Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
yellowlikely · 30/12/2022 08:15

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:21

Why can’t the NHS email appointments?
Instead of posting letters , which are a waste of the price of postage / admin staff / secretary / paper etc.
it’s a huge bugbear of mine , letter is posted out , can’t attend , have to physically call to reschedule , waste of time having to speak to appointment secretary etc. It’s SO antiquated

In my trust the system that generates appointment letters was developed pre email - they can't be linked so can't be sent. The whole NHS needs better IT systems - what we work with is archaic.

Although, around 75% of my patients don't have access to email anyway.

MarieG10 · 30/12/2022 08:14

@HeBeaverandSheBeaver

*Such a huge issue but I'd do the following

• We need to pay more tax to fund social care. End of. No bitching and moaning. We want an nhs it has to be done

  1. Use said tax to fund care homes or convalescent homes with properly paid staff "*

I think the more tax ship has sailed. Huge tax rises are already lined up to reduced the deficit. The tax rate is going to be the highest ever since WW2. I'm afraid each government finds it easy to spend more but that option has run out..... Governments of whatever colour simply now have to cut spending as our economy is not growing....a harsh reality non of them like as they all love promising more spending to curry votes

Wetnovember · 30/12/2022 08:12

@iloveeverykindofcat I’ve had arguments with colleagues who think it’s unethical not to treat the treatable. I hold the opposite view in selected cases.

iloveeverykindofcat · 30/12/2022 08:10

@Wetnovember my mum told the doctors to stop treating my 84 Yr old grandmother with advanced dementia for pneumonia and just make her comfortable. A doctor told her it was absolutely the right decision. Not sure he was really supposed to say that but it's true.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 30/12/2022 08:09

I'm ex-NHS and for me the absolute biggest thing needed is to invest in social care

KRoo22 · 30/12/2022 08:06

Bring back the bursary or fund university places for nurses. Increase training spaces for doctors and get rid of ridiculous pension tax rules for consultants. Increase international recruitment.

Wetnovember · 30/12/2022 08:01

@Virginiaplain ’the confused old 90 year old’
………living largely independently at home with an infection induced delirium = definitely treat.
……….living at home with 5 X day carers, bed bound and wearing incontinence pads or with a catheter…..and with an infection that is making their dementia worse…..well I wouldn’t want to keep going it that was me or either of my parents. But lots of relatives seem to think it’s an acceptable way to keep their relatives alive.

Wetnovember · 30/12/2022 07:55

@PoinsettiaPosturing ….there is a choice re old people, but 99% of the time when you ask relatives what they want they always want treatment. In my 22 year career I’ve had 2 families who have asked me not to treat their relatives with dementia and a UTI/chest infection. In both cases the patient died within 48hrs. In both cases the patient was still living at home, but the families were really struggling to cope and said they knew once their relative went into a NH their quality of life would deteriorate rapidly and we were just ‘delaying the inevitable’ and adding a heap of misery for everyone into the equation. Giving someone a dignified death is a huge privilege, one that’s mostly denied to healthcare workers by well meaning but misguided relatives.

Virginiaplain · 30/12/2022 07:53

Wetnovember · 30/12/2022 07:22

Stop treating everyone for everything, especially older people with dementia. We need to keep dying people comfortable, but we need to stop sending every nursing home resident on a blood thinner into hospital for a CT scan of their head every time they fall over. No one is going to operate if they find a bleed- so what’s the point? In fact we need to stop all meds (except mood stabilizers and pain relief) on anyone going into a nursing home. Life expectancy in a nursing home is 18 months, how about we just keep these people comfortable? Would you want to spend the last 18m of your life surrounded by old people in a smelly home (they all smell-the homes, not the people)?
I know I’ll probably be roasted for this opinion, but we are spending insane amounts of money keeping dying people alive. People in NH are dying, just slowly. The euthanasia argument amuses me. We don’t even let dying people die, we aren’t even close to letting living ones die.
stop giving cancer patients last ditch treatments that cost ££££ and may buy them an extra 2 weeks of life - lying in bed and just about breathing (oncologists are external optimists).
we spend the most at the extremes of life. We need to start being a bit more selective about how we manage these people.
people will talk about less managers and less waste, and there is scope for improvement there too, but it’s the money we are haemorrhaging on keeping dying people alive that is killing the NHS.

I don't agree with all of this post as when you are the old confused 90 year old you are probably keen to hang on to the last weeks/ months of your life.

However, once in a Care Home people are treated with kid gloves - no normal life events, no stairs to climb (in case they fall), no covid allowed etc so they live much longer than they would at home. I feel this is unfair in a way - they have boring lives, the only interests are tv they can't follow, and busy staff to chat to. Their worldly goods gone, No friendy neighbours to wave to.

If someone has a fall or dies unexpectedly in the care home it reaches the front pages of our local newspaper. This needs to stop. We have inspectors, trust them to do their job and the homes to do their best despite shortages of staff etc. and don't unnaturally extend life.

cptartapp · 30/12/2022 07:49

Over thirty years nursing.
Too many people living too long often in very poor health.
And who would you charge for wasted time? Everyone? Children, those on benefits, pensioners? Or just the same poor sods in the middle.

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 30/12/2022 07:38

Get rid of the Tory's, I have worked frontline in A&E under both Labour and Tory, the Tories have destroyed literally everything in this country. I have never seen it as bad, closing beds and wards, no social care, no primary care, GP's that are taking the mick, still binding behind Covid when everyone else gets on with it.

The whole point of the NHS was free at the point of contact, the Government want to privatise it and profit from it, hence why you will see a lot of our ministers now own shares in private medical firms.

They introduced charging all NHS students for their training. Why would anyone get themselves into 45K worth of debt for 25K per year?

Vote these lot out or get what you voted for.

KangarooKenny · 30/12/2022 07:34

I’ve had two letters and a text reminding me to have my covid booster. I’m not having it, so that’s a waste, I should be able to register somewhere that I’m not having it to save that money.

BlandSoup · 30/12/2022 07:34

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 29/12/2022 23:32

Such a huge issue but I'd do the following

  1. We need to pay more tax to fund social care. End of. No bitching and moaning. We want an nhs it has to be done
  2. Use said tax to fund care homes or convalescent homes with properly paid staff
  3. End all uni fees on nurses
  4. Go back to Training nurses on the job with day release Have dedicated staff to do this. This should
Be free
  1. Then end the need for bank staff At extortionate salaries
  2. Same applies to doctors midwife's radiologist etc etc
  3. Wards need to be managed by experienced staff not clerics
  4. Waste. Letters. Stationary one use supplies the list is endless
  5. Get rid of long term underperforming contracts
10. Pay rises 11. Charge people for wasted time 12. Nurses at triage should be able to turn people away at A&e for ridiculous complaints such as paracetamol broken toenails And yes this does happen.

I'm
Sure there are hundreds more but I can't think of them now.

Do you work in the NHS? I didn’t know that triage nurses can’t send people home.

I agree with charging people for wasting time.

Also, on the job training would be great. I thought about retraining but there’s no way I could afford it with two small children at home.

People also need to better understand their own personal responsibility for their health. Eat less crap, exercise more. Sometimes I wonder if people just don’t want to take responsibility for themselves and expect others to sort out their health problems. I mean at the preventative point, like drinking and smoking less in the first place.

Pianofar · 30/12/2022 07:32

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 23:09

I like your ideas @Pianofar but that sounds a lot like more cash needed and a need to recruit more staff - can it be done? What would entice those that have left the system to come back to it? Or should we be looking to recruit from abroad*?

(*As an aside I'm not NHS but I did recently require emergency surgery and two of the three Docs involved were all Eastern Bloc - I received fantastic care and am very grateful.)

The nhs still owns a lot of the estate needed for these local hospitals, and with collaboration with the council could access venues to host clinics- we used to have a room in the library for diabetic clinics and it was great. In my experience these jobs are always more desirable for some as well- closer to home, different environment and pressures to main hospitals, usually more family friendly hours etc; we lost a lot of HCPs with each closure and scaling back of services as they didn't want to work shifts in a main hospital.

Lots of my colleagues have left to continue on with nursing but in the private sector or for agency, imo if things improved ie fairer pay which would naturally lead to better retention and so less stretched working conditions I think many could be enticed back. They love nursing, they haven't left it they've just left the nhs, but it would take major changes.

Recruiting from abroad is a tricky one for me. No shade or disrespect at all to those who come over, they are highly skilled, fantastic assets to the nhs and being realistic have kept it afloat! But there is the question of ethics. There's an informal agreement we are in along with other western countries that we won't exceed x amount of nurses from developing countries as this then depletes their healthcare systems; but we often go over that with no hesitation. Lots also aren't keen to fight for better pay because to them the pay is brilliant. This means the gov can continue to exploit this cheap labour whilst screwing over people here. To be clear, they are great assets but it's the way the government uses them to plug gaps and not improve pay and conditions for all that's the problem.

Essentially the most important part of the nhs is the staff, the government know this but seem loathe to actually do anything about it.

Greendoorsaremyfavourite · 30/12/2022 07:32

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:21

Why can’t the NHS email appointments?
Instead of posting letters , which are a waste of the price of postage / admin staff / secretary / paper etc.
it’s a huge bugbear of mine , letter is posted out , can’t attend , have to physically call to reschedule , waste of time having to speak to appointment secretary etc. It’s SO antiquated

I received a letter, hand delivered (no postage mark, plain envelope) at 7pm the night before an appointment telling me it was cancelled last year. Surely a text message/phone call would have more efficient!

hattie43 · 30/12/2022 07:29

PoinsettiaPosturing · 29/12/2022 23:22

Legalise euthanasia- with strict controls. We cannot sustain millions of 80/90+ year olds with no quality of life and a myriad of health issues when they themselves don't want to live that way.

Honestly I despise the fact that DGran who's got dementia, has no choice but to waste away like a cabbage, when she's always said she would rather go on her terms. We don't treat animals like it, so why do we keep humans 'alive' at any cost, despite the quality of life being nil.

The same could be said of babies born severely disabled them requiring a life time of care . Just because medical science can save them doesn't mean it should .

UniversalAunt · 30/12/2022 07:26

‘…especially older people with dementia.’

?

CoffeandTiaMaria · 30/12/2022 07:26

7 day a week GP/Nurse Practitioner services, stop people overwhelming A+E because they can’t get a GP appointment. Our GP surgery is utter crap since Covid hit, one GP sends you to Ambulatory Care or A+E ‘to be safe’ for the most minor of reasons-might just as well go straight there! (I wouldn’t and don’t)

UniversalAunt · 30/12/2022 07:25

Large national IT system impossible for NHS?

Wonder how utility companies, rail networks, power stations. air traffic control manage large amounts of residential/commercial/real time data & keep operations performance at acceptable levels?

It gets done because it has to be done, & anything less is either commercial or a disaster. This requires commitment, resources & money.

The NHS has not yet decided to do it.

Notplayingball · 30/12/2022 07:22

Have said it for years, too many Chiefs and not enough Indians. Getting rid of many useless management positions would greatly help.

Wetnovember · 30/12/2022 07:22

Stop treating everyone for everything, especially older people with dementia. We need to keep dying people comfortable, but we need to stop sending every nursing home resident on a blood thinner into hospital for a CT scan of their head every time they fall over. No one is going to operate if they find a bleed- so what’s the point? In fact we need to stop all meds (except mood stabilizers and pain relief) on anyone going into a nursing home. Life expectancy in a nursing home is 18 months, how about we just keep these people comfortable? Would you want to spend the last 18m of your life surrounded by old people in a smelly home (they all smell-the homes, not the people)?
I know I’ll probably be roasted for this opinion, but we are spending insane amounts of money keeping dying people alive. People in NH are dying, just slowly. The euthanasia argument amuses me. We don’t even let dying people die, we aren’t even close to letting living ones die.
stop giving cancer patients last ditch treatments that cost ££££ and may buy them an extra 2 weeks of life - lying in bed and just about breathing (oncologists are external optimists).
we spend the most at the extremes of life. We need to start being a bit more selective about how we manage these people.
people will talk about less managers and less waste, and there is scope for improvement there too, but it’s the money we are haemorrhaging on keeping dying people alive that is killing the NHS.

CoffeandTiaMaria · 30/12/2022 07:21

Pianofar · 29/12/2022 23:02

For me there's a myriad of many things, but the main ones:

Reopen community hospitals, minor injury units (and staff them 24/7), and go back to holding clinics in the community.

In addition to ambulances as we know them, reintroduce adequately staffed and suitable vehicles to safely assess and if necessary transport those who have had falls, mental health ambulances, and invest more in training for call handlers to more effectively triage calls. Also an education piece to the public.

Improve staff retention, pay isn't the only way but is a key way and the easiest start point. The nhs is nothing without its staff- you can have the fanciest equipment and tonnes of beds but it's useless without appropriately trained staff. There are tonnes of other things that would need to be done but that's probably another thread.

Government invest in social care to avoid people being 'stuck' in hospital. Also invest in societal things that affect health.

All of these plus;
slim down the management structure, it’s ridiculous how top heavy it is.
bring back State Enrolled Nurse SEN training - one of the biggest mistakes was abolishing this (Project 2000 training was the beginning of the end imo)

LemonBounce · 30/12/2022 07:20

Iluvfriends · 30/12/2022 00:18

So many staff off sick time and time again, weed out the chancers.
Stop employing just anyone to get numbers up. Employing someone not interested or just downright lazy does not help us one bit, and they can't get rid of them because they have a permanent contract. Would it not be sensible to offer 3 or 6 month conracts to see if they are suitable for the job.
The amount that must be getting spent on agency and guild staff must be ridiculous......one I was working with the other day....£60 an hour bank holiday rate.

Maybe staff are sick because of the stress and pressure of being so overworked

PoTayToes80 · 30/12/2022 07:20

PoinsettiaPosturing · 29/12/2022 23:22

Legalise euthanasia- with strict controls. We cannot sustain millions of 80/90+ year olds with no quality of life and a myriad of health issues when they themselves don't want to live that way.

Honestly I despise the fact that DGran who's got dementia, has no choice but to waste away like a cabbage, when she's always said she would rather go on her terms. We don't treat animals like it, so why do we keep humans 'alive' at any cost, despite the quality of life being nil.

I think it would be an absolute disaster to legalise euthanasia within the context of failing health, social care and mental health systems. We need to get so many other things right first before we can open the door to euthanasia.

Blueskythinking123 · 30/12/2022 07:20

Improve the recruitment process would be a good start.

My DD is a student nurse. She has been approved for bank HCA work. However, completing the HR tasks have been both time consuming and ridiculously slow. I fully understand the need for checks (I work for the LA), but most people would not be able to wait without work the time this has taken.

Swipe left for the next trending thread