Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
thesurrealist · 30/12/2022 12:05

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 11:24

"Fire all the managers and hire more nurses" is the taboild opinion of someone who has no idea how the NHS works and what its problems are. It's amazing how prevalent that view still is.

Indeed. I've lost 5 staff in the last 6 months. All of those staff were closely involved in working with services in the community to improve the service for patients. Because they have left and because we are going through yet another re-organisation due to the whims of one of our previous Health Secretaries we cannot replace them, the rest of my team are trying to cover their workload, but failing and I now have 2 of them off on sick leave due to stress and also battling through for too long with long covid.
The services that they were working with in the community are closing at the end of March because without their support they cannot improve and so the ICB will not continue to fund them because of the massive risk to patient safety.

As usual on here there is the usual blaming of old people for being old, childfree/childless people for not giving birth to future taxpayers, NHS management because let's face it no one really knows what we do, but by God they would soon realise if we weren't there (see above example).

As usual there is the "sack all managers", "hire more nurses", "reform", "make people pay" as ill thought out solutions by people who either don't work in the NHS, don't understand the structure and how it works or just know about their own little corner of a ward and don't know what goes on elsewhere.

The solution is actually very simple....
Stop voting Tory
Stop re-organising the NHS and allow us time to do our day jobs without threat of losing those jobs
Stop believing the shite that the Daily Mail and its ilk publishes.

1000yellowdaisies · 30/12/2022 12:03

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 30/12/2022 10:06

slim down the management structure, it’s ridiculous how top heavy it is.

How many managers should there be for an organisation the size of the NHS?

Well for a start there should be less managers than actual staff, which isnt always the case especially in departments like HR, organisational development, corporate comms teams...

bibbif · 30/12/2022 12:03

and then you are paying more tax on it!

MuddlingThroughLife · 30/12/2022 12:03

Improve pay.

Stop treating the NHS as a business (i.e. one dept paying another to do a job!) and get rid of lots of top managers.

Bring back Matron!

Maintain hospitals to avoid closures. This would accommodate so many different types of clinics.

bibbif · 30/12/2022 12:03

No, there needs to be better pay in this country. That is the root of many of our problems.

yes pay is shit!

There has been zero growth, 30k in the early 00s is the same as 50k today but many jobs still pay what they did in the 00s

Ginmonkeyagain · 30/12/2022 11:59

@sequin2000 that is interesting. I contribute considerably more than I get back. But that is to be expected as I am very healthy and child free.

But I am very aware that can turn on the head of a pin, which is why I support the concept of the NHS. My dad after a life time of barely bothering the NHS was a very heavy user in the last year having been diagnosed with rhematoid arthrotis and having a stent fitted. However I am getting to the point where I see the NHS model is not working for longer term healthcare and preventative medicine.

I am lucky I have some private medical proviaion through work so use that for annual health checks and things like physio and dental treatement.

Eleganz · 30/12/2022 11:58

Newmama29 · 30/12/2022 11:51

I’m happy to pay more tax to improve public services but I would like to see higher employment rates. These days, it pays better not to work & I would begrudge paying more tax for many people to sit on the benefit system. I completely understand that we need a benefit system as not everyone can work but there are many people sitting on benefits that can work & there needs to be tighter restrictions to receiving benefits.

No, there needs to be better pay in this country. That is the root of many of our problems.

We have lots people in work who are earning so little they need charity handouts and government benefits to make ends meet. It is not that benefits are too generous it is that work does not pay as pay has been deliberately restrained for over a decade.

I'm guessing you are a Tory voter? The only options you can see are to take even more away from the poorest.

Hotdaisies22 · 30/12/2022 11:58

For the tiny bit of the NHS I'm familiar with, a national education campaign on what to do yourself at home, what to call 111 for, 999 for and GP for. So many people calling for 'an emergency ambulance' when they don't need one at all. All adds to the load. A long serving colleague said to me the other day " for some people, its like we've become the NHS Uber service".

vdbfamily · 30/12/2022 11:55

bibbif · 30/12/2022 11:25

@vdbfamily we have sorted wills, poa & funeral arrangements with parents & in-laws. However they both will not downsize & shut down any conversation. They talk about needing to do it & how the house is too big etc but never now. It won't happen if you go beyond a certain point.

Agreed there is only so much you can do if parents do not want to but I think it is important to be honest with parents as to how much support you can offer in event of them becoming less able. So many families expect hospital staff to say to our patients that they are no longer willing to do this or that. They are difficult conversations but it is so much harder when someone is admitted to hospital and the family declare they are exhausted and can no longer provide the care they have been because those patients then become marooned in a hospital bed. If those conversations happen earlier and private care is arranged or referral made to social services in good time then these delays might be avoided.
Often it is about money. Patients will sit in hospital awaiting a few weeks of short term care until they are seen by a social worker and means tested and then have to pay anyway. If they know they have the means to fund their care, they should be sourcing that as soon as medically fit for discharge and could then leave hospital a month sooner. ( although in many areas the carers are hard to find whatever the funding) I understand the desire to get what you can free, but people seem to not understand how risky it is to stay in hospital. They also need to understand that whilst they are sitting there enjoying their NHS hotel, someone else is stuck outside A& E waiting for someone to leave the hospital to allow them to receive emergency care and whilst that is happening, someone else is on the floor at home with a broken hip, awaiting that ambulance to become available.
Sorry.... this is obviously not about your parents, but as an NHS worker, I am very frustrated with the whole situation at the moment and I feel like the NHS is under the spotlight but society also needs to look at their responsibility and Social Care needs a massive sort out or needs to be reattached to Health. Back to DEPT of Health and Social services.

HalfasleepChrisintheMorning · 30/12/2022 11:54

NHS dentistry is certainly terminal. I’m a dentist so can’t comment on the Health Service overall.
For Dentistry there are 2 options as I see it.
One would be completely private, so everyone even kids. This will lead to a lot of problems in the less well off, also children.
Even wealthy people seem to resent paying privately for children’s teeth for some bizarre reason! (Don’t have more children than you can afford to keep!)
The other would be to stop lying to everyone and fund a minimal core service for children and people on benefits.
Exam, simple scaling, fillings, extractions, plastic dentures and root canal on front teeth only (3-3).
All orthodontics, crowns, bridges, metal dentures, molar and premolar root treatment, gum treatment beyond simple scaling would all be private only. No stupid units of dental activity, the above would be provided in state run clinics, by dental students and newly qualified or by independent practitioners at their hourly rate.

Newmama29 · 30/12/2022 11:51

I’m happy to pay more tax to improve public services but I would like to see higher employment rates. These days, it pays better not to work & I would begrudge paying more tax for many people to sit on the benefit system. I completely understand that we need a benefit system as not everyone can work but there are many people sitting on benefits that can work & there needs to be tighter restrictions to receiving benefits.

whereaw · 30/12/2022 11:51

I think the main issues stem from wanting to centralise services and control. I'm pro localisation and distributed power/ control in most things. Closing community hospitals in particular was a terrible idea.
Human nature is that we will always do more and work harder for those close to us. The nhs has become too abstract a construct that's it's hard to care.

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 11:48

Virginiaplain · 30/12/2022 11:43

It definitely should be improved but who pays?

Tax-payers.

The 'who pays' line is always presented as a gotcha, but polling shows that brits are happy to pay more taxes for improved public services.

(I've also said elsewhere on the thread that you need to sort out the housing crisis to get 20-30-somethings having more children to prop up that tax base. But the 'tax more to improve things' is not fundamentally unpopular.)

Virginiaplain · 30/12/2022 11:48

*No fertility treatment. No cosmetic surgery. No breast reconstruction, no gender realignment surgery. No gastric bands, no acne treatments.

The majority of this is done privately. Acne treatment is usually medication and weight loss in the long term is a health benefit so the nhs wins.

But heart bypasses, every sort of cancer and it's treatment, lung disease, hip fractures. I'm sure these are the drains on finance and can't be avoided.

sequin2000 · 30/12/2022 11:47

www.gocompare.com/health-insurance/the-bill-of-health/
This is an interesting calculator to see how much you have cost the NHS

Ratched · 30/12/2022 11:44

antipodeancanary · 29/12/2022 23:46

I think the NHS needs to do much much less and do it well.
Some conditions are so expensive to manage that we should probably stop. I absolutely love my patients but some require two to one or even three to one care at all times. Its not sustainable.
We should look at quality of life towards the end of life much more actively. People should be allowed to die more easily. No pegs, no dysphagia assessments in end of life, generally speaking.
Yes to voluntary assisted euthanasia. No one should be alive five years after they stopped recognising family members.
No fertility treatment. No cosmetic surgery. No breast reconstruction, no gender realignment surgery. No gastric bands, no acne treatments.
I know people benefit from all those things, but when we have people who haven't been able to see a gp since before covid, are waiting in agony for two years for a hip replacement, who are dying aged 40 from colon cancer that was diagnosed too late and people refuse to pay more tax, then we have tough decisions to make.
I don't actually see a lot of waste in the NHS, but I do see a lot of staff working way over hours for free.

Yes! Total agreement with this.

Mummysgogetter · 30/12/2022 11:43

Haven’t read the whole thread but the number of useless managers there are in my department alone costing £££ is unbelievable- they don’t seem to know or do anything constructive and they most defer to people of my level for advice on how to investigate/fix a situation- plus they don’t have a lot of decision power (I’m talking bands 6-8). So why do we need so many??

Virginiaplain · 30/12/2022 11:43

It definitely should be improved but who pays?

SleeplessInEngland · 30/12/2022 11:41

Virginiaplain · 30/12/2022 11:40

Glibly saying we should improve social care - it really is a bottomless multi million pound pit.

Carers drive miles between cases round here, don't get their petrol fully reimbursed, spend usually half hour with customer, barely enough time to do anything properly. And that's when the client is not disabled or incontinent.

Your second paragraph sounds like a great reason to improve it.

Virginiaplain · 30/12/2022 11:40

Glibly saying we should improve social care - it really is a bottomless multi million pound pit.

Carers drive miles between cases round here, don't get their petrol fully reimbursed, spend usually half hour with customer, barely enough time to do anything properly. And that's when the client is not disabled or incontinent.

cptartapp · 30/12/2022 11:39

bibbif · 30/12/2022 09:29

We need to confront the fact that people are living longer but in poorer health. This is only going to get worse as the baby boom generation (those born 1945 - 1965) move through old age.

But time & time again you hear I paid my stamp, it's all the fault of immigrants, I want to leave my house to the dc.

I have an in-law who is early 70s & now on lots of medication. They are doing great but & have received excellent care but I have been shocked at what is "available to them" if that makes sense. So much medication (often not used), free transport to hospital, attendants allowance, a carer in the home for a few hours a week, therapists etc. If this is replicated across millions no wonder there is no money left.

This. PIL receive attendance allowance and have several hundred thousand sitting doing nothing in the bank. It's not means tested neither is their winter fuel allowance, free prescription, bus pass, etc etc like the abolition of my child benefit. Why?!
And this is 80 year old MIL claiming who paid very little 'stamp'. Gave up work at 28 to raise two DC and never returned.

Virginiaplain · 30/12/2022 11:35

bibbif · 30/12/2022 10:22

@Ginmonkeyagain I was reading there isn't enough of this type of accommodation available.

www.pbctoday.co.uk/news/planning-construction-news/senior-living-housing-shortage-exposes-scale-uk-housing-crisis/116689/

This falls down as land to build on is extortionately expensive - you can't compare us with NZ, Aus and USA.

Yolanda524 · 30/12/2022 11:33

Iluvfriends · 30/12/2022 10:53

To those that say get rid of bank staff, do you actually know the purpose of bank staff.

Bank staff can also hold a substantive post, of which I do.

I don't get paid any more than my substantive post for working a bank shift.

A bank shift is our overtime as the NHS very rarely offers overtime at a higher rate.

Buy yeah take that away from us.

I was thinking the same, I only work as bank as my workplace refused my flexible working request and there is no childcare that can accommodate 12 hour shifts and variable shift work. I get paid less than the normal staff and don’t get sick pay or full holiday pay.
I think most people are confusing bank staff and agency but even agency nurses don’t take that much more it’s the agency themselves that are making the money.
If workplaces were a little bit more family friendly and have a much better work life balance maybe they would retain staff and the reliance on agency would then decrease as well.

Exasperatednow · 30/12/2022 11:33

There are less managers in the nhs than any other comparable business. Read the King's fund report and the research. It's one of the reasons for the problems. The nhs is a people business. Its not widgets.

CoffeeBoy · 30/12/2022 11:31

And I’m not saying fire all the managers but it seems you can’t even have a conversation along these lines of there needing to be some positions lost without being accused of having that opinion.