Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
BorisisaLune · 05/03/2023 12:46

RosesAndHellebores · 05/03/2023 12:34

Point taken @BorisisaLune but the local trust is defending local allegations that asking for the money back puts stress on staff who have received non contractual.payments and pocketed it. The Trust shoukd be focusing on internal incompetence and negligence and external dishonesty. I run a large HR Department and along with other staff I would be dismissed for this level of negligence.

Indefensible isn't it.

BorisisaLune · 05/03/2023 12:45

@JMSA

People are going on disciplinaries at our trust for getting covid twice and then a bout of flu !!! it was 20 days in total inside 6 months, the person i know who this has happened too is now leaving the NHS, she was happy before this, how stupid.

Say if an specialist ICU nurse broke her hip and had 6 months signed off, do you think she should be fired?

Considering the exposure to disease & being attacked, i'm not against the NHS sickness policy, making it tougher would just piss off staff and make retention harder.

Bigger fish to fry with the NHS.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/03/2023 12:34

Point taken @BorisisaLune but the local trust is defending local allegations that asking for the money back puts stress on staff who have received non contractual.payments and pocketed it. The Trust shoukd be focusing on internal incompetence and negligence and external dishonesty. I run a large HR Department and along with other staff I would be dismissed for this level of negligence.

JMSA · 05/03/2023 12:31

A close friend of mine was in the ambulance service (not a paramedic). She said that in order to get fired from the NHS, you'd probably have to kill someone! There's too much dead wood. 6 month sickness leaves are fairly common.

BorisisaLune · 05/03/2023 12:28

Anothermother3 · 05/03/2023 09:48

They do still recruit from developing countries but less brazenly (think agencies attending uni classes a few decades ago to get new graduates to come over). The thing is that while I get that there is not an infinite supply of people what has been done is mass down grading of posts so they’ve scrapped staff at the lower levels or just upped the level of responsibility for lower banded staff. There aren’t infinite people appropriate for health care but if you could make the assistant posts worthwhile to support the more senior posts and give a level of responsibility appropriate to the pay band it would go some way to making things more sustainable and make people want to be HCPs and work in health. I know it’s not simple but that’s got to help. Same as education a teacher with enough support staff in a class where extra Ta support is needed is going to be more likely to remain in post. Surely some of that is possible?

Yes we can tinker around the edges and address retention levels but fundamentally, we have so few HCPs per head of population, i think its about 1/2 that of Germany and France.
Make the rolls more attractive? get more people in, just leaves other sectors short of people, students who can get 2 or 3 A levels are not normally short of career options.

On waste @RosesAndHellebores even if there were non, it doesn't get us more people & yes some management is dire in the NHS, lets face it, if Matt Hancock is the solution, just how bad is the problem?

Anothermother3 · 05/03/2023 09:48

They do still recruit from developing countries but less brazenly (think agencies attending uni classes a few decades ago to get new graduates to come over). The thing is that while I get that there is not an infinite supply of people what has been done is mass down grading of posts so they’ve scrapped staff at the lower levels or just upped the level of responsibility for lower banded staff. There aren’t infinite people appropriate for health care but if you could make the assistant posts worthwhile to support the more senior posts and give a level of responsibility appropriate to the pay band it would go some way to making things more sustainable and make people want to be HCPs and work in health. I know it’s not simple but that’s got to help. Same as education a teacher with enough support staff in a class where extra Ta support is needed is going to be more likely to remain in post. Surely some of that is possible?

Lucy7890 · 05/03/2023 09:46

As long as NHS is used as a political pawn, I expect little will change.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/03/2023 09:15

It's poor management. My local hospital with an inadequate A&E that there are campaigns to save, announced on Friday that is has lost £2 million because it failed to take people off payroll when they left. Almost a million is unaccounted for due to no forwarding contact details. The other million is on repayment plans with a team now hired to administer the fiasco.

It could only happen in the NHS. It is about my money being pissed up the wall.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 05/03/2023 08:25

Big fat yes to an earlier post in getting rid of the internal market, which can be done for free.

I know of patients who spend weeks and months extra in a £2k per week specialist bed, because a different commissioner doesn't want them in a bed a third of the cost because it comes out of that second commissioner's budget. Madness. Wouldn't need any more commissioning staff, just better inter agency working.

CurlyTop1980 · 05/03/2023 08:11

I'm not an NHS worker but I do work in social care. One of the problems with social care is due to cost cutting they got rid of community hubs and made mega adult social care departments across 2 or 3 local authorities. You lose the personal touch. I think with health local GP/community clinics with adult social care based in these would make a lot more sense.

BorisisaLune · 05/03/2023 08:02

@Anothermother3 As far as i can tell, it wouldn't matter if you paid HCP 100k per year, there is a finite number of people suitable and able to be HCPs, all you'd do is take workers from other sectors, leaving these areas short of staff.

We simply do not have enough people in the UK to do the work we currently need doing, if we improved productivity, that might free up workers?

NHS still recruit from developing countries.

Anothermother3 · 04/03/2023 21:38

@BorisisaLune well exactly the point and why you can’t fix one area at a time. Currently a lot of foreign staff are already a big part of things - never mind the countries they come from - they used to come and do the targeted recruitment but that’s now frowned upon. It’s cyclical and if work conditions don’t improve then it’s a downward spiral. More investment in education and the grants that used to make it more possible to study health care roles and end up with a career in health care - so many in health care don’t want to promote it to their own families at the moment which is really sad. I don’t know 😢 I’m one of many who weren’t educated in the UK.

BorisisaLune · 04/03/2023 21:25

@Anothermother3 ..and where will you get these potential degree level students from?
Or the 250k extra social care staff?

Anothermother3 · 04/03/2023 20:56

More staff and keep training to a high level and make sure people at the top actually understand what is needed at a ground service level. Also can’t work unless other services are equally well resourced - social care/housing especially. All the early years support. Education. I get overwhelmed just thinking about it as I don’t know how to manage things. Having people at the top of the pyramid that understand things and care about society as a whole would help (thinking government here).

taxguru · 04/03/2023 19:10

@BorisisaLune

The problem is that the NHS cannot give you that scan because they have a constant stream of people in more urgent need than you.

AND poor admin meaning scarce scan slots are wasted. My OH has needed several MRI scans for his bone marrow cancer over the years. Very rarely have they done it on first appointment. That has been a variety of reasons. Once he turned up and the referral/scan request was apparently "unclear" and the radiographer couldn't contact his consultant so didn't do the scan. Another time, he turned up and they had him down as for a "tracer" injection which he told them he couldn't have (his consultant knew he couldn't have it as it was discussed at the consultation!), so instead of the radiographer doing it without the tracer, they refused to do it - that was an admin balls up by either the oncology admin doing the referral or the scanner admin ticking the wrong box on their day sheet! Another time he turned up at the hospital per his appointment letter, only to be told he should have been at the other hospital 25 miles away!

Until they sort out the shambolic admin, there's really no way to "fix it".

Moreorlessmentallystable · 04/03/2023 14:57

I think like in all organisations the solutions would come from listening to employees at the "bottom" those who are actually doing the jobs that are in contact with the patients, those who know how stuff works (or doesn't), sadly, changes in big organisations are always driven by the top instead of the bottom and a lot of the budget goes in paying those at the top too, as well as on "vanity projects" that sound/look good on paper but don't necessarily improve how the organisation works.

BorisisaLune · 04/03/2023 07:19

Kennykenkencat · 04/03/2023 05:06

After a back injury I thought I would get an
mri which would have cost £300 to find out what was wrong.

However in order to save the £300 they spent over £250,000 over 7 years on me. Not forgetting the sickness benefit I got because I couldn’t walk never mind work and was in so much pain. 7 years of being in agony, 7 years of being shouted at as I wasn’t improving. 7 years where it was decided that I needed a new hip and I couldn’t get one till I was 60. 7 years where I couldn’t work, couldn’t sleep.

I was in so much pain that It very nearly cost me my life.

So the NHS’s
attempt at saving money ended up costing them £249,700
As a minimum.

I know I am not the only one this type of thing has happened to.
Multiply that figure by 1000s and then you see where the money is going.

The problem is that the NHS cannot give you that scan because they have a constant stream of people in more urgent need than you.
The UK has some of the lowest number of scans per capita of any European country and of course, we don't have so many radiographers either.

The NHS is run by people who don't know what they doing, from Govt to Trust leaders, the lack of staff is symptomatic of this, they have the money but do not spend it wisely, esp on training/equipment and most importantly, retention - see below:

Someone i know, a skilled HCP, has had 2 bouts of Covid and flu, yesterday she had her meeting with HR to discuss her sick record and is on a disciplinary measure for the next 6 months, no other absences - and they wonder why staff leave, which is what i ve advised her to do -

A decent private sector company would have the flexibility to work around a sickness policy that is designed to pick up a pattern of absence not punish people who get work related illness.

Virginiaplain · 04/03/2023 07:11

If you employ empathetic touchy feely people to be doctors - where do you get the geeky nerds who stare at xray screens all day. There's a constant shortage.

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 04/03/2023 05:25

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:21

Why can’t the NHS email appointments?
Instead of posting letters , which are a waste of the price of postage / admin staff / secretary / paper etc.
it’s a huge bugbear of mine , letter is posted out , can’t attend , have to physically call to reschedule , waste of time having to speak to appointment secretary etc. It’s SO antiquated

Currently with our current IT technology emailing patients is a far more long winded time consuming process. We book an appointment which generates a letter automatically to the patients address, it gets printed, put in envelope then sent. To email a patient the letter gets printed we have to find said letter from massive pile of other letters, scan on, pdf, then email then hope that the email doesn’t bounce back as people rarely get their addresses wrong but emails are often incorrect or changed. Then you as lowly admin staff are constantly bombared with emails about everything to do with the nhs as the patient now has your email address. I have had emails back asking what bus would get them to their appointment on time.

Kennykenkencat · 04/03/2023 05:06

After a back injury I thought I would get an
mri which would have cost £300 to find out what was wrong.

However in order to save the £300 they spent over £250,000 over 7 years on me. Not forgetting the sickness benefit I got because I couldn’t walk never mind work and was in so much pain. 7 years of being in agony, 7 years of being shouted at as I wasn’t improving. 7 years where it was decided that I needed a new hip and I couldn’t get one till I was 60. 7 years where I couldn’t work, couldn’t sleep.

I was in so much pain that It very nearly cost me my life.

So the NHS’s
attempt at saving money ended up costing them £249,700
As a minimum.

I know I am not the only one this type of thing has happened to.
Multiply that figure by 1000s and then you see where the money is going.

Kennykenkencat · 04/03/2023 05:02

For me I don’t think the nhs needs any more money it just has to stop wasting it
on trying to save money.

grapesandpears · 04/01/2023 16:40

I think, judging from Sunaks speech, he think that he has it:

Sunak said he was confident things would improve within months and asked the country to hold him to account

In other words, bring in more private sector providers.

Another way to make great strides would be to tax more for the NHS and also to raise pay for social care. And to bring at least a modicum of private care provision into the public sector, eliminating the profit motive. Not that this could happen, because it doesn't fit the prevailing philosophy-from either side.

RethinkingLife · 04/01/2023 14:27

grapesandpears · 04/01/2023 14:21

If I were a Tory politician, I would aim to train more young people to gain maths (and science) A levels, so that I'd ensure a steady stream of medical students prepared to be exploited!

I went out for lunch today, and listening around the restaurant, all sorts of people are outraged at the way the nhs has been failed.

Isn't it unthinkably and remarkably grim that even with all of this genuine concern, we all seem stymied at a way to make an effective protest and demand some progress?

grapesandpears · 04/01/2023 14:21

If I were a Tory politician, I would aim to train more young people to gain maths (and science) A levels, so that I'd ensure a steady stream of medical students prepared to be exploited!

I went out for lunch today, and listening around the restaurant, all sorts of people are outraged at the way the nhs has been failed.

RosesAndHellebores · 04/01/2023 12:49

The complaints are always about money and lack of funding. However one recent NHS experience.

  1. Failure to diagnose a fractured T12 despite it showing on Xray. F2 confirming to me that it was not broken.
  2. 6 month delay arose re referral back to rheumatologist whom I was under already due to severe osteoporosis and having zolendronate.
  3. GP refused initially to help re another broken bone - refused further referral, refused physio, refused to accept that T12 was newly broken.
  4. T12 confirmed privately
  5. Referred back to rheumatology.
  6. Saw rheumatologist 10 months after the break. 1.45 minute delay in clinic. No apology, no reason.
  7. Rheumatologist recommended teriparitide. Not covered by NHS so I am paying £2400 for the two year course.
  8. Rheumatologist office and I cancelled the next zolendronate appointment.
  9. Infusion dept phone to tell me to go for bloods before infusion - explain treatment has been changed and I have cancelled the appointment.
10. Infusion dept phone me again and very very slowly explain that I can't have zolendronate and teriparatide. 11. Clearly nobody reads the notes. 12 . Attend appoint yesterday at 11.45. There was a 1.45 hour delay again. No apology, no explanation no attempt to call me in advance. 13. Appointment rescheduled for 28.2 at 9.15. 14. I wasted 2 hours yesterday. I work full time. There is never a calculation for the cost to employers and patients for the time wasting and mismanagement. I am sure these costs double the GDP contribution. 15. Delays in clinics are normalised and have been for my entire 62 years regardless of which government is in power.

I do not understand how giving more resources would prevent the sort of shambles above. The issues arise through mismanagement and because there is zero respect for the time of the patient and nobody, not one individual in the NHS has ever accepted that patient or taxpayer time is as important as that of those in the NHS.