Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
Agsiajva · 30/12/2022 02:20

NHS ITU nurse here. Worked through covid and the current madness.

  1. degree apprenticeships for nurses and on a large scale - thousands, instant bolster to workforce and retention. (Not the old training, a degree apprenticeship). Graduate degree apprenticeships also 1-5-2 years to train a nurse or midwife. Student nurses are keeping the nhs on by a thread. They need a paid wage and also to feel a sense of belonging.
  2. community / rehab / long stay elderly beds (these have all been cut historically and is why we are seeing current problems, for staffing I think we need to look hard and try way harder to encourage people into nursing and care work but also need to recruit abroad if we want our patients to have any care.
  3. Hospital at home teams across the country. Flying squads. Whatever it takes to manage the elderly at home for as long as possible. 93% of beds in my hospital are occupied by over 65s. 75% are delayed discharges. H@H teams do exist and do work it’s just a postcode lottery.
  4. being clear with relatives that just because they want their 95 yo relative to have full escalation and painful interventions it doesn’t mean it’s fair or right and no matter how much threatening they do should not influence care (it shouldn’t but it does)
  5. (I’m not right wing btw 😂) a national service style scheme but for healthcare support roles, (obviously those working in healthcare exempt) people have lost track and sight of what happens in the nhs and also lots of potential nurses physios etc are lost.
  6. a full and frank look at what can and cannot be provided by the nhs, although the potential inequalities in care do scare me.
  7. Closed door EDs (in place some places) and far better walk in GPs for OOH. It works in some places. Better minor injuries / urgent care centres. These are available in places but it’s not uniform or standardised. Good practice needs to be shared.
  8. standardisation of nurse associate / associate practitioner / senior HCA band 4 roles and implementation across the country, but fairly, not instead of staff nurses.
  9. nationalisation of home care, more community day centres etc.
  10. end outsourcing and also , there are many incessant non clinical roles - an irony being quality improvement - quality is low because an RN has 3x the safe and legal amount of patients, it can be improved by more RNs. We need to walk before we can run.
  11. Some decentralisation, too much pressure on large super hospitals. More smaller hospitals and let people be cared for closer to home in a smaller setting.
  12. no more single room general wards, and ideally back to nightingale wards or large bays, this is a slow burn though.
  13. bring back nhs / nursing staff accommodation.
  14. a 0.5-1% on higher rate earners for nhs / health and social care. MPs pay rises to matched and capped % as equal to nhs pay rises.
  15. strict fines and criminal charges where applicable for V&A against nhs staff (capacity dependent). This is a large driver of people leaving.

my most controversial suggestion, we need to legalise euthanasia / assisted suicide in some form, there’s a lot of people living with pain and limited dignity and it’s cruel.

jamimmi · 30/12/2022 01:54

Worked in the NHS for 30 years another 16 to go. It's never been this bad. Colleagues leaving to work in private clinics or abroad. Pay and conditions better in both. Last 3 students I've had have all been aiming to emigrate on graduation.
How do we sort it?
Investment and the country realising if they want a better system like Germany or France it must be paid for.
Reopen local cottage hospitals to allow patients to be rehabed . Most gyms and rehabilitation areas in hospitals went.during COVID and haven't come back . Patients can't cope on d/c fall and come back in.
Better social.care with Investment and training. Most NH are private, they need to make a profit it's not working is it? So why would privatising more of.the NHS work more.
We also need to charge for missed hospital appointments or cancellations within 2 days this really adds to waiting times in my clinics where the wait is.up to 12months for an appointment. Appts go out 4 to 6 weeks in advance by text / email.
People. Need to grow up and take responsibility their own health too.

gertrudemortimer · 30/12/2022 01:06

I would like to see more training provided to the current staff to upband, any training given to staff should result in higher paid people too. At the moment we have staff who won't learn how to take bloods, do cannulas, ecg's etc because they aren't paid any more to be pulled from all directions to do these jobs. Value nhs training and make the most of it.

Nursing associates should be given the FULL training to be a band 5 staff nurse. Similar courses should exist for every single nhs career too. Why is it we say every year how many nhs professionals we are short of but at the same time the uni's have over subscribed medical courses? I know many good healthcares that got rejected on nursing and midwifery courses.

Tighten up the sickness policy too, it is shocking how easy that is to abuse.

I'm probably way off on all of this but I would just like to see more investment in the people and a bit of encouragement. If you're under band 5 you're basically stuck in shit pay unless you put yourself through uni, pay for it and work placements. If the nhs really wants more qualified staff they're going to have to provide the opportunity (in my opinion).

StealingYourWiFi · 30/12/2022 00:46

I’m in the private sector now but did work in a&e for 5 years and nhs theatres for 2 years.

  • legalise assisted dying. It’s brutal what we put people through when they just simply don’t want to live anymore
  • Community hospitals, rehabilitation centres where people who are fit enough to leave hospital but not well enough to go home can stay. Following surgeries, strokes, waiting for care packages to be put in place in their home environment, waiting for residential care places.
  • pay staff more, make the job more attractive. The private sector isn’t much better but I’m paid well. More than the nhs. Plus I get private healthcare too which has served me very well in the two times I’ve needed it.
  • encourage people to become nurses by offering more ‘apprentice’ roles. Pay a wage whilst they train. I earnt £2.30 an hour as a student and then a third of that went on my parking costs at my hospital as ‘students’ weren’t considered for staff rates. There was nowhere nearby to park as all residential permit.
  • less paperwork. So so much time is spent on computer/paperwork. We often finish a whole surgery before even completing that patients paperwork. Give patients choice if they would prefer to go paperless.
antipodeancanary · 30/12/2022 00:36

BungleandGeorge · 30/12/2022 00:10

And what about people who take 8 paracetamol every day? Are they expected to
go to the shop every 4 days? I think you’ll find the nhs really don’t provide people with small amounts of paracetamol anymore

@antipodeancanary you’ll have to explain to me why people can get a hip replacement costing thousands which isn’t life threatening but they can’t get acne treatment which would prevent them from permanent scarring for their lifetime on an area which they can’t cover up? Some acne treatments are quite toxic And need to be prescribed and monitored by hospital consultants. And gastric bands can save a considerable amount of morbidity and thus quite effectively save money long term (including reducing the load on hips and thus the need for hip replacements) You see it’s not quite so
straightforward and that’s the problem. We should really be concentrating on prevention a lot more

Well in those specific cases, mobility problems stop people working, acne less so. Gastric bands are not very successful, hip replacements are. Of course it's not straightforward. I'm not a specialist in everything, but these are discussions we need to be able to have openly. But in general we need to be concentrating on cheap treatments that are successful and that a lot of people need. And the people who get the treatment need to be young enough to have a good potential quality of life.

Snuppeline · 30/12/2022 00:34

Whilst I don’t disagree that euthanasia should be legal it is actually possible to do something, I’ve drawn up a legal document (power of attorney) stipulating when no resuscitation or medical treatment of any kind is to be given. I’m my case when I cannot recognise named family members. Hopefully this will be respected so that if I am afflicted by dementia, or am brain damaged, I will die of a simple infection (Covid, flu, UTI anything) without medical science prolonging a life I have determined at a healthy period of my life (I’m 40) to be of no quality to me. Reason for sharing this is that this is possible for everyone, if they want to take charge for themselves.

Sleepsleeprepeat · 30/12/2022 00:33

Sort out social care. If the 120ish people waiting to be discharged with social care support could go home over night in the hospital I work in, we’d be able to place patients needing admission quickly in to the right bed from the Emergency Department, so no ambulance queues, and we’d be able to run our theatres efficiently. Though it wouldn’t sort out staffing alone, it would mean that people can do the job they’ve chosen to do - rather than, for example, nurses working in surgical wards looking after medical patients, and without some of the compromises being made now.

Babyroobs · 30/12/2022 00:26

Iluvfriends · 30/12/2022 00:18

So many staff off sick time and time again, weed out the chancers.
Stop employing just anyone to get numbers up. Employing someone not interested or just downright lazy does not help us one bit, and they can't get rid of them because they have a permanent contract. Would it not be sensible to offer 3 or 6 month conracts to see if they are suitable for the job.
The amount that must be getting spent on agency and guild staff must be ridiculous......one I was working with the other day....£60 an hour bank holiday rate.

I worked in the NHS for 30 years and never quite got my head around how much sick time was taken off by colleagues . People absolutely milked it because they could - six months on full pay, then they'd come back and take off all their leave that they'd built up during their sick time off. I went to work abroad in their NHS equivalent and you got no paid sick days until you'd worked there for six months.

CrazyBiscuits · 30/12/2022 00:23

As to wasting money, the NHS trust where I live hold random clinic days to carry out health checks on staff. That surely is a waste of money. This is on healthy staff, without symptoms who would surely visit their GP if necessary.
Also the NHS doesn't always investigate where certain departments have high staff turnover and simply waste time and money on recruitment and training.

Communication from seniors to staff is also lacking and staff often have to turn to their peers to find anything out, especially when new, this doesn't help with retaining staff as they feel undervalued.

goingback · 30/12/2022 00:20

waste reduction, fair contracts for equipment, medicines, etc., and better pay to retain and attract staff. invest in prevention -how much money is spent on self-afflicted illnesses. Health as part of the school curriculum.
practical stuff such as early intervention - people not diagnosed for a long time then a long wait for treatment costs far more and potentially more serious outcome. I'm thinking a form of healthbombing where triage and investigations can be concluded over a matter of hours or a couple of days.

Fifi00 · 30/12/2022 00:19

Babyroobs · 30/12/2022 00:13

Tax cigarettes, alcohol and sugary foods more highly and put this towards NHS care. If people want to partake in habits that ruin their health then they should pay more towards their care. We also need to overhaul social care. Where I live as I suspect in many areas there are long waits for care assessments and care packages to be set up.

It's cheaper for the NHS if people quickly die of heart attacks. One of the biggest problems is people actually living longer with dementias for example which cost a fortune. Dementia is going to become the number 1 cause of death in future. Dysphagia treatments, antibiotics, falls , infections , diabetes , the costs mount up and it takes years to die from.

Iluvfriends · 30/12/2022 00:18

So many staff off sick time and time again, weed out the chancers.
Stop employing just anyone to get numbers up. Employing someone not interested or just downright lazy does not help us one bit, and they can't get rid of them because they have a permanent contract. Would it not be sensible to offer 3 or 6 month conracts to see if they are suitable for the job.
The amount that must be getting spent on agency and guild staff must be ridiculous......one I was working with the other day....£60 an hour bank holiday rate.

Soothsayer1 · 30/12/2022 00:17

We have a rapidly aging population with high care needs and multiple co-morbidities
I agree this is a big part of the problem, we've our heads in the sand & haven't accepted this yet😶

Anotherusernameanotheday · 30/12/2022 00:16

@HeBeaverandSheBeaver
Student nurses do train on the job. They are supernumerary too.
The managers aren’t clerical staff. They are senior nurses called ward managers. We still have matrons too.
Bank staff are different from agency staff. No where near as expensive.
I’m not sure whether we are overmanaged. Yes there are different tiers of management who have increasing layers of responsibility and see the bigger picture. This will need replicating with all the myriad of departments and services. People quoting the ‘director of lived experience’ vacancy didn’t read the full thread and it turned out to be a fairly important post to ensure quality of care was maintained.
Agree that wealthy pensioners should be contributing towards their care and not squirrelling money away for their children. My mum paid almost £300k towards her care as she was self funded. Some form of means tested contribution should be implemented so funds build up over the years so canny folk can avoid paying tax.

Babyroobs · 30/12/2022 00:13

Tax cigarettes, alcohol and sugary foods more highly and put this towards NHS care. If people want to partake in habits that ruin their health then they should pay more towards their care. We also need to overhaul social care. Where I live as I suspect in many areas there are long waits for care assessments and care packages to be set up.

TheComptonEffect · 30/12/2022 00:13

Everything mentioned before. And...
Years of shortsightedness.
Years of mismanagement by the wrong people.
Years of politics informing policy when it has absolutely no buisness doing so.
Cronisim and corruption (government)
Years of corner cutting .
Lack of collaboration (pitting trust against trust instead of working together) inclusion (getting the right people involved) participation (making the changes that need to be made- a national IT system for starters).
Setting more targets instead of solving root causes!
Blame rather than support ( look at GPs - setting newer tougher targets rather than saving the problems or paying dentists enough to cover lab fees so they can continue to take NHS patients)

The first year/6 months of pandemic was so dynamic in terms of the changes being made and flexibility and collaboration. Honestly it was incredible what was done without laborious processes (still following all clinical Governance and safety) this should be how it is all the time! Especially as we know it can be done.

Neglect of the most valuable NHS assests- the people delivering care! I have worked in private healthcare systems abroad and it is not a great working environment generally. Accounting for every pair of gloves you use, inferior but cheaper equipment, decisions directly governed by finance not quality of life.

The government want to devalue the NHS so much that it's unfit for purpose, and the public are crying out to sell it off as they can't see an alternative. We are absolutely at the pivotal point right now. The NHS can be saved without an overhaul and correct finance but I am certain that it won't be due to greed. The demise will be painful, and protracted with the money making parts siphoned off and the public picking up the tab for what's left.

Fifi00 · 30/12/2022 00:11

It's not just the NHS , it's social care which links things all together. Care packages aren't in place which leads to delayed discharge, and conditions are becoming more complex to manage in care homes. We have a rapidly aging population with high care needs and multiple co-morbidities , the choices are make healthcare a more attractive profession, pay more taxes or private insurance. Try to attract immigration or maybe accept that keeping people alive in very very very poor health for 10+ years isn't beneficial. I strongly suspect they will legalise assisted dying but it won't be for caring reasons but to reduce the bills.

BungleandGeorge · 30/12/2022 00:10

Stripedbag101 · 29/12/2022 23:58

I would ban prescriptions for low value items that can be bought in the shops. Paracetamol for example.

And what about people who take 8 paracetamol every day? Are they expected to
go to the shop every 4 days? I think you’ll find the nhs really don’t provide people with small amounts of paracetamol anymore

@antipodeancanary you’ll have to explain to me why people can get a hip replacement costing thousands which isn’t life threatening but they can’t get acne treatment which would prevent them from permanent scarring for their lifetime on an area which they can’t cover up? Some acne treatments are quite toxic And need to be prescribed and monitored by hospital consultants. And gastric bands can save a considerable amount of morbidity and thus quite effectively save money long term (including reducing the load on hips and thus the need for hip replacements) You see it’s not quite so
straightforward and that’s the problem. We should really be concentrating on prevention a lot more

supergel · 30/12/2022 00:10

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:21

Why can’t the NHS email appointments?
Instead of posting letters , which are a waste of the price of postage / admin staff / secretary / paper etc.
it’s a huge bugbear of mine , letter is posted out , can’t attend , have to physically call to reschedule , waste of time having to speak to appointment secretary etc. It’s SO antiquated

I haven't had an nhs appointment letter for ages. They usually text with a link and PIN. Once accessed you can download the appointment letter

Namenic · 30/12/2022 00:07

ex nhs. Stop further PFI (philosophy of buy now pay a LOT tomorrow). Good rota software. Retain experienced staff - eg higher pay, flexible working with fewer out of hours shifts for >55s. No big re-orgs (waste lots of money) - first try funding nhs appropriately (so similar ratio of staff per capita to other developed nations).

Beseen22 · 30/12/2022 00:06

We sadly have a very unrealistic attitude towards quality of life vs quantity of life in this country. Even Prince William said of his 96 year old grandmother that they had hoped she would get a bit longer when the Queen passed. I don't support blanket decisions but a discussion between families when someone is well not at a critical point about what they would actually want if they were to deteriorate.

For example, if you had advanced dementia and were non verbal and bed bound and incontinent and you aspirated on some food (because my swallow reflex is deterioring) would you want to be held down to get a cannula in to give you antibiotics and fluids and for an oxygen mask to be held to your face because you don't have a clue what's going on and are petrified. This kind of event happened about 4 times in my grandfathers last year of life. Or would you want to have a form in place that says in the event of x I want to stay at my nursing home where I know the staff and my family can visit at any time with my own surroundings and be given medicine to ensure I do not suffer and come to my natural end?

Zosime · 30/12/2022 00:05

We need to manage the population growth.

Population of England:

1981 46.82m
1991 47.88m
2001 49.45m
2011 53.01m
2021 56.49m

How much over sixty million by 2031? What will be the age structure and health needs of the additional people? Where will they be living? How are you going to plan for it? Or will any attempt to discuss the issue be shut down by accusing people of being racist and anti-immigration?

Bluelightbaby · 29/12/2022 23:59

Pianofar · 29/12/2022 23:02

For me there's a myriad of many things, but the main ones:

Reopen community hospitals, minor injury units (and staff them 24/7), and go back to holding clinics in the community.

In addition to ambulances as we know them, reintroduce adequately staffed and suitable vehicles to safely assess and if necessary transport those who have had falls, mental health ambulances, and invest more in training for call handlers to more effectively triage calls. Also an education piece to the public.

Improve staff retention, pay isn't the only way but is a key way and the easiest start point. The nhs is nothing without its staff- you can have the fanciest equipment and tonnes of beds but it's useless without appropriately trained staff. There are tonnes of other things that would need to be done but that's probably another thread.

Government invest in social care to avoid people being 'stuck' in hospital. Also invest in societal things that affect health.

This 👆🏻

but in addition we need more GP surgeries, more hospitals and a ton more staff.

Today I waited in an ambulance queue to get into the hospital for 8hrs. Some of the patients had been in the corridor for over 12-14hrs !

our population is ever increasing for various reasons but the infrastructure is not

Stripedbag101 · 29/12/2022 23:58

I would ban prescriptions for low value items that can be bought in the shops. Paracetamol for example.

BungleandGeorge · 29/12/2022 23:55

I’d take it out of direct government control and make it independent. Decisions made for the good of the users not political ambition or ideological beliefs. You only have to listen to government ministers for a few minutes to realise that they have little clue how anything works, or what services are provided or what different staff actually do. It’s embarrassing. And we keep wasting money every 4/5 years on major restructuring for very little gain.

Swipe left for the next trending thread