Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not lend neighbour my car?

207 replies

HouseIsOnFire · 29/12/2022 18:37

Just that really... new neighbours (less than a year), not particularly close (friendly when I first moved in but a series of events has lead to some distance).

Was asked out of the blue if I had comprehensive insurance, and if so could they borrow my car as needed to sort something out at their buy-to-let (defrosting a boiler condenser pipe, so not an emergency!)

Been made to feel a bit mean, though I lied and said I didn't have the insurance.

YABU - Perfectly reasonable to ask an acquaintance if you can borrow their car, and it's mean of them not to say yes

YANBU - No, I wouldn't lend my car to someone (except maybe close family)

There's been a whole series of bonkers behaviour and now genuinely wondering if I was mean not to lend it! (I did offer a lift if needed but had to rescind the offer after 4 hours and still no time for said lift given - was clear I was expected to wait about all day in case offer was taken up!)

OP posts:
Plainascanbe123 · 31/12/2022 04:46

I also think you should limit all interactions with them. I just read that you cooked a meal for them and they messaged 5 mins after they were meant to arrive to say their not coming..and the other things they've done seem like they want either to control you or get a reaction. And they wouldn't give you back your own key. They don't sound nice at all. They have serious boundary issues and they view you as a soft touch probably because you're a nice person and you live alone. As neighbours they're way too overbearing so you must keep them at a distance, which means no more favours or giving them any of your time in any way shape or form.

Plainascanbe123 · 31/12/2022 04:25

Wow! How can they even ask you that. That's a serious violation of boundaries to me. They're just a 'neighbour' not flesh and blood. What are they even thinking to ask a question like that. What if they have an accident with your car. Its a definite no.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 31/12/2022 04:07

I have refused to let my sister drive my car, let alone some rando neighbour.

Moser85 · 31/12/2022 04:03

@Brackensmomma
I wasn't saying that she should have let her neighbour or that she should have anything to feel guilty about.

I was saying when my friend borrowed mine she transferred her own insurance to my car, so if she had crashed it then she would have had to claim on her own insurance, in other words there's a way to do it without being a CF about it and risking my insurance.

In regards to people thinking fully comp means they're covered to drive any car, yeah it was standard in the past for someone with fully comp to have 'driving other cars' as standard but they would only provide third party cover on the 'other cars' and 'open driving' (which allows others over 25 with a full licence) to drive your car was common as standard too but now most of the time they are optional extras so a lot of people probably think they're covered because they haven't bothered to check their recent policies!

Brackensmomma · 31/12/2022 03:21

@Moser85 I don't drive. And only knew about the insurance from watching police interceptors on TV. And seeing them seize the car because people think cos they have insurance fully comp on one car that means they are able to drive any car. 9 out 10 times they can't.
Besides the insurance they only neighbours they were very cheeky to ask.

Op Haa nothing to feel guilty about for saying no. Anyone in the right mind would refuse..
If they were that desperate they could hire a car..

Grrrrdarling · 31/12/2022 02:04

HouseIsOnFire · 29/12/2022 18:37

Just that really... new neighbours (less than a year), not particularly close (friendly when I first moved in but a series of events has lead to some distance).

Was asked out of the blue if I had comprehensive insurance, and if so could they borrow my car as needed to sort something out at their buy-to-let (defrosting a boiler condenser pipe, so not an emergency!)

Been made to feel a bit mean, though I lied and said I didn't have the insurance.

YABU - Perfectly reasonable to ask an acquaintance if you can borrow their car, and it's mean of them not to say yes

YANBU - No, I wouldn't lend my car to someone (except maybe close family)

There's been a whole series of bonkers behaviour and now genuinely wondering if I was mean not to lend it! (I did offer a lift if needed but had to rescind the offer after 4 hours and still no time for said lift given - was clear I was expected to wait about all day in case offer was taken up!)

YOU having comprehensive insurance does not insure them to drive your vehicle so for me that would be a fast nope.
I am fully comp & my insurance comes with an extra that allows me to drive other cars, with permission from the owner, but I am only covered TPFT on that vehicle.
You could drive them to the property because believe it or not a frozen pipe on a boiler could be an emergency because it can cause the boiler to 1) stop working & 2) frozen pipes could burst which could flood the property.

angelfacecuti75 · 31/12/2022 01:42

"No sorry my insurance does not cover others driving it and its too big a risk to take, sorry. I can't help you any further with this so please don't keep asking me. "
Repeat ad infinitum.
Cf .

ChellyT · 31/12/2022 01:16

MdNdD · 30/12/2022 21:38

A very British problem. In other countries, the car is insured, regardless of the driver and people lend cars without a second thought.

Are you part of the CF 1% that voted YABU? Clearly not only a British problem as you think. Australia has a battlefield of different types of 'fully comprehensive insurances' listed drivers, age of driver's (young and senior) depending on how much excess you wa

ChellyT · 31/12/2022 00:58

HouseIsOnFire · 29/12/2022 21:22

I think so, I have done a fair number of favours for them and maybe they just assumed because of that I was a pushover! Lesson learnt I guess!

Absolutely what @Soothsayer1 has said. Your narcistic CF neighbours sound like they have done the rounds with the other neighbours and while most have probably pushed back or have given off the 'don't try that shit on me' vibe you unfortunately are a true gem who they have been able to walk over from day 1. Put some distance between you and keep your generous hospitality and nature to others who return your kindness, we're out here just a little wary.

I read the other day 'Whatever words of advice I would give a loved sister, friend, relative in this same situation, I too should take' if you feel like they are gaslighting you, they probably are, if you feel like they are being unreasonable they probably are...

VainAbigail · 31/12/2022 00:50

WitchDancer · 29/12/2022 18:39

I don't like lending DH my car, let alone an almost stranger. YANBU in any way!

100% agree with this.

Canuck48 · 31/12/2022 00:49

MdNdD · 30/12/2022 21:38

A very British problem. In other countries, the car is insured, regardless of the driver and people lend cars without a second thought.

My car car is insured no matter the driver. I do believe I may have put a limit on one thing as it makes it cheaper. I don’t fully remember. I still don’t lend my car out to just anyone. If a neighbour like this one asked I would say no! Where I am, you can’t get around without a vehicle. Yes, there are taxis and Uber et al but it gets super expensive. To get anywhere by transit is usually hours as it sucks and everything is fairly far.

If they f’ up my vehicle I am screwed. Why would I lend it out when they have other options they can pay for? Will I offer a ride if need be, absolutely. If certain ones needed it in an emergency I would lend but not the one the OP described.

Runnerduck34 · 31/12/2022 00:42

YADNBU , they were very cheeky to ask and I think you were right in setting your boundaries .
I would only ask a neighbour ( probably for a lift) if it was an absolute emergency and I had no other options.

Moser85 · 31/12/2022 00:36

Brackensmomma · 30/12/2022 18:21

No way..
Don't lend your car to anyone. Don't matter what insurance you have they have to be insured to drive it.
If they need a car and have a full licence tell them to go hire a car for the day..
Some people take the piss...

I lent mine to my friend once and she transferred her own insurance to my car temporarily.

Delandra · 31/12/2022 00:28

Yanbu. They’re taking the mick!

cookie4640 · 31/12/2022 00:15

Wow! Who are the 1% that voted YABU?! 🤣

taxi?!

Isinglass20 · 30/12/2022 22:02

Taxi?

MdNdD · 30/12/2022 21:38

A very British problem. In other countries, the car is insured, regardless of the driver and people lend cars without a second thought.

HouseIsOnFire · 30/12/2022 21:38

ILoveYouMoreTheEnd · 30/12/2022 21:19

Before you posted that you lived alone, I thought I bet you live on your own and they see you as a softy! I can't believe they did that when you made them the dinner omg 😳 they are definitely the CF's of 2022 xxx

Someone needs to develop a partner-for-hire business for all these scenarios 😂

I'm not at the point of hiring a gigalo to get trade quotes or glare threateningly for me... yet...!

OP posts:
HouseIsOnFire · 30/12/2022 21:36

FictionalCharacter · 30/12/2022 20:32

Weird that isn’t it, especially as it seems she does her own maintenance on the property instead of using an agent. Maybe she thinks she’ll borrow other people’s cars every time she needs to go round.
This person is batshit and I feel sorry for her tenants if she treats her tenants the same as she treats her kind neighbour.

@Irritatedmum Sorry, to clarify, they DO have a car but it wasn't available until the next evening.

Not that it makes it any better, points of uber/car hire/taxi/bus still stand!

OP posts:
ILoveYouMoreTheEnd · 30/12/2022 21:19

Before you posted that you lived alone, I thought I bet you live on your own and they see you as a softy! I can't believe they did that when you made them the dinner omg 😳 they are definitely the CF's of 2022 xxx

Hopeistaysane · 30/12/2022 20:55

Are you kidding me?!?! There is zero chance of me ever lending my crappy little car to anyone, not even my partner 😂😂😂. You are NOT being unreasonable.

AnnieSnap · 30/12/2022 20:55

I absolutely wouldn’t lend a neighbour my car. Unless they had their own insurance cover for cars other than their own, I wouldn’t lend it to a friend, as asking them for many thousands of pounds if it was seriously damaged may offend! Comprehensive insurance only fully covers named drivers!

BaconChops · 30/12/2022 20:51

No, how cheeky of them to ask! Don’t give it another thought.

FictionalCharacter · 30/12/2022 20:32

Irritatedmum · 29/12/2022 20:44

They’ve got a buy to let but not their own car?

Weird that isn’t it, especially as it seems she does her own maintenance on the property instead of using an agent. Maybe she thinks she’ll borrow other people’s cars every time she needs to go round.
This person is batshit and I feel sorry for her tenants if she treats her tenants the same as she treats her kind neighbour.

wentworthinmate · 30/12/2022 20:18

I just can't imagine asking to borrow a car from someone I hardly know! The absolute nerve of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread