Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
Soothsayer1 · 04/01/2023 11:57

I can't help but feel that staff shortages in the NHS are partly to do with the changing role of women in society. Previously it was common for men to be the main earner and that meant that woman's wages could be regarded as pin money at worst or secondary at best. Furthermore the greater part of unpaid caring work in our society was done by women, this further cements the implicit idea that it's normal for women to work for little or no money.
Now we have a situation where it's not uncommon for the woman to be the breadwinner, the main earner, women, seeing that good well-paid jobs are within their reach, are much less willing to do difficult stressful work for low pay. If women are increasingly assuming a breadwinner role within the family they are no longer available to do the unpaid care in work furthermore the unpaid caring work is often too onerous or difficult to be done at home anyway because the elderly living much longer and with much more complex health needs.
I feel that going forward it will be much more difficult to recruit anyone to work in healthcare partly because it was previously propped up by women who had no choice but to be exploited but are no longer prepared to put up with that, and they don't have to, they can vote with their feet and get a better job somewhere else!

TheComptonEffect · 04/01/2023 11:08

Unless they are trained abroad though, any medics, nurses or AHPs will have used NHS resources in their training. There is no other route to qualification in the UK. As a Practice Educator myself it is beyond demoralising that few of NHS trained staff stay not only within our board but also the country or the NHS.

RethinkingLife · 02/01/2023 00:31

billysboy · 01/01/2023 20:54

But they have kicked that idea around for years ! Fiddling whilst Rome burns

I agree PAH is on its knees despite some fab people that work there

I have family friends in Harlow. Your posts are in line with what they've been saying although I hadn't heard about the new triage service to a GP from A&E. Is the hall on the PAH compound or nearby?

MajesticWhine · 01/01/2023 23:26

Would love not to use agency staff but we can't recruit enough permanent staff nor do we have any staff that want extra bank shifts. We have excess cash in the budget and huge waiting lists so of course we use agency.
I agree about the sick pay being too generous. This causes a lot of problems.

RethinkingLife · 01/01/2023 23:25

we can’t expect Scandinavian health services on a basic rate of 20% and nic of 12%.

I'm not knowledgeable about VAT (or its equivalent) in other countries. Does VAT not make a substantial tax contribution in the UK?

Climatic123 · 01/01/2023 21:15

I’m sorry but I’ll but in here and say you’re wrong. As any economist with a knowledge of European tax systems will tell you, the UK is a bit of an outlier in having such a low basic tax rate (see this for instance: ifs.org.uk/taxlab/taxlab-key-questions/how-do-uk-tax-revenues-compare-internationally). It’s an inconvenient truth but we can’t expect Scandinavian health services on a basic rate of 20% and nic of 12%. If you want better services everyone across the board has to pay, and the best way to do that is to increase the basic rate of tax significantly. Only then do we start generating meaningful amounts. Does any political party have the backbone to do this? I don’t think so. They’d rather protect us from the truth and make promises using magic money trees. And yes and everyone needs to stop dealing with businesses that they suspect are dodging their taxes.

But away from the economics and back to the interesting arguments from the medical profession please.

OutOfTheFog9 · 01/01/2023 21:14

'Also re: mental health services. 2 members of staff on a local ward were violently attacked by the same patient who suffers from what consultants have described as an incurable personality disorder, one stuff member being pregnant. This individual is barely an adult. Services will have to care for them until they die because there is nothing fixable. How many others will get hurt?'

@Helplesstohelp22 people forget that the NHS as an employer has a duty of care towards their staff as well as the patients. If there were risk indicators the pregnant staff member should not have been working with this individual in the first place. Staff shortages?

It's heartbreaking, but I understand staff moving on to work elsewhere.

billysboy · 01/01/2023 20:54

Menora · 01/01/2023 20:43

They are building a new hospital at the new M11 junction at some point

PAH is on its knees

But they have kicked that idea around for years ! Fiddling whilst Rome burns

I agree PAH is on its knees despite some fab people that work there

Snowmoab · 01/01/2023 20:49

CharlotteStreetW1 · 01/01/2023 20:31

Bring back convalescent homes.

Introduce private sector sickness policies. Six months on full pay is obscene (not just NHS) and open to abuse which leads me on to...

Get rid of agency staffing. Use bank staff instead.

I don't believe in euthanasia at all but I don't believe in keeping someone alive who has no quality of life. Let them go (naturally).

Finally, get rid of the tories.

Yes making the sickness policy worse will help with the huge retention issue the NHS has. Also agency shifts exist because there are no staff willing to do them for regular pay or for bank rates. Sure if they abolished agency shifts a small percentage might pick them up on the bank but trusts have been cutting back for years and it never works out well.

Alexandra2001 · 01/01/2023 20:46

Introduce private sector sickness policies. Six months on full pay is obscene (not just NHS) and open to abuse which leads me on to...

NHS staff can't come into work like you or me could, us spread a cough or cold around the office all ok but that would kill half the patients on my DD wards, she has been on her rotation for 5 months, had 3 weeks off, 2 lots of Covid and a bout of noro, another got hit in the face, been off for a month or so.

Do you think they should be punished financially for this? .... and how would that aid recruitment?

Aside, most of the private companies i worked for had 6months full pay, it was still subject to HR review if you had more than 3 lots of sickness off in a year.
It was to help employees like my friend whose partner was murdered and another who got cancer.

RethinkingLife · 01/01/2023 20:45

Bring back convalescent homes.

For whom? For what length of stay? Convalescence implies a trajectory towards rehab and improved health. So it wouldn't seem to cover some very senior people or those with multimorbidities and long-term conditions.

Do you intend them to be for people living alone who can't have adequate social care packages?

I'm asking because I don't know very little about them and didn't grow up with people using them or cottage hospitals.

Menora · 01/01/2023 20:43

billysboy · 01/01/2023 12:30

a good thing I saw recently at Harlow An E was at the triage they had the ability to send you over to a GP based across the ( new fancy pants ) hall rather than admit you to A n E for eg a twisted ankle or minor injury

Harlow hospital itself just wants bull dozing selling to the highest bidder to build houses etc and use the proceeds to build a brand new hospital just outside the town

It just seems a bottomless pit the NHS , it is beyond me we pay train drivers what we do and Nurses that we all clapped for a pittance in comparison

Social care is a whole other issue on its own but one that cannot be ignored

They are building a new hospital at the new M11 junction at some point

PAH is on its knees

Keskadale · 01/01/2023 20:39

rwalker · 01/01/2023 20:15

Yes as I said he pays about half of his income
What % of there income do you think they should pay isn’t 50% enough for u

He said..... but its Unlikely, i 'm good friends with a large ground works owner, he is a multi millionaire, worked his way up from digging trenches, lovely couple.

He pays jack in taxes, all legal.

I also used to live near a former football manager, ex premiership, he once told me at one of his neighbourhood garden parties, that his tax bill is about what i earn in a year, he owned 20 plus properties (all high end) and in one year (after promotion) boosted of earning more in one year than i'd see in a life time,
Nice enough bloke but this idea they pay anything like in proportion to the rest of us is laughable.

CharlotteStreetW1 · 01/01/2023 20:31

Bring back convalescent homes.

Introduce private sector sickness policies. Six months on full pay is obscene (not just NHS) and open to abuse which leads me on to...

Get rid of agency staffing. Use bank staff instead.

I don't believe in euthanasia at all but I don't believe in keeping someone alive who has no quality of life. Let them go (naturally).

Finally, get rid of the tories.

rwalker · 01/01/2023 20:15

Soothsayer1 · 01/01/2023 17:38

pays an astronomical amount of tax .there child privately educated they have private health care they literally contribute but take hardly anything out of they system
all his employees have been educated by taxpayer money, he benefits from the fact we have a police force, roads, healthcare so that his employees dont die of minor illnesses. Of course the wealthy benefit from the system @rwalker
He earns what he does in part because of the publicly funded infrastructure which supports his business.
None of us is an island @rwalker

Yes as I said he pays about half of his income
What % of there income do you think they should pay isn’t 50% enough for u

user1497207191 · 01/01/2023 20:03

@Postapocalypticcowgirl

Joining up social care and the NHS surely only makes sense

They'd have to "join up" the NHS itself first. It's horrendously fragmented and dysfunctional with huge numbers of different trusts, the artificial internal market, etc.

Soothsayer1 · 01/01/2023 17:38

pays an astronomical amount of tax .there child privately educated they have private health care they literally contribute but take hardly anything out of they system
all his employees have been educated by taxpayer money, he benefits from the fact we have a police force, roads, healthcare so that his employees dont die of minor illnesses. Of course the wealthy benefit from the system @rwalker
He earns what he does in part because of the publicly funded infrastructure which supports his business.
None of us is an island @rwalker

Ihavedogs · 01/01/2023 17:02

I do also think that pensioners who are asset rich shouldn't get everything given to them for free, paid for by many who will never own a home. I know ultimately they can be made to sell homes to pay for care, but it seems like a long road to get to that point. I know people will say they worked hard all their lives etc etc, but honestly, both my grandmothers were housewives after they had children- they gave up work younger than I am now, and never really returned to it. Their husbands were not that wealthy, either.

The majority of women who have retired more recently or are due to retire in future years will have worked for most of their lives. How will owning a home allow someone to say pay for prescriptions or a bus pass which is about all that pensioners get for ‘free’ unless they are on benefits (note that prescriptions are currently free from 60 and state pension age is currently 66/67? Are you suggesting that people have to release equity from their homes?

Should the same apply to younger disabled people? Should children have to pay for their prescriptions?

That sort of approach will do nothing to sort of the current NHS and social care issues and in fact could make matters worse due to people not taking the medication they need to keep them as healthy as possible and then requiring greater intervention.

Keskadale · 01/01/2023 16:10

@Postapocalypticcowgirl No they wouldn't, people vote for parties that promise lower taxation AND austerity.

@snowsilver the NHS is politics, it was formed under a Labour Govt and opposed by the Tory one.

Both main parties have fundamentally different views on the NHS, this cannot be papered over, no matter how we wish it were different.
Probably why we have such a poor health service compared to European counttries.

15 years ago, we did not have 200people a week dying in the back of ambulances or at home waiting for medical help or 7m on waiting lists, we've had 13 years of the tories, so yes there is blame.

snowsilver · 01/01/2023 16:04

This thread started off well with some excellent and insightful suggestions. It's been diverted into the usual political arguments.
Most threads on the NHS descend into blame. We can all fling blame around but that doesn't solve anything.
We need cross party willingness to construct a long term plan. Without that no party will risk votes and look forward more than 4 years.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 01/01/2023 15:55

If people were given a choice between paying a bit more tax for decent public services, and the amount we'd have to contribute for private healthcare, I think most would choose the former. But the Tories would prefer the latter, because it helps them get rich.

I do also think that pensioners who are asset rich shouldn't get everything given to them for free, paid for by many who will never own a home. I know ultimately they can be made to sell homes to pay for care, but it seems like a long road to get to that point. I know people will say they worked hard all their lives etc etc, but honestly, both my grandmothers were housewives after they had children- they gave up work younger than I am now, and never really returned to it. Their husbands were not that wealthy, either.

Joining up social care and the NHS surely only makes sense- you would then, presumably, get joined up thinking to allow people to return home in stages, rather than bed blocking, with the knock on impacts that has.

But anyway, austerity, austerity and more austerity is not the answer.

rwalker · 01/01/2023 15:38

Soothsayer1 · 01/01/2023 13:28

As I said, he hasn't broken any laws because laws are setup to favour the rich.
You said that he is self made? Who did all the work that he profited from?
I'm not saying he hasn't worked hard but most of the hard work is done by the people who work for him, he didn't lay every brick himself.
Only fools and horses work.

Wow
he’s very hands on worked and worked . Pays staff well as they stay loyal and people queuing up to work for his company

pays an astronomical amount of tax .there child privately educated they have private health care they literally contribute but take hardly anything out of they system
what more would you expect people like him to do .
between top rate tax and ni contribution he’ll be already give us just under 1/2 of what he earns

Alexandra2001 · 01/01/2023 14:11

@Pianofar

Where will you get the staff from for these desirable outcomes?

The UK has worse labour shortages than almost any other European country.

Alexandra2001 · 01/01/2023 14:09

@user1497207191

Yes there is, all you have to do is txfer your investment income into a ISA (20k p.a pp) you can then draw it out tax free.

CGT is still UK - 20%, in France 34% Germany 27%.

The reason the wealthy pay more tax as a % is because the rest of us earn so little, which has benefited the wealthy, as i ve shown with the increases in millionaires.

What you ve not addressed is the alternative, which is either no NHS or a failed NHS.

Tickledtrout · 01/01/2023 13:46

Pianofar · 29/12/2022 23:02

For me there's a myriad of many things, but the main ones:

Reopen community hospitals, minor injury units (and staff them 24/7), and go back to holding clinics in the community.

In addition to ambulances as we know them, reintroduce adequately staffed and suitable vehicles to safely assess and if necessary transport those who have had falls, mental health ambulances, and invest more in training for call handlers to more effectively triage calls. Also an education piece to the public.

Improve staff retention, pay isn't the only way but is a key way and the easiest start point. The nhs is nothing without its staff- you can have the fanciest equipment and tonnes of beds but it's useless without appropriately trained staff. There are tonnes of other things that would need to be done but that's probably another thread.

Government invest in social care to avoid people being 'stuck' in hospital. Also invest in societal things that affect health.

Good start. I'd add walk in centres and cottage hospitals for recuperation to community hospitals.
And self referral to in person counselling - not everyone wants online. People need a human connection

Swipe left for the next trending thread