Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men in women’s spaces

860 replies

BrightSaturn · 30/12/2022 02:22

Just using this to rant really…

2 times in the past month I have encountered men in women only spaces.

  1. I went to a feeding room to breastfeed my daughter in a shopping centre. I walked in and there were two young women in there changing their babies and one of their boyfriends just taking up one of the only chairs just sitting there, sitting using his phone. It’s a small room with 3 chairs in. I didn’t know what to do so I thought I’ll just sit down and get ready slowly and hopefully they’ll leave. I have fed in public but this was a small room so I felt vulnerable and like he shouldn’t be there and I didn’t want to lift my top up whilst he was sitting basically opposite me so I eventually asked if he could leave the room, they looked annoyed but thankfully he did go, after she looked at him and said “it’s up to you”…
  2. I went into a changing room in a shop the other day with my mum, imagine a big room with seats in the middle and curtained dividers all round the outside. My mum was only trying on cardigans so really she just needed a mirror but in the middle on a seat was a boy about 17/18 years old. His girlfriend was trying on clothes. I couldn’t believe it! It wasn’t even doors on the changing rooms, just curtains. Why he thought this was acceptable I have no idea. Again I felt vulnerable and this time I didn’t have the confidence to ask him to leave. If my mum had been actually changing I would have probably found a shop assistant but still it’s not fair that we have to ask them to leave, he should not have been there in the first place!

aibu to think women’s spaces are being invaded more and more? How can we stop this from happening?

OP posts:
BigMama32 · 30/12/2022 19:26

hang on, why is no one getting an enclosed post natal space? Even labour ward was our own room.
I was in an enclosed space the whole time with DH, and the only time we crossed paths with anyone was going up and down the corridor, which was full of new dads taking their little ones for a walk.

I thought nothing of it.

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 19:22

I've just checked my local NHS Trust policy for visiting and it looks as though all visitors have to leave at 5pm, I completely agree with this.

So Mr Obnoxious and Mr Clueless have to leave, hooray!

Men in women’s spaces
roarfeckingroarr · 30/12/2022 19:17

Totally misread @cosystripysocks .

Men should not be on postnatal wards at night. During the day is bad enough.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 30/12/2022 19:15

I have ptsd and was going home hours post emergency section with dc2 because the thought of staying on the postnatal ward in what felt like such an unsafe environment was impossible for me. The first midwife suggested dh stay...the second got a consultant who organised a private room. I fell asleep at one point in the night and woke up screaming loud enough to disturb the bays nearest to my room. The reason I woke up...a man yelling at his partner in the corridor triggered me.

The answer to postnatal wards is more staff not the presence of random men.

In the aftermath of the event which caused my ptsd, I couldn't stand to be around my dad let alone any other man. Even now dh has to shower before coming anywhere near me after exercise because the smell of male sweat takes me straight back.

Blackandwhites · 30/12/2022 19:14

UWhatNow · 30/12/2022 18:06

It does get you down. So many women who are willing to throw others under a bus to please males. But take heart, we’ll keep fighting this and biological reality and the lived reality of biological woman can’t be denied. We have truth on our side. For what it’s worth.

There is no room for dads in a breastfeeding room, but a parenting room, of course dads should be in there! Getting dads as fully involved in the parenting of their child as possible is not ‘throwing them under a bus’. It’s in the best interests of women!

How many other threads are there here where the dad swans off playing golf or down the pub with their mates, leaving all parental responsibilities to the mothers? Loads. We need to make them realise at every opportunity that parenting is an equal job if we don’t want to be left parenting every second of every day while the dads do as they please.

roarfeckingroarr · 30/12/2022 19:13

@cosystripysocks I made the same point earlier. It drives me mad. Why are so many women to needy, so selfish, they put their want to have their bloke there above other women's privacy, feelings, dignity and safety

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 19:13

@cosystripysocks

I am talking about the daytime, men were booted out at night, and quite rightly so.

I was just pointing out how vulnerable women are in this situation, and how Mr Obnoxious and Mr Clueless don't help other women who are trying to cope with all sorts, and for some, for the first time.

Mamamia32 · 30/12/2022 19:10

I understand why you didn't want a man just sat on his phone directly across from you feeding in a little room. And I agree he should have moved once you started to unclip your bra etc.. However, if I went into this room and there were changing tables and a man changing his child's nappy, I wouldn't see that as encroaching on my space, especially as there are rarely changing tables in mens toilets. If it is supposed to be for breastfeeding only it should be labelled as such, with comfy chairs and magazines, and the changing tables placed somewhere else. I wouldn't want to feed my baby sat next to other children getting a nappy change, it's one step away from being expected to breastfeed while sat on the toilet.

The changing room thing I completely understand. The bench for bored husbands and boyfriends should be somewhere out in the middle of the shop, not in the middle of the womens changing rooms.

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 19:01

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 18:55

But WHY are those needs not more important? I could just as easily say your feelings about not having men in the room don't trump my need to have my partner there to look after the baby, and that it shouldn't be that difficult to explain!
And why are dads Mr Obnoxious and Mr Clueless? That's incredibly insulting.

They are Mr Obnoxious and Mr Clueless if they remain in a woman only space. Thankfully they do get booted out over night.

All women have an equal right to dignity and privacy in a single sex space. Visitors are removed over night for this. Your need for your husband only benefits you and potentially traumatises other women. At the least, it makes them uncomfortable. It’s really not that difficult to understand. You may not like it, but forcing women to accept strange men around them at their most vulnerable is not just unkind - it’s cruel. The easiest solution is instead to have a hard line to maintain that dignity and privacy.

You do not need your husband but you say you need support. So you have two options - If you want to have your husband pay for private care with a private room. Otherwise hire a female Doula.

Mentalpiece · 30/12/2022 18:58

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 18:31

That is your solution? I don't have any family who live close and I don't have any female friends who would have been free to be at hospital with me all day and all night.

So what would you do if you were a single parent with no partner?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 30/12/2022 18:58

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 18:55

But WHY are those needs not more important? I could just as easily say your feelings about not having men in the room don't trump my need to have my partner there to look after the baby, and that it shouldn't be that difficult to explain!
And why are dads Mr Obnoxious and Mr Clueless? That's incredibly insulting.

Because it's a WOMENS WARD, that's why! It involves WOMEN being pregnant. If you needed your partner there 24/7, you should have got a private room. Pregnant vulnerable women shouldn't have to put up with men on a WOMENS WARD 24/7. This should not even need explaining.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 18:56

For women (and men) who respect women's rights to single sex spaces when vulnerable - there are a number of petitions to challenge the government to take steps to protect women in certain circumstances - we have a voice and should make it heard.
The petitions board has links to many of them - here's a link specifically addressing the need to remove men from women only safe spaces:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4688427-repeal-the-gra

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 18:55

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 18:39

I get that. I am pregnant at the moment and also don’t have a mum or sister. I have no friends I would ask to support me. DP will be there for the birth but if I have to spend the night on the maternity ward my wants are not more important than the other women having a right to dignity and privacy away from strange men at the most vulnerable time of their lives. It shouldn’t be this difficult to explain.

But WHY are those needs not more important? I could just as easily say your feelings about not having men in the room don't trump my need to have my partner there to look after the baby, and that it shouldn't be that difficult to explain!
And why are dads Mr Obnoxious and Mr Clueless? That's incredibly insulting.

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 18:52

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 18:36

@cosystripysocks

Well how do you know he didn't? You couldn't move, as you say. How do you know what he saw or didn't see, what he got a good eyeful of?

I can remember being in the postnatal ward, and there was lochia dripping everywhere and I was trying really hard to clean it up and change.. with men all around. Sure I had a curtain but it was so difficult and I felt so vulnerable.

I bet it men gave birth out of their penises, women wouldn't be allowed to be anywhere near... can you imagine? 😂

This thread is a joke now.

Your lochia was still dripping out during the day surely? Do you think men shouldn't be there in the day either?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 18:51

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 18:50

What is it with Mumsnet and "I'm not sure your argument is the gotcha you think it is"? What is a gotcha and why is my argument a gotcha and your argument not a gotcha? Is it just a fashionable way of laughing at someone's argument? I should start all my posts that way.
Anyway, the reason the OP was wrong in the first place is that if it's not labelled women only or a breastfeeding room then it isn't a women-only space. The only argument anyone has against that is that these rooms used to be breastfeeding rooms. For that to matter in this case, the specific room the OP was in WOULD have to have been a breastfeeding room in the past. Also still labelled as such otherwise how would the man know he wasn't supposed to be in there. And if it was labelled as such then it would still be a breastfeeding room. Which it isn't. So yeah your argument isn't the gotcha you think it is.

😂😂😂😂😂

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 18:50

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 18:29

I'm not sure your argument is quite the gotcha that you think it is? Nobody has charted the transition of one breastfeeding space into a unisex parent space - although I'm sure it's possible. Older women who were there when it happened, are pointing out that there's a history of women fighting for specific rights (like spaces for breastfeeding women) most of which have now been dismantled so that men can access (for good reasons as fathers taking on childcare responsibilities) but with the consequence that women lost a useful resource.
Not sure why this need so many frantic denials? Confused

What is it with Mumsnet and "I'm not sure your argument is the gotcha you think it is"? What is a gotcha and why is my argument a gotcha and your argument not a gotcha? Is it just a fashionable way of laughing at someone's argument? I should start all my posts that way.
Anyway, the reason the OP was wrong in the first place is that if it's not labelled women only or a breastfeeding room then it isn't a women-only space. The only argument anyone has against that is that these rooms used to be breastfeeding rooms. For that to matter in this case, the specific room the OP was in WOULD have to have been a breastfeeding room in the past. Also still labelled as such otherwise how would the man know he wasn't supposed to be in there. And if it was labelled as such then it would still be a breastfeeding room. Which it isn't. So yeah your argument isn't the gotcha you think it is.

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 18:44

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 18:39

Sorry my children are teens now.. are partners allowed to stay the night on the postnatal ward?

They weren't allowed when I was on the postnatal ward, they had to leave by a certain time, it was lovely once they were gone, much much quieter and it was nice knowing strange men weren't just the other side of the curtain.

Assuming nothing has changed since my last visit, no visitors are allowed overnight. I’m glad of it. I can’t think of anything quite as unsettling as having able bodied Mr Obnoxious chattering away behind the curtain to my right and able bodied Mr Clueless snoring to my left, less than a metre away whilst I’m partially undressed and to struggling up to get to the toilet with blood rushing down my thighs. Fuck that.

CountZacular · 30/12/2022 18:39

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 18:31

That is your solution? I don't have any family who live close and I don't have any female friends who would have been free to be at hospital with me all day and all night.

I get that. I am pregnant at the moment and also don’t have a mum or sister. I have no friends I would ask to support me. DP will be there for the birth but if I have to spend the night on the maternity ward my wants are not more important than the other women having a right to dignity and privacy away from strange men at the most vulnerable time of their lives. It shouldn’t be this difficult to explain.

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 18:39

Sorry my children are teens now.. are partners allowed to stay the night on the postnatal ward?

They weren't allowed when I was on the postnatal ward, they had to leave by a certain time, it was lovely once they were gone, much much quieter and it was nice knowing strange men weren't just the other side of the curtain.

Willowswood · 30/12/2022 18:36

@cosystripysocks

Well how do you know he didn't? You couldn't move, as you say. How do you know what he saw or didn't see, what he got a good eyeful of?

I can remember being in the postnatal ward, and there was lochia dripping everywhere and I was trying really hard to clean it up and change.. with men all around. Sure I had a curtain but it was so difficult and I felt so vulnerable.

I bet it men gave birth out of their penises, women wouldn't be allowed to be anywhere near... can you imagine? 😂

This thread is a joke now.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 30/12/2022 18:32

Neither of those are women only spaces

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 18:31

Mentalpiece · 30/12/2022 18:27

Which comes back to my question of why can't they enlist the help of their mother's, sisters or female friend.
No one is saying that the new mum doesn't need assistance, but it doesn't have to be their partner.

That is your solution? I don't have any family who live close and I don't have any female friends who would have been free to be at hospital with me all day and all night.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 30/12/2022 18:29

minimarshmallowsmore · 30/12/2022 17:55

I've been here the whole thread and I haven't seen any evidence produced for it but anyway, even if breastfeeding rooms used to exist, unless you know the history of every parents room you can't say it used to be a breastfeeding room can you. The one the OP was in may or may not have been so you can't say hey no men are allowed in here! It used to be a breastfeeding room once!

I'm not sure your argument is quite the gotcha that you think it is? Nobody has charted the transition of one breastfeeding space into a unisex parent space - although I'm sure it's possible. Older women who were there when it happened, are pointing out that there's a history of women fighting for specific rights (like spaces for breastfeeding women) most of which have now been dismantled so that men can access (for good reasons as fathers taking on childcare responsibilities) but with the consequence that women lost a useful resource.
Not sure why this need so many frantic denials? Confused

Mentalpiece · 30/12/2022 18:27

cosystripysocks · 30/12/2022 18:22

Firstly, the partners are there all day anyway when everybody is just as vulnerable and I don't see what difference it makes for them to be there at night as well.
Secondly, there aren't generally enough midwives around to do the amount of help the dads are doing. Maybe it was different in previous decades, I don't know. But you yourself are dismissing the needs of women who do need their partner in order to look after their baby. So I guess we're both dismissing the needs of one group of women here.

Which comes back to my question of why can't they enlist the help of their mother's, sisters or female friend.
No one is saying that the new mum doesn't need assistance, but it doesn't have to be their partner.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 30/12/2022 18:26

Westernesse · 30/12/2022 17:18

Menz really don’t. It’s an absolutely tiny number of fetishists and perverts, supported by quisling females, who are causing this issue.

I hope you didn't seriously think I meant all the men? For the sake of pedantry, I maybe should have put "Some men who are a significant extremely dangerous minority" Hmm