Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 30/12/2022 15:08

@Hongkongsuey in all fairness DH and I are 62, still working full-time, and plan to do so for another 3 to 5 years. If we need care in our latter years we expect to pay for it and will do so from our pensions and investments. We do not need to downsize to fund our healthcare needs thank you so don't generalise. Further, we wish to elect for minimal treatment in our dotage to ensure quality of life.

MIL 86 with Parkinsons, a widow for 18 years, has carers daily, paid for by DH because despite teaching for 40 years, her needs do not meet the bar and yet she was raised on cradle to grave lie and thinks that if the NHS doesn't think she's ill enough to pay for the carers she isn't entitled to any care. The foundations of the NHS were disingenuous from day one.

For the previous poster who said th Tory's have had since 2010 to sort out the NHS. Actually there was a Lib/Con coalition from 2010 to 2015 and as a sop to the libs Cameron put in charge Blair's former health adviser Sir Simon Stephens, a man who knew more about privatisation than anyone in the UK, having spent several years in the US.

In 1997 when Blair came to power he was handed a very healthy economy. In 2010, the economy had been absolutely wrecked. And wrecked again in 2020/21 through lockdowns for the sake of the NHS. It doesn't take rocket science to work out that there has been little money for investment.

Ultimately healthcare must be taken out of politics and politics must be taken out of the NHS. However for as long as the NHS tells me the Tories are stinky crooks I shall tell them that the lefties are stinky woke ne'er do wells puffed up on their personal moral superiority. We really must sort out the Dr's annual pension allowance though because despite being high earners they shouldn't be subject to the punitive tax rates faced by others. It's not only Dr's affected by the annual allowance but of course they should get specialist treatment. Just like the soviet communist regime afforded its leaders country dachas and other privileges. It's all a bit too two legs good, four legs bad for my taste. And that is where the rot began.

WimbyAce · 30/12/2022 15:05

NameChangedAsOutraged · 30/12/2022 14:32

I’m sorry the pharmacist treated you like that.

That's OK, I'm quite thick skinned so no problems. GP has already phoned me back. I did apologise which I think she appreciated.

Fifi00 · 30/12/2022 14:55

We have gotten really bad at letting nature take its course especially at the end. We have really good pain relief strategies, people aren't planning for the future or making advanced directives. When I have dementia , I probably will get it as I'm female and it will be the number 1 cause of death. I want to be given pain relief and midozalam , no dysphagia assessments , no artificial nutrition , no Antibiotics, if I fall pain relief no CT. Just let me die peacefully drugged up to the eyeballs. I have nursed numerous people with the condition and that's what I want to die painlessly not kept alive for years on end.

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 30/12/2022 14:44

@Soothsayer1 · Today 13:47
My sister in law works in the NHS. Here's her list of fixes
Reading your list gives me an impression of a system which is deliberately & inherently adversarial and dysfunctional, or designed by people who hate the fact that the peasants get any healthcare at all, like they would rather waste money than spend it on benefiting the people.....

The present system was designed by Conservative government health secretary Andrew Lansley in 2012.

The last labour government spent a decade undoing the damage wrought by the Major/ Thatcher government, only for the Tories to get back into power and continue their project to dismantle the NHS, social care, and local government.

NameChangedAsOutraged · 30/12/2022 14:32

WimbyAce · 30/12/2022 14:24

Thanks, it's for my little one actually, constipation. I've been through it with my older one so not overly concerned but the pharmacist made me feel like a bad mum so now I am bothering a GP when they are busy with more urgent matters.

I’m sorry the pharmacist treated you like that.

WimbyAce · 30/12/2022 14:24

NameChangedAsOutraged · 30/12/2022 14:21

As a GP I want to ensure all patients who contact us - please don’t feel like a fraudster for accessing help you need.

I hope you get better soon.

Thanks, it's for my little one actually, constipation. I've been through it with my older one so not overly concerned but the pharmacist made me feel like a bad mum so now I am bothering a GP when they are busy with more urgent matters.

NameChangedAsOutraged · 30/12/2022 14:21

WimbyAce · 30/12/2022 14:17

I do feel sorry for GPs, have just been to pharmacy as we are advised they can help. They were insistent that I phoned GP today. I have done so but feel a bit of a fraudster tbh.

As a GP I want to ensure all patients who contact us - please don’t feel like a fraudster for accessing help you need.

I hope you get better soon.

Ratched · 30/12/2022 14:19

Off topic ( a bit), but what a brilliant thread this is.
Informative, with differing views, but generally respectful.

Only wish more threads were like this😁

WimbyAce · 30/12/2022 14:17

I do feel sorry for GPs, have just been to pharmacy as we are advised they can help. They were insistent that I phoned GP today. I have done so but feel a bit of a fraudster tbh.

Helplesstohelp22 · 30/12/2022 14:15

Doctors leave university after 5 years with £85k debt and the princely sum of £14 per hour. They pay all their postgraduate exam fees (essential to get into training), GMC and indemnity fees, conference fees (have to publish papers for competitive training). Most hospitals charge for parking and don't provide free accommodation.

It takes 5 years med school + 2 years foundation training + 3 years core training + 3 years specialty training to become a consultant. This sacrifice and dedication is not reflected in pay or conditions.

NameChangedAsOutraged · 30/12/2022 14:07

taxguru · 30/12/2022 13:27

My sister in law works in the NHS. Here's her list of fixes:-

  1. Scrap the internal market which takes up massive amounts of manpower, administration and management time and results in expensive/inefficiency decision making.
  2. Bring back smaller hospitals, cottage hospitals, etc to deal with the routine, run of the mill, simple procedures that don't need the "all singing, all dancing" high tech super hospitals doing the complicated stuff.
  3. Scrap all the different, competing trusts, to stop the damaging fragmentation of the NHS into so many different trusts, all doing different things in different ways using different systems.
  4. Make more services directly accessible instead of having to go through the "gatekeeping" role of GPs which often just wastes their time and causes delays. I.e. in the same way you make your own appointment with a dentist or optician, let people make their own appointments with departments like podiatry or audiology or physiotherapy where it's blatantly obvious that you need an audiologist for hearing loss or a podiatrist for an ingrown toe. If they think you need a specialist or treatment from a different dept., they can refer you, just like a dentist can refer you if they suspect something else when checking your teeth/mouth.
  5. More convalescent/step down wards or homes for people with no medical need to stay in hospital but still need "care" on a temporary basis until ready to return to their usual home.

Point 4 suggests your SIL hasn’t got a clue about the role primary care plays in the NHS.

90% of constants for under 10% of patient funding.

The waiting list for hospital appointments are already at an all time high. If you remove the need for referral to a specialist then the waiting list will meltdown.

Using your example - ENT/Audiology are not going to want to see everyone with hearing loss, their clinics would be overwhelmed. Audiology won’t accept referrals without ears being examined to ensure the hearing loss isn’t simply due to impacted wax that needs aggressive olive oil treatment and that’s it. There are some hearing losses that need to be seen immediately, will the average lay person know what that is? Or will they wait on a waiting list for months whilst their hearing declines and the serious underlying issue deteriorates?

It’s not straightforward and self referral should only be used in very specific circumstances such as Podiatry (in my area) is self referral already and I agree that should be the case nation wide.

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 14:00

Families used to provide care for dependents, whether young or elderly - but that's now economically impossible for many
I would argue that, as well as now being economically impossible it also relied on women being prepared to Sacrifice themselves, forgo their future earning potential so that the man could preserve his.
Women now have more opportunities, we are not prepared to Sacrifice ourselves nor should we, we have talents and abilities that are needed by society, we deserve to flourish and fulfil our potential just like men do

NameChangedAsOutraged · 30/12/2022 13:56

@RosesAndHellebores Striking nurses and paramedics are expressing concern about standards and colleagues. That’s been one of the reasons for their recent strikes. We must be looking at different photographs. I haven’t seen any jolliness from my nursing and paramedic colleagues. I see exhaustion and anger.

Im not denying that there were issues with the Labour government re: the NHS. However the Tories have been in power for 12 years. If what is happening now was directly due to the Labour government’s policies alone, then the current government have have TWELVE YEARS to turn it around. They haven’t. They have let it die. They are responsible for what is happening.

Instead of sniping between right vs left, woke vs whatever the opposite is of woke etc there needs to be focus on fixing this binfire. However that will never happen, so I’m just going to carry on working, doing what I can for my patients whilst experiencing constant abuse and trying to avoid getting seriously burnt out again even though I’m having to admit people to hospital due to hypothermia because they can’t heat their homes due to the cost of living crisis (which I had to do during the most recent cold snap and it broke my woke, leftie heart).

Puzzledandpissedoff · 30/12/2022 13:56

If most of these posts really are from those working in the NHS, it's interesting - though not surprising - to see so many highlight organisational / management / expectation issues rather than just the money
It would also underline the belief of many that there's simply no point wasting more on a system that doesn't work, not least because those spending it would be the same ones making the decisions now

Clearly we need a new approach, but while retaining current clinical staff would be necessary, we'd need to find a way of keeping this management mentality away from it - and how to do that I honestly don't know

Hongkongsuey · 30/12/2022 13:54

Babynameangst · 30/12/2022 10:22

The collapse of the NHS is just one of a plethora of interlinked societal problems. To fix the NHS requires sweeping societal
and political change involving redistribution of wealth and being realistic about how we will manage an increasingly needy, geriatric population.

There is a growing generational wealth gap - compare the affordability of housing and living for current working generation vs their parents and grandparents. The over 65s now own >50% of the wealth in the UK, and median wealth for those in their 60s is 9 times higher for those in their 30s. Source www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personalandhouseholdfinances/incomeandwealth/bulletins/distributionofindividualtotalwealthbycharacteristicingreatbritain/april2018tomarch2020#the-generation-gap

Despite this gross equality there is a perception that the elderly have already "paid their way" and now deserve to retain all of their assets whilst their care should be paid for through general taxation. The voting population (majority of whom are cannot abide the idea that an elderly couple might need to downsize their large family home to pay for their (prolonged) old age. They cannot abide an increase to retirement age. But the taxpayer cannot sustain a retirement that lasts for up to 30 years and is complicated by vastly expensive health and social problems. Something has to give. At the moment, what's giving is the health and social care system.

Older people are the largest group that vote and they vote conservative, I believe primarily to preserve their retirement assets and to preserve the generational wealth gap. Even alternative (eg current Labour) government's still fundamentally serve this same agenda because suggesting that the older generation pay for their own health and social care by reducing their assets is political suicide. The result will be the total collapse of health and social care and a period of great suffering for everyone, that one hopes will eventually be reset by a more equitable system. It can't be fixed by any recommendation from anyone without or within the NHS system IMO.

That said, my recommendations would be:

  • Integrate health and social care
  • Greatly increase health and social care budgets in line with similar developed nations
  • Fix the pension tax trap for NHS consultants
  • Scrap nursing tuition fees and bring back the bursary / a salary for student nurses
  • Pay rise for all staff shortage groups in health and social care
  • Massive initial investment needed to expand and buy back private services and escape PFI contracts, with the effect of greatly reducing ongoing spend
  • For that matter, reverse the health and social care bill 2012 and everything that's followed
  • Get realistic about death (this is it's own topic). Interview anyone and they wouldn't want their future to be end stage dementia with an endless purgatory of delirium whilst all measures (needles, operations, antibiotics, feeding tubes etc) are used to keep them alive as long as possible. But this is the standard approach. Public awareness / cultural mores have a lot to answer for (see reaction to Liverpool Care Pathway)
  • I disagree that the NHS has too many managers. It's a vast and complex organisation it needs good management and good management costs, like everything else. My experience is that administrative and management support is being stripped for clinical staff and that makes the work harder. Clinical staff who are expected to be managers often don't enjoy the work, don't do it well, and aren't well rewarded for it. It causes senior clinicians to leave.

I wish you were my MP-or even better-PM!

Crispyturtle · 30/12/2022 13:51

I’m sure this has already been said but until the issues with social care are fixed the NHS will continue to grind to a halt. I’ve just read that there are 12000 people in hospital beds that no longer need hospital care but there’s nowhere to discharge them to. This means that people are stuck in A&E waiting for ward beds, which in turn means there’s 8+ hour waits to be seen in A&E and ambulances can’t offload patients safely, which in turn means people are waiting hours for ambulances. The whole system needs unblocking, but the blockage isn’t caused by the NHS and so can’t be solved by the NHS.

Unfortunately with rising operating costs I think more private care homes will close, and so the problem will only worsen.

Staff retention in the NHS will improve when they don’t feel like they’re fire-fighting every second of every day with no let up, no one can manage that level of stress and pressure forever.

Blurpy · 30/12/2022 13:48

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 13:36

I agree but, this is difficult and demanding work which few people have a genuine aptitude for, and for those that do the pay is so low that you can't have a decent standard of living. If the pay was high enough to incentivise those with an aptitude for this work well ....we just wouldn't be able to afford it surely?
Many of these traditionally female jobs relied on women being subservient and willing to work for low pay and bad conditions, that ship has sailed, women want to be treated as equal humans now, if healthcare won't treat them properly they will walk and work elsewhere.

I think this is a large part of the problem. Public services are being used to plug holes that have appeared as society has changed. Families used to provide care for dependents, whether young or elderly - but that's now economically impossible for many, hence the massive demand for childcare and elderly care. As you say, no one wants to do those jobs, because they're difficult and poorly paid - perhaps the scarcity of carers will drive up prices to the point where it'll be more cost effective for people to drop out of the labour market and care for their relatives themselves (as it is with childcare). Except the state loses money this way too, through loss of income and paying out welfare.

I don't know - beyond improving the health of the nation, so that people can live HEALTHY lives into old age (through promoting lifelong exercise and education and massively cutting pollution - itself a massive cost commitment) or adopting a Logan's Run style system of killing everyone off at 50, there's no obvious solution.

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 13:47

My sister in law works in the NHS. Here's her list of fixes
Reading your list gives me an impression of a system which is deliberately & inherently adversarial and dysfunctional, or designed by people who hate the fact that the peasants get any healthcare at all, like they would rather waste money than spend it on benefiting the people.....
(The people, the ones who do the actual work that makes all the shareholders rich)

RosesAndHellebores · 30/12/2022 13:44

@NameChangedAsOutraged I don't remember a better NHS when labour were in power. Many of today's deficiencies were rolled out during the Blair government. As GP fund holding was working it was ceased by that government and replaced with an horrendous layer of expensive bureaucracy called PCTs. PFI was rolled out at pace.

The previous Conservative government in the early to mid 90s did not dare Introduce reforms to bring in a Continental System. Thatcher tore up the paper.

Only two or three years ago the public were not allowed to breathe a word against the sacred cow turned behemoth. NHS workers unbranded us if we uttered a word of dissent and told us we were lucky and it was free. It was never free.

As far as I am concerned the NHS has been destroyed by its majority population of right-on leftwingers pedalling their socialist/Marxist principles in a way that is dangerously fundamentalist. Too many jolly nurses on the picket lines for my liking thoroughly enjoying a bit of socialist grandstanding rather than expressing concern about standards or their colleagues. Too many photographs of unlawful picket lines with more than 8 pickets too. I don't recall that being challenged in the press.

If the wealthy people go private it will free up services for the poor I'd have thought and ensure a greater share of a scarce resource for them.

Blame the Tories all you like; I blame the despicable lefties. Not a nice statement is it when the boot is put on the other foot.

NameChangedAsOutraged · 30/12/2022 13:44

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 13:24

Obviously you have far more insight than I do but reading your post it occurs to me that woefull health care for the poor will cause huge problems for the Tory government, we have a labour shortage... not enough people available to do the work that needs to be done!
tories need the poor to be fit and healthy and that means good medical care surely?

The Tories don’t care. Privatisation for them will = money for them and their cronies who own/run private health care. Or money from selling parts of the health service to companies such as Virgin Health etc.

This has been the Tory agenda for many years and many medics/HCPs have seen this coming.

Ironically for a lot of medics, private health will make them more money. But what people don’t realise is that most GPs don’t want that to happen, because we know the care people will receive via the ‘free’ health care stream will be awful. One of the things we want the most is the ability to provide the exemplary care our patients deserve. We can’t do it now because the NHS is dead. The moral injury that is causing is significant.

NHS Primary General Practice will end up like NHS Dentistry. Majority private with shit access to free/partially funded treatment.

Private work for GPs has always been traditionally quite minimal and looked on with derision by most NHS GPs, which is why I’ve always been baffled why people accuse us of working part time to just make more money with private work.

However a friend has set up a private GP clinic over the summer and I’ve just seen a tweet from another former colleague who is setting up a private GP clinic.

It’s terrifying.

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 13:40

taxguru · 30/12/2022 13:32

I think we could be heading back to the time before the NHS whereby big employers provided health/convalescent facilities for their workforce, partly from a sense of responsibility (i.e. Cadbury, Quakers, etc) and partly from a simple need to get workers back to the workplace as quickly as possible. There are lots of "large" old buildings which are now hotels or apartments, but which used to be convalescent homes built/paid for by big employers.

It's been noticeable for a decade or two that larger employers have been providing private healthcare, initially for more senior workers, but which is being slowly extended down through the ranks and some now provide it to all workers, and smaller employers are starting to offer it too.

Thanks for your response, I see what you are saying, it looks as if this is happening almost by default or as a kind of organic thing?

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 13:36

AreOttersJustWetCats · 30/12/2022 08:09

I'm ex-NHS and for me the absolute biggest thing needed is to invest in social care

I agree but, this is difficult and demanding work which few people have a genuine aptitude for, and for those that do the pay is so low that you can't have a decent standard of living. If the pay was high enough to incentivise those with an aptitude for this work well ....we just wouldn't be able to afford it surely?
Many of these traditionally female jobs relied on women being subservient and willing to work for low pay and bad conditions, that ship has sailed, women want to be treated as equal humans now, if healthcare won't treat them properly they will walk and work elsewhere.

taxguru · 30/12/2022 13:32

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 13:24

Obviously you have far more insight than I do but reading your post it occurs to me that woefull health care for the poor will cause huge problems for the Tory government, we have a labour shortage... not enough people available to do the work that needs to be done!
tories need the poor to be fit and healthy and that means good medical care surely?

I think we could be heading back to the time before the NHS whereby big employers provided health/convalescent facilities for their workforce, partly from a sense of responsibility (i.e. Cadbury, Quakers, etc) and partly from a simple need to get workers back to the workplace as quickly as possible. There are lots of "large" old buildings which are now hotels or apartments, but which used to be convalescent homes built/paid for by big employers.

It's been noticeable for a decade or two that larger employers have been providing private healthcare, initially for more senior workers, but which is being slowly extended down through the ranks and some now provide it to all workers, and smaller employers are starting to offer it too.

RosesAndHellebores · 30/12/2022 13:32

@vdbfamily "elderly patients enjoying their free NHS hotel". I'm sorry but that statement leapt off the page. I have never stayed in an hotel where I have had to share a room with 5 others, share a bathroom, usually dirty, with randoms, had men swanning around, been awoken by noise throughout the night, spoken to as though I am a decrepit idiot, served tea in a plastic cup and poor quality like warm food.

If asylum seekers were treated as described above there would be a public outcry. A key problem with the NHS is that those who work in it think the above description is acceptable vis a vis prevailing standards.

taxguru · 30/12/2022 13:27

My sister in law works in the NHS. Here's her list of fixes:-

  1. Scrap the internal market which takes up massive amounts of manpower, administration and management time and results in expensive/inefficiency decision making.
  2. Bring back smaller hospitals, cottage hospitals, etc to deal with the routine, run of the mill, simple procedures that don't need the "all singing, all dancing" high tech super hospitals doing the complicated stuff.
  3. Scrap all the different, competing trusts, to stop the damaging fragmentation of the NHS into so many different trusts, all doing different things in different ways using different systems.
  4. Make more services directly accessible instead of having to go through the "gatekeeping" role of GPs which often just wastes their time and causes delays. I.e. in the same way you make your own appointment with a dentist or optician, let people make their own appointments with departments like podiatry or audiology or physiotherapy where it's blatantly obvious that you need an audiologist for hearing loss or a podiatrist for an ingrown toe. If they think you need a specialist or treatment from a different dept., they can refer you, just like a dentist can refer you if they suspect something else when checking your teeth/mouth.
  5. More convalescent/step down wards or homes for people with no medical need to stay in hospital but still need "care" on a temporary basis until ready to return to their usual home.