Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
CoffeeBoy · 30/12/2022 11:29

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 11:24

"Fire all the managers and hire more nurses" is the taboild opinion of someone who has no idea how the NHS works and what its problems are. It's amazing how prevalent that view still is.

I disagree with that. Prior to working in the nhs I worked for a very large national organisation with thousands and thousands of employees. We went through a restructuring process with external people brought in to make the decisions. A lot of middle management and specialist roles were lost/streamlined.

It worked, the company was just as effective and saved money. Obviously there needs to be finesse in the process but the nhs is currently at that pre restructuring stage and something needs doing.

dollybird · 30/12/2022 11:29

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 11:24

"Fire all the managers and hire more nurses" is the taboild opinion of someone who has no idea how the NHS works and what its problems are. It's amazing how prevalent that view still is.

I hate this frequently made comment too. See also 'fire all the bean counters' as commented by a PP.

bibbif · 30/12/2022 11:27

oh & they are very against stamp duty!

bibbif · 30/12/2022 11:25

@vdbfamily we have sorted wills, poa & funeral arrangements with parents & in-laws. However they both will not downsize & shut down any conversation. They talk about needing to do it & how the house is too big etc but never now. It won't happen if you go beyond a certain point.

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 11:24

"Fire all the managers and hire more nurses" is the taboild opinion of someone who has no idea how the NHS works and what its problems are. It's amazing how prevalent that view still is.

Seaography · 30/12/2022 11:23

What is missing in NHS management is good management skills! Most of them are crap managers and you see the Peter Principle in all its glory. Things are so inefficient and poorly run that you can't get rid of the crap and they get promoted out of the way and just compound the problem elsewhere.

Bullying is rife and it is a toxic environment all in all. One of the issues is that many/most NHS employees have never worked anywhere else. They see shit management and think that is how it is supposed to be. A well managed, motivated workforce who feel valued and appreciated has already won the biggest battle.

I know when I go on a ward and it's a dump, dirty, maintenance jobs not reported, staff shortages etc, that the senior ward staff will treat me like shit on their shoe. When I go in to a clean well run ward with happier staff I will be treated well. Good ward 2managers see everyone as a team with housekeepers, cleaners HCAs etc being treated as valued members of the team and it shows through the whole ward experience.

vdbfamily · 30/12/2022 11:19

Yes there are problems in the NHS but it frustrates me so much that people are not talking about Social Care. The NHS would function far better if people were able to be discharged when medically fit. We spend so much time and energy on trying to increase discharges but it basically means encouraging staff to be able to accept more risks for patients on discharge and get them home without extra care where possible as there is no care available for them.
There are plenty more risks associated with staying in hospital and delayed discharges mean people then catch other illnesses from other patients, or become deconditioned and institutionalised to the point where they may never manage at home again.
Patients and families fight to stay in hospital because they feel safer but they really are not s safer.
This week we had one family member refuse to give her mother's front door key back because she thinks she should be in a home. This lady wants to go home and it's stuck in hospital whilst we are treating people in corridors in A&E. Another man needs his bed moving and his family cannot do it until next week and he refuses anyone else to go in and do it, so he blocks a bed for a week whilst there is nothing wrong with him. There are so many scenarios I could tell you, that is just 2 from yesterday alone.
The NHS needs the general public to also take some ownership of their health needs. There is great too much entitlement around.
Please all make a plan for yourselves and your elderly relatives where you can. Have discussions about the future. Make sure you downside and live somewhere sensible and manageable before you are unable to manage steps and stairs.
Get the GP involved to get DNARS in place and future wishes recorded and known.
Sort out power of attorney for finance and for health and wellbeing. But also understand that your elderly relatives get to decide what happens to them unless they lack capacity. You are entitled to say you will no longer run around after them providing care but you are not entitled to say they cannot return home.
I would say that several times a week in just our one hospital, we have family members who have moved into( or never left) their parents home, saying they will not have their parent home again. We ask who owns the home, always the parent. We explain it is their home and the relative can leave if they want but they cannot stop their parent returning to the house they own but we have had patients returned to the ward because their relative would not let them in to property. We have had to involve police.
We have husband and wives refusing to have their partners home because they don't like them any more. We have to explain they cannot stay in hospital but need to get advice re divorce but we cannot keep partner in hospital until that is sorted out!!
What I am trying to say is, yes, the NHS has problems but they are exacebated by a breakdown in society generally and a complete breakdown of social care.
I don't have the answers but if there were adequate sorry both formal and informal in the community, the NHS would be under far less pressure.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 30/12/2022 11:18

This is a great thread with some excellent suggestions. If only the Government would conduct a similar exercise..

rwalker · 30/12/2022 11:15

I’m sure it’s still the case if your epileptic you get all your prescriptions free
of course epilepsy medication should be free but why do you get all your unrelated medications free as well pay for them like everyone else

bibbif · 30/12/2022 11:04

I do believe children should get free prescriptions though as I think that's better for society.

bibbif · 30/12/2022 11:03

@OverTheRubicon I don't think there are many people who don't work & are in full health & receiving benefits (if you exclude pensioners). I also know people who work with chronic conditions who get that certificate thing.

HearMeSnore · 30/12/2022 11:01

I would work on removing the obstacles that prevent staff from working effectively. The beaurocracy, the micro-management, the excessive hoops we have to jump through to maintain professional registration, the meetings that could have been emails, the rigid and inflexible rules that govern recruitment, and all the meaningless non-jobs.
I'd also reverse the decision to outsource support services to private companies and go back to employing our own cleaners, porters, car park attendants etc. Then we can directly address shortfalls that prevent us from running an effective service. (Eg, Clinical staff having to remove themselves from busy departments to collect ward patients, due to a lack of porters!)

Blackandwhites · 30/12/2022 10:58

RichardMarxisinnocent · 30/12/2022 09:33

I'd be interested to know specifically which corporate admin management roles you'd cut? As in what job titles do these people have and what actual work are they doing that isn't needed?

I am a tax advisor. My colleagues advise NHS trusts in how they can recover VAT. We only work on big projects but there’s lots and lots on VAT what these trusts could be recovering from HMRC on day to day purchases that goes unrecovered due to the trust not employing a full time tax advisor. Employ one person, pay them approx £70k a year and they’ll save the trust over £1m a year. That’s what private companies do. The likes of NHS trusts don’t see this as a necessary job though so the money goes unrecovered.

sequin2000 · 30/12/2022 10:58

supergel · 30/12/2022 00:10

I haven't had an nhs appointment letter for ages. They usually text with a link and PIN. Once accessed you can download the appointment letter

This week I had a letter reminding me to book a COVID booster. 6 pages in colour with pictures and font 24. Totally unnecessary

Pianofar · 30/12/2022 10:54

Iluvfriends · 30/12/2022 10:53

To those that say get rid of bank staff, do you actually know the purpose of bank staff.

Bank staff can also hold a substantive post, of which I do.

I don't get paid any more than my substantive post for working a bank shift.

A bank shift is our overtime as the NHS very rarely offers overtime at a higher rate.

Buy yeah take that away from us.

I suspect many are getting bank and agency staff confused. In any case agency and people doing bank shifts keep things going!

Iluvfriends · 30/12/2022 10:53

To those that say get rid of bank staff, do you actually know the purpose of bank staff.

Bank staff can also hold a substantive post, of which I do.

I don't get paid any more than my substantive post for working a bank shift.

A bank shift is our overtime as the NHS very rarely offers overtime at a higher rate.

Buy yeah take that away from us.

OverTheRubicon · 30/12/2022 10:49

*amping? Amount, rather...

OverTheRubicon · 30/12/2022 10:49

@Eleganz The current prescription charge is £9.35 per item. Yes there are exemptions for some chronic conditions but not sure that removing those would achieve what you are aiming for

As @Shiraztonight says, in theory people pay, but over 90% prescriptions - and probably even more when you look at it on a £ basis - go to people who don't pay, either because of age, socioeconomics or illness type.

This is the kind of misconception that tends to lurk in the heads of healthy(ish) people, who don't realise that a HUGE majority of NHS and social care spend goes to support people who are not in work, not in good health and in many cases will never recover.

That is still a good thing - everyone deserves care, and any of us might find ourselves in that situation one day.

But it also isn't sustainable to have a shrinking pool of people in work, paying a growing amping per head for a growing pool of people who have had far more paid out on them by the government than they ever paid in. This group includes most pensioners, many people on benefits, and also people with lifelong health conditions (I am in this.last group, so am not making a dig, but am wanting to be pragmatic).

Meanwhile people who are in work are struggling to get a basic GP appointment, can't get support without huge waiting lists or going private if their kids are having major mental health troubles or need braces, and know that the money will be gone in a few decades when they need it.

As a social contract, this doesn't work.

snowsilver · 30/12/2022 10:48

I don't work in NHS now but did for 8 years.

It needs managers who are skilled at managing. It also needs clinical people in the management chain. There was no trining for managers and anyone could apply internally. I had 6 line managers in two years and never even met 4 of them.

Technology. DS works in tech in the NHS. It's pitifully backward. Even though large sums have been spent it's not interconnected and they can't recruit skilled IT people because the pay is so much better elsewhere.

On recruitment and retension of staff.
Student loan forgiveness if new doctors work in the NHS for 5 or more years.
Student bursaries brought back for nurses.
Massively expand medical schools in less glamorous areas. Recruitment in Northern towns is impossible but could be incentivised by offering cheaper training / tuition fees if they stay on to work.

Radical changes such as semi privatisation and charging some people for some things.

sequin2000 · 30/12/2022 10:48

AzureOrchid · 29/12/2022 23:18

I think the “ manage the population growth “ was a dig at immigration, not birth rates.

Immigration is needed to solve the issue of low birth rates. We have a dependency ratio crisis looming. People are living longer and retired on average for more than 20 years when in the past the average was 11 years. Due to low birth rates we won't have enough workers paying taxes to pay for their retirement and care. The answer is more children or more immigrants. The latter more effective as it works in the short term and immigrant workers are more likely to have a higher fertility rate. Brexit has added massively to the issue.

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 10:44

TheRedLip · 30/12/2022 10:30

People like you are so the problem.

Pointing out the reason for a problem does not make someone the problem.

rosebunched · 30/12/2022 10:43

LakieLady · 30/12/2022 07:07

Some years ago, I read about a bog standard fridge costing around
£250 via procurement, when they could have bought the identicial model for less than £80 in Currys. If true, that's just mad.

Should add, it was needed for clinical purposes, not just to keep the milk in.

I have got examples of things that can be bought on Amazon etc for much, much cheaper than the price our department is forced to buy it at. Even simple things like office goods. It’s an absolute racket!

Pianofar · 30/12/2022 10:43

TheRedLip · 30/12/2022 10:30

People like you are so the problem.

In what way?

I've been an NHS nurse for nearly 2 decades, I've been fortunate that aside from maternity leave I've only been poorly a handful of days. I just don't think that medical and healthcare professionals should be beholden to the NHS, nor do they owe the NHS anything when they've funded their own training and worked many many placement hours unpaid. I was fortunate and had mine paid for, I wouldn't be able to afford it now. If the NHS looked after their staff better people would also be off less. What part of that makes me the problem? The fact I don't believe we live to serve you.

Blowthemandown · 30/12/2022 10:40

@startingitallagain I thought GPs were actually run as companies and only contracted by the NHS. That would explain why so much variation over performance, what they spend on their phone systems and how many receptionists. Having moved recently I had to change surgery and the new one, while anecdotally having a better reputation, is just nowhere near as good. The attitude seems to come from the practise manager - the last one was amazing and the new one, they just don’t get it right. I was 70 something in the queue the other day. Had to ring old surgery to ask something and was only on hold a very short time. Old surgery could always get seen if needed on the same day. New one, I’ve given up. And so on. I would love to compare their processes and accounts and make sure standards are followed etc.

OverTheRubicon · 30/12/2022 10:39

Agree with all the people saying that while there are inefficiencies, the crucial bit is tied up in social care and end of life care.

Investment in social care and preventative and public health would improve the population's quality of life, as well as reducing health spending.

Some of that money for social care also needs to come from individuals- unless we plan to really encourage euthanasia (horrible thought) an ageing population will mean more money needed, and it's vastly unfair for young people to face a future of paying even more in tax and getting less from the system, in order to allow a wealthy older person to pass on the full value of their house as an inheritance.

We also need to look at elderly and end of life care. There's a lot of talk about treatment being assessed on Quality Adjusted Years of Life, but we don't talk about the long term life (and cost) impact from young children waiting years for autism assessments and speech therapy, or the knock on impact of poor dental care due to lack of funds, while we perform heart operations on 85 year olds, on circumstances where the doctors themselves would absolutely decline treatment for themselves or their loved ones, because the pain will be severe and net benefit minimal if any.

None of this is easy, but we can't go on as is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread