Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
Soothsayer1 · 01/01/2023 13:28

rwalker · 01/01/2023 13:12

I’ve got a friend VERY successful building company self made left school with nothing

lives millionaire lifestyle I could only dream of
yes he’s very rich pays more tax in a few months than I earn a year
don’t see what crime he’s committed by being rich

As I said, he hasn't broken any laws because laws are setup to favour the rich.
You said that he is self made? Who did all the work that he profited from?
I'm not saying he hasn't worked hard but most of the hard work is done by the people who work for him, he didn't lay every brick himself.
Only fools and horses work.

rwalker · 01/01/2023 13:12

Soothsayer1 · 01/01/2023 12:48

UK had 740k millionaires in 2015... it now has 2.4m... so the tax system clearly is not stopping many people becoming extremely rich
Exactly!
the proper function of the tax system is to fairly redistribute wealth, otherwise it just rises to the top even though it's the people at the bottom who do the work that creates the wealth.

Money does not trickle down
Money whooshes UP

The reason that the wealthy are not breaking tax laws is that the laws are made by them to favour them!

I’ve got a friend VERY successful building company self made left school with nothing

lives millionaire lifestyle I could only dream of
yes he’s very rich pays more tax in a few months than I earn a year
don’t see what crime he’s committed by being rich

user1497207191 · 01/01/2023 13:05

@Alexandra2001

Yes under the current tax system but as i pointed out, we have taxes that favour the wealthy.... how many on here benefit from 0% tax on investment income or the very low 20% CGT ?

But millionaires don't benefit from the £12.5k annual tax free income allowance.

They don't benefit from the £1k interest zero rate band.

Not sure why you think there's a O% "investment income" tax rate - there isn't!

The CGT annual exemption is being halved and halved again over the next couple of years, which is something that hits the wealthy more than the poor.

The vast majority of the UK tax revenue is paid by the wealthiest few percent. I don't have the exact numbers to hand, but the piretto principle applies, i.e. something like less the top 20% of earners will be paying over 80% of the total tax raised.

You really can't keep screwing those earning more than average. The ultra wealthy will just use tax havens. Such as Lewis Hamilton buying his private jet via the Isle of Man to avoid paying VAT on it! How are you going to "persuade" a tax haven island to stop being a tax haven - bomb it?

Soothsayer1 · 01/01/2023 12:48

UK had 740k millionaires in 2015... it now has 2.4m... so the tax system clearly is not stopping many people becoming extremely rich
Exactly!
the proper function of the tax system is to fairly redistribute wealth, otherwise it just rises to the top even though it's the people at the bottom who do the work that creates the wealth.

Money does not trickle down
Money whooshes UP

The reason that the wealthy are not breaking tax laws is that the laws are made by them to favour them!

Alexandra2001 · 01/01/2023 12:33

user1497207191 · 01/01/2023 12:09

48% of the official HMRC "tax gap" is due to small business mistakes/evasion.

Only 5% of the "tax gap" relates to the wealthy.

So that clearly shows where the problem lies. Cash in hand work, not registering for VAT, not declaring income, over-declaring expenses, etc. , duty-free sales etc.

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/measuring-tax-gaps/1-tax-gaps-summary

Millions of people engaging in low level tax evasion is a much bigger number than a few ultra-wealthy using tax havens or loopholes.

Talk about missing the point!!

Yes under the current tax system but as i pointed out, we have taxes that favour the wealthy.... how many on here benefit from 0% tax on investment income or the very low 20% CGT ?

UK had 740k millionaires in 2015... it now has 2.4m... so the tax system clearly is not stopping many people becoming extremely rich.

To sort out health/nhs and social care.. we are talking 100s of billions over many years.

billysboy · 01/01/2023 12:30

a good thing I saw recently at Harlow An E was at the triage they had the ability to send you over to a GP based across the ( new fancy pants ) hall rather than admit you to A n E for eg a twisted ankle or minor injury

Harlow hospital itself just wants bull dozing selling to the highest bidder to build houses etc and use the proceeds to build a brand new hospital just outside the town

It just seems a bottomless pit the NHS , it is beyond me we pay train drivers what we do and Nurses that we all clapped for a pittance in comparison

Social care is a whole other issue on its own but one that cannot be ignored

Soothsayer1 · 01/01/2023 12:16

user1497207191 · 01/01/2023 12:09

48% of the official HMRC "tax gap" is due to small business mistakes/evasion.

Only 5% of the "tax gap" relates to the wealthy.

So that clearly shows where the problem lies. Cash in hand work, not registering for VAT, not declaring income, over-declaring expenses, etc. , duty-free sales etc.

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/measuring-tax-gaps/1-tax-gaps-summary

Millions of people engaging in low level tax evasion is a much bigger number than a few ultra-wealthy using tax havens or loopholes.

I think the problem is not so much tax evasion by the wealthy and more the fact that the system is setup to benefit the wealthy so that they get richer and richer at the expense of the rest of us.... The ones who do the real work that keeps them in lamborghinis and swimming pools and mansions
The ones with wealth and power make the rules and they make them to favour themselves.

Soothsayer1 · 01/01/2023 12:12

The trouble is, those millionaires and billionaires aren’t going to take too kindly to paying the kinds of additional taxes that you’re talking about. So the majority will either avoid it, seeing as they can pay some very clever specialist people to do so, or just move their liability to a lower tax regime, and we’ll lose out in even more income, making the whole situation worse
Yes, the richer they are the greater their ability to avoid paying their fair share.
Those of us without money and power are taxed because we are low hanging fruit ....it's easy to get money out of us because we don't have the power to stop them.

The strong are protected and the weak get a kicking, dog eat dog, the law of the jungle, might is right
That is not what I call a civilised society 🤬

user1497207191 · 01/01/2023 12:09

48% of the official HMRC "tax gap" is due to small business mistakes/evasion.

Only 5% of the "tax gap" relates to the wealthy.

So that clearly shows where the problem lies. Cash in hand work, not registering for VAT, not declaring income, over-declaring expenses, etc. , duty-free sales etc.

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/measuring-tax-gaps/1-tax-gaps-summary

Millions of people engaging in low level tax evasion is a much bigger number than a few ultra-wealthy using tax havens or loopholes.

Keskadale · 01/01/2023 12:01

SmokeyPaprika · 01/01/2023 11:45

There’s a lot of cash in hand work going on ime. It’s not the super wealthy but if every other builder or plumber does it mounts up. Also subletting hA property.

it costs money to check these things so they don’t get done.

Nothing like enough to make in roads into health funding plus undeclared income gets spent in their local economy.

BirmaBrite · 01/01/2023 11:59

I’m not saying I don't agree, but it’s the same cyclic argument. To increase spending, where the money is going to come from- a look around this site alone will show just how many are struggling to keep their heads just above water as it is.

It is tricky I agree, to get a German system you would need to pay 20% of your gross wage like they do and the employers another 20% on top of that. So Germans pay for their system, like we do, they just pay more for it. You are quite right though, people are going to struggle to pay more for any type of system, when absolutely everything else people need to pay for, has shot up in price.

SmokeyPaprika · 01/01/2023 11:45

There’s a lot of cash in hand work going on ime. It’s not the super wealthy but if every other builder or plumber does it mounts up. Also subletting hA property.

it costs money to check these things so they don’t get done.

Alexandra2001 · 01/01/2023 11:05

Well, we've been swallowing that line for decades now and its wearing thin.
You can't move property and where are these lower tax regimes that they wouldn't already be using?

CGT in UK is significantly lower than Italy France Germany and Spain & they already charge tax on investment income.......

As for moving, there isn't any really evidence for that, sure you'll get rock stars and F1 drivers but they already live abroad and its not just for tax but live style.

Are you really saying that we can't close loopholes? but other countries can?

DomesticShortHair · 01/01/2023 10:55

Alexandra2001 · 01/01/2023 10:46

Tax is already quite high for low to middle earners... can't come from them.

imho UK is going to have to look at a wealth tax on assets and on higher taxes on the wealthy, 177 billionaires and 2.4m millionaires, tax investment income as "income"..... increase CGT to match income tax rates?

We also need to hold to account people like Sunak who said we'd be better off outside of the EU... i.e a 12billion annual saving and better trading opportunities... points based immigration system (to make up for loss of EU workers).... where has all this gone?

Combine above with looking again at how NHS spends money.

Quite frankly, there is no alternative.... well, there is.... people die needlessly waiting for treatment and thats us.. ordinary folk.., not the wealthy or the political elite.. they wont want for anything.

The trouble is, those millionaires and billionaires aren’t going to take too kindly to paying the kinds of additional taxes that you’re talking about. So the majority will either avoid it, seeing as they can pay some very clever specialist people to do so, or just move their liability to a lower tax regime, and we’ll lose out in even more income, making the whole situation worse.

The reason they squeezed middle is the squeezed middle is not just that they are the easiest option for Chancellors of the Exchequer to increase the tax gain. For the vast majority of the time, they are the only real option. Except that sponge is wrung dry at the moment, and for the foreseeable future.

Alexandra2001 · 01/01/2023 10:46

DomesticShortHair · 01/01/2023 10:02

I’m not saying I don't agree, but it’s the same cyclic argument. To increase spending, where the money is going to come from- a look around this site alone will show just how many are struggling to keep their heads just above water as it is. Even with the political will to do so, there’s no more significant. taxes to be squeezed, in the short-to-medium term at least. What are your thoughts/ideas for this additional funding?

Tax is already quite high for low to middle earners... can't come from them.

imho UK is going to have to look at a wealth tax on assets and on higher taxes on the wealthy, 177 billionaires and 2.4m millionaires, tax investment income as "income"..... increase CGT to match income tax rates?

We also need to hold to account people like Sunak who said we'd be better off outside of the EU... i.e a 12billion annual saving and better trading opportunities... points based immigration system (to make up for loss of EU workers).... where has all this gone?

Combine above with looking again at how NHS spends money.

Quite frankly, there is no alternative.... well, there is.... people die needlessly waiting for treatment and thats us.. ordinary folk.., not the wealthy or the political elite.. they wont want for anything.

Chippy1234 · 01/01/2023 10:17

I was going to make a formal complaint about the staff’s attitude and I am sure some on this thread will say they are burnt out but what if we all behaved liked this, waiters, shop staff etc. Both of which I have been over the years.

The junior doctor was particularly obnoxious especially as it was an End Of Life situation along with the young ward doctor when he was finally moved. Both looked very young (compared to me!) and their attitude was appalling. The consultant I eventually spoke to was much much better.

In the end I decided to just put it down as an awful experience

Chippy1234 · 01/01/2023 10:10

With regard to funding. People generally mean that others should pay. I have seen Amazon, Bill Gates, Musk etc being the people who fund it! If they really don’t believe that Amazon pay enough tax then don’t buy from them. If tax is increased for them then you do know it’s US who will be funding it. As for Bill Gates et al. He is American….

DomesticShortHair · 01/01/2023 10:02

BirmaBrite · 31/12/2022 20:56

We do need to spend more on healthcare, Germany and France spend over 12% of GDP on theirs compared to our 7.8% pre pandemic in 2019, obviously there has been a jump during the pandemic years in the UK, but a lot of that will have been spent on pandemic associated healthcare.

The German system does seem very thorough and looks after people well.

www.howtogermany.com/pages/working.html

I’m not saying I don't agree, but it’s the same cyclic argument. To increase spending, where the money is going to come from- a look around this site alone will show just how many are struggling to keep their heads just above water as it is. Even with the political will to do so, there’s no more significant. taxes to be squeezed, in the short-to-medium term at least. What are your thoughts/ideas for this additional funding?

Chippy1234 · 01/01/2023 09:52

I sadly lost a close family member a few weeks ago so spent a lot of time at the hospital and the majority of the time in A and E. because there were no beds. They didn’t think he would last the night (but he did!).

The staff weren’t great and I ignored the surly almost rude attitude of the nurses and a particular junior doctor but as an observer the people waiting in A and E were a real mixed bag. Whole families cluttering up the waiting area. A middle aged chap demanding a tea because he was ‘parched’. There was a family in the corner playing cards and a guy shouting that he had waited 3 hours and others were being seen before him. Someone else kicking off that they shouldn’t have to pay for parking. It was truly awful. The only people who were ok were the old people who had clearly fallen and were just accepting of the wait time.

I also heard someone saying that you should always call an ambulance because then you were seen quicker and bypassed the queue.

Its not just the staff - it’s us too…

We need to look at a German/French system urgently. As a supplier to the NHS for many many years they job protect massively. Jobs on top of jobs and each Trust doing things differently.

SmokeyPaprika · 01/01/2023 09:45

This goes back to my HRT quote, many women are unhappy at going through the menopause, and it is very hard to separate what the medical profession is able to achieve.

I might have agreed with this once but since having been prescribed medication to block estrogen (post cancer treatment) the side effects were dire. Severe anxiety, depression and no ability to concentrate and a downward spiral as each side effect exacerbated the other, HRT needs more attention by GPs imv.

Menora · 01/01/2023 08:09

iloveeverykindofcat · 01/01/2023 06:33

@Helplesstohelp22

GPs are inundated with requests for secondary care assessment of patients who think they have adult ADHD, mild anxiety, mild depression (but have a job, family, hobbies etc. and are functioning even if they are unhappy).

This is an issue related to defining the NHS remit. Mental illness is real, but not everything is mental illness. Being unhappy or unsatisfied with your life is not mental illness. Being anxious - but functional - during a period of massive economic and ecological turmoil is not an illness. Its normal. I read a quotation from a GP in an Independent (I think) article recently talking about the large number of people who make a doctors appointment not because they're ill but because they're unhappy. "These people used to go to their priest - now they come to me".

This is so absolutely true.

However there are some working solutions being put in place for this with primary care mental health workers under the ARR scheme, along with social prescribers. Reception staff should be trained as care navigators to be able to confidently direct people along to other services but it’s often hard to unpick these issues. As part of my role I have tried to tackle frequent attenders by navigating them to more appropriate services, one lady was coming weekly to complain about her finances, what is a GP going to do to help with that? Some people want ‘things on record’ later down the line for legal claims so will spend time building a medical case for themselves with their GP.

This goes back to my HRT quote, many women are unhappy at going through the menopause, and it is very hard to separate what the medical profession is able to achieve.

Alexandra2001 · 01/01/2023 08:06

BirmaBrite · 31/12/2022 20:56

We do need to spend more on healthcare, Germany and France spend over 12% of GDP on theirs compared to our 7.8% pre pandemic in 2019, obviously there has been a jump during the pandemic years in the UK, but a lot of that will have been spent on pandemic associated healthcare.

The German system does seem very thorough and looks after people well.

www.howtogermany.com/pages/working.html

Yes the point on lower funding seems to go over the heads of those who keep saying the "NHS is broken, can't be fixed"

Apart from the Blair years, we have consistently paid less than EU countries for healthcare for decades.

No other EU country forces nurses and AHPs to go into around 45k of debt either.

iloveeverykindofcat · 01/01/2023 06:33

@Helplesstohelp22

GPs are inundated with requests for secondary care assessment of patients who think they have adult ADHD, mild anxiety, mild depression (but have a job, family, hobbies etc. and are functioning even if they are unhappy).

This is an issue related to defining the NHS remit. Mental illness is real, but not everything is mental illness. Being unhappy or unsatisfied with your life is not mental illness. Being anxious - but functional - during a period of massive economic and ecological turmoil is not an illness. Its normal. I read a quotation from a GP in an Independent (I think) article recently talking about the large number of people who make a doctors appointment not because they're ill but because they're unhappy. "These people used to go to their priest - now they come to me".

AllLopsided · 01/01/2023 00:19

I don't work in the NHS and in fact I'm treated abroad. I pay about £850 a month for health insurance. I get a pretty decent service for that. But:
It doesn't cover all the treatment I need. And
It still took 6 years for a full diagnosis and treatment of endometriosis;
I have an injury that hasn't healed but apparently is untreatable, so I am in pain management, including IVF infusions which are expensive;
I had a surgery where the surgeon screwed up. Ranks were closed, another surgeon corrected it, my insurance paid;
Important drugs are currently out of stock and there is no pressure from the government on the drug companies to get their acts together. I have been fobbed off with a generic painkiller that only costs 10% less but doesn't work properly (the slow release mechanism isn't the same). Luckily my doctors understand the problem and have adjusted my dose.
So even expensive private systems still fail the patients. However I think a European model like France or Germany would work better than the NHS but the restructuring would be very expensive. Also in France there are still areas where it's very difficult to get a GP, or indeed any treatment, because it's a big country and some areas (even densely populated ones, lack doctors and medical facilities.
I would actually happily accept euthanasia now, because my life is so limited, but it's not given for chronic pain.

Fifi00 · 31/12/2022 21:32

Helplesstohelp22 · 31/12/2022 12:41

Also re: mental health services. 2 members of staff on a local ward were violently attacked by the same patient who suffers from what consultants have described as an incurable personality disorder, one stuff member being pregnant. This individual is barely an adult. Services will have to care for them until they die because there is nothing fixable. How many others will get hurt?

Morale is rock bottom because staff are being left to cope with these patients without safe nursing numbers to do so and people are getting hurt.

Severe PD are more common because people are living in dysfunctional families, often in poverty and born to parents with their own untreated mental health issues, and social support is just not available before things get severe.

Could you care for as many as five young women on a ward covered in self harm scars from ankle to face who will ligature if a single member of staff turns their back for a moment? It is like a horror film.

That is the reality of mental health services now.

I left a hospital because they kept moving me to female PD service I have PTSD from all the ligatures , headbanging one even disemboweled themselves on leave with a knife. They are disfigured and so young. it was honestly horrendous much easier looking after hardened criminal men in secure services. I'm now in organics , brain injury and loving life.