simons of the world can noisily trample on a woman's reasonable wish for privacy when partly unclothed. And thus some women will stop going out into public if their needs aren't catered for - which is why spaces for breastfeeding mothers were so hard fought for 30 years ago.

It's regressive and anti women and a shame that some women join in with the men noisily trampling over the needs of women when vulnerable.

Absolutely this.

It's happened in the changing rooms of my local gym - 'girl dick' swinging around for all to see - and the usual namby pamby excuses about 'inclusivity' from the gym.

So the complainant took her complaint to the national media, and kicked up as big a stink about it as she could. The EA was quoted, together with the proviso in that Act for single SEX spaces where these are necessary.

I still attend that gym. Interestingly enough, they take huge care if a male worker needs to attend that space for any reason: a member of the gym staff will come in and give notice so that women can cover up if necessary, or know there's a male present if they need to come out of the showers or sauna.

If I see this, I, too, will be making as big a noise as humanly possible. Complaints to gym, reassurances that they'll cease with that practice, if no luck there, MP, gym franchise's Head Office, local media, national media, local women's rights support networks.

If they're intent on riding roughshod over women's rights, dignity and safety, I'm intent on making this as difficult for them as I possibly can, within the confines of the actual law (not the law as Stonewall et al would like it to be). And I'll quote it at them until I'm blue in the face if necessary.

OP - kudos to you for challenging the bloke in the first scenario. I would have, too.

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 13:08

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 13:02

Fab post IAmWomanHearMeRoar1

it was originally a space for women only. It was unilaterally changed without any input from women. It was taken from us. Men, are the ones that should campaign for their own feeding/changing spaces, instead of colonising ours. Telling women, whose foresisters fought blood and sweat and tears for these spaces FOR WOMEN to 'go campaign for spaces' that we already had, is a massive insult and taking the piss.

It would be fab if it was factually accurate, but it’s not, as pointed out by many posters on this chain

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/12/2022 13:07

Bottle feeding can be done anywhere, so a father bottle feeding a baby wouldn’t need the room.

Breastfeeding CAN of course be done anywhere, but the point of a breastfeeding room is to allow women who don’t feel comfortable bfing in public to have somewhere to go. Some women don’t feel able to do so for religious reasons, as well as many other reasons, so those women would otherwise have the choice of:

  1. never leave the house
  2. Not bf when they otherwise wanted to
  3. let the baby go hungry when out

None of which is a good option.

Some women are at risk of Dv if they showed their breasts or in some cases any part of their body in front of men.

Even if there was arguably a reason why a man needed briefly to be in their to assist his partner (or friend, relative, whatever) he should especially not be on his phone - his phone should be out of sight entirely. If phones can be out in a bf room there’s the possibility of photos being taken etc which is doubly uncomfortable.

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 13:07

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 13:00

It WAS a space for women only. That is what people are missing! It was created by women for women. That it has suddenly changed from Mothers Rooms, to all inclusive doesn't change the fact that it was originally a space for women only. It was unilaterally changed without any input from women. It was taken from us. Men, are the ones that should campaign for their own feeding/changing spaces, instead of colonising ours. Telling women, whose foresisters fought blood and sweat and tears for these spaces FOR WOMEN to 'go campaign for spaces' that we already had, is a massive insult and taking the piss. It reminds me of that woman who went to a rape survivor centre, that was built by women for women, that has no longer women only services after men colonised to 'go build your own'. The irony is women DID build it, then kicked out of it. It's a bloody insult to say we should campaign to get back spaces taken from us, when the men are the ones who should have campaigned for their own, not invaded and colonised ours.

It might be considered a 'parents room' now, but it always was a MOTHERS ROOM originally. We need to go back to calling these spaces mothers rooms. Not parents rooms. Let the men campaign and create their own parents rooms.

It wasn’t a space for women, multiple posters have already corrected you on this so not sure why you keep posting the same incorrect comment.

Why do we need to go back to calling them mothers rooms? They’ve moved with the times, which can only be a good thing, look how many women are impacted by being expected to bear the brunt of the child rearing, spaces like these are a great step to ensuring fathers are able to feed in a quiet space and change just like women are able to.

I’d also challenge your notion of there being mothers rooms in the first place, when having my first 12 years ago there were no rooms in general, mothers or not, then feeding rooms became more common about 5/6 years ago and have expanded massively from there.

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 13:06

I have no idea of the history of something called a 'mothers room', personally I have literally never even seen a parents room like the OP describes, only baby change rooms. But if there was something called a 'mothers room' for general baby care purposes and it was changed to 'parents room' this is surely a progressive feminist step? Why should women always be expected to do all the parenting/be the only ones to take babies out?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 13:03

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 12:59

This is the result of the pressure from organisations like Stonewall determined to erase of the language of women - breastfeeding / nursing mothers, pregnant women etc are now seen as unacceptable.
Once you can't name a group, eg breastfeeding women, then their needs and rights become invisible. Any potential space for them must be renamed - made "gender neutral"
So another quiet private space that enables women to be out in society while breastfeeding is removed so that the Nigels and Simons of the world can noisily trample on a woman's reasonable wish for privacy when partly unclothed. And thus some women will stop going out into public if their needs aren't catered for - which is why spaces for breastfeeding mothers were so hard fought for 30 years ago.

It's regressive and anti women and a shame that some women join in with the men noisily trampling over the needs of women when vulnerable.

Very well said. It boils my blood that people keep saying 'but it's not a womans space, it's a parents room'. It ORIGINALLY WAS A WOMANS SPACE! That's the point people on here are not getting! It was originally a womans space that has been taken away from us. I don't care what they call it now, it was always a Mothers Room and imo always will be a Mothers Room.

It is a womans space. It was never meant to be a 'parents' room'.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 13:02

Fab post IAmWomanHearMeRoar1

it was originally a space for women only. It was unilaterally changed without any input from women. It was taken from us. Men, are the ones that should campaign for their own feeding/changing spaces, instead of colonising ours. Telling women, whose foresisters fought blood and sweat and tears for these spaces FOR WOMEN to 'go campaign for spaces' that we already had, is a massive insult and taking the piss.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 13:00

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 12:50

I agree him playing on his phone would be annoying, but it’s not the same as invading a space for women, as it’s not just a space for women. I’d be just as annoyed by a mother sat there taking up space playing on their phone, but that’s a general courtesy issue instead of a ‘men in womens spaces’ issue surely?

One could also argue that your issues with feeding in public are just that, your issues. And shouldn’t impact on others enjoyment or access to spaces designed for them. If women want a designated womens only BF space they can campaign for those, or ask for adjustments to be made to the existing facilities, our local shopping Center has recently put in a few locked feeding rooms due to requests like this, but the main feeding and changing space is still open for all parents, as it should be imo

It WAS a space for women only. That is what people are missing! It was created by women for women. That it has suddenly changed from Mothers Rooms, to all inclusive doesn't change the fact that it was originally a space for women only. It was unilaterally changed without any input from women. It was taken from us. Men, are the ones that should campaign for their own feeding/changing spaces, instead of colonising ours. Telling women, whose foresisters fought blood and sweat and tears for these spaces FOR WOMEN to 'go campaign for spaces' that we already had, is a massive insult and taking the piss. It reminds me of that woman who went to a rape survivor centre, that was built by women for women, that has no longer women only services after men colonised to 'go build your own'. The irony is women DID build it, then kicked out of it. It's a bloody insult to say we should campaign to get back spaces taken from us, when the men are the ones who should have campaigned for their own, not invaded and colonised ours.

It might be considered a 'parents room' now, but it always was a MOTHERS ROOM originally. We need to go back to calling these spaces mothers rooms. Not parents rooms. Let the men campaign and create their own parents rooms.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 12:59

This is the result of the pressure from organisations like Stonewall determined to erase of the language of women - breastfeeding / nursing mothers, pregnant women etc are now seen as unacceptable.
Once you can't name a group, eg breastfeeding women, then their needs and rights become invisible. Any potential space for them must be renamed - made "gender neutral"
So another quiet private space that enables women to be out in society while breastfeeding is removed so that the Nigels and Simons of the world can noisily trample on a woman's reasonable wish for privacy when partly unclothed. And thus some women will stop going out into public if their needs aren't catered for - which is why spaces for breastfeeding mothers were so hard fought for 30 years ago.

It's regressive and anti women and a shame that some women join in with the men noisily trampling over the needs of women when vulnerable.

BigMama32 · 30/12/2022 12:56

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 12:54

I'm not sure the specific situation the OP talks about is much of a gendered issue. People are saying it's right that men are allowed in parenting rooms, and people are coming back at them saying but he was just pissing around on his phone. Well yes, but is it an issue that he was a man? It was rude of him not to get up straight away and to have to be asked. If he had been a female partner of one of the women changing a baby, and she was just on her phone, she should have vacated that spot when someone came in wanting to sit there to feed their baby. If a man had come in with a baby he wanted to bottle feed there, whoever was in the seat should have moved also. If a man had been sat in the seat bottle feeding his baby then whoever came in next would have to wait their turn. Seems like more of a general etiquette question than anything to do with men in women's spaces. Unless it was designated women only or specifically called a breastfeeding room, which it doesn't sound like it was.

hit the nail on the head !

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 12:54

I'm not sure the specific situation the OP talks about is much of a gendered issue. People are saying it's right that men are allowed in parenting rooms, and people are coming back at them saying but he was just pissing around on his phone. Well yes, but is it an issue that he was a man? It was rude of him not to get up straight away and to have to be asked. If he had been a female partner of one of the women changing a baby, and she was just on her phone, she should have vacated that spot when someone came in wanting to sit there to feed their baby. If a man had come in with a baby he wanted to bottle feed there, whoever was in the seat should have moved also. If a man had been sat in the seat bottle feeding his baby then whoever came in next would have to wait their turn. Seems like more of a general etiquette question than anything to do with men in women's spaces. Unless it was designated women only or specifically called a breastfeeding room, which it doesn't sound like it was.

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 12:50

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 12:39

Aside from the blatant MRAs here, I’m really surprised that not wanting a random man playing on his phone in a room designed for feeding is so contentious. I don’t quite get how other women can’t see it.

I’ve BF in a range of different ‘parent/feeding’ rooms. There’s the really nice individual ones in Mamas and Papas (with a separate room for changing too), to the big changing space in the shopping centre which has a section at the other side of curtained cubicles.

I’ve also fed in ones similar to the OP and I would have found getting my breast out to feed in that situation rather threatening. Those rooms are small and enclosed. If the man had been actively changing or feeding the baby I’d still feel uncomfortable but be a bit more understanding but in the actual case I’d want him to leave too. My privacy and dignity means more than his want to sit on his arse playing on his phone.

I also don’t know why it’s so contentious for women to want to place to breastfed away from men. These rooms were created with this in mind but as with everything, became inclusive. So where are women supposed to go? What’s the solution? Men can go to a quiet cafe, park or anywhere else but what does a breastfeeding woman do if she’s unwilling or unable to feed in public?

I agree him playing on his phone would be annoying, but it’s not the same as invading a space for women, as it’s not just a space for women. I’d be just as annoyed by a mother sat there taking up space playing on their phone, but that’s a general courtesy issue instead of a ‘men in womens spaces’ issue surely?

One could also argue that your issues with feeding in public are just that, your issues. And shouldn’t impact on others enjoyment or access to spaces designed for them. If women want a designated womens only BF space they can campaign for those, or ask for adjustments to be made to the existing facilities, our local shopping Center has recently put in a few locked feeding rooms due to requests like this, but the main feeding and changing space is still open for all parents, as it should be imo

BigMama32 · 30/12/2022 12:47

It’s a feeding space, if someone’s not feeding a baby (bottle or breast) they shouldn’t be in there, don’t think it’s anything to do with being a man really.
My baby has been both and I can tell you when he’s bottle feed gets so distracted it’s impossible to feed him somewhere loud and need a quiet peaceful space to get milk down him. He’s just too interested in everything.

I don’t think a young man should’ve been in a female changing room though.

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 12:45

Burgoo · 30/12/2022 12:40

I am also hearing a lot of FEELING here. Feeling needs to be owned by the feeler.

Do you think women should have single sex spaces at all? Why?

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 12:45

You are not unreasonable about the changing room, but what you’ve described on this post is a feeding or family room, so your first one is a bit off to get annoyed about.

ShrillBill · 30/12/2022 12:42

Single sex spaces are legal in the UK and provided for reasons of biological sex, dignity and privacy - such as a breastfeeding room in the workplace.

Breastfeeding areas are just that. They are not general access. Its not just men that shouldn't be using them, its also women who aren't breastfeeding. They aren't just used for breastfeeding, they are also used by women who are pumping.

If you want to bottle feed there's usually a bottle warmer in the changing room.
breastfeeding.support/uk-breastfeeding-laws/

ClareBlue · 30/12/2022 12:42

Blackandwhites · 30/12/2022 05:01

ITS NOT A BREASTFEEDING ROOM! ITS PARENTS ROOM!!! MEN ARE NOT INVADING ANY SPACES SET ASIDE FOR WOMEN!

if you want a breastfeeding room, ask for one, but you cannot say that parents aren’t supposed to be in a parents room.

Maybe if the parent was actually parenting and not sitting there on his phone.
But another one who can not find a single male in our family who thinks it is OK to go into women only spaces even if they technically can. That's from an 18 year old male up to an 86 year old male and every age between and non binary and broad ranges. There is plenty of room for improvement of fathers involvement in child rearing without it involving sitting in rooms where women are breast feeding and plenty of ways to support your partner without being in a changing room whilst they are trying on clothes.

Burgoo · 30/12/2022 12:40

I am also hearing a lot of FEELING here. Feeling needs to be owned by the feeler.

Burgoo · 30/12/2022 12:39

What is a woman only space ;)

Could the lad see through the curtain? It sounds like he was absorbed in his phone, not peeping like a perv!

That said, it is rude when you are taking up spaces when others need them. Regardless of sex.

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 12:39

Aside from the blatant MRAs here, I’m really surprised that not wanting a random man playing on his phone in a room designed for feeding is so contentious. I don’t quite get how other women can’t see it.

I’ve BF in a range of different ‘parent/feeding’ rooms. There’s the really nice individual ones in Mamas and Papas (with a separate room for changing too), to the big changing space in the shopping centre which has a section at the other side of curtained cubicles.

I’ve also fed in ones similar to the OP and I would have found getting my breast out to feed in that situation rather threatening. Those rooms are small and enclosed. If the man had been actively changing or feeding the baby I’d still feel uncomfortable but be a bit more understanding but in the actual case I’d want him to leave too. My privacy and dignity means more than his want to sit on his arse playing on his phone.

I also don’t know why it’s so contentious for women to want to place to breastfed away from men. These rooms were created with this in mind but as with everything, became inclusive. So where are women supposed to go? What’s the solution? Men can go to a quiet cafe, park or anywhere else but what does a breastfeeding woman do if she’s unwilling or unable to feed in public?

lawandgin · 30/12/2022 12:33

This thread is absolutely mental. Demanding that children go hungry if their dad can't feed them in a busy public space 🤯 that a woman's right to breastfeed is a human right that trumps a child's hunger? Honest to God 😳

No man should ever be actively making a woman uncomfortable. No man should be in a women's changing room. No man should be loitering in a family room without an active purpose of either feeding or changing their child. If there are 2 heterosexual or 2 female parents formula feeding, ideally a woman should go in alone if the room is occupied by a breastfeeding mother. But to suggest a child should go hungry because they refuse to feed in a busy public space and a father cannot enter a family room is absolutely crazy.

What would some of you think about 2 female parents attending together? Would that be okay? I mean they obviously find breasts sexually attractive....?

If my DH encountered someone spouting this crap while trying to feed DD I would 100% back him if he told you to F off. Equally, if I found a lone male hanging around a family room, or the partner of a man who appeared to be doing F all, I would ask them to leave.

Believe it or not, there is a middle ground whereby common sense and decency can be applied by both sides. Although this thread does make me wonder.

CornflakeKerry · 30/12/2022 12:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Letitrainletitrainletitrain · 30/12/2022 12:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

And the fact that you accused me of that when it turns out that the words you insisted were in the post were not actually in the post might have made you a bit more careful about throwing around accusations about reading comprehension today, but apparently not