Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable? Helping out with childcare

329 replies

mortitiaaddams · 29/12/2022 23:57

A and B have worked together for 25+ years. Originally in a very intense 1:1 environment- think NHS. Now less so but still in the same environment. B is married to C.

B and C are godparents to A's DD. A had her DD while single. A didn't realise she was pregnant until very late and had no real plans for raising DD as a single parent. B promised to support her.

A's DD is now 8. B and C have gone above and beyond to help out with childcare since she was born, which can be very difficult because A and B's job involves shifts and unpredictable hours. C doesn't work, so most of this is done by her. B and C's older DC also often babysit, do the school run etc, and are paid by A to do this. A's DD is treated like part of B and C's family when with them. A has always been willing to step in with B and C's DC whenever needed over the years, but this has been much less as C has always been home with the DC.

B is very involved with A's DD- will go to all her sports fixtures, school plays, recitals etc. B and C's DC have started to resent this, because B often missed out on these when they were growing up. This was usually due to work at the time, but B now doesn't make the same effort to get to things for younger DC and DGC that he does for A's DD. C is no longer happy with the arrangement, feels that B is too involved with A's DD and they are having her too often.

A's DD has a sports fixture coming up and needs to be accompanied by a parent/other responsible adult. The fixture is a long drive away and will take up the whole weekend. B has volunteered to take A's DD, as she will be working that weekend. C isn't happy as she wasn't asked first. The sports fixture will likely be one of many next year.

C feels that B is putting helping out A and her DD above his own family, and wants A to sort her own childcare from now on. A and B feel that B and the older DC have been volunteering (and the older DC are being paid) and as long as B is happy to be involved, the arrangement should continue.

Who is being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Museya15 · 30/12/2022 08:37

I'm sorry my brain isn't wired to understand the ABC thing, I was lost by the third sentence.

Elnetthairnet · 30/12/2022 08:36

And I agree with other posters - there is a very very weird dynamic between A’s child and B. Are you sure he isn’t the father? Surely most people would have got sick of this dependency in 8 years otherwise? If I was C, I think I’d be seriously considering leaving.

Believeinyou · 30/12/2022 08:36

Is C really sure that the child isnt Bs? Even if not A&B sound like they are closer than work colleagues and are or were once attached emotionally if not physically

TerraNostra · 30/12/2022 08:35

BeeAFreeBird · 30/12/2022 02:51

Hi - you mentioned that you’re C - in the scenario described you are not being unreasonable. B needs to tone it down and take a step back, and A needs to set a healthy example and be conscious of safeguarding. You are clearly sensible.

There is a lot of kindness on display here, particularly from you, C. How fortunate A and her DD are to know your family. You’ve all really leaned in to make the best out of difficult unanticipated circumstances for A.

But there has to be healthy boundaries. The proverb goes that it takes a village to raise a child. As A’s DD grows up and approaches adolescence, the support structure needs to adapt. And throughout there needs to be adherence to basic safeguarding principles.

Please don’t be offended that I raise safeguarding. I see kindness. There is a lot of vulnerability, though, which means boundaries have to be clear and healthy and mindful of safeguarding.

For me, B covering a weekend - for sports or not - is not appropriate from a cold safeguarding perspective.

No matter how close they are as colleagues, or how trustworthy B is, A’s DD is a vulnerable girl. One of the kindest and most valuable lessons she can be taught is what healthy boundaries look and feel like.

I think the work on that can begin now with an adjustment to the A/ADD/B dynamic, starting with B stepping back from this sports w/e. Perhaps for B it’s a transition from father type figure to an uncle type.

Might you and your husband change the setting with a break away or something to could talk it out and come up with a plan. A plan that identifies and prioritises different sets of needs (ie your family has the primary set of needs) and that establishes re-adjusted boundaries and roles that will keep things healthy.

Good luck C. You’re right about this. x

Sorry, do I have this right? You’re saying that a man can’t take his 8 year-old goddaughter out alone because there’s a risk he might abuse her?

Gosh. Is that the level of paranoia that the world has reached?

(I’m making this comment independently of the question asked, and scenario outlined, in the OP, as the quoted answer is simply saying that B has to stop taking her out for safeguarding reasons)

NotAnotherCrisis · 30/12/2022 08:35

YANBU

NotAnotherCrisis · 30/12/2022 08:34

I reckon they're paramedics and there's the real possibility B is the father of A's DD, but that A knows that B is unlikely to leave C so the arrangement continues.

Just a theory.

Elnetthairnet · 30/12/2022 08:33

You’re not being unreasonable. B seems to care far more for the child of A than he does for his own DC/DGC. B needs to end his emotional affair with A and step back slowly from A’s DD. This arrangement is ridiculous.

Eddielizzard · 30/12/2022 08:26

I feel for your DC who's being disregarded, and you. You are both sacrificing so your DH can swan about being the hero. The whole situation is off.

No to weekends away at sporting fixtures. He's got to step up for his youngest DC.

Seems to me there is an emotional affair going on, but I think from what you say, the close working relationship almost forces this on them and it's known and accepted. What a shit show.

I think you have to scale back the babysitting. Your DH at the very minimum must put his DC first as it's actively damaging their relationship.

Nowdontmakeamess · 30/12/2022 08:21

I would be very concerned that B is grooming the mother/child and think him taking the girl away for the whole weekend is very inappropriate.

That or the child is B’s.

HappyKoala56 · 30/12/2022 08:09

Surely there is a compromise here, B cuts back on contact but stays involved. You can say you won't be childcare anymore and if your older DC are happy to do so they earn more money. B can offer to help, but for no longer than a shift. B can attend school events if he also makes the same effort with his DC/DGC. I think pulling all contact with the child would be damaging, but setting boundaries that puts your family first is perfectly reasonable

rookiemere · 30/12/2022 07:50

Sorry I skim read the OP [I blame the A, B and C malarkey].
I see the DM isn't going to the sporting event, so that is something.

You need to say something OP, but I'd come at it from a place of sadness that he is missing out on his own DCs achievements at the cost of another person's DC.

I'd say that as arrangements have been made for him to go to this sporting event, he can go but this needs to be a line in the sand where he chooses his own DCs and stops putting them second.

Apart from anything else, it starts to be a bit inappropriate for an 8 year old DD to be accompanied by a male non relative.

Ohheythereitsme · 30/12/2022 07:48

I would have a conversation with dh and agree boundaries going forward. If he doesn’t knowing you are uncomfortable with it (and I think most people would be). Then you need to decide what your own boundaries are and whether you want to openly accept what is going on and what may be going on that you aren’t aware of.

Sandunesandseashells · 30/12/2022 07:43

ivykaty44 · 30/12/2022 07:40

Who is being unreasonable?

C is being unreasonable, they are not the boss of B and have started to tell B what they can and can't do

I disagree. That would be true if they were three independent adults but there’s a marriage here and another woman is being put first in that marriage and the wife is being used as a nanny.

lifeinthehills · 30/12/2022 07:42

It sounds like he's volunteered you to mind A's child while they both work or something? That's where you can start saying no. A will have to organise a professional sitter for her child.

ivykaty44 · 30/12/2022 07:40

Who is being unreasonable?

C is being unreasonable, they are not the boss of B and have started to tell B what they can and can't do

rookiemere · 30/12/2022 07:39

I don't think B is the father. I think it's more likely he wants to be knight in shining armour to this woman - and that fits into the narrative of emotional affair.

Yes absolutely put some boundaries in place. Childcare when DC was young and she needed it was a slightly odd, but kind idea. Going away at weekends- is this with the mother- to facilitate a sport, is not necessary and should be your hill to die on.

ColadhSamh · 30/12/2022 07:38

What is your husband's response to your children bring unhappy when he prioritises another (allegedly) man's child? Time for all cards on the table for all your sakes. This farce has gone on long enough. You and some of your children are unhappy, time to get it resolved. Why should you go along with the status quo keep another woman happy?

Paq · 30/12/2022 07:34

Tough situation all round. A is failing her child by being so reliant on others to the point that it's starting to affect their family relationships.

I'd get through this weekend somehow and then sit down as three adults and talk through expectations. I know B promised to support her but circumstances can and do change. Ultimately A is the child's mother.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 30/12/2022 07:20

My brain cannot compute A=XYZ…use names. To anyone who finishes this post and understands it you deserve a Reward.

MintJulia · 30/12/2022 07:19

Wouldn't it be easier for A & B to swap shifts (if that's possible) so A can take her own daughter to the event?

fancyacuppatea · 30/12/2022 07:15

A and B are being unreasonable.
Your kids deserve some time with their dad, and he's too busy being a stand-in dad for A's DD.
I'd be quite pissed off if he was off all weekend. A one-off, maybe, but not if this is going to be frequent.

autienotnaughty · 30/12/2022 07:10

YRNBU
It's too much and your dh is way too invested. It seems like A needs that as without your family it's likely she would have to give up work. How olds her dd? I'd assume the responsibility will naturally lessen over time as her dd gets older and needs less care. But it's also totally reasonable for you to say no to helping out. And to expect your dh to speak to you before he commits himself to helping out.

londonrach · 30/12/2022 07:09

Unless b is the father which seems likely a is a cf and shouldnt take advantage of b and c

Taillighttoobright · 30/12/2022 07:05

Why is B so involved with A's DD?

Scarydinosaurs · 30/12/2022 06:59

What is the response of your DH when your own DC express upset/jealousy?

There will surely be other team parents who can take A’s DD?

Also, I think even if he isn’t the dad to A’s DD, he clearly wants to be.