Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Too much 'stuff'?

111 replies

Whatifthegrassisblue · 30/12/2022 01:13

So many threads about gifts.
AIBU to think once you're a certain age you have everything you need and if you want something you just buy it? Generally speaking of course, its nice to feel special and get the occasional gift, but I don't want loads and load of things anymore.
I struggle to get something for DH, I can find something he'll like, but with him too its just more 'stuff', I even now feeling this with young DC, how many toys and books can one small child have?
I'm starting to feel overwhelmed by just how much 'stuff' we have!
Does anyone else feel this way or AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pelargoniums · 04/01/2023 12:27

Divebar2021 · 30/12/2022 08:16

The problem is when you live with people who don’t share your sentiments. Even Kon Marie doesn’t advocate getting rid of peoples possessions without their permission. So you can be brutal as you like with your own belongings but still end up with a house with too much stuff.

Yes! Even stupid, non-personal stuff: pre-DP I had one bag for life that I used for everything - shopping, laundry, runs to the charity shop. We now have 17 and woe betide me if I attempt a cull. He doesn’t even use them for laundry, he hauls the whole bloody basket downstairs and leaves it there so then we start accumulating a pile of clothes on the landing. Clothes 90% his – I counted the other day in despair and he has 47 pairs of socks FFS.

Ditto first aid: I used to have a box of plasters and one of paracetamol. He can’t get through a minor cold without paracetamol, ibuprofen, aspirin, Lemsip, Vicks vapour rub, Olbas oil and god knows what else. We need an entire cupboard. And this applies to everything! Cleaning stuff, kitchenware, bathroom: his policy seems to be why have one multitasking thing when you can accumulate a cash and carry’s worth “just in case”, always in a disorganised heap wrapped around with all the random cables that just APPEAR and must be kept because also “just in case”. I hate it! Death to all the things!

1HappyTraveller · 04/01/2023 12:18

nomoremsniceperson · 04/01/2023 10:53

Unfortunately I live in a country which doesn't have the same charity shop culture as the UK. You either sell it at a flea market or have to give it away online, which means taking pics, writing a description etc. Or you leave it in a cardboard box on the street, where it may or may not get taken and will likely get soaked if it rains and end up as essentially flytipping. There are clothing banks but I've heard they are operated very unethically. Sometimes I really miss having a place to offload secondhand stuff where I know the money goes to a good cause. It's a good system.

Oh that’s such a shame. Could you take a photo of bundles that would suit one particular age and put online? I’ve had a few bundles like that so I can have what is useful then pass on what I don’t need.

5128gap · 04/01/2023 11:20

I agree. With adult DC who can also buy themselves what they want, it feels rather pointless to be searching for stuff to buy for the sake of it. Over the last few years I've tended to buy experiences rather than things, from concert tickets to city breaks. This year we're all putting our 'pointless gift' budget towards an extended family holiday.

nomoremsniceperson · 04/01/2023 10:53

1HappyTraveller · 03/01/2023 17:41

Please don’t throw it away. There are many charities that would happily accept donations.

Unfortunately I live in a country which doesn't have the same charity shop culture as the UK. You either sell it at a flea market or have to give it away online, which means taking pics, writing a description etc. Or you leave it in a cardboard box on the street, where it may or may not get taken and will likely get soaked if it rains and end up as essentially flytipping. There are clothing banks but I've heard they are operated very unethically. Sometimes I really miss having a place to offload secondhand stuff where I know the money goes to a good cause. It's a good system.

RejectedCitizenOfMoronia · 03/01/2023 17:52

When DS was little we made it a policy to collect up the toys he didnt want/was too old for and donating them to charity on Boxing Day. To instill the spirit of generosity in him, it worked for a while but then his nerd gene kicked in and everything is now part of a "collection" 🙄

1HappyTraveller · 03/01/2023 17:41

nomoremsniceperson · 02/01/2023 22:20

I'm really feeling this way just now. We don't have a huge house and all the kids' xmas gifts just don't fit anywhere. I'll have to try to sell old stuff just to make room. Many of the new toys are just different versions of toys the kids already have. I always ask our relatives to keep things minimal but some just can't do it. MIL in particular buys lots of cheap stuff instead of one really good quality thing. It's awkward because I don't want to seem ungrateful but I can't stop thinking what a waste it all is and how it doesn't really make the kids that happy outside of the dopamine rush of unwrapping a surprise gift. I actually normally love Christmas but the gifts are becoming my least favourite bit of it. Feel like we're drowning in stuff, would feel too guilty to chuck it all in a skip but don't have the time to try to flog any of it. Grrrr

Please don’t throw it away. There are many charities that would happily accept donations.

PeekAtYou · 03/01/2023 16:45

When my kids were younger I decided to buy less at Christmas but then allocate that saved money to outdoor toys in the summer. My kids didn't notice that they had less at Christmas and appreciated some outdoor stuff in late Spring/early summer.

WhereIsMyRollingPin · 03/01/2023 16:42

I took a bag with 25 things in to the charity shop earlier and will take another bag at the weekend. I was tempted by a couple of things but resisted.

CaspianPlover · 02/01/2023 22:42

I asked family to give me a paperback book that they loved, It was a great way to discover new books that I either loved or was indifferent to and the charity shop was happy to take them once read. It was also interesting to see what people liked.

nomoremsniceperson · 02/01/2023 22:20

I'm really feeling this way just now. We don't have a huge house and all the kids' xmas gifts just don't fit anywhere. I'll have to try to sell old stuff just to make room. Many of the new toys are just different versions of toys the kids already have. I always ask our relatives to keep things minimal but some just can't do it. MIL in particular buys lots of cheap stuff instead of one really good quality thing. It's awkward because I don't want to seem ungrateful but I can't stop thinking what a waste it all is and how it doesn't really make the kids that happy outside of the dopamine rush of unwrapping a surprise gift. I actually normally love Christmas but the gifts are becoming my least favourite bit of it. Feel like we're drowning in stuff, would feel too guilty to chuck it all in a skip but don't have the time to try to flog any of it. Grrrr

1HappyTraveller · 02/01/2023 21:50

I really enjoy exchanging gifts. It’s part of the celebration of Christmas (and also birthdays etc).

Something you want
Something you need
Something to wear
Something to read
…I find this useful for children/partners

I try to only gift ‘things’ are consumables that you know the person would actually use… I.e bottle of wine/bubbly, candle, dinner-making kit (spices/sauces rather than pans/dinnerware) that they will enjoy using rather than hoarding.

Would also suggest gifting experiences instead of ‘things’.

I also tell people when I gift that I hope they like it but if not please let me know - would much rather exchange it for something they would like or buy something different next time. I’m quite honest and blunt and I think they know they can tell me if they don’t like/won’t use something.

In terms of having “stuff” - if you think you have too much then get rid of some of it. Obviously when children are things like books build up, but as they get older and are not needed these things can be sold, gifted to charity or swapped. Decluttering is a good habit to do throughout the year. But I don’t think “having too much stuff” is a reason to not gift something.

Pterrydactyl · 01/01/2023 11:59

Yes, my favourite sort of present these days are consumable presents.

Chocolates, wine, cheese, soaps and so on…
Even if they’re not my favourite things, they’ll get used up (or passed on to someone who likes that type of chocolate better) and thrown away with no guilt.

WhereIsMyRollingPin · 01/01/2023 07:54

Stopthebusplease are there any things you would save first?

Not that I'm suggesting you actually do it!

Today I am going to go round the house with one of those big Sainsburys bags with the elephant on and fill it for the charity shop.

RoseMartha · 01/01/2023 01:19

Yes I dont get many gifts now anyway. Although I got useful stuff this year that I have used most of already and should last the year or beyond.

I did buy myself a couple of little gifts.

Stopthebusplease · 01/01/2023 00:54

Am I the only one who has so much STUFF, that I've seriously considered setting fire to the house, and not calling the Fire Brigade until it's all gone, just so that I can get rid of it all and start afresh?

UndertheStares · 01/01/2023 00:43

CurrentHun · 31/12/2022 18:08

I also hate clutter but sorry but this is so fucking privileged and tactless: ‘just ask all your relatives to give your kids money or vouchers or experiences instead.’

Some relatives want to give a gift but what they can afford will be a toy or book that they shopped for in the sales- not a money voucher to a stated value.

An experience doesn’t have to be a night at the opera in Paris - it can just be a handwritten voucher saying “a walk with a flask of hot chocolate next time we meet”. Plenty of kids would love that and it would be a genuine treat for them, rather than another toy to add to a huge pile.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 31/12/2022 23:48

Whatwhatwhatnow · 31/12/2022 20:16

I remember when I went to uni I only had a car's worth of stuff. I never missed anything from my room at home!

Similarly backpacked for months and only had one bag.

Admittedly I don't want to live that minimally, but I could certainly get rid of a lot. Inspired by the pp who started with a kitchen drawer, I have just binned a load of awful, blunt cheap knives that we haven't used for at least 6 years.

Oh yes! I lived out of a suitcase too when I did 6 months travel! I had forgetten about that. Now I have a whole extra wardrobe full of clothes I think I might fit into again ... one day. One bonus is I did stop buying clothes a few years ago whereas before it was probably a weekly occurrence, I actually started to notice how all my clothes were similar anyway.

OP posts:
Whatwhatwhatnow · 31/12/2022 20:16

Whatifthegrassisblue · 30/12/2022 04:22

This is what I wonder, how much do we actually 'need'. If you lived in one of those tiny houses and all your stuff was in a storage container next to you ... how many times would you actually go back to that storage container?

I remember when I went to uni I only had a car's worth of stuff. I never missed anything from my room at home!

Similarly backpacked for months and only had one bag.

Admittedly I don't want to live that minimally, but I could certainly get rid of a lot. Inspired by the pp who started with a kitchen drawer, I have just binned a load of awful, blunt cheap knives that we haven't used for at least 6 years.

upfucked · 31/12/2022 18:41

soberfabulous · 31/12/2022 18:29

Oh wow I love this thread! I can't bear this hideous consumer culture we have all been sucked into and I'm constantly getting rid of stuff and sending stuff to our nanny's family overseas.

My husband travels solo a few times a year and I have to say I purge some of his stuff too: he has never noticed and we've been together for 12 years. He's a terrible hoarder (empty shoe boxes...why?!)

My husband loves a shoe box but he manages to fill them with more stuff.

CurrentHun · 31/12/2022 18:40

Obviously every family is different but some years I have to do the Xmas shopping for elderly relatives to give others. I can tell you that unless they are particularly unwell at the time, they will get anxious about £5 in a card being seen as too small an amount, not special enough etc by either the child or the parents and then they feel they have to go out to buy other ‘stuff’ to go with the cash which is a physical burden or feel that they have to give 15-20 in total in a token, which is a financial burden because it’s money that they don’t really have. I then have to hear about it for days and deal with the emotional fall out of that either way. So YABU

Spect8 · 31/12/2022 18:34

Even though we have a "no present" policy amongst the adults, my nieces and nephews who have their own families now, always buy me something, and that's so good of them.

It is either bouquets of flowers and plants which I love, or wine/chocolates/goodies. I don't drink, but it's great to have some vino to share when people call. The stash I get from them lasts a long time!

I am the maiden auntie, no kids. I am always spoiled by them all. It is so nice really.

I live alone in a house that's just a tad too big for me. Consequently I have plenty of room for hoarding stuff. But twice a year I do a clear out, then I can get MORE stuff lol. One in one out policy here.

soberfabulous · 31/12/2022 18:29

Oh wow I love this thread! I can't bear this hideous consumer culture we have all been sucked into and I'm constantly getting rid of stuff and sending stuff to our nanny's family overseas.

My husband travels solo a few times a year and I have to say I purge some of his stuff too: he has never noticed and we've been together for 12 years. He's a terrible hoarder (empty shoe boxes...why?!)

Sugarfree23 · 31/12/2022 18:21

@CurrentHun the sort of relatives who shop in sales and buy 1 toy or 1 book are not the sort who are adding to the huge amounts of clutter in people's houses.

People generally know their relatives and know who they could ask for money / experiences from.

One of mine has had birthday as well as Christmas in the last week. I managed to give both Grans and all the Aunties 2 ideas each. But because they were 'not enough' they added extras. That's doesn't help my cause!

Sierra259 · 31/12/2022 18:19

This stresses me out so much and is probably the thing that DH and I row most about. He seems incapable of getting rid of things without prompting, and even then it's a struggle. There's stuff he hasn't touched/used since we moved into this house 7 years ago, but he still won't consider clearing it out. Between that and things the kids are reluctant to part with, it does my head in. I try to mitigate it by asking people to buy things for the DC that I know they'll get a lot of use out of, or experience-type gifts but that is often ignored (my DM is a big culprit for this!). I usually ask for vouchers if there's nothing I particularly want. Then I can use them when I need them .

Athenen0ctua · 31/12/2022 18:13

I don't have a lot of money myself so would hate to think I was wasting it on things that weren't wanted or needed.