Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
RethinkingLife · 31/12/2022 21:12

Excellent Twitter thread and article by Shaun Lintern. Lintern lists "Ten fast ways to improve the NHS" in the shorter-term.

twitter.com/ShaunLintern/status/1609253977664659458

Article www.thetimes.co.uk/article/ten-fast-ways-to-improve-the-nhs-mhh7szz8w
Archive version: archive.ph/7VstN

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?
BirmaBrite · 31/12/2022 20:56

We do need to spend more on healthcare, Germany and France spend over 12% of GDP on theirs compared to our 7.8% pre pandemic in 2019, obviously there has been a jump during the pandemic years in the UK, but a lot of that will have been spent on pandemic associated healthcare.

The German system does seem very thorough and looks after people well.

www.howtogermany.com/pages/working.html

HRTQueen · 31/12/2022 12:53

Look at the French and German models accept that the NHS can no longer run as it now is and we have have to let go I wish a political party would be brave enough to announce this

we need to pay more towards our physical and mental healthcare

I work in mh there are too many upper management making decisions for us on wards/units that have no real idea of the day to day running of such places they just want statistics. Often half my day is taken up with supporting patients with everyday tasks or they just need to come and chat this is an essential part of the work but this isn’t calculated in the endless reports. The increase in time spent in meetings since covid is ridiculous

more support in the community 24hr hubs where people can go sometimes they just need company and to talk sadly cut backs in community support has led to the police being relied on which isn’t fair on all involved

no working from home unless it’s work that can be down from home completely

Helplesstohelp22 · 31/12/2022 12:41

Also re: mental health services. 2 members of staff on a local ward were violently attacked by the same patient who suffers from what consultants have described as an incurable personality disorder, one stuff member being pregnant. This individual is barely an adult. Services will have to care for them until they die because there is nothing fixable. How many others will get hurt?

Morale is rock bottom because staff are being left to cope with these patients without safe nursing numbers to do so and people are getting hurt.

Severe PD are more common because people are living in dysfunctional families, often in poverty and born to parents with their own untreated mental health issues, and social support is just not available before things get severe.

Could you care for as many as five young women on a ward covered in self harm scars from ankle to face who will ligature if a single member of staff turns their back for a moment? It is like a horror film.

That is the reality of mental health services now.

Helplesstohelp22 · 31/12/2022 12:34

Re: mental health services.

GPs are inundated with requests for secondary care assessment of patients who think they have adult ADHD, mild anxiety, mild depression (but have a job, family, hobbies etc. and are functioning even if they are unhappy).

Meanwhile inpatient psychiatry and crisis teams are mainly treating severely psychotic patients who have entirely lost touch with reality, complex chronic personality disorder patients who ligature 5x a day and need 1:1 or even 2:1 care. Acute assessment wards are full of patients that secure services refuse because they're too risky.

The public have absolutely no idea (lucky for them) what serous mental illness looks like.

snowsilver · 31/12/2022 10:46

In a similar vein to the DN / housebound thing I don't know if anyone has mentioned patient transport? It costs the NHS nationally around £10 million a year. It's essentially a taxi service and is free. It's supposed to be for the frail and sick who have no other way to get to and from hospital appointments but in my experience is used by people who could easily get a taxi or a lift from family or friend.
I strongly believe that the NHS should not be funding things that aren't healthcare. A fee for such services would mightily reduce demand.

@Menora thanks for your insight. I'm glad this thread hasn't taken the GPO bashing turn that so many do.

cptartapp · 31/12/2022 10:40

CoffeandTiaMaria · 30/12/2022 07:26

7 day a week GP/Nurse Practitioner services, stop people overwhelming A+E because they can’t get a GP appointment. Our GP surgery is utter crap since Covid hit, one GP sends you to Ambulatory Care or A+E ‘to be safe’ for the most minor of reasons-might just as well go straight there! (I wouldn’t and don’t)

We haven't enough staff to staff five days properly, let alone seven. I can work all the Sunday mornings you want, but then won't be there on a Monday afternoon for example. Staff are leaving - another two nurses next month with no replacements, they certainly don't want overtime.

Geneticsbunny · 31/12/2022 10:31

I will completely admit that I haven't read all of the posts on the thread but I think that if social care services were working properly, then a huge pressure would be taken off of the NHS and it would probably be able to manage. The NHS and the police are where the buck stops if people who need social care support can't get it.
Suitable recovery support for elderly people in their homes/ in some sort of nursing / recovery from illness home, properly funded mental health services and more supported accomodation for people who need help to manage their lives would take a huge burden from the police and the NHS.

dollybird · 31/12/2022 10:08

dollybird · 31/12/2022 09:14

I meant why would they be top of band 6 any more than a nurse could be top of band 5. They would still have to get X number of years experience at band 6 to get to the top. And you've just explained to fluffyfluffyfluffy why they are a higher band than a nurse.

I meant to quote CoffeeBoy here

Menora · 31/12/2022 09:52

BlandSoup · 31/12/2022 08:05

@Menora We cannot keep glossing over the issue of health anxiety, improved ease of access to health information (online consults, the internet) and the impact of rising costs and long waits of other services such as dental, opticians etc

I hadn’t considered this before. An interesting point that I’ll need to think about more. I wonder if people have lost confidence in themselves or maybe think that medicine is better than it is. That it can fix more problems than it can.

Thanks for your comment, I really would like people to look inwards to some extent, but this doesn’t take away from being under funded or poorly run I appreciate that. This is not about passing blame to patients.

For instance there is a lot of discourse about HRT in the media. Women are often very disillusioned that HRT does not take away all of their symptoms or feelings and often continually look to health services to address, fix/solve when some of these issues are related to their home and family life, mental well-being, lifestyle and no amount of HRT reviews or med adjustments will make them wake up feeling the way they did 5-10 years before.

Many people are afraid they will waste their time doubling up, ie visiting a pharmacist to then be passed to a GP. Time is precious people don’t want to waste that either, I know of two people in my circle who see sitting in A&E on weekends for a sore throat as a solution to not being able to take time off from their min wage job M-F when their GP is open as their employer is not flexible, and services aren’t always catering to those people. Even I have noticed things like my own impatience at how long queues are nowadays (in shops) and constantly battling with stress about not having the time to wait and be somewhere else.

We noticed a huge influx of sick children in the run up to Christmas with the strep A outbreak but as schools are not open, less children are unwell and now it’s is more the elderly we are seeing who are unwell and people who have lingering viral infections. A lot of people don’t want to be sick at Christmas because the time is precious to them but for instance yesterday, my practice had significantly less calls than it has had on any day across the entire past year. So had everyone suddenly got better or are they busy with their families and self managing? It was a chance for us all to catch up on all of the other work outstanding.

dollybird · 31/12/2022 09:14

dollybird · 31/12/2022 08:46

Top of band 6 is £40,588, and why would they be top of band 6 any more than a nurse? Top of band 5 is £32,934

I meant why would they be top of band 6 any more than a nurse could be top of band 5. They would still have to get X number of years experience at band 6 to get to the top. And you've just explained to fluffyfluffyfluffy why they are a higher band than a nurse.

CoffeeBoy · 31/12/2022 09:07

My dad spent six months in hospital once. Now he had a decent pension and owned his house outright so while he was in hospital he saved so much money. No food to buy, turned his heating at his house right down, etc. his private pension still got paid every month

i know not everyone is in the same position and some people might lose their wage or still have rent to pay but my dad asked if he could contribute to his food and would happily have done so but they said no.

CoffeeBoy · 31/12/2022 09:03

dollybird · 31/12/2022 08:46

Top of band 6 is £40,588, and why would they be top of band 6 any more than a nurse? Top of band 5 is £32,934

Because being a HV is a band 6 role, a nurse is generally a band 5 unless you’re a junior sister or a specialist role. But remember a HV won’t get any unsocial pay so if it wasn’t a band higher nobody would apply as you’d take a significant pay cut from being a ward based nurse working shifts. Plus they do a lot of specialist safeguarding work.

dollybird · 31/12/2022 08:46

fluffyfluffyfluffy · 31/12/2022 03:58

That health visitor who pops round to explain about all the important safety things with your baby, is getting paid top band 6, around £44k per year. That gynae, nicu or a&e nurse is on around £28

Top of band 6 is £40,588, and why would they be top of band 6 any more than a nurse? Top of band 5 is £32,934

BlandSoup · 31/12/2022 08:05

@Menora We cannot keep glossing over the issue of health anxiety, improved ease of access to health information (online consults, the internet) and the impact of rising costs and long waits of other services such as dental, opticians etc

I hadn’t considered this before. An interesting point that I’ll need to think about more. I wonder if people have lost confidence in themselves or maybe think that medicine is better than it is. That it can fix more problems than it can.

Virginiaplain · 31/12/2022 06:50

*District nurses are getting tumped as said before with non housebound patients from GP surgeries, We visit patients who then tell you they are going to hairdressers, appointments etc even to the surgeries themselves,

I raised this earlier. Expecting the hospital to ferry you to the hospital - I lived in the states everyone drove/ knew a driver / paid for a lift. Ambulances attended car collisions but weren't seen much at all.

There was recently a person on the radio whose father had died waiting for an ambulance - (person far away couldn't help) but surely, surely there was a neighbour, taxi, uber. I know that the best option is an ambulance so you can receive treatment en route/ not have the fractured leg moved unneccessarily but if the option is die waiting you'd surely just get there somehow.

We British seem very nannied.

fluffyfluffyfluffy · 31/12/2022 04:00

£28k per year

fluffyfluffyfluffy · 31/12/2022 03:58

That health visitor who pops round to explain about all the important safety things with your baby, is getting paid top band 6, around £44k per year. That gynae, nicu or a&e nurse is on around £28

fluffyfluffyfluffy · 31/12/2022 03:54

Im a qualified nurse and over 15 years I have worked in a huge variety of places.

I would massively reduce the health visiting budget. I worked as a health visitor for around 5 years. About 5% of my job required a qualified professional. Most of my job could have been done, and was done better by childrens centre workers.

Lucy7890 · 31/12/2022 01:33

TheComptonEffect · 31/12/2022 01:21

And who staffs this? NHS trained staff that's who

Not really. We seem to be recruiting more and more staff trained outside of the 'traditional NHS' route

TheComptonEffect · 31/12/2022 01:21

And who staffs this? NHS trained staff that's who

Lucy7890 · 30/12/2022 23:32
  1. Stop expecting the staff to go above and beyond for years on end, just to keep the service running and compensate for underfunding and understaffing. It is a job, not a vocation or a lifelong sacrifice competition.
  1. Do exit interviews - my service lost a lot of experienced staff but not one was asked why they were leaving. It's also quite upsetting to hear managers talk about their dedication to their job and 'our NHS' while completely lacking empathy for those below them, their work choices and refusing to hear their views.
  1. Better work flexibility, addressing bullying behaviour, less reinventing the wheel over and over again (this one is particularily annoying), more part time posts, integrated and user friendly IT systems.
Fifi00 · 30/12/2022 23:12

They are closing NHS funded LD respite beds which is going to cost the government more money. Parents will say they can't cope and SS need to find full time placements or private respite. Keeping carers onside keeps the bill down.

Menora · 30/12/2022 23:04

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 22:50

so many people just don’t listen to advice about healthy lifestyles
I agree, I think we have enabled people to sabotage their own health & expect to be patched up for free....then again, no wonder people are stressed & turn to food, alcohol, etc to try and cope, it's a minefield & idk what the solution is?

You will see this during recession and times of uncertainty, people will turn to these coping mechanisms. It’s not like mental health services have the resources available to assist. People often do not seek help addressing these consequences of poor lifestyle choices until something is going wrong, and then they don’t want to change. Then there is a section of society who are healthy and very health conscious but anxiously so and need a lot of reassurances which is their way of trying to cope with stress

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 22:50

so many people just don’t listen to advice about healthy lifestyles
I agree, I think we have enabled people to sabotage their own health & expect to be patched up for free....then again, no wonder people are stressed & turn to food, alcohol, etc to try and cope, it's a minefield & idk what the solution is?