Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
Shiraztonight · 30/12/2022 10:39

I'm in Scotland so they are free, nearly 90 % are free in UK

Eleganz · 30/12/2022 10:35

Shiraztonight · 30/12/2022 10:31

We need a conversation about what the NHS covers, it can't cover everything. Does it need to be free at the point of access for all? Affordable, but putting a price on something often gives it value, say £1.50 per prescription ( up to a max of say 4 prescriptions) for all adults. We don't expect food for free ( I know we have food banks) so why do we have free medicine? Managers should be managers not ex clinical staff who have been promoted, they may have been good nurses / ahps etc. This does not mean they would make good managers

The current prescription charge is £9.35 per item. Yes there are exemptions for some chronic conditions but not sure that removing those would achieve what you are aiming for.

bibbif · 30/12/2022 10:33

Also why don't older workers who work pay NI particularly as younger people will get seeing pension age pushed out?

bibbif · 30/12/2022 10:33

@Shiraztonight medicine isn't free for many though?

Shiraztonight · 30/12/2022 10:31

We need a conversation about what the NHS covers, it can't cover everything. Does it need to be free at the point of access for all? Affordable, but putting a price on something often gives it value, say £1.50 per prescription ( up to a max of say 4 prescriptions) for all adults. We don't expect food for free ( I know we have food banks) so why do we have free medicine? Managers should be managers not ex clinical staff who have been promoted, they may have been good nurses / ahps etc. This does not mean they would make good managers

bibbif · 30/12/2022 10:31

@TheRedLip how would you attract the best staff?

TheRedLip · 30/12/2022 10:30

Pianofar · 30/12/2022 10:20

Why? They pay university fees and spend many hours on placement without reimbursement. There's a lot written about how much it costs the NHS to train a doctor, but the universities also pay the NHS to have them host students so- not convinced to be honest. Now if fees were paid and perhaps a bursary then sure I'd agree with a return of service arrangement as they have in Wales for some healthcare degrees. The issue is more the the low pay and ridiculous hoops junior doctors need to go through to progress that causes people to leave or move abroad.

Most people I work with have very few sick days, I don't think because some may abuse it it's reasonable to wish it away. Much better would be to improve working conditions (this is proven to reduce sick days).

People like you are so the problem.

catsnthat · 30/12/2022 10:30

I get your point, but not everyone uses email. My elderly parents don't for example.

That's true, but everyone who does use email could supply their email address to be used and anyone without one could still get a letter.

My dad has been having ongoing treatment for the last year and has regular hospital appointments. Not only do they send him emails, they send texts as well, plus letters! Often he gets duplicated letters as well. Huge waste of money.

NameChangedAsOutraged · 30/12/2022 10:28

I’m a GP. I dont think it’s fixable now. We are on the road to a 2 tier health system of private health care for the rich and woeful health care for the poor thanks to the Tory Government.

Blurpy · 30/12/2022 10:28
  1. Sort out IT - but this is probably an impossible task.
  1. Free training for nurses, subsidised training for doctors - work for X amount of years, or pay it back.
  1. No more bank staff. Speed up the recruitment process for permanent staff. More flexible contracts for those that need them. Stop hiring people on short term contracts - they're going to leave for a permanent role as soon as they can and then you've wasted money on recruitment and time and effort on training.
  1. Reduced remit. NHS should provide a basic service and do it well. We're trying to run before we can walk with a lot of therapies/diagnostic services.
  1. Increase walk in/small injuries clinics/community health centres. Educate the public about how to self-triage and self-treat (tbh I feel the NHS website is really excellent - do the public not use it?).
  1. Who has oversight of resource allocation?? I have seen some crazy spending decisions. I kind of agree with previous posters - there is a lot of money sloshing around and I'm not sure 'more money' is the answer.

There have been some great suggestions on this thread. The NHS is so enormous that trying to effect any organisation-wide change in culture/practice is basically impossible. The only practical solutions are around recruitment and remit, I think.

bibbif · 30/12/2022 10:27

However, I think a general change of culture within the public is one of the main things that needs changed. People need to start looking after their own health & taking some responsibility.

See I think there is far more nuance to the above. We know that people die younger in poorer areas & richer areas enjoy better health. It's a socioeconomic issue too.

bibbif · 30/12/2022 10:24

The collapse of the NHS is just one of a plethora of interlinked societal problems. To fix the NHS requires sweeping societa land political change involving redistribution of wealth and being realistic about how we will manage an increasingly needy, geriatric population.

nothing else needs to be said.

Iluvfriends · 30/12/2022 10:23

LemonBounce · 30/12/2022 07:20

Maybe staff are sick because of the stress and pressure of being so overworked

I said weed out the chancers..... of which there are many.

They go off sick, come back just before they go to half pay, work until the full pay kicks in again then off sick they go again.

Eleganz · 30/12/2022 10:22

I don't work in the NHS but elsewhere in the public sector but I can see some of the same issues in the health service as elsewhere.

The whole public sector is a massive political football which means that ill thought out and highly disruptive change just gets layered on top of previous changes, none of which are properly implemented. This leads to a plethora of poorly implemented systems with poor knowledge transfer and lack of efficiency.

So my change would be to focus on doing less organisational change but doing that change better and fully, and to do that you need less political interference, stronger, more capable management and the resources to do it. Which is why it will never happen.

bibbif · 30/12/2022 10:22

@Ginmonkeyagain I was reading there isn't enough of this type of accommodation available.

www.pbctoday.co.uk/news/planning-construction-news/senior-living-housing-shortage-exposes-scale-uk-housing-crisis/116689/

Babynameangst · 30/12/2022 10:22

The collapse of the NHS is just one of a plethora of interlinked societal problems. To fix the NHS requires sweeping societal
and political change involving redistribution of wealth and being realistic about how we will manage an increasingly needy, geriatric population.

There is a growing generational wealth gap - compare the affordability of housing and living for current working generation vs their parents and grandparents. The over 65s now own >50% of the wealth in the UK, and median wealth for those in their 60s is 9 times higher for those in their 30s. Source www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personalandhouseholdfinances/incomeandwealth/bulletins/distributionofindividualtotalwealthbycharacteristicingreatbritain/april2018tomarch2020#the-generation-gap

Despite this gross equality there is a perception that the elderly have already "paid their way" and now deserve to retain all of their assets whilst their care should be paid for through general taxation. The voting population (majority of whom are cannot abide the idea that an elderly couple might need to downsize their large family home to pay for their (prolonged) old age. They cannot abide an increase to retirement age. But the taxpayer cannot sustain a retirement that lasts for up to 30 years and is complicated by vastly expensive health and social problems. Something has to give. At the moment, what's giving is the health and social care system.

Older people are the largest group that vote and they vote conservative, I believe primarily to preserve their retirement assets and to preserve the generational wealth gap. Even alternative (eg current Labour) government's still fundamentally serve this same agenda because suggesting that the older generation pay for their own health and social care by reducing their assets is political suicide. The result will be the total collapse of health and social care and a period of great suffering for everyone, that one hopes will eventually be reset by a more equitable system. It can't be fixed by any recommendation from anyone without or within the NHS system IMO.

That said, my recommendations would be:

  • Integrate health and social care
  • Greatly increase health and social care budgets in line with similar developed nations
  • Fix the pension tax trap for NHS consultants
  • Scrap nursing tuition fees and bring back the bursary / a salary for student nurses
  • Pay rise for all staff shortage groups in health and social care
  • Massive initial investment needed to expand and buy back private services and escape PFI contracts, with the effect of greatly reducing ongoing spend
  • For that matter, reverse the health and social care bill 2012 and everything that's followed
  • Get realistic about death (this is it's own topic). Interview anyone and they wouldn't want their future to be end stage dementia with an endless purgatory of delirium whilst all measures (needles, operations, antibiotics, feeding tubes etc) are used to keep them alive as long as possible. But this is the standard approach. Public awareness / cultural mores have a lot to answer for (see reaction to Liverpool Care Pathway)
  • I disagree that the NHS has too many managers. It's a vast and complex organisation it needs good management and good management costs, like everything else. My experience is that administrative and management support is being stripped for clinical staff and that makes the work harder. Clinical staff who are expected to be managers often don't enjoy the work, don't do it well, and aren't well rewarded for it. It causes senior clinicians to leave.
Pianofar · 30/12/2022 10:20

TheRedLip · 30/12/2022 10:13

Stop newly qualified doctors immediately relocating overseas to work.
Stop funding 6 months paid sick leave within every 12 months. It's horribly abused and no one seems to care.

Why? They pay university fees and spend many hours on placement without reimbursement. There's a lot written about how much it costs the NHS to train a doctor, but the universities also pay the NHS to have them host students so- not convinced to be honest. Now if fees were paid and perhaps a bursary then sure I'd agree with a return of service arrangement as they have in Wales for some healthcare degrees. The issue is more the the low pay and ridiculous hoops junior doctors need to go through to progress that causes people to leave or move abroad.

Most people I work with have very few sick days, I don't think because some may abuse it it's reasonable to wish it away. Much better would be to improve working conditions (this is proven to reduce sick days).

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 30/12/2022 10:18

Doesn't help that the improvement philosophy is a mish-mash of every quality improvement system ever tried.

Obviously you do need quality improvement, but like everything it needs to be headed by the right people, implemented in a straightforward way and there need to be regular checks to ensure it's serving its purpose.

Couldn't agree more with this!

Ginmonkeyagain · 30/12/2022 10:16

One thing that could help is greater emphasis on housing fit for older age and incentives to use it. How many people are rattling around in the the family house needing domicilary care as they can no longer cope?

My friend's parents - both in their mid seventies undergoing cancer treatment - live in a modern apartment complex for older people. It is a well designed one bed flat with a 24 hour warden and communal socialising spaces. They don't need personal care but my friend is pleased there is a warden keeping an eye on them and they live somewhere easy to live in and care for as they age.

It is run by a housing association and they qualified as local residents. I think they put down a substantial deposit and pay a monthly rent as well. They sold their house to move in. There probably won't be much of an inheritance once they go but my friend does not care, it is worty it to know her parents live somewhere suitable.

Pianofar · 30/12/2022 10:15

But I'm curious what NHS workers actually feel privatisation will do?

I honestly don't think that anyone will be interested in buying the NHS, because we are so used to free at point of use it's not as lucrative as elsewhere. Even if people are forced to pay, ie this treatment will cost x it still won't be like places such as the US where elective stuff forms a large part of the income. We've seen it in dentistry here, people pay for the bare minimum (if even that) and go without additional stuff.

The more likely scenario is that more and more gets contracted out to the lowest bidder who squeezes wages, terms and conditions, the level of service suffers whilst they turn a profit.

If it was fully privatised though staff would be paid more as there wouldn't be a monopolistic employment market. Probably help with recruitment as healthcare cover would be included in the employment package.

Newmama29 · 30/12/2022 10:15

I’m a nurse in a receiving area so effectively I’m front door. I have no idea where we would even start with the NHS tbh. However, I think a general change of culture within the public is one of the main things that needs changed. People need to start looking after their own health & taking some responsibility. You don’t have to seek medical assistance for every cold, flu, bump, cut, fever. I also believe that the money needs to be put into the community to help the acute services. We need more care at home available, we need more GPs actually seeing their patients. Do you know how many people are stuck in hospital literally waiting for packages of care or nursing homes? Also, nurses in nursing homes can & should be doing more medical care. We have many people admitted from nursing homes that only need some iv antibiotics or fluids, why can’t a GP go to a nursing home to assess & prescribe this & the nurse can carry it out? Don’t even get me started on management & how much we don’t need them with their crazy salaries 🤦🏼‍♀️

TheRedLip · 30/12/2022 10:13

Stop newly qualified doctors immediately relocating overseas to work.
Stop funding 6 months paid sick leave within every 12 months. It's horribly abused and no one seems to care.

ShandaLear · 30/12/2022 10:13

antipodeancanary · 29/12/2022 23:46

I think the NHS needs to do much much less and do it well.
Some conditions are so expensive to manage that we should probably stop. I absolutely love my patients but some require two to one or even three to one care at all times. Its not sustainable.
We should look at quality of life towards the end of life much more actively. People should be allowed to die more easily. No pegs, no dysphagia assessments in end of life, generally speaking.
Yes to voluntary assisted euthanasia. No one should be alive five years after they stopped recognising family members.
No fertility treatment. No cosmetic surgery. No breast reconstruction, no gender realignment surgery. No gastric bands, no acne treatments.
I know people benefit from all those things, but when we have people who haven't been able to see a gp since before covid, are waiting in agony for two years for a hip replacement, who are dying aged 40 from colon cancer that was diagnosed too late and people refuse to pay more tax, then we have tough decisions to make.
I don't actually see a lot of waste in the NHS, but I do see a lot of staff working way over hours for free.

Agree with all this. A close family member was recently very ill with a bowel disorder and in A&E. He was 82, had diabetes, COPD, and a host of other conditions, and had been given 48 hours to live. The doctor sat down and they had a discussion about the possibility of an operation, even though it would leave him permanently disabled, in a bed in a care home, permanently on oxygen and with a stoma, but he might live for another few years. Luckily, he refused and sadly passed away, but it should not even have been a conversation. How many people are being offered and agreeing to surgery that will leave them with such a poor quality of life at an enormous cost?

RichardMarxisinnocent · 30/12/2022 10:12

CoffeeBoy · 30/12/2022 10:02

There doesn’t seem to be any computer involvement. Appts are made by sticking patient labels in a big a4 paper diary!

Oh crikey, that's worse than I was fearing and is a ridiculous waste of time. Plus if the appointment never actually makes it onto a computer system (which I guess it might, maybe that's what the clnician is doing on the half days?) amongst other things, the Trust won't get paid for it, and will have no way of showing how busy that clinic is and thus no way of eg demonstrating that more staff are needed.

Virginiaplain · 30/12/2022 10:12

It was very clear which way it was all headed but there seemed to be a constant push for more medicine and treatment.. as if they could get better.. I didn’t understand it, it was already bad and was clearly going to get worst (and he was nearly 100!)

I didn't listen to the King's speech but all this tragic loss about HMQ - I mean she had a great life and a good death imv. No tragedy at all.
Ditto Pele and Vivienne Westwood - 81/82 isn't really young even nowadays - great lives and great deaths but no one is saying this - it's all tragedy. We need to be more realistic about dying in the UK - it get's us all!!!