Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is in the wrong? (Fussy eaters)

121 replies

LadyLothbrook · 29/12/2022 20:25

2 children, 11 and 7.
Youngest has adhd and I suspect so does the eldest.

An example of what children will eat:

Most meats chicken, beef, and sausages.

Most vegetables with few exceptions one doesn't like sprouts so much, one doesn't like tomatoes.

They will eat eggs, olives, breads, potatoes, pasta as long as the sauce is smooth, cheeses. They will try cuisines from other cultures.

DC1 enjoys crisps as a snack and DC2 has a sweet tooth. Both will eat chopped salad veg and fruit and berries if prepared for them.

Tonight we had chilli made with a variety of beans. Parents enjoyed theirs but after a few mouthfuls, both children expressed a dislike.

Parent B says its fine to leave but let's them know its a pity because its a nutritious meal. Parent A says yeah leave but tells them no fast food, sweets, junk for 6 months and nothing else for the rest of the night. Parent A won't listen to Parent B when Parent B tries to explain that they probably just don't like it and are not doing it to be fussy. Parent B can sometimes project due to horrific childhood trauma so Parent A feels like they're becoming too 'woke' or 'snowflake' like.

Parent A - Believes children are 'getting worse' with their eating. More fussy, more wanting to eat junk food.

Parent B - Believes children enjoy a variety of foods but has common problems with strong tastes, textures. And believes it will get better with age if not berated.

Who is right in this situation? A, B or both? All responses welcome.

OP posts:
Isahlo · 29/12/2022 22:45

Parent A’s give children eating disorders

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 22:44

Mariposista · 29/12/2022 22:10

6 month punishment is ridiculous. Obviously an empty threat. But the kids should get nothing else that evening if they have refused their meal.

Why? What is this silly idea some posters have on here that children are not allowed to dislike something. Would you do this? If you tried a new meal you’d made and thought ‘yuck, this isn’t nice’ would you sit hungry all evening as punishment for not liking it?

It isn’t morally wrong to dislike a food.

WhereYouLeftIt · 29/12/2022 22:43

Given what you say the children will eat, I do not regard the as fussy eaters. Parent A, on the other hand, I regard as an abusive dickhead who is doing their level best to drive their children away from them and damage the relationship irrevocably.

Their complaints about Parent B undermining them is tosh. Their OTT "no fast food, sweets, junk for 6 months" should be countered as it is not a proportionate response.

Letitrainletitrainletitrain · 29/12/2022 22:43

My parents were parent A's. My sister developed anorexia and I am obese and really struggle with eating in front of people

ButterflyOil · 29/12/2022 22:42

Parent A is being ridiculous. They’ve tried the meal and don’t like it. Why try and force them to eat something they don’t like with over the top threats of no sweets etc for SIX months? Total overreaction and terrible example to the kids.

The children’s diet also doesn’t sound that limited to me.

Id be wondering why on earth parent A thinks these sorts of silly threats to their children of insanely long punishments when the children haven’t even misbehaved is appropriate? What is parent A thinking this will teach their kids??

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 22:42

They don’t sound fussy. Very few people like every single food on earth and will eat everything no matter how it’s cooked. Sometimes you don’t like things. There are lots of meals I don’t cook at home because we don’t like them!

It’s always a stupid idea to threaten ridiculous punishments such as ‘no sweets for 6 months.’ Because they are OTT, won’t actually be followed through, and are a ridiculous punishment for politely disliking a meal. I’ve never punished mine for not liking food. If they didn’t like it I’d say ‘okay, never mind. Do you want some toast?’ Just the same as how I’d react if I tried a food I didn’t like.

PotterLottery · 29/12/2022 22:41

They aren't fussy

B1rds · 29/12/2022 22:39

Provide healthy food. Let them take it or leave it.

CatherinedeBourgh · 29/12/2022 22:38

Unless parent A is doing all the cooking, they should butt out.

If they are doing all the cooking, parent B should step up and help with the cooking.

GoT1904 · 29/12/2022 22:37

So he gets to make a completely ridiculous and disproportionate punishment and then if you try be the voice of reason, then you're 'undermining' him? He sounds awful in this situation:(

If he is refusing to read up on matters, and won't entertain a debate about his approach.. I don't know how you'll solve this issue.

Your children will end up with disordered eating, though. My mum made me eat every last bite or I'd not get anything else for the day, or some other punishment. So I force fed myself every meal and had to ignore when I felt full. Didn't matter if I hated the food, or if my portion was huge. Now I'm overweight, always have been, and have an awful relationship with food. I'm still scared to leave any, age 32.

Talaforniababe · 29/12/2022 22:34

I wouldn't punish them for not eating it but I wouldn't offer anything else other than toast or fruit. And obviously no treats in the aftermath of the meal if they don't eat it. My stance would be 'eat what you want but I'm not a restaurant'. I wouldn't see this as a punishment, just as a natural consequence.

Overandunderit · 29/12/2022 22:34

Parent A is a controlling twat.

wanttokickoffbutcant · 29/12/2022 22:32

I eat nearly everything but I don’t like beans in chilli so a bean chilli would be a no for me and I am fifty. It may be a weird texture for a child unless you are vegetarian and your kids aren’t.

RafaistheKingofClay · 29/12/2022 22:31

Depending on context, I might also be reluctant to offer nothing else that evening - perhaps just rice and peas, so no reward for not eating the main offering.

I agree. I guess it depends on age and what you offer or how you structure meals. Nobody’s going to win from a toddler going through a developmental fussy phase waking up ravenous at 4am because a parent decided to stick to their guns and offer nothing else all evening. Whereas if you always offer something they do eat alongside something new or always offer yogurt/cheese and/or fruit after a main you can make sure they have eaten something without seeing any particular part as a reward or lack of it as a punishment.

I’m quite uncomfortable with the idea of withholding particular foods as a punishment for not eating the healthy nutritious part of a meal. I don’t think it’s a very healthy message to be giving children. Or adults for that matter.

Mariposista · 29/12/2022 22:10

6 month punishment is ridiculous. Obviously an empty threat. But the kids should get nothing else that evening if they have refused their meal.

lanthanum · 29/12/2022 22:03

6 months is far too long for a consequence at this age. Out of proportion, and also means that consequence isn't available another time. Depending on context, I might also be reluctant to offer nothing else that evening - perhaps just rice and peas, so no reward for not eating the main offering.

Chilli can be difficult because of the spiciness, which children often find too much. I only cope with very mild chilli, with plenty of rice. I used to help on a youth holiday, and we had chilli the night before the kids (12+) arrived, because experience showed that there were usually several kids for whom it was a problem - a pity as it was an easy one to do in huge quantities.

jadedspark · 29/12/2022 21:52

I HATE this undermining crap. It's perfectly ok to stand up for your children when they are being treated unfairly. Is there something he strongly disagrees with like smacking for example? Would he just stand there and accept his children being hit as not to undermine you?

Why does he get to make the final decision? You could equally say he is undermining you and your rules. Would he actually enforce 6 months of no treats? If so that's honestly unhinged. No pudding that night would be more reasonable.

RafaistheKingofClay · 29/12/2022 21:51

Parent A is going to create a food issue that doesn’t currently exist. It doesn’t sound like they are fussy and they were willing to try something new.

Even if they were fussy, number one rule would be to take all emotion out of it and not get into a battle of wills. So he’s going completely the wrong way about sorting it out. And that’s before you add in using food as a punishment or ridiculous punishments that are way over the top and nobody will follow through on.

PopUpMoon · 29/12/2022 21:49

Parent A is a twat. Are they this controlling in other aspects? Are your children not allowed tastebuds?

JetBlackSteed · 29/12/2022 21:47

Interesting that you described yourself as Parent B.
Are you feeling second place?

My reading of your OP, you aren't in the wrong.

User837463839 · 29/12/2022 21:44

carbonarya · 29/12/2022 20:31

Parent A sounds like a cunt.

This 100%!

exLtEveDallas · 29/12/2022 21:42

My DH used to give DD unreasonable or ridiculous punishments (“right, no more sweets EVER”, “Do that again and we won’t go on holiday”). All it meant was that by the time she hit teen years, she barely listened to anything he said. Parent A is setting himself up for a fall.

I’m not a fussy eater at all, but cannot abide mixed bean chilli - the texture is just horrible and dry/paste like in my mouth. Absolutely love Chilli Con Carne made with beef mince. Your kids aren’t necessarily being fussy not liking this meal, maybe they just don’t like it - we are all allowed preferences.

coodawoodashooda · 29/12/2022 21:37

carbonarya · 29/12/2022 20:31

Parent A sounds like a cunt.

This

Talia99 · 29/12/2022 21:35

Parent A sounds abusive. Parent B refusing to assist him in abusing the children and intervening is ‘undermining his parenting’ and thank goodness for that - when ‘parenting styles’ cross the line to abuse, either the other parent or (if as often occurs the other parent doesn’t intervene) the state need to stop the abuse.

There is no absolute right to do anything you like to your children, much as Parent A may regret that fact.

Also, I hate chili and would never in a million years eat the meal described. When my mother made chili while I was visiting for Christmas, she pulled the leftovers of a meal I did like out of the freezer. Simple.

LadyLothbrook · 29/12/2022 21:32

laalaaland · 29/12/2022 21:29

Parent A is a controlling unreasonable arsehole who is going to cause major food anxieties in your children unless you keep standing up to him.

I had two parent A types growing up. It was awful.

Children are not getting worse with their eating, attitudes towards children have changed, they are thankfully treated more as human beings now, with valid opinions and feelings.

I agree with this and everyone on this thread. Thank god attitudes are changing. My childhood has left me a ghost walking this earth, I know things can be different for my children if they learn boundaries and are treated with respect.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread