Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect them to put the heating on?!

260 replies

womanontheedge2022 · 29/12/2022 23:01

DH and I have just got back from 2 nights with our oldest friends. We are as close to them as family for context. We have been absolutely freezing for the entire 48 hours! One of them just refuses to put any heating on. He has form
for this but has got worse. He has always been extremely tight, improved slightly with age but sometimes reverts to type. I get that heating is far from cheap atm but there are no categorically no money issues and it was sub zero, worse than camping. We asked him repeatedly to put heating on, even offered to contribute but he is stubborn and dug his heels in. We nearly went home. His other half is always diplomatic but I'm sure agreed with us! AIBU to expect a bit of heat in December in a draughty old house Mumsnet?!!

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 30/12/2022 08:25

DH is very underweight due to health issues and he definitely feels the cold more than I do. I did turn the thermostat down initially, but he was absolutely miserable and as we can afford it I wouldn't want to make my husband cold and miserable.

My sister and BIL are "well insulated" and don't feel the cold, whereas I do.

BIL is very sneery about the fact that I feel the cold, but he is generally a sneery person anyway so I don't take it personally.

How much sitting still do people in 12 degree houses do?

Stuffin · 30/12/2022 08:22

Blueborage · 30/12/2022 08:16

Leaving aside the issue of the vile smell of mothballs, are the people who find 12 degrees comfortable fat? I feel I may have to name change after this because it's just not PC to suggest that a thick covering of fat has definite insulating properties. Or possibly quite a lot of Viking ancestry?

I definitely feel the cold more having lost 3 stone. My DH also feels the cold more having lost even more weight.

Going back to the OP, they were bad hosts if they openly ignored your request to put the heating on.

I am cold in the house here at 17 degrees. It's ok at 18 so we tend to fluctuate between 17 and 18. I would find 12 degrees miserable especially if you are sat still.

Yogagrandmum · 30/12/2022 08:19

Blueborage · 30/12/2022 08:16

Leaving aside the issue of the vile smell of mothballs, are the people who find 12 degrees comfortable fat? I feel I may have to name change after this because it's just not PC to suggest that a thick covering of fat has definite insulating properties. Or possibly quite a lot of Viking ancestry?

My mother has lost weight and openly admits she feels the cold now because she’s no longer fat.

Forever42 · 30/12/2022 08:17

Our heating was off for a day and a half over Christmas while we stayed with relatives. The temperature was 13 degrees when we got home and it felt very cold inside.

Blueborage · 30/12/2022 08:16

Leaving aside the issue of the vile smell of mothballs, are the people who find 12 degrees comfortable fat? I feel I may have to name change after this because it's just not PC to suggest that a thick covering of fat has definite insulating properties. Or possibly quite a lot of Viking ancestry?

BiasedBinding · 30/12/2022 08:15

RampantIvy · 30/12/2022 08:00

TBH I'm a little sceptical at claims that the inside of the house is actually 12 degrees, unless they never put any kind of heating on. I suspect the house is a little warmer than that. It is currently 19 degrees in my house and I am wearing a nightie and dressing gown and am comfortable. When I get dressed I will be wearing jeans a T-shirt and a warm jumper.

You can be as sceptical as you like, but I have a room thermometer in my study and it was 9-12C during the day. The heating was off at that point but it came on morning and evening. What makes you think I’m not telling the truth?

gamerchick · 30/12/2022 08:14

You don't allow guests to be cold. I tend not to have visitors during the winter. It's not a nice thing to do to guests.

Hellybelly84 · 30/12/2022 08:13

18 is the lowest temperature heating should be set at (we have our heating set at that in the evenings and morning). Off during the day as we’re usually out at work or not sitting around. It must have been extremely miserable if it was 12 and I would have packed up, said im feeling ill and gone home. Living in 12 degrees will make them ill and also cause damage to their house. I wouldn’t go back and its not unreasonable to tell them why.

HarvestThyme · 30/12/2022 08:04

For most people, a 16C minimum indoors- at least during the day and not under a duvet at night - is about right. (That's why it's the H&S standard.) No doubt some will sweat buckets above 10C, and fair enough - keep the heat off and I hope your homes are not susceptible to mould or damp.

Naturally people are different, but being comfortable at 12C indoors means you are an outlier. You should not expect others to be comfortable below 15C. Just because your guests are too polite to say something, doesn't mean they are not cold.

LolaSmiles · 30/12/2022 08:03

We'd have left. It's poor hosting.

Someone we know seems to take pride in not having the heating on. They also complain they can't get clothes dry in winter so I had to explain that cold clothes on clothes racks in a cold house aren't going to dry and their air is getting damp. We don't spend a lot of time there because of it.

ivykaty44 · 30/12/2022 08:02

For those saying they don’t mind very low temperatures are you not worried about the damage to clothes and furnishings?

I grew up in a house without central heating, the sitting room had a coal fire and the kitchen and some bedrooms had gas fires - but they weren't always used. The rooms wouldn't have been heated to 18-19 degrees, they were large 16ft x 20ft rooms with 8 ft ceilings

The house was cold by todays standards, but never ever had a problem with mould or damaged furniture, we had moth balls in the wardrobes. The house was "lived" in not empty.

RampantIvy · 30/12/2022 08:00

TBH I'm a little sceptical at claims that the inside of the house is actually 12 degrees, unless they never put any kind of heating on. I suspect the house is a little warmer than that. It is currently 19 degrees in my house and I am wearing a nightie and dressing gown and am comfortable. When I get dressed I will be wearing jeans a T-shirt and a warm jumper.

Piglet89 · 30/12/2022 07:58

I fucking HATE being cold when visiting peeps’ houses. My husband bought me a heated blanket for Christmas so I can keep our heating off and still stay warm on the days I work from home (but then I’m alone so nobody else affected except DCat);

Energy prices are absolutely insane ATM; I imagine I will pack my heated blanket sometimes - esp when we go to visit our very cold housed friends in Edinburgh!

@womanontheedge2022 would your hosts have been annoyed, had you plugged in a heated blanket (if you had one!)

BiasedBinding · 30/12/2022 07:55

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 30/12/2022 07:51

For those saying they don’t mind very low temperatures are you not worried about the damage to clothes and furnishings? When we bought our home it had been un heated and shut up for a while and the leather sofas were covered in green mould.
We have a log burner which is lit from getting up until 9pm everyday in winter. Our thick stone walls absorb the heat and the room stays warm all night.
Have just been away for Christmas and our hosts kept the house comfortably warm. However nothing compares to my toasty sitting room.
Also all of the anti log burner people have gone very quiet since the energy crisis.

Well I do have the heating on a couple of times a day so it only got to 9-12 degrees in some rooms when we had the cold snap. It won’t have damaged clothes and furniture for that brief period. But I don’t have the luxury of a log burner, just have to use the gas central heating and associates cost. I’m not anti log burner (my parents have one) but if you don’t have one you can’t use one.

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 30/12/2022 07:51

For those saying they don’t mind very low temperatures are you not worried about the damage to clothes and furnishings? When we bought our home it had been un heated and shut up for a while and the leather sofas were covered in green mould.
We have a log burner which is lit from getting up until 9pm everyday in winter. Our thick stone walls absorb the heat and the room stays warm all night.
Have just been away for Christmas and our hosts kept the house comfortably warm. However nothing compares to my toasty sitting room.
Also all of the anti log burner people have gone very quiet since the energy crisis.

schnauzerbeard · 30/12/2022 07:46

I wouldn't mind this. I would hate 20 degrees, dries out my skin and gives me a headache. Everyone different though.

ivykaty44 · 30/12/2022 07:36

There is a middle road between a cold house and a stifling house. 18 - 20 degrees is not stifling.

everyone is different and for me the house would be very much stifling at 18-20

I can cope and am comfortable at 17-18 but anything higher than that and I start struggling.

I recently stayed away where the temperature was cranked up to 19 and I went to bed, shut the door and opened the window, regardless of the fact it was -5 outside

ivykaty44 · 30/12/2022 07:30

I haven't got the heating on and its 14.5 in the house, will be most of the day - rises to about 15.5 and then in the evening the heating will come on for an hour

I have a friend who comes to visit and I have to put the heating on for her as she is cold at that temperature - I will roast and just wear a t shirt, fortunately its not overnight. I wouldn't cope with the heating on overnight as it affects my asthma, being a dry heat of central heating.

are you sure your friends just don't think you're joking about it being so cold?

Roselilly36 · 30/12/2022 07:23

I hate the cold, I would have said heating on or I am going. Would have been happy to pay too. Being cold is so miserable and bad for health.

Heatherbell1978 · 30/12/2022 07:21

Our heating broke for 3 days here in Scotland when it was -5 a couple of weeks ago. Modern, well insulated house and it got down to 11/12 degrees in the house. Absolutely freezing, I can't believe people think that's ok? I'm not a blast the heating person, thermostat at 18/19 in the day and off at night normally. At 12 in the house we were having to put electric heaters in, walk around with Oodies, go to sleep in onesies and socks...I was worried about damp and burst pipes etc at that temperature indoors as well (possibly over-reacting as it was just a couple of days)

ichundich · 30/12/2022 07:18

People claiming to be "comfortable" in their 12 degree houses 🤣. Why do you even waste money on having a house; a shed or tent should do.

Zanatdy · 30/12/2022 07:16

I’d have left. I find that very rude if your visitor asked you to put it on and even offered to contribute and he still said no! Unbelievable. I wouldn’t be visiting again

Spanielsarepainless · 30/12/2022 07:15

A friend is like this. Gives you a blanket and a heated beanbag as you walk in the door.

RampantIvy · 30/12/2022 07:12

I wear warm clothes in winter, but 12 degrees is unsustainable for me. I can't work bundled up in a blanket. I need the ambient temperature to be at least 18 degrees when sitting still to be able to concentrate.

There is a middle road between a cold house and a stifling house. 18 - 20 degrees is not stifling. It is a pleasant ambient temperature. I suppose the posters who find this stifling are on the "I hate summer" threads as soon as the thermometer creeps above 18 degrees.

When I am cold all I can think about is how cold I am and nothing else. DH and I once left a wedding reception early because we were so cold

Toocooltoboogie · 30/12/2022 07:03

lking679 The article you've provided the link for isn't relevant to this discussion. The guy doing the experiment was wearing shorts and a cotton shirt. People living in cooler homes are usually prepared and take steps to wear warmer clothes, use blankets etc.
Op yanbu - I prefer a cooler home - always have prior to the heating rises, however I always make the house warmer when we have guests. Your hosts should have at least prepared you.