Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
antipodeancanary · 29/12/2022 23:52

123woop · 29/12/2022 23:46

So as someone who knows a lot of people who work for the NHS at various levels, the thing that's struck me is the amount of "middle management" or "behind the scenes" people who are paid staggering amounts of money, when that money imho would be much better going to doctors and nurses and the people "on the frontline", I guess you'd say.
To give a recent well publicised example, the "director of lived experience" role for NHS midlands who earns £115,000 a year, but I know quite a few people who work for the NHS in a "consultancy" style role (not medical consultancy but HR for eg) who earn THOUSANDS, and as it's not a private business it goes unquestioned. They're just ones I know - it infuriates my doctor and nurse friends who know of many more examples.

I think that if the NHS is relying on well meaning people to allow themselves to be exploited because "long reign the NHS", then it's a failing business model.

That's before you get into the nitty gritty of how it's actually run day to day on the ground....

Apparently only 2% oh NHS monies goes on management, which is much less than the private sector. Getting rid of a manager who costs 100k a year would pay for two months care, if that, for one of my patients. It's an absolute drop in the ocean

Itsbiasedhere · 29/12/2022 23:51

antipodeancanary · 29/12/2022 23:46

I think the NHS needs to do much much less and do it well.
Some conditions are so expensive to manage that we should probably stop. I absolutely love my patients but some require two to one or even three to one care at all times. Its not sustainable.
We should look at quality of life towards the end of life much more actively. People should be allowed to die more easily. No pegs, no dysphagia assessments in end of life, generally speaking.
Yes to voluntary assisted euthanasia. No one should be alive five years after they stopped recognising family members.
No fertility treatment. No cosmetic surgery. No breast reconstruction, no gender realignment surgery. No gastric bands, no acne treatments.
I know people benefit from all those things, but when we have people who haven't been able to see a gp since before covid, are waiting in agony for two years for a hip replacement, who are dying aged 40 from colon cancer that was diagnosed too late and people refuse to pay more tax, then we have tough decisions to make.
I don't actually see a lot of waste in the NHS, but I do see a lot of staff working way over hours for free.

Absolutely correct. The modern NHS does too much it should be a basic heath service but do it well. I see waste though from middle management jobs doing stuff that isn't core like that "director of lived experience " and too many managers and poor procurement.

justgettingthroughtheday · 29/12/2022 23:47

We need to separate out care costs from the other local authority budget.
We need to accept that quality care costs and be prepared to pay for it. Care homes are not making big profits despite what some previous posters say. They need 95% occupancy to break even these days.
We need more short term accommodation for those who need short term support and are not able to go home but are well enough to not be in hospital.
We need a falls team who are able to get those who have fallen and are unable to get up but are not injured off the floor freeing up paramedics.
GPs need to be open longer hours every day and move back towards a preventative rather than a reactive health service.
More local drop in services for the elderly to increase general well-being.

antipodeancanary · 29/12/2022 23:46

I think the NHS needs to do much much less and do it well.
Some conditions are so expensive to manage that we should probably stop. I absolutely love my patients but some require two to one or even three to one care at all times. Its not sustainable.
We should look at quality of life towards the end of life much more actively. People should be allowed to die more easily. No pegs, no dysphagia assessments in end of life, generally speaking.
Yes to voluntary assisted euthanasia. No one should be alive five years after they stopped recognising family members.
No fertility treatment. No cosmetic surgery. No breast reconstruction, no gender realignment surgery. No gastric bands, no acne treatments.
I know people benefit from all those things, but when we have people who haven't been able to see a gp since before covid, are waiting in agony for two years for a hip replacement, who are dying aged 40 from colon cancer that was diagnosed too late and people refuse to pay more tax, then we have tough decisions to make.
I don't actually see a lot of waste in the NHS, but I do see a lot of staff working way over hours for free.

123woop · 29/12/2022 23:46

So as someone who knows a lot of people who work for the NHS at various levels, the thing that's struck me is the amount of "middle management" or "behind the scenes" people who are paid staggering amounts of money, when that money imho would be much better going to doctors and nurses and the people "on the frontline", I guess you'd say.
To give a recent well publicised example, the "director of lived experience" role for NHS midlands who earns £115,000 a year, but I know quite a few people who work for the NHS in a "consultancy" style role (not medical consultancy but HR for eg) who earn THOUSANDS, and as it's not a private business it goes unquestioned. They're just ones I know - it infuriates my doctor and nurse friends who know of many more examples.

I think that if the NHS is relying on well meaning people to allow themselves to be exploited because "long reign the NHS", then it's a failing business model.

That's before you get into the nitty gritty of how it's actually run day to day on the ground....

RethinkingLife · 29/12/2022 23:45

The Health Foundation, Nuffield Trust, and King's Fund have many excellent analyses and reports.

E.g.,

www.health.org.uk/publications?

www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/news-item/myth-3-we-should-copy-other-countries-and-adopt-a-social-insurance-model

www.kingsfund.org.uk/publications

sixfeetabove · 29/12/2022 23:43

PoinsettiaPosturing · 29/12/2022 23:22

Legalise euthanasia- with strict controls. We cannot sustain millions of 80/90+ year olds with no quality of life and a myriad of health issues when they themselves don't want to live that way.

Honestly I despise the fact that DGran who's got dementia, has no choice but to waste away like a cabbage, when she's always said she would rather go on her terms. We don't treat animals like it, so why do we keep humans 'alive' at any cost, despite the quality of life being nil.

I completely agree with this.

I've watched 3 family members die in the last 18 months.

All of them have been terminal and have died slowly and in pain. One of them was extremely annoyed that they were being kept alive against their will, when all it was doing was prolonging their suffering.

They were terminal, in their late 80s, and very clear minded. Refused a DNR but had to keep removing their own tubes.

bluefoxcub · 29/12/2022 23:39

@Pianofar "Reopen community hospitals, minor injury units (and staff them 24/7), and go back to holding clinics in the community. "
I don't know where you are but as a community nurse this already happens. We even run clinics on Christmas Day!
One of the many problem is hospitals refer non housebound patients to district nurses without questioning if they could go to the practice nurse or clinic.
When patients are informed of this they complain because the hospital or GP said we would visit.
Practice nurses are not given the time to do training for things like compression so the only option is clinics or home visits. We get complex wounds patients referred to us that make demand's because they do not like waiting in for us but as a service we cannot give times as we expect them
to be in.
We cannot give times because someone dying or a blocked catheter takes priority.
We try to encourage independence but families see it as a "nurses job" such as pain patch changes or insulin.
We get asked to do blood pressures by the GP when they are not our patients rather than loan a BP machine to them.
To cut a long story short we are taken advantage of, because we have a duty of care.

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 29/12/2022 23:38

Replace the convalescent hospitals and cottage hospitals that have nearly all been closed during the 12 years of this car-crash of a Tory government.

That would largely resolve the bed-blocking problem and enable ambulances to function again.

It was not long ago that all these facilities were closed down, and it was a decade ago that the Conservative government decided the NHS had to run above safe capacity for “efficiency” despite being told it would have the opposite effect. How come the entire nation seems to have developed the memory of a goldfish and forgotten all this happening? It was in the news an awful lot at the time…..

Also, bring social and residential care back into state provision rather than being farmed out to profit-making private equity firms, who load care homes up with debt, charge vast fees, take huge profits, but pay the staff the minimum wage.

Then, start investing in a healthy population: day centres for the elderly and adults with learning disabilities; good municipal leisure centres/ facilities to encourage healthy lifestyles; access to good quality outdoor play space. We did have all this in the recent past - before it was all cut in the name of “austerity” and the ideology of a small state.

A healthier population is what’s needed for the NHS to survive long-term. But for that, you need government to give a stuff about the well-being of ordinary voters, and we haven’t had that for over 12 years. No wonder it’s all such a mess.

DogInATent · 29/12/2022 23:36

I'm an outsider who sometimes works with (and occasionally within) the NHS and LA social care and have done on-and-off for 20 years. You cannot separate the problems of the NHS from the problems of social care.

Connect the NHS to social care. For a couple of decades they've been playing budgets off against each other because of the disconnect. It's an artificial competition that the Treasury plays.

If DTOCs could be largely eliminated and the whole TOC process made to work reliably, efficiently and to time, then there's a chance of getting enough fluidity in the acute care system to keep things moving. You could firehose cash at this in the short term, but this would be expensive and temporary.

Separate acute/emergency from chronic/elective.
Invest in respite and rehabilitation centres.
Re-invest in preventative measures based in the community.
Start a debate with the public about what the GDP health spend should be, what this means for overall government funding, and the public thinks should be funded and what should not - with some honest discussion about quality of life. Don't give the public the decision though, they're bad at those, but let them have opportunity to understand the issues.

Coxspurplepippin · 29/12/2022 23:36

Get rid of the agency staffing system - 'middle men' agencies earning ££££ an hour. Pay NHS staff the rates that agency staff receive.

Funded tuition for medical personnel on the understanding they work 10 years in the NHS after qualifying.

Look at sick pay (this should apply to all local govt, civil service etc) full paid sick leave for 6 months in every 12 months is unsustainable.

Agree with PP about community hospitals, convalescence spaces, 24 hour clinics.

Prevention is better than cure - ensuring everyone has access to good food, return of surestart centres, exercise brought back into primary schools.

Folkishgal · 29/12/2022 23:33

I've not worked directly for the NHS, but I'm trained in within a specialised mental health field and my MSc was geared up to be pipelined in to the NHS, so have done a lot of volunteering within NHS services.

Middle management is such a huge issue. Jobs that just don't need to exist filled by people who honestly just make work for themselves. It must cost the NHS billions.

The lack of money in mental health care is shocking, and when their are roles available they are 6 months contracts which take months to fill because all the paperwork that needs to be filled out is across different systems and departments.

And just generally too many people to cater too who aren't paying NI toward the services. The NHS is a great idea in theory, but the UK is very different now compared to when the NHS was started after WWII.

Like a PP said I think it's a lot worse than the general public realise, I honestly don't see their being an NHS for that much longer.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 29/12/2022 23:32

Such a huge issue but I'd do the following

  1. We need to pay more tax to fund social care. End of. No bitching and moaning. We want an nhs it has to be done
  2. Use said tax to fund care homes or convalescent homes with properly paid staff
  3. End all uni fees on nurses
  4. Go back to Training nurses on the job with day release Have dedicated staff to do this. This should
Be free
  1. Then end the need for bank staff At extortionate salaries
  2. Same applies to doctors midwife's radiologist etc etc
  3. Wards need to be managed by experienced staff not clerics
  4. Waste. Letters. Stationary one use supplies the list is endless
  5. Get rid of long term underperforming contracts
10. Pay rises 11. Charge people for wasted time 12. Nurses at triage should be able to turn people away at A&e for ridiculous complaints such as paracetamol broken toenails And yes this does happen.

I'm
Sure there are hundreds more but I can't think of them now.

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:31

BabyFour2023 · 29/12/2022 23:29

I think this varies by trust as I’m currently pregnant and I’ve received text messages for all my appointments. Our GP surgery always texts about appointments and the SALT team that my son uses sends emails. So much more efficient!

The only texts I get are when my GP surgery goes to emergency only and they text to say “ do not call - emergency only “
So if the GP is emergency only then where do people turn ? And they wonder why A & E are overwhelmed

BabyFour2023 · 29/12/2022 23:29

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:21

Why can’t the NHS email appointments?
Instead of posting letters , which are a waste of the price of postage / admin staff / secretary / paper etc.
it’s a huge bugbear of mine , letter is posted out , can’t attend , have to physically call to reschedule , waste of time having to speak to appointment secretary etc. It’s SO antiquated

I think this varies by trust as I’m currently pregnant and I’ve received text messages for all my appointments. Our GP surgery always texts about appointments and the SALT team that my son uses sends emails. So much more efficient!

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 23:26

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:21

Why can’t the NHS email appointments?
Instead of posting letters , which are a waste of the price of postage / admin staff / secretary / paper etc.
it’s a huge bugbear of mine , letter is posted out , can’t attend , have to physically call to reschedule , waste of time having to speak to appointment secretary etc. It’s SO antiquated

I get your point, but not everyone uses email. My elderly parents don't for example.

On the other hand, in the last week I had a txt to tell me that I needed to book my Health Check as per the letter that was sent out. I've had no letter though - guess it's in the postal backlog somewhere!

OP posts:
startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 23:24

nellyelloe · 29/12/2022 23:07

We need to manage the population growth.

I don't think that helps at all. From what I can see, there's a lot of bed blocking by elderly who need some care at home rather than hospital, and we need the staff/cash for that. It's not the younger member of society that are causing the issue from what I can see. And having just recovered from surgery by DRs from the Easter Bloc myself, I sincerely hope it's not an immigration dig. Perhaps you can clarify though if I've misunderstood?

OP posts:
AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:23

PoinsettiaPosturing · 29/12/2022 23:22

Legalise euthanasia- with strict controls. We cannot sustain millions of 80/90+ year olds with no quality of life and a myriad of health issues when they themselves don't want to live that way.

Honestly I despise the fact that DGran who's got dementia, has no choice but to waste away like a cabbage, when she's always said she would rather go on her terms. We don't treat animals like it, so why do we keep humans 'alive' at any cost, despite the quality of life being nil.

I agree
My DF has said so many times to not keep him going if anything happens but in reality this won’t be the case with current laws etc.

Zib · 29/12/2022 23:23

We need to get people to pay towards their healthcare and social care, sadly. With support for people who can't afford to pay, and charges for people who can.

Hospitals are at breaking point because of lack of social care. GPs have an unreasonable workload. People are going to A&E for things that should be addressed by their GP, or that they could go to a pharmacy for. Services which are free at the point of use tend not to be used wisely.

PoinsettiaPosturing · 29/12/2022 23:22

Legalise euthanasia- with strict controls. We cannot sustain millions of 80/90+ year olds with no quality of life and a myriad of health issues when they themselves don't want to live that way.

Honestly I despise the fact that DGran who's got dementia, has no choice but to waste away like a cabbage, when she's always said she would rather go on her terms. We don't treat animals like it, so why do we keep humans 'alive' at any cost, despite the quality of life being nil.

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:21

Why can’t the NHS email appointments?
Instead of posting letters , which are a waste of the price of postage / admin staff / secretary / paper etc.
it’s a huge bugbear of mine , letter is posted out , can’t attend , have to physically call to reschedule , waste of time having to speak to appointment secretary etc. It’s SO antiquated

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 23:20

So at the moment I think the majority so far say it needs far more funding - would everyone pay more tax though to fund it? Conservatives aren't known for raising taxes so I guess that's not happening whilst they're in power.

OP posts:
Fireandflight · 29/12/2022 23:19

There are so many excellent suggestions here. All wasted effort, though, as the government's agenda is to ignore all issues until people are glad to pay.

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:18

redflowerbluethorns · 29/12/2022 23:16

We need to manage the population growth

You know birth rates are so low that the government is trying to work out how to get more women to have children?
People are living longer nowadays.

I think the “ manage the population growth “ was a dig at immigration, not birth rates.

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 23:17

I am going to 100% agree with the social care aspect - seen this first hand with my own elderly parents - bloody nightmare all round and the stress for everyone involved was awful.

OP posts: