Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in the NHS, how would you fix it?

489 replies

startingitallagain · 29/12/2022 22:54

Or AIBU to think it can't be fixed and we're gradually slipping down the slope of eventually not having an NHS?

I do absolutely understand how many staff within the NHS are struggling to cope under the pressure, with many leaving due to their own mental/physical health issues that the job has caused.

This has been inspired by another thread where the poster can't get a GP appt for their father who has terminal cancer and can't keep food down (and hasn't been able to for a number of weeks). www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4708090-to-wonder-what-my-gp-surgery-is-actually-doing?page=1

With elderly parents myself and having to occasionally battle for them to get care, I find the prospect of getting older in this country quite terrifying, so much so I think I'd rather plan for euthanasia if I was facing end of life and no care!

Is it funding? Is it lack of staff? Would more money solve the issue? WWYD?
(As an aside I remember watching the documentary 'Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS?' a number of years back - made interesting viewing about the issues then!)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Helpmeoutforamoment · 07/03/2023 18:40

@Whammyyammy yes, I have visited a hospital in the states. It cost £265 for ear drops that in the UK, even with a private prescription would have cost me £4.52. No thanks

Blossomtoes · 07/03/2023 18:27

Whammyyammy · 07/03/2023 16:53

Because it would be ran as a business. Have you ever visited a hospital in the states? I have and they're bloody brilliant.

Sames as most private hospitals in uk and eu

If you introduce a profit element, you’re immediately diverting money from front line services to shareholders’ dividends. However “bloody brilliant” US hospitals might be, they’re not much help to people with no money or insurance, are they? I don’t want “bloody brilliant” hospitals that exclude the most vulnerable in our society.

UK private healthcare uses NHS staff and cherry picks the easiest procedures, those hospitals aren’t where you want to be if you have a life threatening condition. In fact, if you need intensive care they send you to the NHS because they haven’t got the staff or facilities you need.

Wetnovember · 07/03/2023 18:11

@Whammyyammy i hate to break it to you but your annual NI payments probably won’t cover 1 month of family insurance under a private scheme. Hospitals in the US are brilliant….if you can afford to pay, which an enormous % of the population can’t. And a quick glance down any street in the US, with their abundance of fast food outlets and morbidly obese population will tell you that having to pay for healthcare doesn’t appear to induce healthier living.

Whammyyammy · 07/03/2023 16:53

Blossomtoes · 07/03/2023 11:48

How does that work? How is it going to be improved by introducing a profit element? If that happened it would be the first public service ever that had.

Because it would be ran as a business. Have you ever visited a hospital in the states? I have and they're bloody brilliant.

Sames as most private hospitals in uk and eu

Blossomtoes · 07/03/2023 11:48

Whammyyammy · 07/03/2023 11:33

I'd personally privatise it. The staff would then receive a decent salary, appoints would be available, people wouldn't waste time and not turn up to appointments as it would stoll cosy them, facilities would be clean and not run down.

Stop taking national insurance premiums off people, and we can pay for insurance for a fit for function healthcare system.

Simple

How does that work? How is it going to be improved by introducing a profit element? If that happened it would be the first public service ever that had.

Whammyyammy · 07/03/2023 11:33

I'd personally privatise it. The staff would then receive a decent salary, appoints would be available, people wouldn't waste time and not turn up to appointments as it would stoll cosy them, facilities would be clean and not run down.

Stop taking national insurance premiums off people, and we can pay for insurance for a fit for function healthcare system.

Simple

Anothermother3 · 07/03/2023 11:03

I didn’t realise it was still so brazen 😢 agree with all you’re saying. I’m trying to have some hope that something will shift. Otherwise I have to just see what I can to support the people in front of me day by day as it’s too overwhelming otherwise.

Blossomtoes · 06/03/2023 18:55

Alexandra2001 · 06/03/2023 18:26

I just spent the afternoon in Derriford Hospital, vast majority of patients were old, very old, not saying many cannot use email at all but i do wonder how many appointments will be "non attendance" if they were sent out email only?

Thousands is the answer. It’s not just old people either. There are lots of people of all ages who don’t use email. Communication has to cover the largest number of people possible. You can’t just say people should use email, I reckon we’re a good ten or 20 years away from that.

Our local trust retains the car parking itself but has sold the admin to a national parking company. To the detriment of all users.

Alexandra2001 · 06/03/2023 18:26

garlictwist · 06/03/2023 16:07

"I get your point, but not everyone uses email. My elderly parents don't for example."

I'm sorry, but they should use email. Why should a system use old, clunky and expensive methods like the post because a few people haven't joined the 21st century? The world moves on and email has been around for about 25 years.

I just spent the afternoon in Derriford Hospital, vast majority of patients were old, very old, not saying many cannot use email at all but i do wonder how many appointments will be "non attendance" if they were sent out email only?

Alexandra2001 · 06/03/2023 18:23

Blossomtoes · 06/03/2023 16:00

Most of them do own the land, they’ve subcontracted the parking.

Do they? ours and two others in the region have got rid and sold off and/or long term lease.
But either way, none have painted a car park in Rainbow.

garlictwist · 06/03/2023 16:07

"I get your point, but not everyone uses email. My elderly parents don't for example."

I'm sorry, but they should use email. Why should a system use old, clunky and expensive methods like the post because a few people haven't joined the 21st century? The world moves on and email has been around for about 25 years.

Blossomtoes · 06/03/2023 16:00

Alexandra2001 · 06/03/2023 11:27

Very few trusts own parking land (so its done by another company) and with the money they charge staff to park, (my DD's daily parking cost is £8) they have enough money to paint the whole hospital in Rainbow.

Most of them do own the land, they’ve subcontracted the parking.

Alexandra2001 · 06/03/2023 11:27

Kennykenkencat · 06/03/2023 08:17

Why if the NHS is so broke do they have the money for painting the car parks in rainbow colours

Very few trusts own parking land (so its done by another company) and with the money they charge staff to park, (my DD's daily parking cost is £8) they have enough money to paint the whole hospital in Rainbow.

Kennykenkencat · 06/03/2023 08:17

Why if the NHS is so broke do they have the money for painting the car parks in rainbow colours

Kennykenkencat · 06/03/2023 08:16

BorisisaLune · 04/03/2023 07:19

The problem is that the NHS cannot give you that scan because they have a constant stream of people in more urgent need than you.
The UK has some of the lowest number of scans per capita of any European country and of course, we don't have so many radiographers either.

The NHS is run by people who don't know what they doing, from Govt to Trust leaders, the lack of staff is symptomatic of this, they have the money but do not spend it wisely, esp on training/equipment and most importantly, retention - see below:

Someone i know, a skilled HCP, has had 2 bouts of Covid and flu, yesterday she had her meeting with HR to discuss her sick record and is on a disciplinary measure for the next 6 months, no other absences - and they wonder why staff leave, which is what i ve advised her to do -

A decent private sector company would have the flexibility to work around a sickness policy that is designed to pick up a pattern of absence not punish people who get work related illness.

No queues.

When I asked would I be having an mri the consultant reply was that the NHS wasn’t made of money and they would get to the diagnosis through guesswork. He liked discovering what was wrong with a patient.

Given he said all this without looking in my direction and never once looked at me I did think at that point someone would get to a diagnosis when I was passed on to physio.

What you say doesn’t make sense

How can there be so many people having scans that there is a waiting list of longer than 7 years yet also have very few people being scanned.

I think the lack of testing is the fundamental reason the NHS is failing.

Like my back issues where a £300 test could have diagnosed the problem and got it fixed within 6 months my Dh had cancer. He returned to the GPs surgery at increasingly frequent appointments over 6 months.
He was displaying all signs of bowel cancer but even though he asked to be referred for tests he was told to stop worrying and using Dr Google. (He wasn’t. His df had died of bowel cancer)

The GPs never referred him on for tests. Instead I had to carry him into A&E where he was diagnosed.

Testing after the first appointment would have meant a pretty simple op. An over night stay in hospital.

Instead he spent 4 months in hospital only to be told that there was an operataion he would be suitable for. But then told he couldn’t get it (I think we lived in the wrong postcode) We ended up paying for it.
The NHS wanted to put him on a care pathway to death.

We talked over the time he was in hospital to other patients and the one theme that came out of this was that everyone knew what they had wrong but heir GPs wouldn’t test until they got to such a bad stage that it involved extended hospital
stays and sometimes operations that might never have been necessary if they had tested after the first appointment.

The money the NHS waste by not testing is where the problem lies.

No good spending money on adverts to show what to look out for if when you go to the Dr’s they ignore you

MichelleScarn · 06/03/2023 06:12

whatyoulookingfor · 05/03/2023 17:42

Recognise that quality of life is better than quantity of life. Accept that people die. The number of patients that I end up going to who are he'd bound, have severe dementia and yet we are keeping their blood pressure down which stops them having a stroke (but prolongs a their hideously undignified existence), is phenomenal.

Stop semi privatising the health service. At the moment we have to commission out services to the cheapest bidder every few years, which 1) inevitably means that its a shit service and 2) you have to pay a commissioner around £50k a year to do it, plus a procurement team. It's a complete waste of money. The NHS never used to be semi privatised and it worked a lot better.

Enforce Health and Safety Legislation that says that care homes must be equipped and insured to pick patients up off the floor safely, so they don't just call an ambulance saying "we aren't ensured to pick people up", we'll actually, legally you have to be.

Reopen community hospitals and increase funding for social care from the money you've saved above.

That's what I'd do in my first 100 days as the CEO of NHS England

Absolutely this!

MarieG10 · 06/03/2023 05:42

Anothermother3 · 05/03/2023 09:48

They do still recruit from developing countries but less brazenly (think agencies attending uni classes a few decades ago to get new graduates to come over). The thing is that while I get that there is not an infinite supply of people what has been done is mass down grading of posts so they’ve scrapped staff at the lower levels or just upped the level of responsibility for lower banded staff. There aren’t infinite people appropriate for health care but if you could make the assistant posts worthwhile to support the more senior posts and give a level of responsibility appropriate to the pay band it would go some way to making things more sustainable and make people want to be HCPs and work in health. I know it’s not simple but that’s got to help. Same as education a teacher with enough support staff in a class where extra Ta support is needed is going to be more likely to remain in post. Surely some of that is possible?

Sorry...but it is totally brazen. There are either recruitment teams from agencies, or the Trusts own staff doing stints abroad to support recruitment. Teams of people doing airport meet and greets. It is so totally wrong but it is currently the only way to staff nursing roles to anywhere near funded levels. However, it is just raiding the low levels of resources in developing countries.

If the govt scrapped tuition fees and kept the NHS bursary they may find recruitment eases, but also look at the high ,Eve,s of attrition from nursing courses..part of which is students being put on placements in hospitals and being used and abused to fill huge gaps in Healthcare Support Workers instead of learning.

The whole system is collapsing and frankly as someone with a private sector background I do not intend to stay as rank incompetence riddles the whole organisation

Franticbutterfly · 06/03/2023 00:00

There are a lot of people in the admin side of the NHS who refuse to cross train or do anything that is beyond their job description, or god forbid, above or below their band. You don't get that "luxury" so much in the commercial world. As a result of this there are people employed to do very specific jobs where they have nothing beyond the basic requirements of their role expected of them, and it creates a mindset and attitude of "nothing to do with me"; this can be a real issue and causes more hold ups in helping patients than there are already.

Obviously this is not the case for everyone, and I know people who are doing the job of more than one other person atm, as well as their own. But I often think that there could be more teamwork and shared responsibility. The band system can be restrictive for a number of reasons, and this is just one of them.

Virginiaplain · 05/03/2023 19:48

I can’t believe that the community hospitals will work - they are quite small and surely within a short time they will just become care homes full of elderly patients who can’t manage on their own.
Why would we be able to move on patients from community hosps that we can’t move on from regular hosps.
Are they all fittish, non dementia suffering individuals able to manage at home ? If we can afford physios/ OTs/ social workers for those in community hosps we can afford the same for those in general hosps.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 05/03/2023 18:23

CurlyTop1980 · 05/03/2023 08:11

I'm not an NHS worker but I do work in social care. One of the problems with social care is due to cost cutting they got rid of community hubs and made mega adult social care departments across 2 or 3 local authorities. You lose the personal touch. I think with health local GP/community clinics with adult social care based in these would make a lot more sense.

very much agree. Can’t sort out NHS with social care is in such a mess. Co location of nhs & social care in the community as well as hospitals definitely helps. So much time is wasted going back & forth on emails & doing phone & paperwork catch ups with people you barely know. Relationships make such a difference

Throwncrumbs · 05/03/2023 18:16

Let all the staff work from home because it’s the new way and productivity is better when working from home, plus I will always be there in the school holidays to look after my kids.

whatyoulookingfor · 05/03/2023 17:42

Recognise that quality of life is better than quantity of life. Accept that people die. The number of patients that I end up going to who are he'd bound, have severe dementia and yet we are keeping their blood pressure down which stops them having a stroke (but prolongs a their hideously undignified existence), is phenomenal.

Stop semi privatising the health service. At the moment we have to commission out services to the cheapest bidder every few years, which 1) inevitably means that its a shit service and 2) you have to pay a commissioner around £50k a year to do it, plus a procurement team. It's a complete waste of money. The NHS never used to be semi privatised and it worked a lot better.

Enforce Health and Safety Legislation that says that care homes must be equipped and insured to pick patients up off the floor safely, so they don't just call an ambulance saying "we aren't ensured to pick people up", we'll actually, legally you have to be.

Reopen community hospitals and increase funding for social care from the money you've saved above.

That's what I'd do in my first 100 days as the CEO of NHS England

BungleandGeorge · 05/03/2023 17:24

Companies need to keep hold of their staff who are qualified and highly trained- because they’re difficult to replace so it pays to give a generous sick pay. It also has to be earned with years of service in the nhs. It’s not as if people can just take whatever they like. I think it’s very fair that people working directly with sick people get more sick pay, it doesn’t take a genius to realise that they’re likely to
to be sick more often! Not to mention contact with toxic substances such as radioactivity, cleaning solutions, entonox, blood
and bodily fluids

BorisisaLune · 05/03/2023 15:52

Plenty of private sector have very generous sick policies, especially in the more skilled sectors.
I ve always had very generous sick pay & BT, OpenReach and Babcocks all pay over 3 months full pay and 3 half and thats just the 3 companies i have had dealings with, longer term employees get better - its good to work for an employer that cares about your health and wellbeing.

Going back to our ICU nurse, so she is dismissed (goes and works for the DWP on 37k as an assessment worker) and the trust is a specialist nurse down, they then employ agency staff for 3 years until a replacement nurse is trained up.

Meanwhile, other staff see how she was treated and that they are all now on 2 weeks full & then SSP and start to leave, meaning more agency required.

taxguru · 05/03/2023 15:18

@BorisisaLune

Say if an specialist ICU nurse broke her hip and had 6 months signed off, do you think she should be fired?

The trouble is that she'll be on full pay for those 6 months in the NHS. In the private sector, she could be on as little as basic SSP. So, it costs the NHS more to have "sick" staff because they're ham-strung by the contracts which force them to give their staff full pay for months, then half pay for months, etc So, from a financial point of view, it can be cheaper to get rid rather than pay wages for months or even years for them not working. Of course, that argument falls flat on it's face when there's a shortage of staff and no one to take the job of the person potentially being fired (but if they're not working anyway, what's the difference?).

Swipe left for the next trending thread