Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the way DD plays with dolls odd?

116 replies

AllInTheDollsPlay · 29/12/2022 21:38

DD is 8, school year 4 if relevant.

She loves dolls. Has several baby annabells and similar. She likes to push them round in a toy pram or carry them around, they do go everywhere with her - they sit and watch her in the bath or go in the bath with her if they can - but she doesn’t feed them or change their nappies or their clothes, she just carries them and pushes them around. She does wash the babies in the bath and is constantly singing to them.

I thought it was because she was an only child with little experience of babies as all my friends have older DC.

But a friend said her only DD knew how to “play” with dolls and fed them and changed them etc. I didn;t have much contact with babies but remember feeding and dressing my dolls up.

DD does have dyspraxia and dyslexia as well as Arthritis and Shallow sockets in her joints, not sure if this is why.

She’s happy as she is; laughs if someone pretends to feed her dolls and doesn’t get upset if I change their clothes, she just doesn’t do it herself.

She does play “normally” with other types of toys, she loves building schools with her playmobil and lego, has a lol dolls house she plays shops with (the lego men go shopping as well) and she has remote control cars that she drives up and down the hallway saying their racing and they often have a doll or soft toy or barbie sat in them.

So AIBU or is my DD “normal”?

OP posts:
nomcachange · 29/12/2022 22:26

I’m not sure what I voted for as I’m sure YANBU means you mustn’t worry but clearly there is confusion! She sounds fine and fun 🥰

Spiderboy · 29/12/2022 22:25

It’s normal.
being an only child has zero to do with it 😂 some children just naturally lean more towards this type of play. My niece did and even know at 14 she’ll take the time out her day to fetch her baby cousins drinks and play games with them on their level.

caravanbuckie · 29/12/2022 22:25

AllInTheDollsPlay · 29/12/2022 22:22

Thanks everyone, reassured that my DD is perfectly normal. I have a younger sibling so that might be why I fed and changed my dolls.

I think pretend company sounds great though, she's happy enough. She got a few dolls for Christmas and she loves them and said thank you for them so I do just think it's her and how she plays.

Did you ever play with her changing and feeding the dolls when she was little, or did you just leave her to get on with it?

LovingTheAbbreviations · 29/12/2022 22:25

I wouldn’t worry at all, I never fed my dolls either, or changed them, and I had a younger sister. I also used to just leave them and forget where they were…worrying! I cut their hair and it didn’t grow back, and also tried to make one of them do the splits and pulled it’s leg off, then sellotaped it back on so my parents wouldn’t know. And I’m not even a psychopath…..

SunshineLoving · 29/12/2022 22:24

All sounds perfectly normal to me. Your DD seems to be 'caring' for the dolls as she bathes them. I would only be concerned if she was doing something strange like being violent with the dolls. She probably just doesn't find the pretend feeding and changing interesting. She uses her imagination to care for the dolls in other ways. There's no right way to play.

Bossa09 · 29/12/2022 22:23

Hmm I wouldn’t look into it too much. She’s obviously enjoying playing with them as she does. And there’s nothing wrong with that at all.

However, you mention dyspraxia. Does this affect how your daughter gets dressed? Her co-ordination or how she eats? It could transpire over as not being something she enjoys therefore why would she wanna do that with her dolly?? Maybe I’m looking too much into it when it’s not necessary.
dyspraxia runs in my family. I’ve never been tested but have an older and younger brother with it. Both struggled with getting dressed as kids!

AllInTheDollsPlay · 29/12/2022 22:22

Thanks everyone, reassured that my DD is perfectly normal. I have a younger sibling so that might be why I fed and changed my dolls.

I think pretend company sounds great though, she's happy enough. She got a few dolls for Christmas and she loves them and said thank you for them so I do just think it's her and how she plays.

OP posts:
StressedSandwich · 29/12/2022 22:19

I don't think I ever fed my dolls apart from the one that had them cherry ball things (and that was because I liked the smell) I was too busy drawing on their faces and cutting/plaitting hair.

I was also a only child :)

Holly6547 · 29/12/2022 22:17

My sister used to feed her doll and I never did because I knew mine didn’t need to eat. I also never changed them. I have never had any interest in changing a baby or doing baby related things until I had my own.

I did cuddle my doll and carry it around with me and liked dolls more in general than my sister. Every child is different.

harrassedmumto3 · 29/12/2022 22:17

Sounds to me like she enjoys the fun parts of playing with her dolls, whereas changing or feeding them could be perceived as boring Grin Smart lass, if you ask me!

supersop60 · 29/12/2022 22:15

It sounds normal to me.
My dd (22) used to tie her Barbies to the legs of chairs and tables.
I asked her recently why and she said she didn't know. sigh

Rinatinabina · 29/12/2022 22:14

Dd 3 mainly has dolls that require medical attention. Sometimes she invites them to dinner, they are expected to feed themselves. There’s no “right” way.

GimmeBiscuits · 29/12/2022 22:13

I used to take the clothes off my dolls and give them mud packs/treatments. I had a plastic pram which I used to put water in, then put the muddy naked dolls in and push them around as if they were in a giant bath on wheels.

I didn't ever 'feed' or 'change' them. I never saw them as pretend children or babies.

SarahAndQuack · 29/12/2022 22:13

Shadope · 29/12/2022 22:02

@SkylightSkylight but whether a child has a sibling or not doesn’t affect their understanding babies need to be fed and changed! And surely even if true this would only ever be factual for the older sibling hence all youngest siblings would be ‘onlies’ in this respect. Only children are not less caring, not more selfish and not less happy.

Confused Of course whether or not a child has a sibling being changed/fed will affect their understanding! It's nothing to do with whether a child is caring or not - a child who has a younger sibling, and for whom it's a daily reality to see that sibling fed or changed, will simply have these things on the radar in a way a child not seeing those things, won't.
PartyHelp · 29/12/2022 22:10

Your friend sounds like an asshole, there isn't a right way to play with dolls, you DD sounds absolutely lovely. My DD hates dolls and has never played with any, god knows what your friend would think of that!

ChocolateCroissantCafe · 29/12/2022 22:10

In our house a cuddly toy or doll often comes along just to hang out. As another poster says, they're imaginary company. No issues with imagination and there are lots of Playmobil camping trips, theatre shows and so on. But the larger scale toys just sit there to make things friendlier.

purpledalmation · 29/12/2022 22:09

Tv adverts are a big influence on learned behaviour

SarahAndQuack · 29/12/2022 22:08

I think this sounds very normal. I think it'd be highly unusual for a child to engage in totally 'realistic' imitative play with all of their toys.

Shadope · 29/12/2022 22:02

@SkylightSkylight but whether a child has a sibling or not doesn’t affect their understanding babies need to be fed and changed! And surely even if true this would only ever be factual for the older sibling hence all youngest siblings would be ‘onlies’ in this respect. Only children are not less caring, not more selfish and not less happy.

jetadore · 29/12/2022 22:02

The idea that there’s a “right” way to play with dolls (or any toy for that matter) is the only thing that’s “weird” here.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 29/12/2022 22:00

I never fed my dolls, because they were made of plastic so I fully understood that they didn't eat, drink, pee or poop. Apart from Tiny Tears, and I can tell you I only gave her one drink.

Your friend is being ridiculous.

Reugny · 29/12/2022 21:59

@SkylightSkylight there are other settings were onlies and youngest children see babies being fed and changed.

Toddlerteaplease · 29/12/2022 21:59

I can't remember changing my many cabbage patch kids nappies. I only ever fed the one that had a bottle in a pouch round her neck (and burped)

Quveas · 29/12/2022 21:59

My parents - and I am now 65 - kept buying me dolls. They went on a shelf and barely ever got touched. There is no right or wrong way to play with dolls, any more than there is a need to play with them at all simply because you are a girl. There is no such thing as "normal" - she's playing, she's happy, leave her to it. Not aspiring to have babies / change nappies etc sounds like no bad thing!

SkylightSkylight · 29/12/2022 21:57

Shadope · 29/12/2022 21:51

And none of this has fuck all to do with being an only child!! How can it.

@Shadope because unlike children with younger siblings, 'onlies' don't see babies being fed & changed at home.

@AllInTheDollsPlay Fact. children are weird!! 😂😂. I think it's only natural that 'onlies' are less focussed on feeding & changing 'babies/dolls' whereas those with younger siblings are less focussed on it. I think they see babies as more 'interesting & interested' than they are!

I don't think it means your DD will forget to wash, change & feed her children in the future!

some 'onlies' will E more mothering & others will be more 'inventive'. It really doesn't mean anything!!

your friend made a weird comment, best to just ignore.