Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men in women’s spaces

860 replies

BrightSaturn · 30/12/2022 02:22

Just using this to rant really…

2 times in the past month I have encountered men in women only spaces.

  1. I went to a feeding room to breastfeed my daughter in a shopping centre. I walked in and there were two young women in there changing their babies and one of their boyfriends just taking up one of the only chairs just sitting there, sitting using his phone. It’s a small room with 3 chairs in. I didn’t know what to do so I thought I’ll just sit down and get ready slowly and hopefully they’ll leave. I have fed in public but this was a small room so I felt vulnerable and like he shouldn’t be there and I didn’t want to lift my top up whilst he was sitting basically opposite me so I eventually asked if he could leave the room, they looked annoyed but thankfully he did go, after she looked at him and said “it’s up to you”…
  2. I went into a changing room in a shop the other day with my mum, imagine a big room with seats in the middle and curtained dividers all round the outside. My mum was only trying on cardigans so really she just needed a mirror but in the middle on a seat was a boy about 17/18 years old. His girlfriend was trying on clothes. I couldn’t believe it! It wasn’t even doors on the changing rooms, just curtains. Why he thought this was acceptable I have no idea. Again I felt vulnerable and this time I didn’t have the confidence to ask him to leave. If my mum had been actually changing I would have probably found a shop assistant but still it’s not fair that we have to ask them to leave, he should not have been there in the first place!

aibu to think women’s spaces are being invaded more and more? How can we stop this from happening?

OP posts:
Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:48

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 14:44

Wrong! You've been corrected on this so many times now. Women campaigned for these spaces so they could breastfeed in private. WOMEN campaigned for these spaces.

Women campaigned for the feeding room in the specific shopping Center referred to in the OP?

Even if it were true, doubtful since only you and one other person can seem to remember this and you’re not even in the UK so not sure how much knowledge you have about John Lewis in the UK over in Australia.

This wasn’t a John Lewis, this particular feeding room you have no idea if it was a mothers room 30 years ago. It’s simply ridiculous to think feeding rooms were all mothers rooms, when most were installed less than 5 years ago!

If you want a private space to BF then yes please do campaign for them, just like women did near me so now the feeding rooms have private spaces for BF.

atomsgirl · 30/12/2022 14:47

@Tryingformore1 I am English. I do recall campaigns for women to have somewhere to breastfeed in public places. I recall this being in the seventies.

The internet didn't exist then.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 14:47

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:41

If women want to get their tits out that’s on them, it’s a feeding room, for parents, male or female.

it’s unreasonable to expect people allowed to and even in many cases encouraged to use them not to use them because a minority of women are uncomfortable.

Typically the person with the problem needs to own the campaigning for a separate solution.

Men have already got a space to FF, they’re called feeding and or parent rooms, you’re the one who wants that changed. Shameful really.

Um, how else do you breastfeed but get your tit out?

The majority, not minority, of women are uncomfortable having a man watch them with their breast out.

Women should not have to RE-campaign for something we already campaigned for, and got! A place to.....BREASTFEED. Men don't breastfeed. If men want to FF, the onus is on them to campaign for their own space, just as us women had to.

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 14:47

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 14:42

Something that is being missed here is that feeding rooms of any kind barely even exist. I've never seen one and many on this thread say they've never seen one so complaining that women have nowhere to go to breastfeed in private because men might be in the parents room misses the point.

I think it depends. If I go into my closest city the shopping centre has one and JL (which is in the shopping centre). I can’t think of anywhere else. My closest retail park had nothing of the sort and I’d have to resort to feeding in the car until I built up the confidence to feed in public.

I kind of think that’s a separate problem of its own. There will always be a need for these spaces but I appreciate they take space. I just wish some spaces could exist for women than men didn’t feel entitled to stomp all over. It really should be obvious why the need exists - and why that need is greater than a general ‘feeding room’ open to anyone who feels like it.

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 14:46

@cosystripysocks

How is it ridiculous? I would not feel comfortable getting my breasts out to breastfeed in front of a man. My daughter would not either, or any of my friends for that matter.

I don't see how that's ridiculous? That's just how some women do feel. Surely that's ok for us to feel that way?

orchid220 · 30/12/2022 14:46

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 14:38

Absolutely wrong! The 'trans' party in this are men coming in to areas where women get their tits out. If men want to bottle feed, they are the ones who need to campaign for mens spaces. Women breastfeed, men don't. Men are the interlopers here, don't dare twist it.

Rightly or wrongly, the "feeding" rooms have never been women only as they were available to anyone feeding a baby including bottle fed babies. Not only women feed babies.

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:44

Deadringer · 30/12/2022 14:42

No wonder men rule the world, with so many women fighting for them to be anywhere they want to be.

or anywhere they’re allowed.

A womens changing room - not ok

a family room or feeding room - not a womens only space so why the heck not?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 14:44

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:39

They weren’t rooms anyone campaigned for, if you want a special breastfeeding room no one is stopping you for asking for one.

What you can’t do is remove facilities from parents of either sex.

Wrong! You've been corrected on this so many times now. Women campaigned for these spaces so they could breastfeed in private. WOMEN campaigned for these spaces.

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:43

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 14:40

Hint - online wasn't such a thing back in the 80s early 90s. Just because our experiences weren't recorded online for posterity doesn't mean they didn't happen.
Women did campaign for specific spaces for breastfeeding in shops and shopping centres back in the 1980s / 90s. Many of these facilities have now been converted in mixed sex family / parent rooms. Laudable in some ways but sadly excluding those women wanting privacy from unknown men when breastfeeding.
I'm not going to engage any further with someone displaying such unexpected ingrained hostility towards women so you have a good day.

Online wasn’t a thing in the 1920’s either yet there is a lot of information around how women got the right to vote.

it’s not hostility to expect people making claims to be able to back them up, neither you or the one other poster claiming this to be true (that other poster also isn’t even UK based) can provide anything other than you remembering it being a thing.

Deadringer · 30/12/2022 14:42

No wonder men rule the world, with so many women fighting for them to be anywhere they want to be.

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 14:42

Something that is being missed here is that feeding rooms of any kind barely even exist. I've never seen one and many on this thread say they've never seen one so complaining that women have nowhere to go to breastfeed in private because men might be in the parents room misses the point.

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:41

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 14:38

Absolutely wrong! The 'trans' party in this are men coming in to areas where women get their tits out. If men want to bottle feed, they are the ones who need to campaign for mens spaces. Women breastfeed, men don't. Men are the interlopers here, don't dare twist it.

If women want to get their tits out that’s on them, it’s a feeding room, for parents, male or female.

it’s unreasonable to expect people allowed to and even in many cases encouraged to use them not to use them because a minority of women are uncomfortable.

Typically the person with the problem needs to own the campaigning for a separate solution.

Men have already got a space to FF, they’re called feeding and or parent rooms, you’re the one who wants that changed. Shameful really.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 14:40

atomsgirl · 30/12/2022 14:24

I do recall campaigns for women to have a place to go to breastfeed in public so they could go out and do their shopping. This was back in the seventies.

Yes, and this is why they were for women. They have now changed to 'parents' rooms. Unfortunately people are not informed of this and can only think back like 6 years ago. Not 30 or 40 years ago.

emilyelf · 30/12/2022 14:40

A shopping centre I go to have these large rooms for changing, bottle feeding facilities with seats but also separate rooms for bf with a sign. The airports I've used in different countries have a few family rooms and I lock the door and use the room to myself. There's one couch, one toilet and one changing facility in a tiny space just similar to disabled toilets and once made the mistake of leaving the door open where a man and a woman came in whilst mid exposed, the man just stood in the corner in close proximity and l never made that mistake again thinking If I'm feeding and someone else can make use of the changing facility at the same time. I told the lady cleaning the facilities and she said there's a lock on their for a reason, next time make sure you lock the door.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 14:40

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:18

You’re aware that’s different to the claim that all feeding rooms were originally mother and baby rooms and converted?

Also you can type what you like, your recollection doesn’t seem to tally with reality, if it was such a big thing there would be some trace of it online.

Hint - online wasn't such a thing back in the 80s early 90s. Just because our experiences weren't recorded online for posterity doesn't mean they didn't happen.
Women did campaign for specific spaces for breastfeeding in shops and shopping centres back in the 1980s / 90s. Many of these facilities have now been converted in mixed sex family / parent rooms. Laudable in some ways but sadly excluding those women wanting privacy from unknown men when breastfeeding.
I'm not going to engage any further with someone displaying such unexpected ingrained hostility towards women so you have a good day.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 14:39

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:22

It wasn’t their private space. Feeding spaces aren’t just for women btw

It is a traditional places for mothers to breastfeed. It is not for men. Men don't breastfeed. Nursing mothers is the clue. They need to petition for their own feeding spaces.

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:39

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/12/2022 14:33

By all means campaign for a separate room that dads can use when ffing. No one is stopping you. But these were rooms women campaigned for, as PPs have said.

They weren’t rooms anyone campaigned for, if you want a special breastfeeding room no one is stopping you for asking for one.

What you can’t do is remove facilities from parents of either sex.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 14:38

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:20

Somewhere else?

Being uncomfortable BF in public is a personal issue, one that you can’t expect others to lose out over because you don’t want to feed in front of other parents.

If you are that funny about it there are options that don’t impact others. You could ask for the family feeding rooms to have some private spaces installed, you could ask for third spaces, in this scenario you are the trans party in this discussion so need to make the effort to petition for a third space.

Absolutely wrong! The 'trans' party in this are men coming in to areas where women get their tits out. If men want to bottle feed, they are the ones who need to campaign for mens spaces. Women breastfeed, men don't. Men are the interlopers here, don't dare twist it.

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 14:36

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 14:31

@Tryingformore1

How is a woman supposed to feel comfortable getting her boobs out to breastfeed her baby with a man in the same area??

What sort of man thinks this is in anyway acceptable? My DH would be absolutely mortified if he was in an area where a woman was trying to breastfeed. And rightly so.

Goodness me, do we really need to spell this out to people?

Most women do! I know lots of breastfeeding mothers (and am one) and they all breastfeed in public where men might be and like knowing they are welcome to do so. Some use a cover. Obviously there are some women who won't do this and would only feed in a private room but your "how is a woman supposed to feel comfortable" question is ridiculous.

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 14:35

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 14:20

Somewhere else?

Being uncomfortable BF in public is a personal issue, one that you can’t expect others to lose out over because you don’t want to feed in front of other parents.

If you are that funny about it there are options that don’t impact others. You could ask for the family feeding rooms to have some private spaces installed, you could ask for third spaces, in this scenario you are the trans party in this discussion so need to make the effort to petition for a third space.

Then men with babies who fidget when feeding could find another quiet space... somewhere else?

Mothers are the predominant carers for infants. I’m struggling to find the exact stats but men do not on the whole take parental leave. Apparently only a third took paternity leave in 21-22. From what I can see, it looks like only 2% of women took SPL:

www.peoplemanagement.co.uk/article/1747288/use-shared-parental-leave-dropped-17-per-cent-during-covid-study-finds

Despite that, you still think that women who need dignity and privacy need to budge over to allow for the few men who are feeding (or worse, hanger on men who are sitting around as extras) than the women who really do require the space.

These rooms were created with breastfeeding in mind because for a very long time (and somewhat now) breastfeeding in public was frowned upon and women needed to be hidden away elsewhere.

Finding breastfeeding uncomfortable is a societal issue - not a personal one. Until breasts stopped being viewed with the male gaze as sexual objects it will also cause tensions. There’s also a very real issue of women who have a history of violence or sexual assault not wanting to expose their breast in public. And of course women who for religious reasons cannot feed in public. It’s odd that you don’t seem to understand why there is a need for this space for breastfeeding women - and specifically over a man who unless he is actually feeding doesn’t need to be in there at all. And even then I’d question if it’s really needed.

I feel like we are a stones throw away from the suggestions we’ve all heard before - change in the toilet or don’t go out if that’s hard for you. And always, shows how accommodating we are to everyone - expect vulnerable women who need a bit of privacy and dignity.

atomsgirl · 30/12/2022 14:33

I don't want anyone who was born with male genitals in a women's space as they are stronger and faster than those born with female genitals. Im sure we are also all aware that males are more likely to attack females than the other way round.

Therefore, I don't agree females should be accommodating men in their safe spaces.

If certain men have the need for a safe space, they should request one for themselves.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/12/2022 14:33

Tryingformore1 · 30/12/2022 13:09

You clearly haven’t had a baby who can’t focus on FF without being away from crowds.

Also family rooms are often where the changing and bottle warming facilities are located in most shopping centres and retail parks

By all means campaign for a separate room that dads can use when ffing. No one is stopping you. But these were rooms women campaigned for, as PPs have said.

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 14:33

@Grumpybutfunny

Nice try but that's completely missing the point. I'd rather have a woman look me up and down when I'm trying to breastfeed than any man, whether he's actually looking at me or not.

It's just the fact that the man is there in the first place.

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 14:31

@Tryingformore1

How is a woman supposed to feel comfortable getting her boobs out to breastfeed her baby with a man in the same area??

What sort of man thinks this is in anyway acceptable? My DH would be absolutely mortified if he was in an area where a woman was trying to breastfeed. And rightly so.

Goodness me, do we really need to spell this out to people?

Grumpybutfunny · 30/12/2022 14:24

@Willowswood actually I've found woman are more judgy and more likely to look a woman up and down than a man. Its women that comment on friends not losing the baby weight or "letting themselves go" after having a kid not men. Also a transgender men is more vulnerable going into a males toilet because he XY not XX than girls in a mixed space when he's there.

Support doesn't have to mean privacy it can be things like passing an extra muslin cloth etc to make the experience more pleasant.

Stop putting blocks on men being good fathers, it's things like this that discourage shared maternity leave only further widening the gender pay gap. It would be better for people to stop breastfeeding than push more and more onto woman.

Out of interest just looked on Intu as they have eldon square and the metro centre near us......they aren't even called parent rooms!! They are baby feeding and changing rooms so no gender mention at all.